Skip to main content /LAW /LAW
find law dictionary

Attorney says developments might cause McVeigh to fight execution

After meeting with McVeigh, Nigh said his client is willing to take a "fresh look" at his options  

WASHINGTON (CNN) - An attorney for condemned Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh said Friday that his client might consider fighting his execution in light of the execution being delayed.

U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft announced Friday that he was delaying the execution because the FBI failed to turn over more than 3,000 pages of documents to McVeigh's trial defense.

McVeigh has previously waived all appeals in the case saying he preferred to die rather than spend his life in prison. But attorney Robert Nigh met with McVeigh Friday and afterward said McVeigh is considering his options and might decide to fight his execution.


• About 3,100 pages of documents and pieces of evidence including "Form 302" documents that give the essence of interviews that FBI agents conducted following the Oklahoma City bombing. Many of the documents deal with the search for "John Doe No. 2."


• The Justice Department says it does not believe the documents have "material bearing" on the case, but McVeigh attorney Nathan Chambers called the discovery "a cause for great concern."


• The evidence could be grounds for an appeal, but McVeigh's attorneys cannot file one without his consent because he has not been proven to be mentally incompetent.


"Now that this has occurred, he is willing to take a fresh look and evaluate the information," Nigh said.

When asked if McVeigh would initiate legal proceedings to fight his execution, Nigh said, "It is certainly possible. He is going to make an informed decision upon the information contained within the documents and the discussions that we have with him." (Full story)

Latest developments

• The Associated Press reported that the FBI began gathering all the reports and documents generated during the investigation last December, according to Special Agent Danny Defenbaugh, who led the investigation.

The documents were logged and compared with information stored in 26 investigative databases in the FBI's main computer system, described by law enforcement officials as antiquated.

Problem was, "some of the materials from various FBI field offices were not part of the investigative database," said Defenbaugh in a statement. "Moreover, this was the first time the OKBOMB task force had seen these materials and none were used in the government's case," he said.

• Ashcroft said that he did not expect anything in the files to contradict the verdict against McVeigh, who was sentenced to die for the 1995 truck bombing of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City that killed 168 people.

But Ashcroft said questions posed by the withholding of the documents were serious and that it was his duty to "protect the integrity of the system of justice."

The FBI documents, which included reports of FBI interviews, known as "Form 302s" and "inserts," and physical evidence, such as photographs, written correspondence and tapes, were turned over to McVeigh's attorneys Thursday, less than a week before his scheduled execution. (Full story)

graphic VIDEO
CNN's Wolf Blitzer reports on what the McVeigh execution delay may mean for McVeigh and Nichols (May 11)

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)

McVeigh lawyer Robert Nigh says his client will evaluate new information to decide whether he now wants fo fight execuition

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)
graphic DOCUMENT
FBI documents from special agent in charge (FindLaw) (PDF format)
Documents in PDF format require Adobe® Acrobat® Reader™ for viewing.
graphic ALSO
Previous FBI controversies

Newly revealed FBI documents prompt Nichols' appeal

More on the McVeigh execution
The Execution of Timothy McVeigh
graphic CNN ACCESS
Former McVeigh attorney: McVeigh protected others

McVeigh prosecutor: Newly disclosed documents won't prompt new trial

• McVeigh attorney Nathan Chambers said Friday he has "only scratched the surface" in his examination of the documents and he does not know what the files contain. He said he did not know if 30 days would be enough time to study the files.

• Attorneys say McVeigh was "distressed" by the news that his execution had been delayed because he had prepared himself to die and he is concerned that he will have to go through the process again.

"He had said his good-byes to his family and to his friends. He is distressed that he has had to put these people that he cares about through this process and may only have to put them through it again," Nigh said.

The lawyer said his client's reaction to the FBI's admission and the production of the documents "certainly was not (one of) amusement."

• McVeigh's execution was rescheduled for June 11. Ashcroft said the one-month delay was granted "to allow his attorneys ample and adequate time to review these documents and to take any action they might deem appropriate in that interval." He said he had asked the Justice Department's inspector general to investigate why the FBI failed to turn over the documents.

• The decision to delay the execution by 26 days cannot be shortened -- even if McVeigh pleads for the execution to proceed as planned, officials say. But senior Justice Department officials who asked not to be identified acknowledged, however, that court actions could intervene to further postpone the execution.

McVeigh's defense team would be required to first take a request for an appeal of his conviction to a three-judge panel of the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver, Colorado, the government lawyers said. But the Justice Department's view is that there is no legal basis for McVeigh's attorneys to succeed in court.

"They can try anything, but that doesn't mean it will succeed," said one of the officials. (Full story)

• The lead attorney for convicted Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh blasted the agency's conduct and competency.

"This is the FBI's most important investigation, maybe ever, and they hold themselves out as being the premier law enforcement agency in the world," Nathan Chambers told a news conference. "If they're incapable of handling their most important investigation in a matter that instills confidence, we all need to be concerned."

Oklahoma Gov. Frank Keating, a former FBI agent and U.S. attorney whose state was targeted for McVeigh's attack, called the failure to disclose documents an "unforgivable screw-up." But he said he doesn't think the mistake was deliberate or a sign of FBI incompetence. (Full story)

• Bombing conspirator Terry Nichols plans to appeal his conviction and life sentence to the U.S. Supreme Court following FBI revelations that it had failed to hand over evidentiary documents to defense attorneys.

Nichols was convicted on charges of conspiracy and involuntary manslaughter in a trial that followed McVeigh's. Michael Tigar, Nichols' attorney, told CNN that his client has until midnight Friday to ask the court to order the solicitor general to look into the impact of the newly disclosed files from the investigation on his case.

"We will meet that deadline," Tigar said. "Terry Nichols was acquitted of most of the charges against him. He's got a real defense here." (Full story)

• FBI Director Louis Freeh was informed Thursday about the problems in the McVeigh case, a bureau official told CNN on Friday.

The discovery that the documents had been withheld was communicated to FBI headquarters on Tuesday.

FBI spokesman Mike Korten told CNN that Freeh was informed of the extraordinary developments "early in the day" Thursday. Asked to explain the delay in informing the director, Korten said officials were looking into the "extent of the problem during that period." (Full story)

• The congressional committee with oversight over the FBI sent a letter last month to Freeh saying it is "concerned that the FBI has information technology systems that are slow, unreliable and obsolete -- systems that are unable to address the Bureau's critical needs."

The House Judiciary Committee letter, which was provided to CNN, asks Freeh to give an evaluation of the problems "plaguing" the bureau's computer system and an assessment of what can be done to fix them.

Freeh, who announced recently he would retire from the bureau next month, has not responded to the congressional request. (Full story)

• Former McVeigh prosecutor Patrick Ryan said Friday that the discovery of new FBI documents won't be enough to win a new trial. "We had a very clear, concise case of absolute responsibility on McVeigh's part for this bombing. He's since admitted that he took his part in delivering the bomb to the Oklahoma City Murrah Building, where the people were killed," Ryan said. "I don't think there's any chance at all for any evidence in these documents that will be favorable to the defense or provide any type of defense." (Full story)

• Stephen Jones, McVeigh's one-time lead attorney, is convinced that his former client exaggerated his own guilt to shield others from prosecution in the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing. Thursday's revelation that the FBI failed to hand over hundreds of pages of documents to McVeigh's defense was something of a "vindication" for Jones, who had long contended that the attorneys had not seen all the evidence.

But he said he didn't think the documents would have any effect on the outcome of the case.

"I mean, Tim McVeigh has said publicly that he committed the crime. And though I think he's exaggerated his guilt, if he says he's guilty, then how could these documents make any difference?" Jones said. (Full story)

McVeigh execution witness list climbs to 300
May 2, 2001
Oklahoma City remembers
April 19, 2001
U.S. wants McVeigh webcast lawsuit dismissed
April 12, 2001
Bill Press: McVeigh to die on television
April 13, 2001
Ashcroft OKs closed TV feed of McVeigh execution
April 11, 2001
FBI: McVeigh knew children would be killed in OKC blast
March 29, 2001
McVeigh autopsy deal says no 'invasive procedure'
March 18, 2001
McVeigh scheduled to die by lethal injection May 16
January 16, 2001
Judge says McVeigh can drop appeals
December 28, 2000

Federal Bureau of Investigation
U.S. Department of Justice
The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms
Oklahoma State Government
Death Penalty Information Center
US Federal Bureau of Prisons

Note: Pages will open in a new browser window
External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.



Back to the top