Cookie consent

We use cookies to improve your experience on this website. By continuing to browse our site you agree to our use of cookies. Tell me more | Cookie preferences

Sandy-damaged 9/11 photos combine pivotal New York events

Story highlights

  • Firefighter's negatives from 9/11 ground zero damaged by Superstorm Sandy's flooding
  • Family member developed negatives; firefighter found them "haunting in their own respect"
  • Images are now on display in Manhattan in an exhibit the curator describes as "arresting"

After the September 11 attacks, a New York firefighter took a series of photographs capturing the destruction. Eleven years later, Superstorm Sandy damaged the photographs as they sat in the basement of his Queens home.

Partially destroyed, the photographs encapsulate two traumatic events burned in the minds of New Yorkers. The firefighter, Michael Redpath, now has his photos on display in an installation called "Residual Images" in Manhattan.

Redpath, a 15-year veteran of the city fire department, was off duty September 11, 2001, and was called in that afternoon. One of hundreds of emergency responders, he was stunned by what he found upon arriving at ground zero.

"It was like a nuclear winter. It was very quiet. Everything was covered with fine white dust. It looked like a black-and-white photograph," Redpath said.

Redpath had brought his camera, and recognizing the magnitude of the attacks, he began snapping shots of the wreckage.

The angel of Ocean Breeze

    Just Watched

    The angel of Ocean Breeze

The angel of Ocean Breeze 11:54
Sandy's impact on Cuba

    Just Watched

    Sandy's impact on Cuba

Sandy's impact on Cuba 02:30
Sandy tested Jersey's resilience

    Just Watched

    Sandy tested Jersey's resilience

Sandy tested Jersey's resilience 03:03
Weather forecasting changes after Sandy

    Just Watched

    Weather forecasting changes after Sandy

Weather forecasting changes after Sandy 02:13

"I was just trying to convey the scale, which is almost impossible to do," he said.

Having studied photography, some images jumped out at Redpath over the months he spent at ground zero. He was most struck by the efforts of police officers, firemen, iron workers and crane operators, he said.

Redpath developed some of the photos and stored the negatives in a box in the basement of his home in the Rockaways section of Queens. Redpath initially considered showing the photographs for the 10th anniversary of 9/11. But a decade later, he just wasn't ready.

Last year, when Superstorm Sandy slammed into the East Coast, Redpath's home, including the basement housing his 9/11 pictures, suffered extensive flood damage. Redpath likened it to losing family photos.

A family member later scanned the negatives and gave them to Redpath as a gift. They were altered but not ruined.

"It was almost like a whole other layer, destruction on destruction. The new images were haunting in their own respect," Redpath said

The New York Times' Niko Koppel curated the show with the OSMOS Address, an exhibition space. The show is on display at Manhattan's First Street Green through Tuesday, the anniversary of Sandy hitting New York, described the photographs as "arresting."

The outdoor exhibit is situated between two buildings and features more than 100 of Redpath's images projected onto two large screens in 15-minute increments.

One image shows piles of rubble and collapsed iron, and Sandy's murky floodwater added what appear to be superimposed black clouds. Another photo of a firefighter standing, back to the camera, before the World Trade Center rubble at ground zero has scratches and water damage that give the picture a smoky, three-dimensional feel.

On Sunday, passersby stopped to take a look, some briefly, while others sat for longer spells, mesmerized as they were reminded of the tragedies.

"It is very powerful. The juxtaposition of the two gets really interesting," said a neighborhood woman.

Said another man who walked cautiously toward the projections, "It brings up bad memories."

      Hurricane Sandy, a year later

    • Sailing the Atlantic on a perfect blue-sky day, HMS Bounty survivor Jessica Hewitt knew this would have been a beautiful moment to share with Claudene Christian.
    • Carol Mittelsdorf looks through debris to find keepsakes that may have washed away after the storm.

      Carol Mittelsdorf discovers Ocean Breeze, a neighborhood struggling to survive after Hurricane Sandy.
    • Governor Chris Christie, Secretary of Transportation Ray Lahood and Lt. Governor Kim Guadagno survey the Hurricane Sandy damaged areas of Barnegat Bay and Bayhead along Rt 35 than hold press conference at the FEMA Help Center in Brick, N.J. on Friday, Nov. 2, 2012.

      One major issue Sandy victims still have: Their dealings with FEMA, the Federal Emergency Management Agency.
    • Partially destroyed, the photographs of 9/11 damaged by Sandy encapsulate two traumatic events burned in the minds of New Yorkers.
    • pkg  Oppmann Cuba Hurricane Sandy anniversary_00005007.jpg

      CNN's Patrick Oppmann introduces us to a Cuban family still living in the ruins of their home a year later.
    • zarrella.sandy.forecast.changes_00001724.jpg

      CNN's John Zarrella reports a year after Superstorm Sandy on new ways to warn and safeguard the public from disaster.