Skip to main content

Livestrong bracelet: To wear or not to wear?

By Emanuella Grinberg, CNN
October 22, 2012 -- Updated 1459 GMT (2259 HKT)
iReporter Paul Smeulders created this image after reading the USADA doping report implicating Lance Armstrong.
iReporter Paul Smeulders created this image after reading the USADA doping report implicating Lance Armstrong.
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Doping allegations against Lance Armstrong bring out conflicting views over his legacy
  • Many fans say Livestrong is "bigger than Armstrong" and will continue wearing the bracelet
  • Others who say he was face of hope for cancer survivors are devastated by allegations
  • "I can't wear it with pride," says woman whose father was cremated wearing bracelet

(CNN) -- Lou Hablas has supported Livestrong for years and worn the iconic yellow bracelet in honor of his uncle, stepmother and friends who have lost loved ones to cancer. He also has volunteered for the cancer charity as a photographer at sporting events that raise money for Livestrong's programs.

The 49-year-old Georgia resident says he'll continue to wear the bracelet despite news that embattled cyclist Lance Armstrong is stepping down as chairman of the charity he founded 15 years ago. But the poster of Armstrong leading his Discovery teammates in the team time trial at the 2005 Tour de France is coming down from his office wall amid news that the U.S. Anti-Doping Agency found "overwhelming" evidence of Armstrong's involvement in doping as a professional cycler.

"As a human being who has watched too many people suffer the loss of a loved one -- especially children -- I love what Lance created in Livestrong," Hablas said. "As a cyclist, I love what Lance accomplished, though like so many others I always suspected that he was guilty of doping."

Like many who admired the accomplished cyclist and cancer research advocate, Hablas is attempting to reconcile images of Armstrong as a fallen hero and a cancer survivor who used his stardom to dramatically change the stigma attached to the disease.

Board: Armstrong has no place in cycling
Piers: Armstrong a 'disgraceful fraud'
Cataloging Armstrong's fall from grace
Nike drops Lance Armstrong

"What Lance initiated through the formation of a foundation in his name and efforts through Livestrong far exceed this formal and seemingly final recognition of Lance's fallibility," Hablas said in a CNN iReport. "Cancer sucks and it is much bigger than Lance Armstrong."

In the wake of news that the allegations cost Armstrong a major endorsement deal and chairmanship of Livestrong, CNN iReport solicited views on Twitter on Armstrong's conflicting legacy using the hashtag #livestrongthoughts. Also, the International Cycling Union announced Monday that Armstrong is being stripped of his Tour de France titles.

"Casting the doping allegations aside, Lance Armstrong did more good than bad, he changed a generation's view on cancer," tweeted Eric Liu, echoing a common sentiment.

"My #livestrongthoughts are it's not about Lance but about helping cancer patients. Doper or not, cancer patients rely on #livestrong," user Alex Anderson said.

Others, however, who saw Armstrong as a symbol of hope and solidarity were completely devastated by his fall, with some cynically wondering if Livestrong was a front to deflect attention from doping allegations.

"It seemed that only a few years after his early comeback, he reverted into the same crass and cocky fella he was known to be pre-cancer. He lost any humility and never seemed contrite or thankful to be alive anymore," iReporter Paul Smeulders said. 'It appeared he started using LIVESTRONG as a brand to elevate himself and as a shield to cover or dodge criticism of his unsportsmanlike behavior."

Wendy Adams of Manchester, Pennsylvania, and her sisters have been wearing their yellow bracelets since their father was diagnosed with end stage prostate cancer in 2004.

"We bought bracelets for more strength, for unity, and suddenly Lance wasn't just an athlete any longer, he was hope," Adams, 51, said in a CNN iReport. "We were connected to others who were proudly wearing the same [bracelet] yet living this horror of cancer, all of us, together with Lance, a man who went through it, and came out stronger and better."

When her father died in 2005, the family respected his wish to be cremated wearing the bracelet and spent $200 dollars on the bracelets for family and friends to hand out.

Now, she says she can't wear the bracelet with pride anymore because of its connection to Armstrong and the organization. She has taken it off and vows to never again wear it.

"My heart is broken by this news. I never thought Lance was involved in doping, I thought he was above it, an honest man with integrity and honor," she said. "Lance is Livestrong, he is the face of hope. And when that face is that of a liar, a manipulator, for me? I can't wear it with pride anymore."

Still many see the charity as something bigger than Armstrong and plan to continue supporting the charity and wearing the bracelet. Less certain is whether Armstrong will retain his hero status.

Sarah Atwell, a 29-year-old breast cancer survivor, said she'll continue to wear the bracelet because of what it means for those who have been touched by the disease.

"To me, the organization has become more than Lance. It has established itself as a valuable resource for cancer survivors and families and that is more important than these allegations," Atwell said in an iReport.

"The yellow wrist band that I wear each day reminds me of all that I have been through, the people I have known and lost along the way, and that we have a long way to go in our collective fight against cancer," she said. "It represents my friend Adam's struggle and shows cancer survivors that others are thinking about cancer."

Avid cyclist Eric Hoffman lost his father to bladder cancer in 2001, two painful months after his diagnosis.

"My father's death afforded me the opportunity to look at life in a very different way. That day that I saw him close his eyes for the last time, I knew that I didn't want anyone else to have to go through the same experience that he did."

He purchased a Livestrong bracelet as a sign of hope, strength and perseverance against the disease, he said.

"I also use it as a reminder, when I'm climbing those long lonely steep canyons on the bike, that the pain and suffering that I'm enduring is pittance and short-lived compared to what others are experiencing in their battle against cancer," Hoffman, 42, said in an iReport.

When a friend recently asked if he still wears the bracelet, Hoffman told him, "it'll come off when there's a cure for cancer."

"I still wear the bracelet and always will until this thing is cured. It helps me to maintain focus on what is important."

Carlos Rosado, and iReporter, believes that Armstrong's controversy has tainted Livestrong's legacy. Rosado has supported the charity since its inception, but he would like to see its name changed in order to continue his support. He also says that Armstrong should no longer be the face of the charity.

"Seven Tour de France wins is a long time to keep up a lie. He was worshipped and adored by many people," said Rosado, 42.

"If you can't accomplish the feat without cheating then it is not a feat," he said. "It is a lie, and lots of people were looking up to those lies."

"Like" CNN Living on Facebook

Jamescia Thomas contributed to this report.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Lance Armstrong
January 19, 2013 -- Updated 1513 GMT (2313 HKT)
The fairy tale of a cancer survivor who beat the odds to win the Tour de France a record seven times has crashed and burned. What can we learn?
January 19, 2013 -- Updated 1518 GMT (2318 HKT)
When it comes to seeking public redemption for crimes and misdemeanors, such as cheating in the Tour de France, surely being interviewed by Oprah Winfrey is, well, cheating.
January 19, 2013 -- Updated 0121 GMT (0921 HKT)
In July, when the riders of the Tour de France headed into Paris during the final stage of the race, they gave the honor of leading the pack onto the Champs-Elysees to George Hincapie.
January 19, 2013 -- Updated 1525 GMT (2325 HKT)
After years of tenacious spin that he was innocent, Lance Armstrong confessed said he used performance-enhancing drugs.
January 18, 2013 -- Updated 1806 GMT (0206 HKT)
Armstrong still must face judgment from a different group of fans: those who have personal experience with cancer.
January 18, 2013 -- Updated 0406 GMT (1206 HKT)
In a sense, Fred Schuster has a permanent reminder of disgraced cyclist Lance Armstrong etched into his skin.
January 18, 2013 -- Updated 1843 GMT (0243 HKT)
Jan Ullrich of Germany (left/silver), Viacheslav Ekimov of Russia (center/gold) and Lance Armstrong of the United States (right/bronze) celebrate their medals after the final of the Men's Individual Time Trial at the 2000 Olympic Games in Sydney.
Cheating arises from desires, incentives, pressures.
January 18, 2013 -- Updated 1256 GMT (2056 HKT)
Lance Armstrong
Lance Armstrong admitted to using performance-enhancing drugs. Here's a look at what they are, and how they work.
January 18, 2013 -- Updated 1939 GMT (0339 HKT)
CNN asked for views on whether disgraced cyclist Lance Armstrong deserves another chance.
January 17, 2013 -- Updated 1346 GMT (2146 HKT)
Armstrong has not only spent years vehemently denying using banned performance-enhancing drugs; he also has viciously attacked those who told what they knew about doping in the sport and implicated him in the process.
January 15, 2013 -- Updated 2127 GMT (0527 HKT)
The court of public opinion weighed in decidedly against Lance Armstrong, even before the broadcast of an interview in which he is said to acknowledge using performance-enhancing drugs after years of denials.
February 22, 2013 -- Updated 2314 GMT (0714 HKT)
Lance Armstrong's feat of winning seven consecutive Tour de France titles was like the demigod Hercules achieving his "Twelve Labors."
October 22, 2012 -- Updated 1940 GMT (0340 HKT)
The International Cycling Union announces hat Lance Armstrong is being stripped of his seven Tour de France titles.
ADVERTISEMENT