Skip to main content /LAW
CNN.com /LAW
CNN TV
EDITIONS
SERVICES
CNN TV
EDITIONS


find law dictionary
 

Report: Enron execs hid losses, made millions



NEW YORK (CNN) -- Enron executives reaped millions of dollars from off-the-books partnerships while the energy giant violated basic rules of accounting and ethics, according to a report commissioned by Enron's board of directors.

The report, released Saturday and conducted by outside investigators, said former Enron CEO Kenneth Lay personally approved some of the partnerships, criticizing him for functioning more as a director in the company than a real member of management.

When it was revealed last fall the partnerships had inflated Enron's earnings, it marked the beginning of Enron's financial collapse, leading to the Houston,Texas-based energy trader's eventual decision to file for bankruptcy in December.

After the partnerships were disclosed, Enron's board ousted Chief Financial Officer Andrew S. Fastow, who set them up.

"Enron employees involved in the partnerships were enriched, in the aggregate, by tens of millions of dollars they should never have received," said the so-called Powers Report, named for William Powers Jr., head of the special investigation committee that wrote it.

Powers is a member of Enron's board of directors and the dean of the University of Texas Law School. He was assisted in the investigation by former SEC investigators.

RESOURCES
Document: Powers Report
9.5MB (PDF)

VIDEO
CNN's Kelly Wallace reports on the Enron collapse and the widening investigation in Washington (February 2)

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)
 
MORE STORIES
Commerce, Treasury told to keep Enron papers 
 
Enron Collapse
 VIDEO/AUDIO
  •  Senate unit faults Enron board
  •  Corporate corruption in America
 MORE STORIES
  •  3 Britons charged in Enron fraud
  •  Bush pushes for tougher corporate rules
  •  Playboy exposes Enron workers
 EXTRA INFORMATION
  •  Document: Powers report
9.5MB (PDF)
  •  CNN/Money Special Report: Your 401(k)
  •  Timeline: Shredding through history
 RESOURCES
  •  In-Depth: The end of Enron?
  •  TIME.com: Inside the scandal

  LEGAL RESOURCES

Latest Legal News

Law Library

FindLaw Consumer Center
 

The report's authors said they have "no evidence that any of these employees, except [CFO] Fastow, obtained the permission required by Enron's Code of Conduct of Business Affairs to own interest in the partnerships."

It said Fastow garnered $30 million in profits from the arrangements.

None of the individual Enron executives named in the report returned CNN calls for comment.

"The report has made the board aware of numerous past events for the first time. These events are deeply regretted by the board," a statement from Enron said late Saturday.

The report, the result of a three-month long investigation, was filed with the federal bankruptcy court in New York, which is handling all the many claims to Enron's remaining assets. It was published Saturday afternoon on the court's Web site.

Management, the report said, "spent considerable time and effort working to say as little as possible" about one of the partnerships.

"These partnerships ... were used by Enron management to enter into transactions that it could not, or would not, do with unrelated commercial entities," according to the report.

"Many of the most significant transactions apparently were designed to accomplish favorable financial statement results, not to achieve bona fide economic objectives or transfer risk," the report said.

That effort, combined with how critical the partnerships were to Enron's finances, "should have raised red flags for senior management, as well as for Enron's outside auditors and lawyers."

Enron set up hundreds of partnerships to move debt and losses of its balance sheet. Such partnerships are legal if structured according to present accounting rules.

The report said the partnerships did not follow what it called "applicable accounting rules."

The Justice Department is conducting its own investigation of Enron's collapse. Congressional hearings into the matter began in January. Lay is scheduled to testify before a Senate committee Monday.

The report also leveled criticism at Enron's outside auditors, Arthur Andersen LLP, saying it made simple and not so simple accounting mistakes. It said the accounting firm was seemingly complicit in the maneuverings.

"In virtually all the transactions, Enron's accounting treatment was determined with extensive participation and structuring advice from Andersen, which management reported to the Board," report said.

Andersen appeared to profit from the partnership accounting, as well.

"Enron's records show that Andersen billed Enron $5.7 million for advice in connection with the LJM and Chewco transactions alone, above and beyond its regular audit fees," the report said.

Vinson & Elkins, Enron's main law firm, also came under fire. The report said it "should have brought a stronger, more objective and more critical voice to the disclosure process."

The Enron statement said the company's board was forming a restructuring committee, one of whose members will be Raymond Troubh, one of the independent directors who served on the investigation committee.

-- CNN Senior Correspondent Brooks Jackson contributed to this report.



 
 
 
 


RELATED STORIES:
RELATED SITES:
Note: Pages will open in a new browser window
External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.

LAW TOP STORIES:

 Search   

Back to the top