Apple moves to share cost burden in China

CEO Tim Cook tours a Foxconn plant in Zhengzhou, China on Wednesday, March 28. The plant employs 120,000 workers.

Story highlights

  • CEO Tim Cook toured Chinese factories that make Apple products
  • Visit coincided with release of report that found numerous working violations
  • Intended to soothe criticism of Apple profiting from low-paid workers in poor conditions

The tour of China by Tim Cook this week had all the trappings of an official visit by a popular head of state.

There were the staged photos of the Apple chief executive's handshake with the Chinese vice-premier and of his visit to an iPhone production line, not forgetting the "man of the people" shot of him posing with customers at an Apple store.

Mr Cook is, after all, the head of a company whose $108bn in sales in its last fiscal year was equivalent to the gross domestic product of Iraq.

The Apple chief appeared to be revered and his attention to China appreciated by ordinary people.

"It is laudable that he shows up here, where people work so hard to make Apple products and spend so much money to buy them," said one of many comments on Sina Weibo, China's leading Twitter equivalent.

But while this was, by all accounts, a successful diplomatic and trade mission, its political implications spread well beyond China's borders. The visit appeared timed to coincide with Thursday's release of the Fair Labor Association's report on conditions in Chinese factories where Apple products are made. It found at least 50 "serious and pressing non-compliances" with its own workplace code of conduct and Chinese labour law.

Apple's welcoming of the report's recommendations and Mr Cook's visit to the factory floor seemed intended to soothe international criticism that alleged Apple made huge profits on the back of poorly paid and badly treated assembly workers in China.

Foxconn audit shows 'excessive overtime'
Foxconn audit shows 'excessive overtime'


    Foxconn audit shows 'excessive overtime'


Foxconn audit shows 'excessive overtime' 06:48
Audit of Foxconn finds major violations
Audit of Foxconn finds major violations


    Audit of Foxconn finds major violations


Audit of Foxconn finds major violations 03:43
Reporter: Daisey story didn't ring true
Reporter: Daisey story didn't ring true


    Reporter: Daisey story didn't ring true


Reporter: Daisey story didn't ring true 04:45
Chinese writers sue Apple
Chinese writers sue Apple


    Chinese writers sue Apple


Chinese writers sue Apple 02:13
Apple legal headache over iPad in China
Apple legal headache over iPad in China


    Apple legal headache over iPad in China


Apple legal headache over iPad in China 02:33

Dozens of labour rights organisations from the US to Poland, India and Indonesia wrote an open letter to Mr Cook this week demanding Apple provide a living wage for Chinese workers so they did not have to work excessive overtime. They wanted an end to the use of involuntary labour in the shape of student interns and called for staff to be given health and safety training and the ability to form a genuine trade union.

The recommendations of the FLA and the agreement to them by Apple and its main supplier Foxconn appear to answer these points. There were commitments that would reduce working hours to legal limits while protecting pay and improving conditions.

"If implemented, these commitments will significantly improve the lives of more than 1.2m Foxconn employees and set a new standard for Chinese factories," said Auret van Heerden, FLA president.

But perceptions of Chinese conditions and Apple and Foxconn's behaviour are different in China itself, where jobs in the factories are seen as highly desirable and paying well above the going rate. A queue of 1,000 people awaited interviews outside a Foxconn facility near Shenzhen last month.

A younger generation of Chinese also have a different work ethic -- preferring to work excessively to get the money they need and then leaving a company -- giving employers like Foxconn the problem of a high turnover rate, one of the biggest issues faced by Chinese manufacturers. The promise to the FLA of more substantial basic pay may actually help Foxconn keep employees longer term.

Indirectly, being seen as a force for higher pay and better working conditions in China may also help to support Apple's recent efforts to appeal to Chinese consumers.

Although Apple has recognised China in recent years as one of its fastest-growing markets, for a long time it did little to give it special treatment. Its China subsidiary is run by a low-key former Hewlett-Packard executive, who industry insiders say has little clout with headquarters.

In stark contrast to many other multinationals, which make great efforts to highlight their special commitment to China with local research and development, frequent new investments and customised products, Apple has refused to divert from the marketing strategy it uses in other markets.

For a while, the delayed launches and scarce supply of its products in China seemed to fire up local consumers' enthusiasm for the cult brand even further. But over the past year, the company started seeing limits to that approach and faced a series of challenges.

Its past two local product launches triggered riots involving the unlicensed resellers who have come to dominate the distribution and retailing of iPhones and iPads in China.

Following the launch of the new iPad this month, Chinese customs started stricter checks aimed at stopping smugglers from bringing in the device for resale in the country. This week, a crackdown on grey-market iPhone resellers in the southern city of Shenzhen triggered a suspension of iPhone sales by a number of unlicensed online traders.

Apple is also fighting a legal battle over the Chinese iPad trademark, which is registered under the name of Proview Shenzhen, a struggling technology firm.

Analysts expect Apple to swallow much, if not all, of the costs of the improvements recommended by the FLA. Labour rights organisations have pointed out Foxconn's limited ability to do so with profit margins falling as low as 1.5 per cent compared with those of more than 30 per cent for Apple. Foxconn has already implemented a series of wage increases over the past two years.

"When Foxconn hiked wages the last time, Apple paid for it," said Kirk Yang, head of Asia ex-Japan tech hardware research at Barclays Capital. "Apple used to pay Foxconn $8 for every iPhone and $10 for every iPad, but they hiked the price by about 30 per cent."

The larger burden for Apple is part of a shift that has been under way since 2010.

When Foxconn announced its first wage increase after a series of suicides among its Chinese workers, it said the time had come for other parts of the technology value chain to shoulder some of the soaring labour costs in China.

"There does seem to be a new trend that customers [of contract manufacturers] are more willing to share the cost when it comes to labour-related issues," said Jenny Lai, analyst at HSBC.

Thompson Wu, a technology analyst with Credit Suisse, said the review of Apple's supply chain, which is being continued by the FLA beyond the initial three Foxconn factories, was likely to influence other contract manufacturers as well.

"Particularly, Quanta, which plays an important role in the MacBook space, and Pegatron, which assembles iPhones, are likely to come under similar examination," he said.

With a huge share of contract manufacturing for the global supply chain done in China, many companies with smaller financial resources than Apple -- the world's most valuable company by market capitalisation -- will be viewing the cost of this week's events with trepidation.

      Inside Foxconn

    • CEO Tim Cook tours a Foxconn plant in Zhengzhou, China on Wednesday, March 28. The plant employs 120,000 workers.

      Supplier audit finds major violations

      A report on working conditions at Apple supplier Foxconn documents major labor-rights violations, including excessive overtime, unpaid wages and low salaries.
    • grant china sour apple _00010606

      Apple tastes sour for worker

      Stan Grant talks to a young Foxconn worker who describes the unpredictable hours and militaristic culture at the plants that make products such as Apple's iPad.
    • Workers on a production line at Foxconn's Longhua plant, which employs 300,000 people and makes products for Apple.

      Q&A: Apple's China supplier in spotlight

      Earlier this month, Apple released its annual supplier responsibility report which detailed alleged workplace health and safety protocol violations by its suppliers.
    • A general view of a red lantern lamp is seen in front of the Apple's Beijing flagship store on January 13, 2012 in Beijing, China.

      Apple criticized for factory conditions

      Activist Mark Shields discusses an online petition demanding better conditions in factories that supply the likes of Apple, Microsoft, Dell and Hewlett-Packard.
    • Foxconn's Longhua plant, which employs 300,000 workers.

      Inside China factory hit by suicides

      At first glance, Foxconn's factory in the Chinese city of Shenzhen seems like a university campus as young workers scurry from dormitories to their workplaces.
    • The Apple logo is seen hanging inside the Apple store on West 66th Street on October 5, 2011 in New York City.

      Apple: Made in China

      Apple continues to make its products in China, while many Americans are still out of work. CNN's Jim Clancy reports.
    • lklv grant china foxconn factory_00003004

      Apple, consumers must urge justice

      In the wake of reports about worker suicides and strikes over conditions, writer John Cary argues consumers need to pressure Apple to improve its supply-side standards.
    • Participants take part in a protest against technology giant Foxconn, which manufactures Apple products in mainland China, on May 7, 2011 in Hong Kong.

      Guilty about your iPhone?

      A recent newspaper report painted a horrifying picture of life inside a plant in China that makes Apple's iPads and iPhones. Now some are threatening a boycott.