Skip to main content

Sorry about that, NFL chief says of replacements

By Michael Pearson, CNN
October 1, 2012 -- Updated 1647 GMT (0047 HKT)
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • NEW: Fans give officials standing ovation before Thursday game at Baltimore
  • Monday night mistake didn't force settlement, NFL commissioner says
  • The NFL labor deal with referees locks in pay raises, protects pensions for five years
  • It comes 48 hours after furor erupted over Monday night's game

(CNN) -- The touchdown catch that wasn't. The first touchdown interception. The inaccurate reception. Whatever you call it, don't call the controversial call by replacement refs in the Green Bay Packers-Seattle Seahawks game a catalyst for the tentative labor deal with National Football League referees, Commissioner Roger Goodell said Thursday.

"It may have pushed the parties farther along, but we were really in intensive negotiations for the last two weeks," Goodell told reporters in a conference call Thursday to discuss the agreement, reached late Wednesday.

Goodell also said he was sorry the league felt it had to resort to the replacements, few of whom had any previous NFL officiating experience. Many were high school or low-level college officials who hold down myriad other jobs, from schoolteachers to attorneys.

"We worked as hard as we could and we did the best we could," said Henry Zaborniak, a fill-in line judge who lives in Ohio. "None of us felt like we could replace the regular guys. You can't replace that sort of ability en masse."

Zaborniak, who spent 15 years as a Big Ten official, said he and his colleagues never imagined working this long. He thought they'd work one game and go home. While the officials were excoriated in the media, Zaborniak said the players were very professional.

"I can't think of one unkind thing I could say about them," he said. "They were tremendous."

Goodell declined to criticize the replacements despite weeks of botched calls that raised the ire of fans nationwide.

'Real' refs to return to NFL after deal
NFL referees to return to the gridiron
The Seattle Seahawks defeated the Green Bay Packers 14-12 on Monday, September 24, after replacement officials, standing in for locked-out NFL regulars, gave possession of a disputed ball to Seattle receiver Golden Tate. Officials in the end zone gave competing signals: one indicating a touchdown, the other an interception. The Seattle Seahawks defeated the Green Bay Packers 14-12 on Monday, September 24, after replacement officials, standing in for locked-out NFL regulars, gave possession of a disputed ball to Seattle receiver Golden Tate. Officials in the end zone gave competing signals: one indicating a touchdown, the other an interception.
Blown calls in sports history
HIDE CAPTION
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
>
>>
Photos: Blown calls in sports Photos: Blown calls in sports

"Everything they did, every call, was magnified," Goodell said. "They kept the game going. They worked hard. They trained hard. They were incredibly focused and dedicated."

The eight-year deal -- the longest ever for officials, according to the NFL -- gives the union referees a pay raise and keeps their pension program in place for five years.

It suspends a lockout that began before the league's preseason, leading to a series of gaffes that climaxed in a furor over a botched call that allowed the Seahawks to walk away with a victory in Monday night's nationally televised game. The league acknowledged Tuesday that the Packers should have won, but allowed the result of the game to stand.

Fans and players rejoiced in the news that regular referees would return, beginning with Thursday night's game between the Cleveland Browns and the Baltimore Ravens.

"Never thought I would be excited for the refs to come back to work but it's about time," Cleveland Browns receiver Josh Cribbs tweeted Thursday. "It was definitely necessary!"

Photos: Blown calls

In place of the replacement referees, most of whom had officiated no more than a handful of pro games, the league put together a veteran crew with a combined 70 seasons of NFL experience to handle Thursday night's game at Baltimore.

Before the game, fans stood and clapped for the officials as the seven men tipped their caps.

Goodell said it was challenging to figure out how to get regular referees back on the field less than 24 hours after striking the tentative deal, but not for lack of enthusiasm among the officials to get back to work.

"They wanted to do what they love doing and make a contribution to the game, and that's a tribute to them," Goodell said.

While they have not called a game since last season, the league's veteran crews will be ready to go, said retired official Mason "Red" Cashion.

"These guys have been working every week, really since May, to get ready for the season, through conference calls, through video, through meetings of their own," Cashion said. "And that's something that the officials have done simply because they have enough pride in what they do that they wanted to be ready. And they are ready."

SI: NFL's most embarrassing moments

Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson throws the winning touchdown pass against the Green Bay Packers in Seattle on Monday night. The Seahawks defeated the Packers 14-12 after a much-questioned call by the referees. Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson throws the winning touchdown pass against the Green Bay Packers in Seattle on Monday night. The Seahawks defeated the Packers 14-12 after a much-questioned call by the referees.
Controversial end to Seahawks-Packers game
HIDE CAPTION
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
>
>>
Photos: The Seahawks-Packers final play Photos: The Seahawks-Packers final play
Officials in the end zone give different signals on the final play of the Green Bay-Seattle game on Monday night. The Seahawks beat the Packers 14-12 on a controversial call in the end zone on the final play at CenturyLink Field in Seattle. Check out the action from Week 3 of the 2012 National Football League season. Look back at the best of Week 2 and see more of CNN's best photography. Officials in the end zone give different signals on the final play of the Green Bay-Seattle game on Monday night. The Seahawks beat the Packers 14-12 on a controversial call in the end zone on the final play at CenturyLink Field in Seattle. Check out the action from Week 3 of the 2012 National Football League season. Look back at the best of Week 2 and see more of CNN's best photography.
NFL Week 3: The best photos
HIDE CAPTION
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
>
>>
NFL Week 3: The best photos NFL Week 3: The best photos

The eight-year deal, which must be ratified by union members, includes details about officials' pensions and retirement benefits, and adds a pay bump from $149,000 a year in 2011 to $173,000 in 2013. The pay will rise to $205,000 by 2019.

The agreement will also allow the NFL to hire some officials on a year-round basis and hire additional referees so they can be trained.

"This agreement supports long-term reforms that will make officiating better. The teams, players and fans want and deserve both consistency and quality in officiating," Goodell said.

What the refs were negotiating

The return of the league's regular referees won't put an end to controversial calls, said retired NFL player Tiki Barber. But it will raise the respect level between coaches and players and officials, Barber said.

"There's still going to be arguing with referees," he said. "They're still going to make bad calls. But now we're going to know that it's coming from a base of knowledge. These guys know what they're talking about and they're going to have an argument for why they do what they do on the field."

Fired up over NFL referees? Share your thoughts.

The deal came almost exactly 48 hours after the controversial ending of the Monday night game, which the Seahawks won 14-12 after replacement officials gave possession of a disputed ball, and a touchdown, to Seattle receiver Golden Tate.

In what became a widely mocked symbol of the quality of officiating by the replacements, a photo from that game shows two officials in the end zone displaying competing signals: one indicating a touchdown, the other an interception.

The result generated intense and immediate criticism of the league -- even President Barack Obama weighed in Tuesday urging a quick resolution. On Thursday, White House spokesman Jay Carney said Obama was "very pleased" with the resolution.

Goodell said he was not surprised by the outcry.

"I've come to learn in the NFL, particularly with the popularity of the game and the influence it has in today's society, not much surprises me about what happens in the NFL," he said.

Despite prodding by reporters, he declined to closely dissect the play that ended Monday night's game beyond the statement the NFL issued Tuesday. In that statement, the NFL said the replacement refs should have called an offensive pass interference penalty on Seattle that would have ended the game, but supported the referees' decision not to overturn the ruling on the catch.

Goodell also declined to grade the replacements, saying that wasn't part of his duties. But he warned fans that mistakes will still happen, even with the return of the veterans.

"It's not realistic to think that officiating will be perfect," he said.

Much as it was after the Monday game, Twitter was buzzing with discussion of the deal. For a while, in the early morning, the name of one of the NFL's more iconic officials, the heavily muscled Ed Hochuli, was one of the most-discussed topics among Twitter users in the United States.

"I've never been more excited to see another man's biceps than this Sunday to see Ed Hochuli back officiating," a Twitter user named Robby Donoho wrote. "It's. About. Time."

CNN's Javi Morgado and Joseph Miller contributed to this report.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT