Source: ‘Highly credible’ info led to new Hoffa dig; murder put on Detroit mob

Story highlights

NEW: FBI agent says information "reached the threshold of probable cause"

The search is based in part in information provided by an alleged mobster

The FBI has spent months looking into Tony Zerilli's claims

Hoffa, then 62, was last seen on July 30, 1975, outside a Detroit-area restaurant

Oakland Township, Michigan CNN  — 

The FBI on Tuesday spent a second day digging in a Detroit-area field in the latest search for the remains of former Teamsters boss Jimmy Hoffa – an effort spurred by information from an aging reputed mobster.

The information that sparked the latest hunt in the nearly four-decades-long search for Hoffa is “highly credible,” the source said.

Agents were executing a search warrant for a field in Oakland Township, north of Detroit, based in part on information provided by alleged mobster Tony Zerilli.

The paperwork filed under seal that accompanies the search warrant is described as “several pages long,” according to the source, and it explains why the FBI believes the search is justified.

“The information provided by Tony Zerilli is highly credible,” the source said.

By late afternoon, the search had been underway for several hours but there were no indications of any developments.

The search was on private property, and media and curious onlookers were kept some distance from the search site.

FBI Special Agent Bob Foley, head of the agency’s Detroit office, told CNN at the scene that the information leading to the search “reached the threshold of probable cause, which was sufficient to allow us to obtain a search warrant.

“If it didn’t rise to that level then, certainly, we wouldn’t be out here.”

Earlier this year, Zerilli, now in his 80s, told New York’s NBC 4 that Hoffa was buried in a Michigan field about 20 miles north of where he was last seen in 1975.

The FBI spent months looking into Zerilli’s claims before seeking court authorization to excavate the field and look for evidence of a shallow grave, according to a law enforcement source.

Contrary to what’s been thought for years, Zerilli said he was told Hoffa’s disappearance was not connected to Anthony “Tony Pro” Provensano, the New York City-area Genovese family crime boss who allegedly wanted to get rid of Hoffa.

Instead, according to the source, Zerilli – convicted years ago of crimes in connection with organized crime in Detroit – told the FBI that Detroit mobsters wanted Hoffa dead.

At the time, Hoffa was thought to be trying to get back into a power position with the labor movement after his release from prison. He was convicted in 1967 for jury tampering and fraud. President Richard Nixon pardoned him in 1971.

Hoffa, then 62, was last seen on July 30, 1975, outside a Detroit-area restaurant. The FBI said at the time that the disappearance could have been linked to Hoffa’s efforts to regain power in the Teamsters and to the mob’s influence over the union’s pension funds.

Zerilli was in prison himself when Hoffa disappeared.

Zerilli, according to the law enforcement source, said that when he was freed, he asked a mob enforcer what happened to Hoffa.

The mobster allegedly told Zerilli that Detroit’s crime bosses ordered the Hoffa hit. They lured him to a meeting and then drove him to a farm owned by a mob underboss. The enforcer allegedly told Zerilli that Hoffa was killed and buried on the property, which covers several acres.

The area being searched was described as relatively small – about the size of a small party tent, according to the source. Aerial video showed a somewhat larger area had been cleared of grass.

Hoffa’s disappearance and presumed death have vexed investigators. As recently as October, soil samples were taken from a home in a suburban Detroit community after a tipster claimed he saw a body buried in the yard a day after Hoffa disappeared.

The soil samples were tested, and showed no evidence of human remains or decomposition.

Zerilli was freed in 2008 after his last prison sentence. Keith Corbett, a former U.S. attorney, told CNN earlier this year that Zerilli headed a Detroit organized crime family from 1970 to 1975, but was in prison when Hoffa vanished.

In an interview with CNN affiliate WDIV-TV, Zerilli denied playing any role in Hoffa’s disappearance.

Man convicted in mob crimes says he’s ‘certain’ where Hoffa is buried

CNN’s Laura Batchelor contributed to this report.