Cookie consent

We use cookies to improve your experience on this website. By continuing to browse our site you agree to our use of cookies. Tell me more | Cookie preferences

Bo and Gu on trial, in different ways

Timeline: Bo Xilai's downfall

    Just Watched

    Timeline: Bo Xilai's downfall

Timeline: Bo Xilai's downfall 01:23

Story highlights

  • Bo Xilai's political career nose-dived since wife's arrest on murder charges
  • Gu Kailai accused of murdering British businessman Neil Heywood last November
  • Bo stripped of posts but still popular in Chongqing where he championed populist agenda
  • Analysts say Bo's downfall may owe more to his political policies than wife's alleged actions

In the high-stakes world of Communist Party politics, it sometimes takes a politician only one wrong move to slide from fame to shame.

That may be the fate awaiting Bo Xilai.

Until last April, he was already an influential -- and controversial -- member of the Communist Party's politburo, the elite group of 25 men who run China.

Bo, 63, was the party chief of Chongqing, a bustling southwestern metropolis. He was widely expected to get into the Politburo's nine-member standing committee -- the country's supreme decision-making body -- later this year, when the Communist Party convenes for its once-in-a-decade leadership change.

But Bo's career has since nose-dived.

Politician's wife charged with murder

    Just Watched

    Gu trial set to begin in China

Gu trial set to begin in China 02:32

Timeline: Bo Xilai's fall from grace

Trying to gain access to Gu Kailai trial

    Just Watched

    Trying to gain access to Gu Kailai trial

Trying to gain access to Gu Kailai trial 03:00

In April, he was sacked from all his top Communist Party posts, detained and accused of an unspecified "serious breach of party regulations."

Who is Gu Kailai?

    Just Watched

    Who is Gu Kailai?

Who is Gu Kailai? 02:26
Bo Xilai's son responds

    Just Watched

    Bo Xilai's son responds

Bo Xilai's son responds 05:50
Politician's wife charged with murder

    Just Watched

    Politician's wife charged with murder

Politician's wife charged with murder 01:22
Will scandal bring change to China?

    Just Watched

    Will scandal bring change to China?

Will scandal bring change to China? 01:36
Evan Osnos on corruption in China

    Just Watched

    Evan Osnos on corruption in China

Evan Osnos on corruption in China 00:40
Brother of Bo Xilai resigns

    Just Watched

    Brother of Bo Xilai resigns

Brother of Bo Xilai resigns 02:52

This week his wife Gu Kailai and family aide Zhang Xiaojun are going on trial, accused of murdering British businessman Neil Heywood.

"We're looking at probably the most powerful politburo member and his wife in such a serious situation before a major party congress that is supposed to have a leadership transition," explained Wenran Jiang, a political science professor at the University of Alberta in Canada. "So the significance of the criminal case itself against Bo Xilai's wife has gone beyond simply a murder of a foreigner."

If Gu Kailai is convicted, Jiang opined, "it would mean the end of Bo Xilai's political life."

Gu Kailai: China's 'Jackie Kennedy'

Bo has his share of critics who will be pleased to see his downfall.

Critics dismissed the tall and photogenic leader, claiming that he acted like an authoritarian strongman, resorting to extra-legal means in dealing with gangsters and political enemies.

Others ridiculed him as a "hypocrite" who mouthed populist, pro-poor views while his family allegedly enjoyed luxurious and privileged lives.

Bo did enjoy a privileged pedigree.

Read more: Bo Xilai: From rising star to scandal

He is a "taizidang" or "princeling"-- sons and daughters of revolutionary veterans who still wield special influence. He has close connections in the party, the government and the army.

Over the years, Bo has also created a much-talked-about albeit controversial record in Dalian, where he served as city mayor, and in Chongqing, where he pioneered what some have hailed as the "Chongqing Model."

"I think Bo Xilai is seen as too assertive, too aggressive and maybe just too smart for people of his same rank," said Jiang.

His downfall, Jiang added, may be more about what he did in Chongqing, which included pushing a populist agenda.

"Some of the policies he carried out in Chongqing are, in Beijing, perceived as reform-orientated policies against the status quo, and the status quo now is the widening gap between the rich and the poor," he said.

"China is going toward a direction of more polarization, more inequality. Some of the policies Bo pushed through -- disregarding his personal views, personal conduct and misconduct -- were popular among certain segments. If you talk to people in Chongqing or Dalian, he is still popular today."

Read more: Why the Gu trial is important

Bo and his wife have not been seen or heard from since March and are unreachable for comment. However, when the scandal first broke earlier this year, Bo denied any wrongdoing and accused critics of slinging mud at the family for political reasons.

His dismissal, political analysts say, hints at cracks in the facade of unity and harmony in the Communist Party.

To the outside world, China appears like a massive monolith, a top-down command structure rigidly ruled by the Communist Party.

Far from it, analysts say.

Following three decades of economic reform, China is now a mix of wealth creation, regional rivalries and ethnic tensions, with a deep divide between the rich and poor.

Deng Xiaoping's much-vaunted reform, launched in 1979, has eroded the tight control of the Communist Party. It has also undermined the socialist ideology that gave it legitimacy, analysts say.

At the outset, Deng famously told the Chinese to look out for themselves and seek a better life.

In recent years, millions have dramatically bettered their lives.

Still, hundreds of millions believe they have been left behind by China's breakneck pace of economic growth.

Disparities in income have never been wider.

Now, there is a raft of social, political and economic problems. Crime is rising in many Chinese cities. And one issue that makes the Chinese most angry is rampant corruption.

Since many in China are seeking to make money, the result is widespread nepotism, influence-peddling, bribes, ostentatious spending and misuse of public funds.

Yet leaders face the dilemma of having to demonstrate their resolve in curbing corruption while not tarnishing the Communist Party's image and threatening its legitimacy.

If the anti-graft campaign goes too far, analysts say, the party's image is tarnished and the stability of the leadership could be jeopardized.

One pundit puts it succinctly: "If you push anti-corruption through to the end, the Communist Party will die. If you don't, the country will die."

Some critics are no longer afraid to air grievances to local and central leadership. In recent months, they have taken desperate measures to seek redress.

On July 28, thousands of people in the eastern Qidong city in Jiangsu Province gathered in front of the city hall. Defying the police, they broke into the building in protest against a project to build a wastewater pipeline. Angry that the project could pollute their environment, they ransacked the government offices and man-handled senior city officials.

This incident is the latest in a series of recent embarrassments for the Chinese government -- signs, analysts say, of a fragile system fraying at its seams.

Other domestic factors, including environmental damage and slowing economic growth, all require Beijing's urgent attention.

Do current leaders have the skill, ideas and toughness to deal with them?

University of Alberta's Wenran Jiang said: "Ten years ago, when Hu Jintao and Wen Jiabao both came to power, what they first promised to the society was to fix some of the inequality issues. But ten years later, the issues have not gone away. Unless the new Party leadership can show that they can manage these problems, they will continue to face doubts from the general public."

China today has a few political and economic experiments underway, competing against each other.

With or without Bo Xilai, analysts say Beijing's leadership must find innovative and effective ways to govern a nation increasingly diverse and disunited after 30 years of reform.

      Bo Xilai scandal

    • chinese.politician.sentenced_00023923.jpg

      Political science professor Yuhua Wang says he's surprised by the severity of the life sentence given to Chinese politician Bo Xilai.
    • This screen grab taken from state television CCTV footage broadcast on August 24, 2013 shows ousted Chinese political star Bo Xilai (C) speaking in the courtroom as he stands trial at the Intermediate People's Court in Jinan, China.

      In a letter to his family, the disgraced Communist Party leader reiterated his innocence but said he expected a lengthy prison sentence.
    • Was the trial of Bo Xilai (right) any more transparent than that of Jiang Qing and the "Gang of Four"?

      CNN Beijing bureau chief Jaime Florcruz compares his experience covering Bo's trial with a similarly explosive story in the early 1980s -- the "Gang of Four" trial.
    • This picture taken on September 29, 2008 shows the then Chongqing mayor Bo Xilan attending the "Ode to Motherland" singsong gathering in Chongqing. China's once high-flying communist politician Bo Xilai has been indicted for bribery and abuse of power, state media said on July 25, 2013 following a scandal that exposed deep divisions at the highest levels of government. CHINA OUT AFP PHOTOSTR/AFP/Getty Images

      While Chinese state media hailed the Bo Xilai trial as a show of "historic transparency," analysts saw its theatrics as part of a high-profile show trial.
    • This frame grab taken from Chinese television CCTV shows on September 18, 2012 shows former police chief Wang Lijun (R) facing the court during his trial in Chengdu, in southwest China's Sichuan province. The former police chief who set off China's biggest political scandal in years "did not contest" charges including defection and bribery at his trial, which ended on September 19, a court in Chengdu said. CHINA OUT AFP PHOTO / CCTV

      The trial of Bo Xilai concluded with claims from Bo that his former police chief had a crush on his wife, Gu Kailai, who is serving time for murder.
    • The wife of a high-profile Chinese politician found guilty of murder has been described as funny, personable, attractive and charismatic.
    • Wang Lijun pictured last year at the National People's Congress in Beijing.

      The trigger of China's biggest political scandal in a generation, Wang Lijun was once a feared police chief whose crime fighting exploits inspired a TV series.
    • pkg grant inside china heywood hotel mystery_00002515

      A run-down hotel on the outskirts of Chongqing is the unlikely setting for a murder mystery. CNN's Stan Grant looks inside.