Skip to main content

Russians meet with adoptive parents of dead boy; U.S. urges no rush to judgment

By Elise Labott, Alla Eshchenko and Marlena Baldacci, CNN
February 20, 2013 -- Updated 0229 GMT (1029 HKT)
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • NEW: U.S. State Department says Russians have rushed to judgment
  • NEW: Russian officials meet with brother, who also was adopted
  • Governor of Russia's Pskov region suspends adoptions by Americans
  • West Texas officials say the boy's death is suspicious, but no charges have been filed

(CNN) -- The U.S. State Department is countering Russian criticism of how American authorities are handling of case of a 3-year-old adopted boy who died in Texas.

"What is very troubling about this case is that the Russians are making very wild accusations against the (adoptive) parents before they have information," a senior State Department official told CNN. "I think it is irresponsible of the Russians to say the parents did x, y or z before we find out what happened.

In West Texas, the Ector County Medical Examiner's Office is investigating because of the "suspicious" nature of the boy's death, investigator Kim Harrington said.

Russian officials Tuesday met with the boy's unnamed adoptive parents and his surviving brother, also adopted from Russia, after the State Department coordinated the session through Texas Child Protective Services. U.S. officials said.

Meanwhile, a Russian governor halted the foreign adoption of orphans in his region after the boy's death.

"If we know the facts and they are as the Russians claimed, they have every right to be upset just as we would be upset if an American child was adopted in Russia and the same thing happened. But there shouldn't be a rush to judgment when these parents might be in terrible pain over what happened to their son," said the State Department official, who requested anonymity to speak candidly about the sensitive issue.

The case of the 3-year-old's death has aggravated State Department efforts push through more than 500 adoption cases in which American families have already begun the process to adopt a Russian child before Moscow in December passed a law banning adoptions of Russian children by Americans.

That pending law would ban adoptions by Americans ostensibly because of documented cases of abuse by adoptive parents. But others say the Russian move is in retaliation for a U.S. law that places restrictions on Russian human rights abusers.

"This is a very difficult case for us and the timing couldn't be worse," the State Department official said. "We are trying to revolve the rest of these cases, but having a case like this makes it more difficult."

Officials said, including the death in Texas, 20 of about 60,000 Russian children adopted by Americans in the past two decades have died in the United States.

"We share one hundred percent the Russian concerns about these cases of death and abuse," another senior State Department official said. Acknowledging that 20 Russian children have died with U.S. families, the official added, "We do not disagree this is unacceptable."

State Department officials said they hope to travel to Moscow to discuss the pending adoption cases.

Adoptions halted in one Russian region

Adopted Russian boy in suspicious death
Russia PM: Adoption crisis 'complex'
Russian adoption ban hits U.S. families

The governor of Russia's Pskov region is not waiting for the national ban to take effect, and announced Tuesday that all orphan adoptions to foreigners would be temporarily stopped.

"Another cruel crime against a child was committed in the United States," Pskov Gov. Andrey Turchak said.

The boy was born on January 9, 2010, and died on January 21, said Konstantin Dolgov, the Russian Foreign Ministry's special representative for human rights.

Dolgov said the child suffered injuries to his head and legs, as well as to his abdomen and internal organs. The wounds, he said, "could only be caused by strong blows."

Authorities in Texas have not released such details. But they have offered some specifics.

The child was found unresponsive at his residence and his mother called 911, Ector County Forensic Death Investigator Sondra Woolf said. The boy was transported to the emergency room by the fire department, then pronounced dead by an emergency room doctor, she said.

The body has been sent to Fort Worth for an autopsy, and results could take weeks, she added.

Patrick Crimmins, of Texas Child Protective Services, said his office is investigating allegations including physical abuse and neglectful supervision, or neglect.

Sgt. Gary Duesler, a spokesman for the Ector County Sheriff's Office, said his office also is investigating. No arrests have been made, and officials are waiting for autopsy results, he said.

Governor wants brother sent back to Russia

The boy's death is confirmation of Russia's decision to ban U.S. adoptions, the Pskov governor said.

"We need to do everything and create all necessary conditions for the orphans to find families here in our Pskov region and in Russia," he said.

Tuchak said his office is working to bring the brother back to his native Russia, even though the American parents have not been charged with any crime or publicly named.

"You need to start taking the necessary procedures today," Turchak said. The brother "can't stay in the United States. With American legislation, he would be transferred from one hand to another. It's an additional trauma for the kid. He's not a dog or a cat."

Texas Child Protective Services says its top priority is the surviving child or children at the home, Crimmins said.

"At any time, if we feel the surviving child or children may be at risk, we can remove immediately," he said.

A call seeking comment to a number listed for the boy's adoptive parents was not immediately returned. A voice message told reporters the parents would have no comment.

In December, Russian President Vladimir Putin signed into law the measure that would ban the adoption of Russian children by U.S. families. It is scheduled to take effect in January 2014.

Americans adopted close to 1,000 Russian children last year, according to U.S. State Department figures.

Though the number has been dropping in recent years, Russia remains the third most popular foreign country -- after China and Ethiopia -- for U.S. foreign adoptions.

The Russian measure also bars any political activities by nongovernmental organizations receiving funding from the United States, if such activities could affect Russian interests, Russia's semiofficial RIA Novosti news agency said.

And it imposes sanctions on U.S. officials thought to have violated human rights.

The move is widely seen as retaliation for a bill that U.S. President Barack Obama signed into law on December 14. That law, called the Magnitsky Act, imposes U.S. travel and financial restrictions on human rights abusers in Russia.

The act is named for Russian lawyer Sergei Magnitsky, who uncovered the largest tax fraud in the country's history in the form of rebates claimed by government officials who stole money from the state. Magnitsky was apparently beaten to death in 2009 after a year in a Moscow detention center.

Backers of the Russian bill said American adoptive parents have been abusive, citing what they say are the 20 deaths of adopted Russian children since the 1990s.

The Russian public supported the bill, with 56% of respondents in a poll conducted by the Public Opinion Foundation saying they backed the ban, RIA Novosti reported.

In 2010, an American woman sparked outrage after she sent her adopted son back to Russia alone on a one-way flight, saying the boy, then 7, had violent episodes that made her family fear for its safety.

CNN's Zarifmo Aslamshoyeva and Chandler Friedman contributed to this report.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
May 24, 2013 -- Updated 0122 GMT (0922 HKT)
"It's always the one we feared, the lone wolf that can come from nowhere and not be on our radar," said ex-London police chief John Yates.
One woman's never-ending battle against sex slavery in the Philippines, with a warrior ally in her corner. Watch the compelling documentary here.
May 23, 2013 -- Updated 1043 GMT (1843 HKT)
Ai Weiwei, the controversial Chinese artist-activist, has released a music single and video inspired by his harrowing detention by the government.
May 24, 2013 -- Updated 0209 GMT (1009 HKT)
CNN's Christiane Amanpour and Nic Robertson give their insight on the brutal murder of a man in broad daylight.
May 23, 2013 -- Updated 1549 GMT (2349 HKT)
President Obama is to speak on the CIA drone program and plans for the Guantanamo Bay prison camp. Here are common counterterrorism myths.
May 23, 2013 -- Updated 1415 GMT (2215 HKT)
Illuminated houses made with bare paint
Imagine if you could paint a working light switch directly onto your wall, without any need for sockets, cables or wiring. Well, now you can.
May 23, 2013 -- Updated 1445 GMT (2245 HKT)
Rare Apple 1 computer
A rare Apple 1 computer, with only 50 in existence today, could sell at auction for $400,000.
May 24, 2013 -- Updated 0020 GMT (0820 HKT)
1,400 members of the Boy Scouts of America's national council are expected to vote on whether to end the 103-year-old group's ban on gay youths.
May 21, 2013 -- Updated 1714 GMT (0114 HKT)
Did you know that hurricanes can also produce tornadoes? Read facts you didn't know about destructive twisters.
May 22, 2013 -- Updated 1301 GMT (2101 HKT)
The petite frame of 19-year-old Zoe Smith should fool nobody -- she's a weightlifting warrior who has fought stereotypes and broken a British record.
May 22, 2013 -- Updated 1455 GMT (2255 HKT)
According to the United Nations' mission in Iraq, 712 Iraqis were violently killed in April 2013. This is both normal and extraordinary.
May 23, 2013 -- Updated 1119 GMT (1919 HKT)
The World Economic Forum has declared Egypt one of the most dangerous places for tourists, above Yemen and Pakistan in terms of risks for visitors.
May 23, 2013 -- Updated 2107 GMT (0507 HKT)
Doctors used an experimental technique never before tried on a human to save the life of a six-week-old baby from a rare lung condition.
May 22, 2013 -- Updated 2126 GMT (0526 HKT)
Since hitting the Web in 2007, the hit blogs among the 105 million hosted on Tumblr have tended to be silly, snarky or both.
Five years after the 2008 Olympics construction boom, new Beijing hotels keep right on coming.
ADVERTISEMENT