Skip to main content

Trump brings peace to Miss California USA imbroglio

  • Story Highlights
  • Carrie Prejean to keep title despite disputes over photos, duties
  • Donald Trump, who owns the pageant, made final decision
  • Seminude photos don't violate contract Prejean signed, Trump says
  • Prejean initially in news for her response to question about same-sex marriage
By Alan Duke
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font

(CNN) -- Donald Trump will let Miss California USA Carrie Prejean keep her title despite controversy over seminude photos and charges by state pageant officials that she had abandoned her duties to devote time to opposition to same-sex marriage.

Donald Trump, who owns the pageant, made the announcement at a Tuesday news conference.

Miss California USA Carrie Prejean caused controversy with remarks she made at the Miss USA pageant.

Trump, no apprentice at turning a negative into positive publicity, brought several weeks of controversy to a conclusion at his New York headquarters Tuesday with winners all around.

Trump said his Miss USA pageant stays "so relevant," unlike the rival Miss America pageant seen only on a small cable channel.

Prejean gained a national following that could help her post-pageant career. Video Watch Prejean defend herself »

The Miss California USA organization has a beauty queen better known than the woman who won the Miss USA title -- Kristen Dalton of North Carolina.

Celebrity bloggers, such as Perez Hilton, whose question to Prejean ignited the firestorm, gained a higher profile and more readers for their Web sites.

And groups both for and against same-sex marriage gained energy for their fundraising and publicity campaigns.

Prejean stepped into the limelight unexpectedly just over three weeks ago when she declared her opposition to same-sex marriage in response to a question asked during the national pageant by Hilton, a pageant judge. Video Watch Hilton get dismissive »

Prejean finished as first runner-up, but it was not clear if her answer cost her the crown.

"He [Hilton] gave her very low marks," Trump said. "It certainly didn't help."

Hilton, who is openly gay and a strong supporter of same-sex marriage, later posted a video rant online in which he called Prejean "a dumb bitch."

This caught the national mainstream media's attention, and Hilton was invited to appear on TV shows to talk about it.

Prejean -- with pageant approval -- also talked publicly about her same-sex marriage opposition.

But when she appeared at a news conference for the National Organization for Marriage, a same-sex marriage opposition group, the controversy intensified.

Lawyers for the Miss USA group demanded that NOM stop using video clips of the pageant in its TV ads.

The controversy boiled to a new level last week when a photo of Prejean, wearing only pink panties but showing mainly a bare back, was published by gossip Web sites.

Miss California USA officials -- some of them outspoken advocates of same-sex marriage -- suggested that the seminude photo breached the contract Prejean signed with the pageant. Her title might be taken away, they said. Video Watch Miss California USA offficials scold Prejean »

These officials also complained they couldn't reach Prejean and she had missed important pageant events. They charged that their beauty queen had been hijacked by anti-same-sex marriage forces.

But it was up to Trump, who bought the Miss USA and Miss Universe pageants a decade ago, to decide what to do about Carrie Prejean.

Trump united her with California pageant co-executive directors Shanna Moakler -- a former Playboy centerfold -- and Keith Lewis in his New York office Tuesday morning for a peacemaking session.

It ended with hugs and smiles at Trump's news conference. Video Watch Trump's announcement »

Those photos of a topless Prejean do not violate the contract she signed when entering the pageant competition, Trump said.

"Some were very beautiful," he said. "Some were risque, but again, we're in the 21st century."

Trump praised Prejean for giving a "very, very honest answer" to a tough question during the pageant.

"It's the same answer that the president of the United States gave," he said.

And he said he would not hesitate to invite Hilton back as a pageant judge, despite the firestorm he set off.

"He's doing his thing," Trump said. "What's the big deal?"

"We want tough questions," he said. "We don't want to be in a position that Miss America is in that they're now on a small cable channel."

He noted that NBC recently extended the Miss USA and Miss Universe TV contracts for three years.

Prejean said she has forgiven Hilton and the other critical bloggers.

"I willingly forgive them before all of you today," she told reporters.

She said she was the victim of "hateful attacks, despicable rumors and false allegations" for exercising her freedom of speech, but the situation has given her a new message to carry as a role model to young people.

"Think about how much better our society would be if we could just agree to disagree and show respect," she said.


As she resumes public appearances as Miss California USA, Prejean said she will not be an activist against same-sex marriage.

"I'm going to resume my duties as Miss California, but also stay true to who I am and have my own personal opinions," she said. "We will see how we will balance the two."

All About Donald TrumpCarrie PrejeanPerez Hilton

  • E-mail
  • Save
  • Print