Skip to main content

Sotomayor would be part of court's Catholic shift

  • Story Highlights
  • If confirmed, Judge Sonia Sotomayor would be Supreme Court's sixth Catholic
  • Five current Catholic justices were appointed by Republican presidents
  • Catholic League president says Sotomayor would lean more left than other justices
By Lisa Desjardins
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font

WASHINGTON (CNN) -- As Supreme Court hopeful Sonia Sotomayor breaks ground for Hispanics, she is poised to add an exclamation point to another historic demographic shift: the move to a Catholic court.

If confirmed, Sonia Sotomayor would be the sixth Catholic justice on the U.S. Supreme Court.

If confirmed, Sonia Sotomayor would be the sixth Catholic justice on the U.S. Supreme Court.

Sotomayor was raised Catholic and if she is confirmed, six out of nine, or two-thirds of the justices on the court will be from the faith. Catholics make up about one-quarter of the U.S. population.

"It's most unusual," said Barbara Perry, a government professor at Sweetbriar College who was already writing a book about Catholics on the Supreme Court when Sotomayor was named as the next nominee.

"Presidents used to reserve a Catholic seat and a Jewish seat on the Supreme Court," Perry told CNN Radio. "Now we've moved from a Catholic seat on the court to a Catholic court."

Of the 110 people who have served on the Supreme Court, 11 have been Catholic. Five of those justices -- Samuel Alito, Anthony Kennedy, Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas and Chief Justice John Roberts -- are currently on the court.

"It is more than a random selection process that yielded the current five Catholics on the bench," Perry said.

The five current Catholic justices were appointed by Republican presidents, which Perry notes may be a key reason why so many Catholics have joined the high court in recent years.

"It's their tie to conservative Catholicism which made them agreeable to (Republican) presidents' ideology," she said.

Perry sees Catholics as swing voters with a base of socially conservative principles, and therefore naturally attractive for Republican presidents.

Catholic League President Bill Donohue goes further, hypothesizing that Catholics have conservative credentials on issues such as abortion, without the political baggage of terms such as the "religious right" or "evangelicals."

"Is it safer to nominate a Catholic as opposed to an evangelical to get votes? I think the answer is decidedly yes," Donohue said.

Donohue also suggests the vigorous education in Catholic schools during the 20th century produced sharp legal minds.

"I think there might be a certain kind of Catholic edge, so to speak, as a residual property of a Catholic education," he said.

Roberts, Scalia and Thomas attended Catholic school as children, as did Sotomayor. Video Watch more about Sotomayor's personal history »

Underlying causes aside, Perry sees the fast shift as a sign that centuries of American concern about Catholics are over.

In 1985, a lone Catholic justice, William J. Brennan, Jr., sat on the court. A generation later, that number is poised to become six.

"What that tells is that in our politics, religion doesn't matter anymore," Perry said. Then she added: "I don't think our politics are ready for an Islamic justice at this point."

The current court is composed of two Jewish members -- Justices Stephen Breyer and Ruth Bader Ginsburg. If Sotomayor joins the bench, Justice John Paul Stevens would be the solitary Protestant on a court once dominated by white Protestant men. Learn about the other Supreme Court justices »

Court observers wonder what, if anything, six Catholic justices would mean for Supreme Court decisions.

The five Catholics currently on the bench concurred in a 2007 decision, Gonzales v. Carhart, which upheld a state ban on late-term abortions.

Sotomayor has faced few abortion cases, and no tests on issues such gay rights or the death penalty. However, Donohue expects a Justice Sotomayor to lean more left than her fellow Catholics on the court. Read about Sotomayor's record »

"I think she's more reliably liberal," Donohue said.


Donohue said he still would like to see Sotomayor join the bench.

"Even though I'm a conservative and she is not, there's still a certain way that you do root for the home team," he said.

All About U.S. Supreme CourtSonia SotomayorThe Roman Catholic Church

  • E-mail
  • Save
  • Print