Skip to main content

Can Oscar Pistorius get a fair trial?

By Kelly Phelps, special to CNN
June 6, 2013 -- Updated 1210 GMT (2010 HKT)
The judge in the case of Oscar Pistorius -- seen leaving court in Pretoria on June 4, 2013 -- has warned of
The judge in the case of Oscar Pistorius -- seen leaving court in Pretoria on June 4, 2013 -- has warned of "trial by media."
  • Olympian and Paralympian Oscar Pistorius accused of killing girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp
  • Pistorius denies murder, says he believed Steenkamp was an intruder
  • Judge in the case has warned of danger of "trial by media" because of press reports
  • Phelps: We simply don't have enough information yet to know truth of the case

Editor's note: Kelly Phelps is a senior lecturer in the Public Law Department at the University of Cape Town, and a former assistant editor of the South African Journal of Criminal Justice.

Cape Town, South Africa (CNN) -- Judging by the ferocity with which Gerrie Nel pursued a case of "planned and premeditated" murder against Oscar Pistorius at his bail hearing, it would not be unreasonable to assume the state had a strong case. From the outset, however, the veracity of the state's case appeared to dwindle.

At the bail hearing in February, the then-lead investigator Hilton Botha crumbled on the stand and had to concede that there was little appreciable evidence gathered to back up the state's claims. Worse, he admitted serious breaches of investigation protocol, including the failure to wear protective foot coverings at the crime scene, thereby contaminating certain forensic evidence. Botha also had to concede that Pistorius' version of events was not implausible.

Kelly Phelps
Kelly Phelps

This of course did not help Pistorius in the court of public opinion, as once the state's sensational claims were made they were immediately disseminated around the world. Nonetheless, much of the state's case was castigated by Magistrate Nair in his unusually long bail decision.

Adding to the perception that the state's case is floundering, on Tuesday, rather than presenting their charges to which Pistorius would plead, the state requested a two-month postponement to conduct further investigations. This equivocation is in stark contrast to their initial aggression at the bail proceedings.

The most interesting part of the postponement hearing was the stark warning the magistrate issued to the media and the state to act responsibly and avoid "scandalising the sanctity of justice" through a "trial by media."

Read more: Pistorius judge warns of 'trial by media'

Clearly he was referring to the leaked photographs of the crime scene which were recently published. The leaking of these pictures, as well as reports in local newspapers that numerous police cell phones have subsequently been confiscated, adds to the perception that the state is mismanaging this case.

Pistorius judge warns of 'trial by media'

This begs the question: considering a litany of state missteps and the wild public speculation triggered at the bail proceedings, can Pistorius get a fair trial?

Pistorius back in court
Legacy of Pistorius on trial
Why was Pistorius trial delayed?

Regarding his eventual trial in a court of law, the answer is clearly "yes."

South Africa abandoned trial by jury in 1969. Pistorius' trial will thus be presided over by either a regional magistrate or a high court judge, possibly assisted by assessors. Judicial officers in South Africa are highly skilled and experienced and are keenly aware of their responsibility to apply the law in an impartial manner, guided by the evidence presented in court, not discussions occurring outside court.

This much was inherently acknowledged by the magistrate's warning yesterday -- he did not focus on the fairness of the trial being damaged but rather the sanctity of the justice system being called into disrepute.

Read more: Photos show Steenkamp's transformation

However, Pistorius is unlikely to fare as well in the court of public opinion.

To many South Africans Pistorius' story of triumph over adversity came to symbolize the country's own story. His personal fallibility has thus touched an uncomfortable nerve, reminding the country of its own fallibility, and leading to an angry backlash. To this segment of society Pistorius is already guilty of murder -- irrespective of what the evidence ends up revealing.

The state's bungles have only served to fuel the determination of Pistorius naysayers: if he is acquitted of murder it will not be put down to the fact that he was telling the truth, but because the state dropped the ball.

This stance fails to acknowledge that even the best-run cases can result in an acquittal when the facts, as revealed through the evidence gathered, end up supporting an acquittal.

Oscar Pistorius murder trial postponed
Steenkamp crime scene pictures published
Exclusive: The anguish of Oscar Pistorius
Uncle tells of Oscar Pistorius' anguish

So where does the evidence currently point? It is simply too soon to tell. What we can ascertain is what evidence is likely to become pivotal.

For example, the question of whether or not Pistorius was wearing his prosthetics is critical. Thus the ballistics evidence will be critical. The state appears to be relying on a contention that he took the time to put on his prosthetics before firing through the bathroom door. This, they claim, shows premeditation.

Read more: Oscar Pistorius heartbroken, uncle says

The defence has claimed he was not wearing his prosthetics, which left him feeling particularly vulnerable to a suspected intruder, thus flooding him with fear.

The evidence at trial will eventually support one of these versions over the other. Before that evidence is offered in court, the public cannot be clairvoyant -- despite firmly held beliefs either way, we simply don't yet have enough information to know the truth.

This is the purpose of a criminal trial, it is essentially a truth-finding mission and the rules of evidence and procedure are set up to enhance this.

Hilton Botha, now retired from the police service, would do well to remind himself of this. He has given interviews to the media vociferously claiming Pistorius' guilt and affirming that he will be called at trial to testify for the state. With respect, more is required than a policeman's hunch to convict a person of murder. If he is trying to serve the interests of justice, rather than merely grinding an axe, he would do well to stop talking to the media and save his words for court.

Read more: Who is 'Blade Runner' Oscar Pistorius?

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Kelly Phelps.

Part of complete coverage on
Oscar Pistorius
October 21, 2014 -- Updated 2117 GMT (0517 HKT)
A stuffy, overcrowded cell. Perhaps two or three men to a single bunk. Lockdown for most of the day.
October 21, 2014 -- Updated 0939 GMT (1739 HKT)
He was the so-called "Fastest Man on No Legs," and his inspiring story captured the imagination of the world at the London Olympics.
September 13, 2014 -- Updated 0423 GMT (1223 HKT)
The striking, platinum-haired model was gearing up for her reality television debut.
October 13, 2014 -- Updated 1251 GMT (2051 HKT)
Her name is Thokozile Matilda Masipa, and she is the woman who decided the fate of athlete Oscar Pistorius.
June 3, 2013 -- Updated 1745 GMT (0145 HKT)
Reeva Steenkamp on the beach in Port Elizabeth, South Africa.
Previously unseen photographs of Reeva Steenkamp show the South African beauty just months before her tragic death.
February 16, 2014 -- Updated 1708 GMT (0108 HKT)
The photos of Oscar Pistorius and girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp appear to show a young couple in love.
October 20, 2014 -- Updated 1507 GMT (2307 HKT)
A week before her death, South African model Reeva Steenkamp talked about her secure, blissful environment.
March 3, 2014 -- Updated 0913 GMT (1713 HKT)
He was the first amputee to compete at an able-bodied Olympics. Now, he's being accused of murdering his girlfriend.
September 12, 2014 -- Updated 0831 GMT (1631 HKT)
Judge Masipa has Oscar Pistorius stand up as she reads her verdicts.
September 11, 2014 -- Updated 1518 GMT (2318 HKT)
CNN's Robyn Curnow looks back at some of the key moments in the trial.
October 21, 2014 -- Updated 0907 GMT (1707 HKT)
CNN's Robyn Curnow reflects on her visit to athlete Oscar Pistorius' home, before he was on trial for murder.
June 30, 2014 -- Updated 0744 GMT (1544 HKT)
Take a virtual tour of the athlete's apartment to see what happened.
April 14, 2014 -- Updated 0926 GMT (1726 HKT)
Prosecutor Gerrie Nel is known as the "bull dog" in South Africa's legal circles, and it's easy to see why.
April 10, 2014 -- Updated 1156 GMT (1956 HKT)
As the athlete is grilled in court, Becky Anderson asks psychologist Dr. James Thompson about his state of mind.