Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on

Study: Organic yields 25% lower than conventional farming

By Matthew Knight, CNN
April 27, 2012 -- Updated 0959 GMT (1759 HKT)
A new study of organic farming has found its yields are in some cases are over a third lower that conventional farming
A new study of organic farming has found its yields are in some cases are over a third lower that conventional farming
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • New study reveals organic farming yields fall short of conventional farming by an average of 25%
  • Organic cereals and vegetables fare worst, while fruits and oilseed crops nearly match conventional yields
  • Study's co-author says organic/conventional debates are often quite heated
  • "We should not be looking for the silver bullet solution, but rather combining different approaches," says co-author

(CNN) -- Organic farming is widely perceived to be a healthy, more environmentally-friendly alternative to conventional agricultural techniques.

But its role in providing for an increasingly crowded planet remains unclear with its merits hotly contested.

New research looks set to refuel the debate revealing yields from organic farming to be, on average, 25% lower than conventionally-farmed produce.

Reporting in the science journal Nature, researchers from Canada's McGill University and the U.S.'s University of Minnesota say that the differences are not uniform across every crop with some performing better than others.

The comprehensive analysis of current scientific literature compared 316 organic and conventional crops across 34 species from 62 study sites.

Organic cereals and vegetables fared worst with yields 26% and 33% respectively lower than conventional agriculture.

We need to have a more nuanced debate about organic versus conventional agriculture
Verena Seufert, McGill University

But other organic produce fared much better.

Legumes (e.g. soybeans) were 11% lower while fruits were almost comparable with conventional farming with yields just 3% lower.

"I think what we were able to do is identify situations where organic agriculture performs well and situations where (it) is not so good," said co-author Verena Seufert from McGill University.

"What we should do is try to address the issues and build systems that achieve high organic yields,"she added.

Researchers say higher quantities of nitrogen in the soil enable organic crops to perform better while pH-neutral soils can also provide a better growing environment.

Adhering to the best organic management practices can also help, closing the average yield gap with conventional farming to just 13%, according to researchers.

Achieving sustainable food security will require many different farming techniques including organic, conventional and possibly "hybrid" systems, researchers say, enabling food production at affordable prices for both farmers and consumers, while limiting the impact on the environment.

"We need to have a more nuanced debate about organic versus conventional agriculture. Instead of saying it's an either/or, or it's black and white, we need to take the best of both approaches and identify the situations that work and those that don't," Seufert said.

What we need to do is to try and understand the arguments on both sides and assess the different options as objectively as possible
Verena Seufert

As the study points out, numerous comparative studies of organic and conventional yields have already been conducted with conflicting results.

A 2007 study "Organic agriculture and the global food supply" concluded organic food could match and, in some instances, exceed the production of conventional farming.

But, as Seufert and colleagues point out, the findings were queried for use of data from "crops not truly under organic management and inappropriate yield comparisons."

The new study has attempted to address some of the criticisms by limiting analysis to "truly" organic systems.

Food is an emotional topic, says Seufert and much more than about consuming nutrients.

"There are a lot of social and cultural values that we associate with food. So many of these food debates -- like meat or vegetarian diets, about local or global food systems -- all of these debates are often quite heated," she said.

"What we need to do is to try and understand the arguments on both sides and assess the different options as objectively as possible, by supporting them with empirical evidence.

"Maybe we should not be looking for the silver bullet solution, but rather combining different approaches and taking the best from different suggestions."

But Megan Kintzer, director of development at the Rodale Institute, an organic farm and research center in Pennsylvania, says that organic farming is a more sustainable system.

"There is less energy use from organic farming, and the conventional systems produce 40% more greenhouse gases," Kintzer said.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
January 21, 2013 -- Updated 0230 GMT (1030 HKT)
Patricia Wu looks at efforts to combat food waste in Hong Kong.
January 14, 2013 -- Updated 0233 GMT (1033 HKT)
CNN's Pauline Chiou goes to Hong Kong's annual toy fair to find out about the growing market for eco-friendly toys.
December 31, 2012 -- Updated 0415 GMT (1215 HKT)
CNN's Liz Neisloss reports on a roof that is only a sample of the greening of Singapore's skyline.
December 19, 2012 -- Updated 0216 GMT (1016 HKT)
A dam project in Cambodia could destroy livelihoods and ecosystems, says Conservation International
December 18, 2012 -- Updated 0322 GMT (1122 HKT)
Shipping lines, port authorities and technology companies are taking the initiative to go green and reduce costs.
December 10, 2012 -- Updated 0206 GMT (1006 HKT)
Less than 20 miles from Singapore's skyscrapers is a completely different set of high-rise towers.
December 6, 2012 -- Updated 1104 GMT (1904 HKT)
The Pitcairn Islands might only have 55 human inhabitants, but the waters surrounding them are teeming with marine life.
December 3, 2012 -- Updated 0322 GMT (1122 HKT)
Biofuel made from sugar cane waste in Brazil could revolutionize the global energy industry.
November 26, 2012 -- Updated 0258 GMT (1058 HKT)
Many believe that fuel-cell cars will overtake electric vehicles in the near future.
November 19, 2012 -- Updated 0820 GMT (1620 HKT)
Modern and sustainable buildings in the UAE are taking cues from an ancient Arabic design tradition.
November 12, 2012 -- Updated 0409 GMT (1209 HKT)
One man's artistic vision is distracting divers from Cancun's threatened underwater ecosystem.
November 12, 2012 -- Updated 1746 GMT (0146 HKT)
Lake Victoria, Africa's largest lake, has been plagued by water hyacinth plants for over two decades.
A turtle on Australia's Great Barrier Reef
Just how much are natural wonders like the Great Barrier Reef worth in monetary terms?
ADVERTISEMENT