Skip to main content
Part of complete coverage on

Why shareholder value is 'the dumbest idea in the world'

By Andre Spicer, Special to CNN
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1136 GMT (1936 HKT)
Initiatives are often designed to appeal to the markets, which fail to deliver value in the long term, Andre Spicer writes.
Initiatives are often designed to appeal to the markets, which fail to deliver value in the long term, Andre Spicer writes.
  • Executives should be incentivized on different dimensions -- not just shareholder value, Spicer says
  • Corporations with strict focus on maximizing shareholder value tend to employ managers with short-term commitment
  • He argues that impacts on customers, suppliers, communities and employees all need to be discussed

Editor's note: Andre Spicer is a Professor of Organizational Behaviour at Cass Business School in London. He is also the director of Ethos: The Centre for Responsible Enterprise. Follow him on Twitter. The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Andre Spicer.

(CNN) -- If you ask a class of aspiring managers in a business school for the purpose of the corporation, you get a remarkably rapid response. The purpose of the corporation, they will tell you, is to maximize shareholder value.

But like any simple answer, it is not only wrong, it is also profoundly damaging. To paraphrase Jack Welch, the legendary ex-CEO of GE, the idea that purpose of the corporation is to maximize shareholder value is "the dumbest idea in the world."

Corporations with a strict focus on maximizing shareholder value tend to employ a cadre of generalist managers who have relatively short-term commitment to the firm.

Andre Spicer
Andre Spicer

Because their compensation and future prospects are directly tied to share price, executives spend much of their time courting financial analysts. CEOs will often go to any lengths to keep this relatively small audience happy.

This means announcing all manner of initiatives which will boost the share price -- including mergers and acquisitions, restructuring, and downsizing.

Usually these initiatives look good on paper, and therefore deliver a rapid boost to the company's share price. However, actually delivering the value these initiatives promise is much more tricky.

The result is that up to 80% of these initiatives fail to deliver on their promises. Meanwhile, the executives who started them years earlier have banked their bonus, sold their share options and moved on, often to start similar restructuring initiatives at another company.

To paraphrase Jack Welch, the legendary ex-CEO of GE, the idea that purpose of the corporation is to maximize shareholder value is "the dumbest idea in the world."
Andre Spicer

The people left behind -- such as longer term shareholders and employees -- are left to pick up the pieces.

Many large corporations are remarkably resilient. The people working for them are often able to get over failed initiative and get back to delivering the results which matter.

But this resilience can be rapidly eroded if the company -- driven by a relentless search for shareholder value -- goes through rounds of appointing heroic new CEOs who implement promising initiatives, create temporary share price boosts, then deliver disappointing or disastrous long-term results.

When this happens repeatedly, a corporation can easily go into a death spiral. Employees become bitter and cynical. The best leave, while the worst stick around. The quality of products and services suffer, and customers become dissatisfied.

The company diverts resources from innovation into providing immediate returns to shareholders. This can mean the company gets quickly overtaken by competitors.

Movin' on up, it's Money Time!
'The Wolf of Wall Street' backlash
Pelosi: Female GM CEO a "very big deal"

Over time, analysts begin to sniff the creeping signs of corporate decline and begin making more sell recommendations than buy ones. The result is that the share price begins to decline. Ever more change and turnaround efforts seem to add fuel to the fire. Eventually the firm goes out of business, or is taken over.

There are many groups who lose from this process.

Employees lose jobs, customers lose loved products and services, suppliers lose value customers, governments lose tax revenues and investors lose the value of their investment portfolio.

One group who gains from this are the senior executives who keep moving between companies to get away from impending disasters and increase their pay packet. The other group are many professionals who skim the transaction costs off the multiple restructuring efforts, change initiatives and other activities designed to increase shareholder value.

Pulling companies out of these death spirals is notoriously difficult, and senior executives' responses can make matters worse. They usually launch flashy initiatives designed to appeal to the markets, which ultimately fail to deliver value in the long term.

Executives should be measured and incentivized on a number of different dimensions -- only one of which would be shareholder value.
Andre Spicer

But one of the biggest steps which we can take to avoid the fate of companies like the banks or Blackberry is to drop the myopic focus on maximizing shareholder value.

Instead, it is vital we recognize corporations have multiple goals -- such as creating fulfilling jobs, building up industry, satisfying consumers and delivering returns to shareholders.

The task of senior business leaders should be about balancing these multiple goals.

To ensure corporations drop their shareholder value myopia, there are some immediate practical steps that can be taken.

Corporate boards might include a range of representatives which goes beyond just shareholders. They might include employee, customer and community representatives.

Corporations should report not just their financial performance to shareholders, but also how they perform along other important metrics such as customer satisfaction, social and environmental benefits.

Executives should be measured and incentivized on a number of different dimensions -- only one of which would be shareholder value.

The corporation itself needs to take active steps to repudiate a broad culture where share price is the only thing which matters.

Questions such as how this impacts on customers, suppliers, communities and employees all need to be equally valid topics of discussion in the new corporation. The most damaging practices designed to boost shareholder value in the short term, such as share buyback schemes, could be banned.

These measures are likely to create an environment where plans are rigorously tested against different criteria before they are hastily rolled out.

CNN's complete coverage from Davos

From 007 to the boardroom: What the Royal Navy can teach leaders

Opinion: Why it's time to rein in CEO pay

The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of Andre Spicer.

Part of complete coverage on
January 27, 2014 -- Updated 1714 GMT (0114 HKT)
The World Economic Forum in Davos was a missed opportunity to start real dialogue and must change if it is to stay relevant, argues Richard Quest
January 27, 2014 -- Updated 1700 GMT (0100 HKT)
Nina dos Santos was in Davos interviewing world leaders by day, mingling at the parties of millionaires by night. So what are they really like?
January 28, 2014 -- Updated 0902 GMT (1702 HKT)
The World Economic Forum usually attracts protesters but this year's were very quiet. So why were they there?
January 25, 2014 -- Updated 1419 GMT (2219 HKT)
IMF chief Christine Lagarde says governments should beware of the global deflation genie coming out of its bottle.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1136 GMT (1936 HKT)
A relentless quest for share price boosts can result in disastrous long-term results, writes Andre Spicer.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1753 GMT (0153 HKT)
Actress Goldie Hawn says CEOs are discovering how to cope with stress and make better decisions .
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 2207 GMT (0607 HKT)
Richard Quest speaks to U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon about the progress being made in establishing Syrian peace.
January 25, 2014 -- Updated 1658 GMT (0058 HKT)
selfie Richard Quest
Selfie is the word du jour and CNN's Richard Quest set himself a selfie challenge, but which VIPs agreed to pose?
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 0931 GMT (1731 HKT)
Israel's President points a finger at Iran over the carnage in Syria, due to support for Shiite militant group Hezbollah.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 0755 GMT (1555 HKT)
World Bank chief Jim Yong Kim calls for a concerted global effort to help Syria's refugees, saying the response so far has been inadequate.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 2206 GMT (0606 HKT)
Richard Quest speaks to Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu about why cyber security is so important to the Israeli economy.
Think you're paid what you're worth? Explore how your wage compares to the average in your country, then see where you sit globally.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 2225 GMT (0625 HKT)
CNN's Richard Quest speaks to Cantor Fitzgerald CEO Howard Lutnick about the lack of a crisis at Davos 2014.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 2213 GMT (0613 HKT)
Richard Quest speaks to the OECD's Angel Gurria on how inequality and lack of economic growth are tied together.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 1910 GMT (0310 HKT)
It's town of cuckoo clocks, $20 pasta and very slippery pavements -- tread carefully, warns first-timer Chris Pepper.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 1920 GMT (0320 HKT)
Nina dos Santos speaks to former U.S. Treasury Sec. Larry Summers who says public sector investment should be encouraged.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 0949 GMT (1749 HKT)
Almost 40 years and trillions worth of GDP after Mao, an entire generation still has little idea of what kind of nation to strive for, writes Damien Ma.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 1518 GMT (2318 HKT)
CNN anchors Richard Quest and Nina dos Santos disagree as to whether this meeting of power players can make a difference to global inequality.
January 23, 2014 -- Updated 0517 GMT (1317 HKT)
The crisis in Syria was front and center for the movers and shakers as Davos formally got underway.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 1641 GMT (0041 HKT)
Richard Quest heads to Davos, where everyone, it seems, has an event they want him to attend. Read his view of the parties.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 2204 GMT (0604 HKT)
Richard Quest speaks to European Commission Pres. Jose Manuel Barroso about what can be done about the Ukrainian protests.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 0818 GMT (1618 HKT)
Egypt has entrusted its democracy to the army, the police, a disempowered political class, writes Aalam Wassef.
Answer 4 questions to tell us if your mood is up or down, and see how others are responding.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 2301 GMT (0701 HKT)
Speaking at the WEF in Davos, Japanese PM Shinzo Abe said that by 2020 women occupy 30% of leadership positions.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 1546 GMT (2346 HKT)
Norway's Crown Prince Haakon says it is dangerous not to let youth help reshape the world, as they have the resources to act.
January 22, 2014 -- Updated 1503 GMT (2303 HKT)
Three years after the Arab Spring, its issues are back on the agenda and Syrian peace talks have begun. A Tunisian writer says little has changed.
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1915 GMT (0315 HKT)
Ostentation-adverse Pope Francis has some serious cards to lay on the table in the game of global economic reform, writes John Allen.
January 21, 2014 -- Updated 1758 GMT (0158 HKT)
The World Economic Forum is not just a global gabfest. History is often made there, as Nina Dos Santos reports.
January 20, 2014 -- Updated 1251 GMT (2051 HKT)
We need to invest in human capital to combat a predatory capitalist system, argues Anne-Marie Slaughter.
January 21, 2014 -- Updated 1304 GMT (2104 HKT)
today's emerging markets can be divided into the tortoises and hares, CNN's John Defterios writes. But which will win 2014?
January 21, 2014 -- Updated 1030 GMT (1830 HKT)
CNN's Isa Soares talks to chef Alexandre Kroll about the challenges of cooking for the world's financial leaders in Davos.
January 21, 2014 -- Updated 1159 GMT (1959 HKT)
Why would a young person with a job, or in education, or training, want to riot and loot, when they have a stake in the future?
January 24, 2014 -- Updated 1929 GMT (0329 HKT)
The small Swiss town of Davos readies for its annual onslaught of world leaders and power players.
January 20, 2014 -- Updated 1552 GMT (2352 HKT)
CNN's Richard Quest says growing income inequality will be high on the agenda at the World Economic Forum.
January 17, 2014 -- Updated 1115 GMT (1915 HKT)
CNN's Richard Quest ponders whether he's climbing a Swiss mountain to learn the meaning of "heterarchy."
January 19, 2014 -- Updated 1214 GMT (2014 HKT)
What will business leaders, heads of government, entrepreneurs and celebrities discuss in Davos?
January 20, 2014 -- Updated 1726 GMT (0126 HKT)
Davos is invitation-only, but even if you made the cut, could you afford the entry fee? And once there, what do you need to do to fit in?