Skip to main content

Blowing in the wind? Trump threatens to ditch $1B Scottish golf resort

By Paul Gittings, CNN
March 1, 2012 -- Updated 1138 GMT (1938 HKT)
Donald Trump received a bagpipe welcome on one of his visits to the site of his championship course in Aberdeenshire. Donald Trump received a bagpipe welcome on one of his visits to the site of his championship course in Aberdeenshire.
Scotland welcomes Trump
Classic links course
Carved from giant dunes
Wind farm plan angers Trump
First Minister must decide
Golf course plans in the balance
  • Donald Trump threatens to pull plug on $1.2 billion Scottish golf course development
  • American tycoon angered by plans to build giant wind farm nearby in Aberdeenshire
  • Final decision on renewable energy project rests with Marine Scotland later in 2012
  • Trump appeals directly to Scotland's First Minister Alex Salmond in a letter

(CNN) -- When the first sod was laid on Donald Trump's billion-dollar championship golf resort in Scotland last April, few people could have predicted that less than a year later the whole project would be under threat.

The flamboyant American billionaire has publicly stated his intention of building "the greatest golf course in the world" on a stretch of protected sand dunes on the Aberdeenshire coast near Menie.

After a five-year planning battle to face down the objections of local campaigners and environmental groups, Trump himself cut the ribbon to start construction work in June 2010 -- and progress since then has been swift.

The 18-hole championship links course, designed by leading golf architect Dr. Martin Hawtree, will open in mid-2012.

You seem hell-bent on destroying Scotland's coastline and Scotland itself
Donald Trump

But the accompanying hotel and leisure resort, nearly 1,500 holiday homes and houses plus a second course have been put on hold because of plans by a leading renewable energy supplier, Vattenfall, to build 11 giant wind turbines about a mile and a half (2 km) off the coast from Trump's land.

He has reacted furiously by threatening to mothball the project, and reportedly donated £10 million ($15.9 million) to an anti-wind farm group, Communities against Turbines Scotland.

Political dilemma

Caught in the middle of the verbal crossfire is Scotland's political leader Alex Salmond, who has boasted that the country will generate all its electricity demands from renewables by 2020.

The First Minister, who is the Member of Scottish Parliament (MSP) for the area that covers the Aberdeenshire course, has supported the Trump project because of the jobs and economic regeneration it promises to bring.

But his views on the wind farm application, which will be ruled on by a governmental body called Marine Scotland, have yet to be made public. Salmond's office told CNN that he could not comment, but issued the following statement.

We were consistently told that there would not be wind turbines in this area of the coastline
George Sorial

"An application for consent for the European Offshore Wind Deployment Center was submitted to Marine Scotland on 2 August 2011 and is still under consideration. We have a target of determining applications in nine months from receipt and we are currently considering the views of consultees, interested parties, and the public."

But Trump clearly believes Salmond is sympathetic to the application and launched a verbal broadside in a letter dated February 9, 2012 in which he claimed that subsidizing wind farm projects would "destroy Scotland and its economy."

"You seem hell-bent on destroying Scotland's coastline and Scotland itself," it read. "With this reckless installation of these monsters, you will have single-handedly done more damage to Scotland than any event in its history."

Promises not kept?

George Sorial, Trump's attorney, told CNN that his boss was so angry because he believes the Scottish authorities had not kept to promises made back in 2006.

"We were consistently told that there would not be wind turbines in this area of the coastline," he said.

Salmond's Scottish National Party was not in power back in 2006, but Lewis MacDonald, a senior member of the then ruling Labour Party, said he believed no such undertakings were given by its First Minister Jack McConnell.

MacDonald is also an MSP for the Aberdeenshire region, and until recently was shadow minister for energy.

It would be a great shame if the development did not go ahead
Lewis Macdonald, MSP

Like political adversary Salmond, he supported the Trump project, but believes the tycoon is misguided in his opposition to the turbines.

"It would be a great shame if the development did not go ahead," he told CNN. "The fact you are an interested party in one planning application does not give you a veto over another.

"Offshore wind development has great economic potential for Scotland and will help shift the emphasis from oil and gas to renewables over the coming generations."

Finding a compromise

David Rodger, a spokesman for Vattenfall, which has been given €40 million ($54 million) by the European Union to fund its project, is urging Trump's team to compromise.

"Our point of view is that both these projects can exist in harmony," Rodger told CNN. "This project has been no secret and has been six years in development. It will test the next generation of off-shore wind turbines and would be a world first.

"We have been involved a close dialogue with all stakeholders and believe we have found the best site for the project."

Our point of view is that both these projects can exist in harmony
David Rodger, Vattenfall

None of this washes with Sorial, who is adamant that whatever Marine Scotland's decision, the Trump team will fight on.

"It's a war of attrition and we are in a superior position," he said.

MacDonald said there are few avenues of appeal in the event of Vattenfall's application being given the go-head by Marine Scotland.

"Vattenfall have already made significant steps to accommodate other users and reduce the scale of the wind farm, they cannot be criticized for not responding to concerns," he said.

Scottish roots

But Trump, who counts some of the most powerful men in the world as his acquaintances, is not used to losing a battle and is appealing to the country's political leader to use his influence.

I am doing this to save Scotland, and honor my mother, Mary MacLeod, who as you know was born and raised in Stornoway
Donald Trump

"Please understand, I am doing this to save Scotland, and honor my mother, Mary MacLeod, who as you know was born and raised in Stornoway. She would not believe what you are doing to her beloved Scotland!" Trump signed off his letter to Salmond.

By the time Trump comes to northern Scotland in June to open his championship links, the result of Vattenfall's planning application will be known.

What happens next will be anyone's guess, but for now Trump's planned $1.2 billion investment appears in the balance and has left Salmond, who is renowned as being "canny," with a difficult dilemma.

And in a sign that Trump may be turning his attentions elsewhere, his organization announced it would be buying the famous Doral Resort & Spa in Florida out of bankruptcy for $150 million.

The 800-acre resort complex -- which hosts the 2012 edition of the WGC-Cadillac Championship in early March -- includes four golf courses, 700 hotel rooms across 10 lodges and a range of other retail and leisure facilities.

It has been in bankruptcy since early 2011 after the property market turned sour in the United States.

Part of complete coverage on
December 18, 2014 -- Updated 1547 GMT (2347 HKT)
If golf has a reputation for being a bit stuffy, then the Bryan brothers and their trick shots are a much-needed blast of fresh air.
December 11, 2014 -- Updated 1318 GMT (2118 HKT)
Not many people make the leap from teenage market trader to golf pro and fashion entrepreneur, but that's just what Ian Poulter has done.
November 12, 2014 -- Updated 1129 GMT (1929 HKT)
"Sleep, as far as mental and physical recovery goes, has never been more important ..." says sport sleep coach Nick Littlehales.
November 4, 2014 -- Updated 1024 GMT (1824 HKT)
Joe Miller is devouring his second steak of the day and the clock has barely nudged 2pm. You need lots of fuel to smash a drive 474 yards.
October 13, 2014 -- Updated 1449 GMT (2249 HKT)
There have been many dark days for Oliver Wilson, but golf's unluckiest loser is finally riding an upward swing of his career roller coaster.
October 7, 2014 -- Updated 1648 GMT (0048 HKT)
They dress like it's the 1930s and they swing antique equipment that eschews cutting-edge technology -- this is hickory golf.
September 15, 2014 -- Updated 1609 GMT (0009 HKT)
CNN's Living Golf focuses on women's golf, charting the growth of the sport from royal pastime to multi-million dollar machine.
October 1, 2014 -- Updated 0846 GMT (1646 HKT)
"I don't know how to paint happy," says golf's poster girl Michelle Wie. "I think it releases a lot of the darker feelings in me."
September 29, 2014 -- Updated 1213 GMT (2013 HKT)
Phil Mickelson of the United States talks during a press conference after the United States were defeated by Europe after the Singles Matches of the 2014 Ryder Cup on the PGA Centenary course at the Gleneagles Hotel on September 28, 2014 in Auchterarder, Scotland.
If you're a U.S. golf fan, or Tom Watson, look away now.
September 25, 2014 -- Updated 2318 GMT (0718 HKT)
A ban on uploading social media pictures from the course at Gleneagles was dropped for the Ryder Cup.
September 24, 2014 -- Updated 1052 GMT (1852 HKT)
A spot of shopping, the odd spa day and some serious flag waving. Welcome to the life of a Ryder Cup WAG.
September 23, 2014 -- Updated 1301 GMT (2101 HKT)
Tom Watson has learned plenty in the 21 years since he was last U.S. Ryder Cup captain, but social media is proving to be problematic.
September 22, 2014 -- Updated 1243 GMT (2043 HKT)
Patriotism will reach fever pitch when the USA and Europe collide in golf's Ryder Cup ... and it looks like Rickie Fowler has let it go to his head.
September 22, 2014 -- Updated 1342 GMT (2142 HKT)
Pressure is inescapable in the cauldron of Ryder Cup competition -- pressure and ping pong.
September 23, 2014 -- Updated 1150 GMT (1950 HKT)
Millions of golf fans were watching on television with great anticipation. All Martin Kaymer could think about was getting his phone out.