Skip to main content

Royal baby photos: Are Prince George family snaps pleasingly cozy or just bad?

By Laura Smith-Spark and Melissa Gray, CNN
August 20, 2013 -- Updated 1225 GMT (2025 HKT)
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • "Babies, happy parents and dogs all bring smiles," CNN reader says of the pictures
  • Professional photographers question the lighting, focus and composition of the snaps
  • "They're not terrible," but they don't have royal grandeur, says one photographer
  • "You can still make it casual, but this is just casual and poor quality," says another

London (CNN) -- It's a classic family scene. The proud parents showing off their new baby in the garden. A doting grandpa snapping photographs.

Fine for Facebook or Instagram. But when the baby in question is the future British king, and the photos are the first official photos, it doesn't take long for the world to weigh in -- on their quality, no less.

Most seem to agree that Michael Middleton, father of Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, and granddad to Prince George of Cambridge, should leave royal photography to the professionals.

"They are lovely snaps for a grandfather to have taken. But in terms of the quality, they are not really what you want for such a historic picture" is the verdict of Eddie Mulholland, vice chairman of the British Press Photographers Association and a photographer for the Daily Telegraph.

New photos of Prince George
Prince's first interview as a dad
Baby added to royal family lookalikes

The Daily Mail describes Catherine and Prince William's decision to use "one of proud grandpa Mike's happy family snaps" as "a startling break with tradition."

Most criticism zeroed in on the focus and the lighting -- always a challenge for amateur photographers not equipped with fancy flashes or reflectors.

Prince William and Catherine, the latter holding Prince George swaddled in a white blanket, are posed on the lawn of her parents' home in Berkshire with the sun behind them, a difficult shot to pull off.

"I guess the reason Kate's father chose backlight was to avoid bright sun on little George," speculates the Mirror's royal photographer, Kent Gavin.

He's happy to share some advice though. "Back-lighting is always a little tricky for the non-professionals but it does give a nice result. Photographing against the sun needs a fill-in flash. Another option would be to use an area in shade away from harsh light."

His other tip? "My professional view would be to see more of baby George."

'Babies, happy parents and dogs all bring smiles'

The inclusion of the family pets -- the Cambridges' cocker spaniel Lupo and the Middletons' golden retriever Tilly -- in some of the snaps also gets a mixed reception.

A reporter for The Times of London remarked that the official photographs came "in a choice of formats: with or without dogs."

Mulholland, of the Telegraph, was more scathing. "The photograph with the dogs is the worst. One of the dogs in the corner looks like a furry rug," he wrote.

But the pictures got a more favorable write-up from some CNN readers who commented on the story.

"Babies, happy parents and dogs all bring smiles and the world needs more smiles!" said Earlypro.

"Its nice to see a family snap and not a professional one. Its a special time with a new baby I hope the press backs off and let them enjoy it," wrote Ann.

The public also weighed in on Twitter.

"Who cares? The photos are beautiful and show a new family! I think it's great that 'Grandad' got to take the photos," tweeted MammaMia, a mother of two from the English West Midlands.

"I'm no royal watcher, but love choice new family made to release photos snapped by baby George grampa. Can u blame them?" posted @MemoryMan Studios, a portrait studio in Dublin, Ireland.

No 'feeling of grandeur'

However, John Keatley, an editorial and celebrity photographer in Seattle, told CNN that taking such informal pictures jars the royal "brand."

"The amateur image that these photos put across certainly doesn't create the most grand or royal image in the viewer's mind," he said.

"They're decent photos. They're not terrible. But at the same time, they certainly don't have the same shine and pop and feeling of grandeur that you often see from official royal family photos."

He acknowledged that the family may have been trying to project a casual, informal image.

But, he added, "You can still make it casual. But this is just casual and poor quality. They didn't have to make a bad quality product to put that idea across."

Christopher Barr, a professional photographer in Arizona, agrees.

"It's obvious that a professional didn't take these. It hasn't been color-corrected. Even somebody with a modicum of Photoshop knowledge could improve these pictures immeasurably," he said.

"It's not a very good effort. It's a particularly poor effort given that he's taking pictures of such an important thing at such an important time."

But Lana Marks, a friend of the late Diana, Princess of Wales, told CNN's "AC360" show that she thinks William's mother would have been delighted by his approach.

"One of the things she told me is that she so much wanted William to have a normal life with his family in the future, with whoever he wed and had children with," she said.

"All of her dreams have come true and her legacy's coming true, and all the influences she's had on William, the normalcy, is showing through so greatly now. She would be immensely happy."

READ: Prince William interview: Future king talks fatherhood, baby George

INTERACTIVE: Where does Prince George of Cambridge fit in to the royal family tree?

CNN's Laura Smith-Spark wrote and reported in London, and Melissa Gray reported in Atlanta.

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
July 19, 2014 -- Updated 2149 GMT (0549 HKT)
Believe it or not, it has been almost a year since the birth of Prince George Alexander Louis. Here are 5 things to know about the youngster.
April 25, 2014 -- Updated 1629 GMT (0029 HKT)
Photos: Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, Prince William, Duke of Cambridge and Prince George of Cambridge embark on a Royal Tour.
April 7, 2014 -- Updated 1315 GMT (2115 HKT)
He can't even walk yet but Prince George took a momentous step on Monday in what's set to be a lifetime of royal duties.
June 16, 2014 -- Updated 1120 GMT (1920 HKT)
The first official images of Prince George are released, taken by his grandfather Michael Middleton in Berkshire, England.
July 23, 2013 -- Updated 1627 GMT (0027 HKT)
It's a boy! Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge, and husband Prince William welcomed their first child - baby son.
July 17, 2013 -- Updated 2022 GMT (0422 HKT)
Think you know all you could ever want to about royal babies amid all the excitement about the new arrival? Well did you know this...
July 23, 2013 -- Updated 1546 GMT (2346 HKT)
The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, Prince William and his wife Kate are expecting their first baby, due in mid-July.
Let us least spare a thought for the unfortunate newborn caught, through no fault other than his ancestry, in the global spotlight, Simon Hooper writes.
July 5, 2013 -- Updated 0942 GMT (1742 HKT)
The royal family on the balcony at Buckingham Palace September 12, 1937 after the coronation of King George VI. King George VI (R) stands with Princess Elizabeth (C) and Princess Margaret.
Britain's royals are a pretty traditional bunch when it comes to picking baby names -- so what are the chances of a Queen Ella or King Terry?
Confused by who's linked to who in the royal family? Explore the Middleton and Windsor branches of our interactive family tree.
July 10, 2013 -- Updated 1604 GMT (0004 HKT)
Here's a look at some interesting statistics about royal births in Britain.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1358 GMT (2158 HKT)
As well as being wonderful news for the royal couple the new baby will have positive implications for the future of the UK monarchy.
August 7, 2014 -- Updated 2126 GMT (0526 HKT)
Prince William has spent decades in the public eye. Follow the royal's life in pictures, from baby to proud father-to-be.
June 25, 2013 -- Updated 1407 GMT (2207 HKT)
Changes to the law mean Prince William and Catherine's new baby will be heir to the British throne, whether it is a boy or a girl.
October 20, 2013 -- Updated 1214 GMT (2014 HKT)
Catherine has proved quite the fashionista since being catapulted into the limelight thanks to her appearance in a university catwalk show.
Get all the latest news, photos and videos on Kate and William's baby and the rest of the royal family.
ADVERTISEMENT