Skip to main content

Obama scraps Bush-era missile defense for new plan

  • Story Highlights
  • NEW: Polish, Czech leaders cautiously optimistic about U.S. commitment
  • Russian president: "We appreciate the responsible approach" of U.S. leader
  • Defense chief Robert Gates denies U.S. "scrapping" missile defense
  • Change of gears does creates diplomatic problems for U.S., expert says
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font

WASHINGTON (CNN) -- The United States is significantly overhauling Bush-era plans for a missile defense shield in Europe, based partly on the latest analysis of Iran's offensive capabilities, President Barack Obama said Thursday.

President Obama and Russian President Dmitry Medvedev met in Moscow in July.

President Obama on Thursday says the Bush-era missile defense plan will be replaced with a new system.

The "new missile defense architecture in Europe" will be ready faster, work with existing technology and provide better missile defense than the program proposed by former President George W. Bush, Obama said.

Obama said the change of gears was based on an "updated intelligence assessment" about Iran's ability to hit Europe with missiles.

The Islamic republic's "short- and medium-range" missiles pose the most current threat, he said, and "this new ballistic missile defense will best address" that threat.

A top expert at the Council on Foreign Relations backed Obama's decision.

"The system that President George W. Bush proposed ... would have deployed interceptor missiles that had yet to be tested under real-world conditions to defend against long-range missiles that Iran had yet to develop," said the council's senior vice president, James Lindsay.

"Meanwhile, the interceptors would have been useless against the short- and medium-range missiles that Iran is rapidly developing," he said in a written statement.

But the change of gears, while making strategic sense, does present Obama with diplomatic problems, Lindsay said.

"Poles and Czechs worry that his decision signals a softening U.S. commitment to their security. Both countries saw the system as a way to tie themselves more closely to the United States and thereby deter an increasingly belligerent Russia," he said.

"Critics will also insist that the Poles and Czechs are right: He axed the Bush program in a foolish and doomed bid to 'reset' relations with Russia," he said. "Here, Moscow isn't likely to be of much help to the White House. The Kremlin will claim a diplomatic victory and it won't offer any concessions in return."

Reaction from Poland and the Czech Republic was cautious, with leaders saying they were assured that the United States remained committed to a strong relationship and their security.

The Council on Foreign Relations released a report Thursday that said repeated technological failures had put the Bush missile plan behind schedule and likely over budget as well.

Defense Secretary Robert Gates, speaking from the Pentagon immediately after the president's announcement, denied the United States was "scrapping" missile defense.

"This new approach provides a better missile defense capability for our forces in Europe, for our European allies and eventually for our homeland than the program I recommended almost three years ago," he said. Video Watch as Obama says the new approach is suited to threats of 21st century »

Gates served as secretary of defense in the last two years of the Bush administration, and stayed on in the post when Obama took office.

The Bush-era proposal called for the United States to set up a radar site in the Czech Republic and 10 missile interceptors in Poland to counter the threat of Iran launching long-range missiles at America's allies in Europe. See how the system would have worked » | See a map of proposed sites under the Bush-era plan »

The new system will have "hundreds" of missile interceptors instead, the Pentagon's point man on it said.

It also will have mobile radars, including some in space, "that can move to wherever the threat actually emanates and wherever we feel we need to defend ourselves," said Gen. James Cartwright, vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

He contrasted the new sensor technology with the radar systems envisioned in the old plan, which he called "basically left over from the Cold War."

The new plans include three types of missiles to shoot down incoming threats -- Patriot missiles, which defend a single location; SM-3 interceptors, which he said could protect "a general area like the area from Philadelphia to Washington, D.C.;" and large ground-based interceptors in Alaska and California.

Pentagon spokesman Geoff Morrell said that the Missile Defense Agency's budget would remain the same through fiscal year 2015.

"Now that the plan is official, we are working with MDA (Missile Defense Agency) to review all costs," he said.

The Government Accountability Office reported in February that the MDA had spent about $56 billion since since 2002 and is budgeted to spend an additional $50 billion through 2013.

The European strategy, the MDA said, was budgeted at $4.5 billion.

Cartwright did not say how much the new plan would cost compared with the old one, but pointed out that Patriot and SM-3 missiles were significantly cheaper than the interceptors the Bush proposal relied on.

"You do not want to go after large numbers (of missiles) with the very expensive missiles unless it's absolutely essential," he said.

He said the fact that the United States sells Patriot and Aegis systems to other countries reduces the cost to Washington. The SM-3 missiles are part of the Aegis Ballistic Missile Defense system.

Other countries, he said, are helping to fund the research and development of the systems.

The first phase of the system is due to be in place in 2011, with the subsequent phases rolling out around 2015, 2018 and 2020, he said.

Obama's Republican adversaries were quick to accuse him of selling out allies to placate Russia.

The "decision calls into question the security and diplomatic commitments the United States has made to Poland and the Czech Republic," said U.S. Senator John McCain of Arizona, the 2008 Republican nominee for president.

Russia's President Dmitry Medvedev welcomed Obama's statement with televised remarks from Moscow. Video Watch how Obama's plan may affect U.S.-Russian ties »

"We appreciate the responsible approach of the U.S. president," he said, characterizing the new U.S. position as "putting into practice" an agreement he made with Obama earlier this year.

"I discussed this issue with the U.S. president during our meetings in London and Moscow. At that time, in our joint statement, we agreed to, and set in stone that Russia and the United States will seek to work together to assess the risks of missile proliferation in the world," Medvedev said. Video Watch CNN's Matthew Chance report on the U.S. missile defense shield »

Russia's ambassador to the United Nations grinned when asked if he had heard Obama's announcement.

"Oh, yes," Vitaly Churkin said with a smile.

Missile defense has been a sore point in relations between Washington and Moscow, with Russia believing the shield would ultimately erode its own strategic nuclear deterrent.

Obama has been seeking a stronger relationship with Russia and better cooperation from the Kremlin to support tough U.N. economic sanctions against Iran if it continues to pursue its nuclear ambitions.

Obama has maintained that Russia had nothing to fear from a U.S. missile defense system, which would be designed to intercept a solitary missile from Iran or North Korea, as opposed to "a mighty Russian arsenal."

A senior administration official flatly denied a diplomatic motive to scrapping the missile defense program.

"This has nothing to do with Russia," the official said before Obama made his announcement Thursday morning. "The notion that we're abandoning missile defense is completely false. It's evolving into a different system."

A U.S. delegation held high-level meetings Thursday in both Poland and the Czech Republic to discuss the missile defense system.

Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk told reporters he spoke to Obama and other U.S. officials and received "certain other signals" that left him cautiously optimistic about "Poland's future security and our relationship with the United States."

Czech Prime Minister Jan Fischer issued a statement saying that Obama told him in a Wednesday phone call that the United States would shelve its plans.


"At the NATO summit in April, we adopted a resolution focusing on building a defense system against real, existing threats, i.e. short-range and medium-range missiles," Fischer said. "We expect that the United States will continue cooperating with the Czech Republic on concluding the relevant agreements on our mutual (research and development) and military collaboration, including the financing of specific projects."

American officials, including Obama, insisted Thursday's announcement did not reflect any lesser commitment to European defense.

CNN's Suzanne Malveaux and Barbara Starr in Washington, Per Nyberg in London, England, Matthew Chance and Michael Sefanov in Moscow, Russia, and Richard Roth at the United Nations contributed to this report.

All About RussiaPolandCzech Republic

  • E-mail
  • Save
  • Print