Web privacy group seeks to block Toysmart sale

From...

July 10, 2000
Web posted at: 11:14 a.m. EDT (1514 GMT)

by Linda Rosencrance

(IDG) -- An organization that developed a set of online data-privacy guidelines is taking legal action aimed at stopping failed Internet retailers that signed up to get its seal of approval from selling their customer lists and other information to third parties.

San Jose-based TRUSTe said it plans to file a brief in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Massachusetts in an attempt to prevent Toysmart.com from selling data it collected on customers as part of a liquidation process that began after the online toy store closed its virtual doors in May.

Toysmart, which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection last month, included its customer lists and database among the items it wants to dispose of in a motion seeking the bankruptcy court's approval for a public sale of the company's remaining assets. The court gave Toysmart permission to proceed with the bidding process pending a July 26 hearing on the public sale motion.

But Toysmart was a participant in TRUSTe's program, and TRUSTe spokesman Dave Steer claimed that a sale of the Waltham, Mass.-based company's customer records would violate its legally-binding contract with the organization, as well as the privacy policy that was posted on Toysmart's Web site.

MORE COMPUTING INTELLIGENCE

IDG.net home page

Computerworld's home page

Toysmart goes out of business

Privacy concerns rankle industry

CEO: Partnership hurt Toysmart

Reviews & in-depth info at IDG.net

E-BusinessWorld

TechInformer

Questions about computers? Let IDG.net's editors help you

Subscribe to IDG.net's free daily newsletter for IT leaders

Search IDG.net in 12 languages

News Radio

Fusion audio primers

Computerworld Minute

"Toysmart.com entered into a contract with their customers saying they would not release customer data to third parties," Steer said. "And we're making the assertion that Toysmart is in breach of [that] contract, and what it is doing is illegal." TRUSTe also has asked the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to investigate Toysmart's actions, he added.

Toysmart officials couldn't be reached for comment, and Alex Rodolakis, one of the Boston-based attorneys representing the company in its bankruptcy case, didn't return a phone call. Meanwhile, a spokesman for the FTC said he could neither confirm nor deny that the commission is looking into the matter.

Toysmart, which was majority-owned by The Walt Disney Co., is just one of nearly a half-dozen online retailers that went out of business this spring as funding began to dry up for unprofitable Internet ventures.

The controversy over the proposed sale of Toysmart's customer list comes amidst a high-profile debate over whether the federal government should pass privacy legislation or continue allowing companies to self-regulate themselves.

Jason Catlett, president of privacy advocate Junkbusters in Green Brook, N.J., said a federally enforceable law is the only way to guarantee the privacy of online shoppers. "This is one of the many cases where the current legal processes [related to consumer privacy] are grossly unsatisfactory," he said.

"There's not a lot of law around the issue of privacy in the U.S.," said Jonathan Moskin, an intellectual property lawyer with New York law firm Pennie & Edmonds LLP. "But TRUSTe may have a claim for breach of contract, which could very well result in the court issuing an injunction against [the sale proposed by] Toysmart."

Steer said TRUSTe also has enlisted the help of Massachusetts Lt. Gov. Jane Swift and the state's attorney general. In June of last year, Swift filed privacy legislation aimed at protecting the personal information of Massachusetts consumers by preventing online companies from selling that data to third parties without an individual's consent.

But the bill is stalled in a legislative committee, and Swift said state government officials are trying to determine what, if anything, they can do in the Toysmart case. "There are a lot of questions about whether privacy protections are better considered at the [state or] federal level," she said. "But there's no movement in the [FTC]."

U.S. antidrug site dealing cookies
June 23, 2000
Senate committee revises Internet security bill
June 22, 2000
Michigan charges Web sites with privacy violations
June 19, 2000
A low-cost utility that hides your tracks
June 8, 2000
Three necessary principles behind privacy laws
June 7, 2000

Toysmart goes out of business
(Computerworld)
Privacy concerns rankle industry
(Computerworld)
CEO: Partnership hurt Toysmart
(Computerworld)
Boo.com failure raises questions about online boutiques
(Computerworld)
ToyTime.com closes up shop
(Computerworld)
TRUSTe to file antiprivacy brief against Toysmart
(The Industry Standard)
E-tail sites down for the count
(The Industry Standard)

Toysmart bankruptcy sale
TRUSTe

Note: Pages will open in a new browser window

External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.