Skip to main content

5 questions on Susan Rice

From Elise Labott and Dana Bash, CNN
November 29, 2012 -- Updated 1234 GMT (2034 HKT)
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Rice is focal point in Benghazi response; GOP feels she misled Americans in comments
  • Some Republicans don't think Rice is independent enough to be secretary of state
  • For John McCain, the fight over a possible Rice nomination may be personal
  • Rice has supporters in Congress; most Republican senators give her good marks

(CNN) -- U.N. Ambassador Susan Rice made a second trip to Capitol Hill on Wednesday to answer questions from Republican senators about the September 11 attack on a U.S. diplomatic mission in Libya that killed Ambassador Christopher Stevens and three other Americans.

Rice, who is believed to be President Barack Obama's choice to replace Hillary Clinton as secretary of state, triggered controversy with her appearance on television talk shows in the days after the Benghazi attack to explain what was known about it.

She spoke from unclassified talking points provided by the intelligence community which said the armed assault was spontaneous and fueled by an anti-Islam video produced in the United States that had already sparked a notable protest in Egypt.

U.S. officials have since described it as a terror attack aimed at American interests.

Ayotte: Rice 'certainly' misled on Libya
Sen. Isakson: Rice 'put on tip of spear'
GOP remains critical after Rice meeting

In a statement released after her Senate meetings on Tuesday, Rice said that she explained to senators that "the talking points provided by the intelligence community -- and the initial assessment upon which they were based -- were incorrect in a key respect: There was no protest or demonstration in Benghazi. While we certainly wish that we had had perfect information just days after the terrorist attack, as is often the case, the intelligence assessment has evolved."

Opinion: Republican obsession with Benghazi makes no sense

Here are five questions around Rice's involvement in the controversy.

Q: Why is Rice the focal point in the Benghazi attack?

A: Rice was the the Obama administration's spokesman on Sunday talk shows several days following the attack and made several claims that turned out to be wrong. The primary complaint from Republicans is that Rice's remarks were centered on anger over the anti-Islam film, "Innocence of Muslims," when there was classified intelligence available suggesting a possible al Qaeda link.

Ayotte: Rice 'certainly' misled on Benghazi, but unsure of motive

Republicans feel that the administration misled the American people before the presidential election, won by Barack Obama, because an al Qaeda attack countered the narrative that Obama's policies, in Rice's words, had "decimated" al Qaeda. For Republican critics, Rice illustrates their problems with how the Obama administration has responded to the Benghazi attack and its fallout.

Q: What are Republican problems with her possible nomination as secretary of state?

A: Most opposition to Rice as a candidate to replace Clinton centers around her role in the Benghazi affair. Sen. Lindsay Graham, who has been supportive of Obama's nominees for the Surpreme Court, says he does not feel comfortable with someone who, in his view, was involved in using misinformation as a Cabinet-level official.

Other Republicans argue that Rice is not independent enough to be America's top diplomat. They see her as someone who blindly follows Obama and puts politics over national security. In a dig at Rice, Sen. Bob Corker, who is on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said Rice would be a better fit for chairman of the Democratic National Committee than secretary of state.

Could the GOP block Rice for secretary of state?

Rice is not without her supporters, however. In addition to staunch backing among Senate Democrats, Sen. Joseph Lieberman, a Connecticut Independent and chairman of the Homeland Security Committee, met with Rice and said he was satisfied with her answers.

"Based on her public record and her public service, I would not feel that her appearances and anything she said on those Sunday morning talk shows September 16th would disqualify her for appointment to any other office," Lieberman said.

But Rice's biggest champion is Obama. During a news conference earlier this month, he said: "Susan Rice, she has done exemplary work. She has represented the United States and our interests in the United Nations with skill, and professionalism, and toughness, and grace."

Rice fails to subdue Republicans' criticism over Libya attack

Q: How much of the GOP's questioning of Rice is politically motivated?

A: To some extent, the harsh treatment of Rice is motivated by politics. Republicans believe the president's handling of the aftermath of the Benghazi attack shows a lack of leadership and tried to make that a campaign issue. Ironically, some are frustrated that Obama's challenger, Mitt Romney, did not take enough advantage of this in the presidential campaign.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid this week called the attacks on Rice "outrageous, utterly unmoored from facts and reality." In a statement, Reid said, "The election is over. It is time to drop these partisan political games, and focus our attention on the real challenges facing us as a nation."

Q: Are there other issues besides political ones?

A: For some senators like John McCain, this is personal. Christopher Stevens was a good friend of McCain, which is why he is working hard to avenge his death. Others have voiced questions about whether Rice is the best choice for the job -- she is a tough talker who some might see as too blunt to be secretary of state. However, most Republican senators have generally had positive remarks about her record as U.N. ambassador and said their criticism centers around her role in the Benghazi affair.

Q: Are there others they would rather see Obama nominate to replace Clinton?

A: McCain and several other senators have said that Sen. John Kerry, D-Massachusetts, would make an excellent choice. Kerry is another top contender for the position who has made no secret of the fact he would like the job.

After meeting with Rice on Wednesday, Republican Sen. Susan Collins of Maine said, "I think John Kerry would be an excellent appointment and would be easily confirmed by his colleagues."

Some political experts speculate that part of the enthusiasm for Kerry could be that his departure would trigger a special election in Massachusetts, where recently defeated Republican Scott Brown could run again and give the GOP another seat in the Senate.

Collins leaves Rice meeting with questions; says Kerry would be confirmed easily

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT