Skip to main content

Author's description of Catherine as 'machine-made' doll sparks angry reactions

By Laura Smith-Spark, CNN
February 19, 2013 -- Updated 1647 GMT (0047 HKT)
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • NEW: "She has a winning smile and easy charm," royal commentator says of Catherine
  • NEW: Duchess says it would be "unnatural" if she was not nervous about having a child
  • Author Hilary Mantel describes Catherine as "precision-made, machine-made"
  • UK newspapers criticize Mantel's comments as cheap and venomous

London (CNN) -- An award-winning author has whipped up controversy by describing Catherine, the Duchess of Cambridge, as a "machine-made" doll with a "plastic smile" who lacks the personality and human frailty shown by Princess Diana.

Hilary Mantel, who has twice won the Man Booker Prize for her historical novels set in Tudor times, made the comments in a talk for the London Review of Books titled "Royal Bodies," looking at how royal lives play out under the public gaze.

READ: Hilary Mantel becomes first woman to win literary prize twice

The furor over her comments came as Catherine carried out her first official engagement since she announced her pregnancy, with a visit to an addiction treatment clinic in London.

While there, she told reporters it would be "unnatural" if she was not nervous about having a child.

Paul Emsley's "The Duchess of Cambridge" has been unveiled at the National Portrait Gallery in London. The painting is the first official portrait of Catherine, wife of Britain's Prince William, at the gallery. It joins centuries-worth of official paintings and photographs of the British royal family in the gallery's collection. Paul Emsley's "The Duchess of Cambridge" has been unveiled at the National Portrait Gallery in London. The painting is the first official portrait of Catherine, wife of Britain's Prince William, at the gallery. It joins centuries-worth of official paintings and photographs of the British royal family in the gallery's collection.
Duchess of Cambridge's portrait unveiled
HIDE CAPTION
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
>
>>
Duchess of Cambridge\'s portrait unveiled Duchess of Cambridge's portrait unveiled
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, participates in a SportsAid Athlete Workshop in London on Friday, October 18. She showed up for the charity event in skinny jeans, a smart blazer and wedges. Click through to see more photos of her style through the years. Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, participates in a SportsAid Athlete Workshop in London on Friday, October 18. She showed up for the charity event in skinny jeans, a smart blazer and wedges. Click through to see more photos of her style through the years.
The Duchess of Cambridge's best looks
HIDE CAPTION
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
>
>>
Photos: Kate\'s best looks Photos: Kate's best looks
See the Duchess and her royal bump
Duchess of Cambridge's fashion secrets
Critics slam Kate Middleton's portrait
Royal pregnancy births new jokes

The duchess, who is patron of the charity that runs the clinic, Action on Addiction, was briefly hospitalized late last year with acute morning sickness. She and husband Prince William are expecting a baby in July.

READ: Royal baby due in July

In her lecture, Mantel described how Catherine's public image was first defined by her clothes, and then her pregnancy.

Before she became a mother-to-be, "I saw Kate becoming a jointed doll on which certain rags are hung," Mantel said, and "a shop-window mannequin, with no personality of her own, entirely defined by what she wore." Now, she will be portrayed as "her only point and purpose being to give birth."

READ: Duchess of Cambridge's fashion secrets revealed

The author also suggested the chief attribute brought by Catherine to her royal marriage was good manners, adding that the duchess "appeared to have been designed by a committee and built by craftsmen, with a perfect plastic smile and the spindles of her limbs hand-turned and gloss-varnished."

And Mantel contrasted that with the potential for disaster that Diana, the late Princess of Wales and mother to princes William and Harry, carried with her, saying Kate was "irreproachable: as painfully thin as anyone could wish, without quirks, without oddities, without the risk of the emergence of character."

Unlike Diana, "whose human awkwardness and emotional incontinence showed in her every gesture," Mantel said, Kate appears to be "precision-made, machine-made."

In the first official portrait of the duchess, unveiled by artist Paul Emsley in January, her "eyes are dead" and she wears a strained smile, the author added.

Mantel was also critical of the public and the media, which, she suggests, place royal women under unhealthy scrutiny, particularly when it comes to producing a royal heir.

Nonetheless, her words attracted fierce criticism Tuesday.

Royal commentator Robert Jobson dismissed Mantel's remarks as "a cheap publicity stunt" and questioned whether she had ever met Catherine or seen her at work.

"People who meet Kate warm to her," he told CNN. "She has a winning smile and easy charm. Yes, she has a long way to go, and is not the new Princess Diana as many in the media are hoping for.

"But I think she is slowly but surely carving out a role for herself."

In the Telegraph newspaper, women's editor Emma Barnett branded Mantel's comments "not only unfounded, but incredibly cheap."

Opinion: Author's rant on Catherine 'mean and cheap'

It is very early days for Kate as a royal, and her image is being carefully managed, Barnett said. "She has ample time to develop her public persona and become a fully-fledged role model if needs be," she said.

Nor does Catherine have the luxury of answering criticism, she added. "As a fully paid-up member of the royal family, she can only respond by doing the very same thing Mantel has criticized her for: staying quiet."

The Daily Mail also blasted Mantel's comments as "an astonishing and venomous attack."

Mantel's literary agent, Bill Hamilton, said Tuesday the author had no comment on the controversy over her lecture. "The article speaks for itself," he said.

Mantel last year became the first woman to twice win the Man Booker Prize, for her novel "Bring Up the Bodies." She previously won in 2009 with "Wolf Hall."

Her novels focus on the Tudors -- and in the lecture, she draws a parallel between the current fascination with Catherine's body and the public scrutiny under which the wives of Henry VIII sought to produce a male heir.

Last week, an Italian magazine provoked an uproar in the UK media when it published pictures of a bikini-clad Catherine on vacation, with her "baby bump" visible. Palace officials said they were disappointed by what they said was a clear breach of privacy.

READ: Magazine defends photos of pregnant, bikini-clad Duchess of Cambridge

"Long before Kate's big news was announced, the tabloids wanted to look inside her to see if she was pregnant," Mantel said.

"Cheerful curiosity can easily become cruelty. It can easily become fatal. We don't cut off the heads of royal ladies these days, but we do sacrifice them, and we did memorably drive one to destruction a scant generation ago."

The institution of monarchy may be irrational, Mantel added, but those outside don't have to forget their principles as they observe the "entertainment" the royals provide.

"I'm not asking for censorship. I'm not asking for pious humbug and smarmy reverence. I'm asking us to back off and not be brutes," she said.

Emily Bell, director of the Tow Center for Digital Journalism at the Columbia Journalism School, defended Mantel via Twitter, saying the furor exemplified the author's point about the media's role.

"The Middleton row is caused by the Mail turning Hilary Mantel's rather wonderful lecture into an example of exactly what Mantel warns of..." she said.

CNN's royal correspondent Max Foster and Peter Wilkinson contributed to this report.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge
January 14, 2013 -- Updated 1833 GMT (0233 HKT)
Media representatives gather in front of British artist Paul Emsley's portrait of Catherine, The Duchess of Cambridge after its unveiling at the National Portrait Gallery in central London on January 11, 2013.
The first official portrait of the Duchess of Cambridge has been unveiled - to a mixed reaction from art critics.
January 7, 2013 -- Updated 2243 GMT (0643 HKT)
British Vogue Deputy Editor Emily Sheffield talks to CNN about the Duchess of Cambridge's style and brand preferences.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1347 GMT (2147 HKT)
Britain's Prince William and Catherine Middleton are expecting their first child after 19 months of marriage, the palace announced Monday.
December 4, 2012 -- Updated 1400 GMT (2200 HKT)
"A nation's joy, a husband's nerves," exclaimed the Daily Mail, contrasting William's anxious wait at his wife's bedside with exciting news.
December 4, 2012 -- Updated 1746 GMT (0146 HKT)
The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are intensely private; they are also the most famous couple on the planet. This presents a dilemma.
December 3, 2012 -- Updated 2309 GMT (0709 HKT)
CNN's Atika Shubert reports hyperemesis gravidarum, the pregnancy-related medical condition the Duchess of Cambridge has.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1359 GMT (2159 HKT)
CNN's Richard Quest explains how the birth of the baby the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are expecting will affect the royal family.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1358 GMT (2158 HKT)
The news that William and Catherine are expecting has positive implications for the future of the British monarchy, says Andrew Roberts.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1407 GMT (2207 HKT)
Until 2011, any daughter born to the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge would not have enjoyed an equal right to inherit the British throne.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1350 GMT (2150 HKT)
The Duchess of Cambridge - formerly known as Kate Middleton - is the daughter of self-made millionaires from rural England.
November 21, 2012 -- Updated 1239 GMT (2039 HKT)
Wherever she goes, the Duchess is surrounded by photographers. This time, she stayed behind the camera.
May 4, 2012 -- Updated 1734 GMT (0134 HKT)
Has Britain's royal family learned from the legacy of Diana, Princess of Wales, as they protect Kate Middleton?
May 4, 2012 -- Updated 1734 GMT (0134 HKT)
Every time Kate Middleton steps out in public, the fashion world pays attention. Whatever she wears is an instant hit.
March 19, 2012 -- Updated 1949 GMT (0349 HKT)
The Duchess of Cambridge visits and formally opens The Treehouse, a children's hospice in Ipswich, England.
January 9, 2012 -- Updated 1728 GMT (0128 HKT)
Kate Middleton is surrounded by photographers as she leaves her flat in Chelsea, London, on her 25th birthday, January 9, 2007.
As the Duchess of Cambridge celebrates her 30th birthday, CNN takes a look back at her childhood and her royal romance.
ADVERTISEMENT