How Colombia is busting drug cartels

Police guard alleged members of the 'Loco Barrera' (Crazy Barrera) drug trafficking ring. The U.S. wants them extradited.

Story highlights

  • William Rempel: Colombia is fighting drug lords by allowing extradition to U.S.
  • Rempel: Extradition doesn't stop smuggling, but it damages cartels
  • Traffickers in U.S. cells can't run operations from luxury prisons in Colombia, he says
  • Rempel says Mexico should take lessons from Colombia's successful strategy

Gruesome and seemingly endless accounts of violence in Mexico have obscured one notable bright spot in Latin America's high-stakes struggle with powerful drug gangs. In Colombia, once home to the world's biggest cocaine cartels, new crime organizations are being picked apart with silent efficiency -- aided by Bogota's enthusiastic embrace of extradition.

In recent years, more than 1,300 of Colombia's top crime bosses and their most dangerous enforcers have been sent north to face trafficking charges in the United States, a dramatic turnabout from the 1990s when extradition was outlawed under coercive pressure from the Medellin and Cali cartels.

Traffickers who might have continued to operate their drug organizations from luxury prison cells near their Colombian homes find themselves serving extended terms far away in U.S. penitentiaries without wall-to-wall carpets, big-screen TVs or easy phone access. Many offer to become witnesses hoping to reduce their sentences.

The result has been a steady erosion of organized crime's capabilities in Colombia -- a lesson for Mexico and other countries in the region threatened by drug gangs. Mexico's historic reluctance to extradite its citizens to the United States should be reassessed in the face of Colombia's success.

The beauty of extradition as practiced by Colombia is not its power to stop drug smuggling. There is scant evidence it has had much direct effect in that regard. But it continues to splinter the leadership of trafficking gangs, keeping them in a perpetual state of rebuilding. In short, extradition disorganizes organized crime.

William Rempel

And that's what makes it such a winning strategy in a country once thoroughly compromised by cartel threats and bribes. In those days, barely 20 years ago, the Medellin and Cali cartels vied for power with the Bogota government that too often seemed to be a hostage to criminal forces. Extradition became the prize they fought over.

Pablo Escobar, once the most feared thug in the drug world, was so afraid of being carted off for trial in Florida or Texas or New York that he demanded an end to extradition. He famously insisted that he preferred "the grave in Colombia" to a prison cell in the States. But when his demands were unheeded, Escobar launched a terror campaign of political assassination, socialite kidnappings, and deadly bombings.

While Escobar went to war, rival Cali cartel bosses went to the bank. They spread favors of cash, women and Caribbean vacations to any and all receptive politicians. Democracy was no match for the combined forces of corruption and intimidation. Colombia capitulated to the drug kings and let cartel lawyers rewrite portions of the national constitution to outlaw extradition.

It was banned for more than six years until restored in December 1997. More recently, its use soared as part of former President Alvaro Uribe's campaign to disarm and demobilize narco-trafficking paramilitary groups. And he put extradition processing on a fast track after discovering that imprisoned gangsters were still running criminal enterprises from their Colombian jails.

Colombia remains highly motivated today by fear of a return to the bad old days when criminal demands trumped national interests. And its success has been noticed. Mexico is showing more willingness to extradite Mexican nationals accused of major trafficking offenses in the U.S., but its numbers are small compared with Colombia's.

About a dozen Mexican drug bosses are in various stages of extradition, a cumbersome and often frustrating process that can take two to five years. U.S. authorities complain that, among other things, Mexico requires excessive documentation before approving extradition applications -- notably the identities of certain key witnesses that can jeopardize their safety.

Some of the lingering reluctance comes from national pride, from the conviction that Mexico should and can take care of its own crime problems. To that end, Mexican anti-narcotics units have been beefed up and security at its federal prisons improved. But that's not enough.

"There's no prison anywhere in Mexico or Colombia that puts these guys out of business like U.S. prisons," says one American law enforcement official.

There is a cost, of course. Federal prosecutions and extended incarcerations are expensive. Yet, what are the alternatives? When Colombia was overrun by cartels, the U.S. poured in a billion dollars of aid to help a friend and ally fight back. Recently, Texas Gov. Rick Perry suggested sending U.S. troops to help Mexico, an option loaded with political as well as financial costs. It only underscores the point: Extradition is a bargain.

It's also the most potent weapon against organized crime available in the region. Mexico and its Central American neighbors should embrace it with Colombian enthusiasm.

Jorge Salcedo: What I saw inside the Cali cartel

Join CNN Opinion on Facebook and follow updates on Twitter

        Mexico drug war

      • Pictures of Mario Armando Ramirez Trevino, aka 'El Pelon' or 'X-20' - alleged leader of Cartel del Golfo - are presented during a press conference at the Interior Ministry building in Mexico City, on August 18, 2013. AFP PHOTO/ALFREDO ESTRELLA (Photo credit should read ALFREDO ESTRELLA/AFP/Getty Images)

        Alleged Gulf Cartel chief nabbed

        Suspected cartel chief Mario Armando Ramirez Trevino, aka X-20, was caught near Texas with thousands in cash, said Mexico's government.
      • Vanishing victims

        The death toll of Mexico's drug war grabs global attention, but forced disappearances are also a troubling problem that Mexico faces.
      • An armored car carries troops through Mexico City's historic center. The gun battles, mass graves and fiery road blockades in other parts of the country are not part of daily life in Mexico's capital.

        Is Mexico City next target?

        Once dogged by a crime-ridden reputation, Mexico's capital has become a refuge. But in Mexico's drug war, are there any sanctuaries?
      • A 14-year-old boy was found guilty last year of torturing and beheading at least four people for the South Pacific drug cartel.

        Children in Mexico

        At least 30,000 children in Mexico are involved in some sort of organized crime, according to an alliance of civic and social groups.
      • our of seven alleged drug traffickers members of the 'Rastrojos' gang of the Cali Cartel cover their faces during a press conference on January 15, 2009, in Bogota. A

        What I saw inside a drug cartel

        Jorge Salcedo, an ex-member of the Cali drug cartel, writes about life inside the group: "Corruption is the oxygen that keeps organized crime alive."
      • Bundles of cash siezed by the DEA during a drug bust.

        Unlikely front in drug war

        In suburbs and small towns across the U.S., police are increasingly finding drugs, guns and money they can trace to Mexican cartels.
      • Border Patrol officers roam the U.S. side of the border. Palomas, Mexico, is the sister city to Columbs.

        A border town robbed of trust

        A New Mexico town struggles for survival and redemption after its mayor, police chief and village trustee sold out, running guns to cartels.
      • CNNMexico.com

        Follow the latest news, features and analysis from a Mexico perspective and in Spanish at CNNMexico.com