Skip to main content

After the quakes: Are Japan's nuclear plants safe?

By Paul Armstrong, CNN
Japan's Kashiwazaki-Kariwa nuclear power plant, where four reactors automatically shut down after an earthquake in 2007.
Japan's Kashiwazaki-Kariwa nuclear power plant, where four reactors automatically shut down after an earthquake in 2007.
  • Four nuclear power plants in eastern Japan shut down after massive earthquake
  • Authorities pumping cooling water into overheating reactor in one plant
  • Similar cooling malfunction at Three Mile Island plant in U.S. in 1979
  • Expert: Modern plants expensive to build because of number of in-built safety measures

(CNN) -- Four nuclear power plants appear to have survived the 8.9-magnitude earthquake which rocked Japan Friday triggering a massive tsunami, according to Japanese authorities.

The plants were all safely shut down, authorities said, though residents near one of the facilities on Japan's east coast have been evacuated as a precautionary measure because one of its reactors cannot cool down.

How serious is this?

The plant's operators have several hours to pump emergency cooling water to the overheating reactor, according to Malcolm Grimston, a nuclear energy expert from Britain's Chatham House think-tank. "They just need to keep water flowing over the core at this stage. There's nothing cleverer to it than that," he said.

Evacuations ordered near nuclear plant

"If this cooling process fails and some of the fuel in the reactor starts to melt, then that would write off the reactor as a commercial concern -- and that is a huge consideration as they are very expensive. But even at this stage you wouldn't get much in the way of airborne releases of radioactive material."

Moment of the Japan quake
Gallery: Massive quake hits Japan

But if the fuel has time to melt to the bottom of the reactor, then there is the possibility of it getting into water supplies, though this scenario is much further down the line, he said.

Grimston cited the example of a similar cooling malfunction at the Three Mile Island nuclear plant in the United States in 1979, when part of a reactor core melted. The incident caused no injuries or significant releases of hazardous material.

The fact the plant reactors had been shut down and the generation of energy -- known as the fission process -- halted, did much to avoid the lethal radioactive fallout witnessed during the Chernobyl disaster in 1986. This occurred when scientists at the former Soviet plant in the Ukraine failed to shut down an overheating reactor during an experiment, leading to two devastating explosions.

How vulnerable are nuclear plants to natural disasters?

Modern nuclear plants -- especially the Japanese designs -- are hugely expensive to build because of the number of in-built safety measures, experts say. According to Grimston, the Chernobyl plant -- by far the most significant accident at a nuclear facility -- differed from accepted standards in that its four reactors were not housed in a reinforced concrete shell.

Its reactor design was also considered unstable, unlike its western counterparts which shut down very easily. "This is the point the Japanese authorities are trying to make," said Grimston. "The reactors in their plants shut down as they are designed to do.

The reactors in their plants shut down as they are designed to do.
--Nuclear expert Malcolm Grimston

"Even at Three Mile Island the fission process was successfully stopped as soon as the incident started. This gave them many hours to decide on a course of action which safeguarded people."

The core in the very middle of a modern nuclear power station is typically encased in a thick concrete and steel shell, mounted on a type of spring -- particularly in earthquake zones.

"They absorb much of the impact of the ground movement," added Grimston. "So breaching that is pretty much impossible to imagine.

"But the circuit which carries the water that keeps the reactor core cool is the potential vulnerable point. If this cracks -- perfectly feasible in an earthquake situation -- then it loses water and doesn't protect the core it the way it is meant to."

What happens next in these circumstances?

This is when the next safety stage begins -- pumping emergency cooling water into the core. This appears to be what is happening at the Fukushima Daiichi power plant in Japan.

According to Grimston, poor instrumentation at Three Mile Island led plant officials to switch off the circuit which would have cooled the reactor core. As a result the core was left uncovered and 30-40% of the core melted.

"Much was learned from this accident, with much done with the instrumentation to reduce the extent to which operators can intervene in the automatic safety system," he said.

Do nuclear plants have failsafe systems?

Yes. They are designed with an inter-connected system of fail-safes that ensure there are multiple ways of counteracting a malfunction.

According to the World Nuclear Association, all modern nuclear plants in the western world operate using a "defense-in-depth" approach. This includes:

- High-quality design and construction

- Equipment to prevent operational disturbances or human failures and errors developing into problems

- Comprehensive monitoring and regular testing to detect equipment or operator failures

- Redundant and diverse systems to control damage to the fuel and prevent significant radioactive releases

- Provision to confine the effects of severe fuel damage to the plant itself.

Part of complete coverage on
Wedding bells toll post-quake
One effect of Japan's deadly quake has been to remind many of the importance of family and to drive them to the altar.
Toyota makes drastic production cuts
Toyota has announced drastic production cuts due to difficulty in supplying parts following the earthquake in Japan.
Chernobyl's 25-year shadow
There's an eerie stillness about the desolate buildings and empty streets of Pripyat.
Inside evacuation 'ghost town'
A photographer documents the ghost town left behind by the nuclear crisis in Japan. What he found was a "time stop."
One month since the quake
Somber ceremonies mark one month since the earthquake and tsunami killed as many as 25,000 people.
First moments of a tsunami
Witnesses capture the very first moments of the devastating tsunami that struck Japan in March.
The 'nuclear renaissance' that wasn't
A month after a devastating earthquake sent a wall of water across the Japanese landscape, the global terrain of the atomic power industry has been forever altered.
Drone peers into damaged reactors
Engineers use a flying drone to peer into the damaged reactors at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant.