Skip to main content

Gates: Persuasion better tack against Iran's nuclear pursuits

  • Story Highlights
  • Defense chief: Striking at Iran's nuclear program wouldn't deter their continued efforts
  • Gates' suggestion: Convince Iran it would trigger an arms race and be less secure
  • Gates, Secretary of State Clinton appeared before the Senate Appropriations panel
  • Other big issues: Relocation of Gitmo terrorists, situation in Pakistan
From Mike Mount
CNN Senior Pentagon Producer
Decrease font Decrease font
Enlarge font Enlarge font

WASHINGTON (CNN) -- U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates said Thursday that a military strike on Iran's nuclear program would not stop that country from pursuing the development of a nuclear weapon.

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Defense Secretary Robert Gates appear before Senate committee Thursday.

Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Defense Secretary Robert Gates appear before Senate committee Thursday.

Gates told a Senate panel that a military option would only delay Iran's nuclear ambitions and would further drive it underground, making it more difficult to monitor.

Gates said the better option would be for the U.S. and its allies to convince Iran that building a nuclear program would start an arms race that would leave Iran less secure.

"Their security interests are actually badly served by trying to have nuclear weapons," Gates said. "They will start a nuclear arms race in the Middle East and they will be less secure at the end than they are now."

Gates was joined by Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in an appearance before the Senate Appropriations Committee Thursday to discuss the 2009 supplemental budget request.

Clinton and Gates told the panel that the U.S. and its allies should pressure Iran with tougher sanctions.

"We do have intensive consultation efforts going on with our friends and like-minded nations, not only in the region but elsewhere in the world, concerning the threats that Iran poses," Clinton said.

Gates said the U.S. should partner with Russia on missile defense programs in the region to isolate Iran, an issue that has soured relations with Russia recently.

"I think there is value in pursuing a partnership with the Russians on missile defense in Europe and in Russia itself," Gates continued, but did not elaborate.

Another hot-button issue touched off questions by panel members worried about the final destination of suspected terrorists held at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

Gates said the relocation to the United States of dozens of suspected terrorists held by the U.S. in Cuba is being discussed by U.S. authorities this week.

Gates told senators the Department of Justice has started working on relocation plans within the United States for detainees who cannot be tried or transferred to another country.

The issue of moving the detainees is a touchy subject among politicians who do not want the high-profile prisoners in their "backyards."

Gates told Committee members he understands that the majority of Congressional members will file legislation barring the U.S. from moving the detainees to their states.

While the Department of Justice is sorting through the 241 detainee cases to see who will not be put on trial or be taken by other countries, Gates said the number will most likely fall between 50 and 100 that could be relocated.

"There clearly will be a specific plan that comes out of this, but what we've had to await is the determination, roughly speaking, of about how big a group of people we will be talking about. And so the review of each of these case files has to precede the development of a specific plan in terms of where the prisoners would go," Gates said.

An early possibility is the Army's prison facility at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, which is being considered as a site to build a detention facility especially for the detainees. Video Watch Sen. Mitch McConnell's exchange with Defense Secretary Robert Gates »

Kansans have been outspoken about rejecting the idea, and panel member Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kansas, started his questioning of Gates with a plea.

"Please not at Leavenworth. I think you should look overall, and I'm glad you're looking at Europe with that," he said.

"It's a hot topic with your commander at that base, whose primary mission is educational," Brownback continued.

"What we are attempting to do is try to convince other countries to take back their own nationalities of detainees and perhaps even others," Clinton said when asked about the status of the closing down the detention facility.

Senators were also concerned whether the current Pakistani leadership understands what is happening inside that country.

As Taliban forces threaten to move closer to the capital Islamabad, and instability throughout the country looms, Gates likened the struggle to a familiar fight in the U.S.

"The United States was first attacked by al Qaida in 1993. Al Qaida was at war with the United States for eight years before we decided we were at war with al Qaida," Gates said. "I think the same kind of thing has kind of happened in Pakistan, the Pakistanis haven't realized the threat that has been posed to them over the last several years," he said.


In a follow up to Gates' answer, Sen. Richard Shelby, R-Alabama, asked Gates, "If this is not a wake-up call, I don't know what could be. Do you?"

Gates simply replied, "I agree."

All About Nuclear WeaponsGuantanamo BayHillary ClintonRobert GatesIranPakistan

  • E-mail
  • Save
  • Print