Skip to main content

Why the royal fuss? Mantel made sense on Kate

By Julia Bell, Special for CNN
August 5, 2013 -- Updated 1006 GMT (1806 HKT)
Julia Bell likens the furore over Hilary Mantel's comments to the reaction to someone telling children that Santa is not real.
Julia Bell likens the furore over Hilary Mantel's comments to the reaction to someone telling children that Santa is not real.
  • Award-winning novelist Hilary Mantel described the Duchess of Cambridge as "machine-made"
  • Mantel's comments have sparked criticism, including from UK Prime Minister David Cameron
  • Julia Bell argues that Mantel has been misinterpreted by a press wanting headlines
  • She says the novelist was asking why Britain needs to "believe in" the royal family

Editor's note: Julia Bell is a novelist and poet and senior lecturer in creative writing at Birkbeck, University of London. She is co-editor of the "Creative Writing Coursebook" and founder and director of the Writers' Hub. Follow @juliabell on Twitter.

(CNN) -- When I was a child I had an illustrated chart of all the kings and queens of England on my bedroom wall. I loved that poster: There was moody King Alfred sighing over burnt cakes, fat, arrogant Henry VIII, Queen Elizabeth I with her inscrutable half-smile, Charles II hiding in the tree. They were live and vivid stories of heroism, frailty, failure, fealty, attached to real ruins that real families (including ours) seemed to trudge off to engage with at weekends -- thanks to the National Trust. To me they were a kind of half-fantasy. Factually real, but entirely constructed in my imagination.

No wonder then, that historical novels have such an enduring appeal -- the latest blockbuster on the life of Katherine Parr is about to hit our shelves. For the writer imagining what it must have been "really like" back then is a huge part of the appeal.

The late author Christopher Hitchens called the royal family our "national fetish."

Shrunk now from the awesome Tudor kingdoms, the current royal family now has a largely "soft" social and tabloid power, and any negative mention of the royals, especially by someone who has been as handsomely rewarded as Mantel by the establishment, is met with screams of utter hysterical disapproval.

Read more: Author's description of Catherine as 'machine-made' doll sparks angry reactions

Author calls Kate Middleton "plastic"
Author: Duchess a 'machine-made' doll
Critics slam Kate Middleton's portrait
See the Duchess and her royal bump

If you read the original article it's an erudite, writerly essay that speculates about the national drama that is the royal family, and acknowledges -- much like the spectacle that is playing out at the Vatican -- that the royal family is pure theater with real living human beings playing out these arcane rituals stuck in the middle.

Mantel is not actually calling Kate a "jointed doll," she is suggesting that the duchess's public image -- the role she plays in the collective psyche -- has overtaken the real person, much like it did with Diana, Princess of Wales.

But the fact that the Daily Mail and other conservative commentators have broken out in such a bad case of shrill hysteria in the face of this examination of the author's mixed feelings about the royal family is quite amusing, actually, because it sounds so utterly insincere.

Aside from the fact that Kate is pregnant and the Mail needs to keep her in the headlines, such is their fawning need to be seen as the courtiers-in-chief, there is also a question of why Mantel's essay has caused such a fuss. It's almost like someone has just told all the children that Santa is not real.

Mantel is merely pointing out that Catherine is not really a duchess, just a woman who agreed through marriage to play this role, which few would wish to have for all the kingdoms in the world -- all that suffocating attention.

Read more: Duchess of Cambridge -- from college sweetheart to queen in waiting

Mantel, like all good novelists, understands the power of the imagination to create reality: all she is doing is pointing out the drama that the royal family play out on a national stage. We agree as a nation, to believe in the royal family -- why? Because we always have? This is the really interesting question and the one that Mantel was asking.

That she should be met with such opprobrium for asking it suggests something interesting about the national psyche. In the absence of any real national culture the royal family is increasingly the obsession of the English -- the Scots and the Welsh would take independence if they could have it. They are expensive, anachronistic, a sentimental link in a chain to a collective history -- a bit like a living breathing monument. But the issue about whose nation they represent, and what they are really for remains louder than ever.

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Julia Bell.

Part of complete coverage on
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge
January 14, 2013 -- Updated 1833 GMT (0233 HKT)
Media representatives gather in front of British artist Paul Emsley's portrait of Catherine, The Duchess of Cambridge after its unveiling at the National Portrait Gallery in central London on January 11, 2013.
The first official portrait of the Duchess of Cambridge has been unveiled - to a mixed reaction from art critics.
January 7, 2013 -- Updated 2243 GMT (0643 HKT)
British Vogue Deputy Editor Emily Sheffield talks to CNN about the Duchess of Cambridge's style and brand preferences.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1347 GMT (2147 HKT)
Britain's Prince William and Catherine Middleton are expecting their first child after 19 months of marriage, the palace announced Monday.
December 4, 2012 -- Updated 1400 GMT (2200 HKT)
"A nation's joy, a husband's nerves," exclaimed the Daily Mail, contrasting William's anxious wait at his wife's bedside with exciting news.
December 4, 2012 -- Updated 1746 GMT (0146 HKT)
The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are intensely private; they are also the most famous couple on the planet. This presents a dilemma.
December 3, 2012 -- Updated 2309 GMT (0709 HKT)
CNN's Atika Shubert reports hyperemesis gravidarum, the pregnancy-related medical condition the Duchess of Cambridge has.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1359 GMT (2159 HKT)
CNN's Richard Quest explains how the birth of the baby the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are expecting will affect the royal family.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1358 GMT (2158 HKT)
The news that William and Catherine are expecting has positive implications for the future of the British monarchy, says Andrew Roberts.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1407 GMT (2207 HKT)
Until 2011, any daughter born to the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge would not have enjoyed an equal right to inherit the British throne.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1350 GMT (2150 HKT)
The Duchess of Cambridge - formerly known as Kate Middleton - is the daughter of self-made millionaires from rural England.
November 21, 2012 -- Updated 1239 GMT (2039 HKT)
Wherever she goes, the Duchess is surrounded by photographers. This time, she stayed behind the camera.
May 4, 2012 -- Updated 1734 GMT (0134 HKT)
Has Britain's royal family learned from the legacy of Diana, Princess of Wales, as they protect Kate Middleton?
May 4, 2012 -- Updated 1734 GMT (0134 HKT)
Every time Kate Middleton steps out in public, the fashion world pays attention. Whatever she wears is an instant hit.
March 19, 2012 -- Updated 1949 GMT (0349 HKT)
The Duchess of Cambridge visits and formally opens The Treehouse, a children's hospice in Ipswich, England.
January 9, 2012 -- Updated 1728 GMT (0128 HKT)
Kate Middleton is surrounded by photographers as she leaves her flat in Chelsea, London, on her 25th birthday, January 9, 2007.
As the Duchess of Cambridge celebrates her 30th birthday, CNN takes a look back at her childhood and her royal romance.