Skip to main content

Man faces fallout for spreading false Sandy reports on Twitter

Doug Gross, CNN
This tweet was one of several false reports posted by Twitter user @ComfortablySmug as Sandy pummeled New York.
This tweet was one of several false reports posted by Twitter user @ComfortablySmug as Sandy pummeled New York.
  • A Twitter user who spread lies about Superstorm Sandy is exposed
  • Shashank Tripathi was managing the campaign of a Congress hopeful
  • His 6,500 followers got fake reports of flooding, other destruction
  • New York councilman has asked for a criminal investigation

(CNN) -- As Superstorm Sandy slammed into the East Coast on Monday night, one Twitter user in New York City posted a flurry of alarming reports about fallout from the storm -- from plans to shut down all power in Manhattan to floodwaters pouring into the New York Stock Exchange.

Like many social media messages about Sandy, they were scary and confusing, but some of them were reported as facts by news outlets.

And, it turns out, many of them were outright lies. They were apparently posted by a Wall Street analyst who doubled as campaign manager for a candidate for Congress. After a blogger exposed him, the analyst apologized on Twitter Tuesday night amid a flood of online scorn and left the campaign. An elected official is pushing for criminal charges.

Hurricane safety: When the lights go out

The case reinforces how social media can spread misinformation at lightning speed and raises the question of whether users should face prosecution for knowingly posting false information during a natural disaster or other emergency.

NYC Crane crippled by Sandy

It all began Monday when Hurricane Sandy was approaching landfall and the owner of the Twitter account @ComfortablySmug, whose bio lists interests including "Finance, Gin, Politics, Books, Food, Fine Clothing (and) Meeting Strangers," began posting rapid-fire tweets to his 6,500 followers.

Sandy's damage to Central Park

The tone of many of the tweets, which included false accounts of destruction, seem intended to spread confusion and fear.

USCG: 168 people stranded NYC for Sandy

"BREAKING: Con Edison has begun shutting down all power in Manhattan," read one tweet.

"BREAKING: Governor Cuomo is trapped in Manhattan. Has been taken to a secure shelter," said another.

The user also wrote that all major lines of the New York City subways had been flooded and would be closed for at least a week. And he contributed to the confusion surrounding reports, which proved to be false, that the New York Stock Exchange had flooded. Some news outlets, including CNN, briefly mentioned the NYSE flooding accounts after they were reported on the National Weather Service's website.

7 ways to manage stress in a disaster

Two of ComfortablySmug's posts about Sandy were retweeted more than 500 times each. But many Twitter users challenged the truth of his reports, and the Con Edison tweet drew a direct rebuttal from the company itself.

The Twitter account has no real name attached to it. But Buzzfeed contributor Jack Stuef reported he was able to compare altered photos posted on the account to unedited versions of them elsewhere on the Internet. Stuef identified the account owner as Shashank Tripathi, a hedge fund analyst and campaign manager for a candidate for Congress.

While never giving his name, the account holder seemed to acknowledge as much Tuesday night in a post apologizing for his actions. He also announced his resignation from the campaign of Republican Christopher Wight, who is seeking New York's 12th Congressional seat.

"I wish to offer the people of New York a sincere, humble and unconditional apology," he wrote after Stuef's story had identified him. He then linked to a longer note.

"While some would use the anonymity and instant feedback of social media as an excuse, I take full responsibility for my actions," he continued. "I deeply regret any distress or harm they may have caused."

On Wednesday morning, Wight's campaign website said Tripathi had been replaced.

Tripathi did not respond Wednesday to a Twitter message seeking comment.

5 things you need to know

An investment banker on leave from J.P. Morgan, Wight faces Democratic incumbent Rep. Carolyn Maloney in a district that includes parts of Brooklyn, Queens and Manhattan and voted overwhelmingly for President Obama in 2008.

In a statement posted Wednesday afternoon on his campaign site, Wight said he was "shocked and disgusted" by Tripathi's behavior.

"His actions were all the more distressing, occurring as they did, in the midst of Monday's disastrous weather -- during a time when no one was truly safe," he wrote. "I learned from online reports yesterday, just as others did, that Shashank had been spreading false information from a personal and anonymous Twitter account. While he had been with my campaign for seven months, I had no indication that he was capable of the type of behavior he exhibited."

Less is known about Tripathi, whose account links to a fund raising site for GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney and who used Sandy to pepper his feed with nasty political jabs, including this fake retweet from President Obama's account: "RT @BarackObama: If you are trapped in New York City and are running out of food, remember to eat your dogs first before going outside -bo"

His tweets suggest he attended this year's Republican National Convention, and he's listed as a volunteer coordinator for Romney and other GOP candidates.

At least one elected official has asked that criminal charges be considered in the case.

New York City Councilman Peter Vallone says he has asked the Manhattan district attorney's office to look into the possibility that Tripathi's tweets were the digital equivalent of shouting "Fire!" in a crowded theater.

"The Manhattan DA is taking this very seriously," Vallone, a Democrat, told Buzzfeed, while acknowledging it may be a hard case to make. "I hope the fact that I'm asking for criminal charges to be seriously considered will make him much less comfortable and much less smug."

How you can help

Part of complete coverage on
CNN recommends
November 5, 2012 -- Updated 1317 GMT (2117 HKT)
A mother learns that her newborn is part of a hospital evacuation. Facebook posts from a member of the HMS Bounty turn ominous. A man worries about the wind and rain, but another force of nature hits home.
November 8, 2012 -- Updated 0919 GMT (1719 HKT)
President Barack Obama faces a lengthy and familiar set of challenges after riding a wave of support from moderates, women and minorities to a re-election victory.
November 7, 2012 -- Updated 1924 GMT (0324 HKT)
In a historic turnaround, the ballot box is showing America's shifting attitudes about same-sex marriage. The rights passed in at least two states.
November 6, 2012 -- Updated 0242 GMT (1042 HKT)
How far are consumers willing to go in their quest for homegrown goods? The answer might surprise you.
November 6, 2012 -- Updated 1803 GMT (0203 HKT)
For all of its expected action and drama, the new "Halo 4" boils down to an essential question: Are its central characters humans, machines or something in between?
November 6, 2012 -- Updated 2037 GMT (0437 HKT)
Lakota warrior Crazy Horse has long been a controversial figure, so perhaps it's only appropriate that his memorial follow suit.
November 11, 2012 -- Updated 1918 GMT (0318 HKT)
It may be one of the most-quoted lines in American literature -- and if you dare to quote it, you might have to pay.
November 7, 2012 -- Updated 1502 GMT (2302 HKT)
While the U.S. presidential election dominated coverage, news from across the world certainly hasn't stopped.
September 20, 2012 -- Updated 1705 GMT (0105 HKT)
For their extraordinary efforts to help change the world and better the lives of others, 10 everyday people will receive $50,000 to continue their work.