Skip to main content

Food fight! Disarm a combative holiday dinner

By Terri Trespicio, Martha Stewart Living
November 26, 2013 -- Updated 1416 GMT (2216 HKT)
Alf Garnett (Warren Mitchel) and son-in-law Mike (Anthony Booth) argue during Christmas dinner in the BBC's
Alf Garnett (Warren Mitchel) and son-in-law Mike (Anthony Booth) argue during Christmas dinner in the BBC's "Till Death Do Us Part."
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Set reasonable goals -- no holiday is perfect
  • Survey says 75% have at least one family member who gets on their nerves
  • If the tension reaches a boiling point, have an exit strategy and/or pre-planned family ally

(CNN) -- You can see it now: your combative Aunt Barb cornering you at a family get-together, your squinty-eyed sister-in-law calling your personal life into question over pumpkin pie. 'Tis the season for family fetes and festivities -- and the increased potential for feuds.

Whereas you can limit your interactions the rest of the year, come holiday time, there's simply nowhere to hide. Throw in a little extra tension (thanks to all the shopping, cooking, and traveling) plus a pinch of unnaturally high expectations about how the day "should" go, and you've got the recipe for a miserable time.

15 Kitchen Shortcuts That Will Change the Way You Cook

Stay in touch!
Don't miss out on the conversation we're having at CNN Living. Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for the latest stories and tell us what's influencing your life.

Of course, not everyone dreads gathering with the relatives. But most Americans experience significant tension at one or more family events each year -- with Thanksgiving chief among them, says psychologist Leonard Felder, author of "When Difficult Relatives Happen to Good People."

In a random sample of more than 1,350 people, Felder found that 75% had at least one family member who gets on their nerves. Chances are, you know just who that is in your clan: the one who's going to make a careless comment when you walk in the door, or drink too much at dinner, or end up in tears by dessert.

Curb Your Food Cravings with Yoga

"Most people face the holidays with mixed emotions, which can include feeling trapped and coerced," says Cheryl Dellasega, author of "Forced to Be Family." But if you can change the way you perceive and navigate the event, you'll set yourself up for a considerably more positive experience.

This doesn't mean you have to grin and bear it, or leave another meal with your neck veins bulging. Arm yourself with the following strategies and face the holidays head on -- while maintaining a Zen-like cool.

Shift your expectations

If your idea of a perfect holiday is one in which everyone laughs, gets along and clasps hands for a round of "Kumbaya," then no wonder you leave disappointed. Felder's suggestion? Set different goals.

"Maybe last year you had five good minutes out of a three-hour visit when you connected with a difficult or complicated family member," he says. "This year, aim for 10 good minutes. That's a 100% improvement." Maybe your intention is to laugh a little more, breathe a little easier, or say a few kind words to even the most challenging relative. Set reasonable goals and you won't feel let down.

Go late, leave early

Do things typically go smoothly for the first few hours, then take an ugly turn?

"It's perfectly OK to cut your visit short," says etiquette consultant Jodi R. R. Smith, founder of Boston-based Mannersmith Etiquette Consulting. "If your mother-in-law says come at noon, but dinner's ready at 5, then let her know in advance that you'll get there closer to 3. You might even take separate cars, she adds, so that even if your spouse wants to stay, you can excuse the kids (and yourself) before it gets too late -- or too unbearable.

Don't go in swinging (but come armed)

It's one thing to fantasize about putting your sister-in-law in her place once and for all. But to do it can be a big mistake. "This is not the time to have that interaction," says Dellasega. Better to deflect her cutting comments with a light, humorous response that shows you're not taking the bait -- and then change the subject.

Instant Organization: Get It Together in 15 Minutes or Less

Rather than brace yourself for the inevitable bad turn in conversation, consider bringing information you do want to share to the table. Smith suggests redirecting the focus as best you can with news (about a friend's baby, a promotion), show-and-tell (a copy of the poem you had published or pictures of the kids), or even games that engage the family in something other than your personal life.

20 Super-Efficient, Super-Effective Ways to Clean All the Things

Another tactic? Stay out of the line of fire. "My strategy is simply to keep moving," says Smith. "When I see a particularly difficult person come into the room, I wait a few minutes so it's not obvious, then find a reason to help out in the kitchen or refresh my drink." The goal isn't to face off with someone, but to make your visit as smooth as possible.

Call for backup

You know going into it that your father will question your parenting skills (as he always does) and your aunt will comment on the 20 pounds you still haven't lost. So why not tap your spouse or another family member to jump in when you suddenly find yourself playing defense?

19 Tips for Perfect Laundry Every Time

Enlist that person's support ahead of time, articulating what you need: "When your mother starts in about my vegetarian eating, I need you to support me." That way, if an aggressive relative lays into you, your backup will know whether you want him to play the hero, the subject-changer, or a different role entirely.

Even if you haven't lined up an ally beforehand, you can often solicit one in the moment. "Usually there's someone in the group who has more clout, someone that the others will listen to," says Felder. "Draw that person into the conversation to take the pressure off you."

Keep a friend on speed dial

If things get tense or your nerves wear thin, take a break and call a friend (ideally, someone who you've asked to be on call). "This can help you just get outside that world for a moment," says Felder. "Even if you just leave a message saying, 'Hi. I'm with my family right now. Can you think of any redeeming qualities I have that I've completely forgotten about?' " If anything, it'll give you an occasion to laugh and keep it all in perspective.

Consider it a crash course in self-growth

You don't have to like or get along with everyone in your family to learn a valuable lesson from them. If you're interested in growing and expanding as a person, right there with the kinfolk is the place to do it."They'll challenge you to work on the qualities of patience, acceptance, and self-control," says Felder. "You'll learn more from your family about who you want -- and don't want -- to be than from anyone else."

Don't Shelve These Clever Bookshelf Decorating Ideas

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
CNN Living reflects your life. From advice for modern parents to the freshest news in food: It's all here.
Summer is practically synonymous with cooking food over the fire and sharing it with friends and family. Here's how to grill great food, step-by-step.
July 14, 2014 -- Updated 1316 GMT (2116 HKT)
Do you wish you could outsource the summer cooking, cleaning and camp planning associated with kids? You can.
July 9, 2014 -- Updated 1208 GMT (2008 HKT)
In April, Carol Rossetti began a personal project to continue practicing her drawing technique, "while saying something worthy."
June 25, 2014 -- Updated 1249 GMT (2049 HKT)
"Obvious Child" has all the story arcs for romantic-comedy gold, but one of the film's major topics isn't often broached in theaters: abortion.
May 27, 2014 -- Updated 1845 GMT (0245 HKT)
A teen planned to build a tiny house with her parents for a school project, but after her father's sudden death, more powerful lessons emerged.
May 8, 2014 -- Updated 1615 GMT (0015 HKT)
Our mothers and the women we look up to offer our first lessons in beauty and personal maintenance. What do they tell us about loving our gray hair?
May 23, 2014 -- Updated 1349 GMT (2149 HKT)
rings matrimony
When a partner is terminally ill, do you still go through with the wedding? Meet people who said 'I do' with a future in doubt.
April 2, 2014 -- Updated 2140 GMT (0540 HKT)
You have a new home or your first apartment and dozens of crazy ideas to make it look the way you want. But what's your decorating style?
ADVERTISEMENT