Cookie consent

We use cookies to improve your experience on this website. By continuing to browse our site you agree to our use of cookies. Tell me more | Cookie preferences

Scotland and England: Better together or more affluent apart?

    Just Watched

    Scotland to decide on full independence

Scotland to decide on full independence 03:01

Story highlights

  • One question has never ceased to prey upon the Scottish people's psyche: would the country be better off on its own?
  • Nina dos Santos explores the complex relationship between Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom
  • She finds that while Scotland might want to split away, the complexities of such a move are extreme

Writing almost a century after the Acts of Union joined Scotland with England, and 50 years since its Jacobite uprisings were brutally suppressed, the bard Robert Burns bemoaned the real reason behind his nation's loss of independence: money and its ability to sway the vote.

"The English steel we could disdain,

Secure in valor's station;

But English gold has been our bane,

Such a parcel of rogues in a nation!"

Two world wars and countless upheavals have come to pass since, with Scotland standing valiantly -- if sometimes uneasily -- alongside the rest of the United Kingdom.

    Nina dos Santos

    Yet one question has never ceased to prey upon its people's psyche: would Scotland be better off on its own?

    And what would have happened had its own parliament, which Burns so bitterly berates, not condoned a merger between the two famous foes?

    On 18 September, some 300 years after that fateful marriage, the people of Scotland -- not England, Wales or Northern Ireland -- will finally have their chance to reverse that move in a ground-breaking referendum.

    And, once again, finances are likely to play a significant role.

    With a population less than a tenth the size of the UK's and a GDP worth a quarter of a trillion dollars, Scotland's inhabitants are relatively comfortable in comparison to many of their neighbors across the border.

    Scotland enjoys its own legal and education systems, as well as more generous healthcare provisions than England.

    It has its own parliament in Edinburgh and Scottish MPs can represent their constituencies in Westminster too, which in effect gives Scotland two voices in one home nation.

    Still, the ruling Scottish National Party believes that Scotland should be separate; that its foundations are not only sturdy enough to support an independent state, but also to nurture a new tiger economy in northern Europe, as Burns may well have enthused.

      Just Watched

      Why is Scotland seeking indepence now?

    Why is Scotland seeking indepence now? 03:11

      Just Watched

      Scottish independence: Euro or pound?

    Scottish independence: Euro or pound? 03:55

      Just Watched

      Scotland's rocky relationship with England

    Scotland's rocky relationship with England 03:11

    How so?

    Because independence, the SNP argues, would give Scotland leeway to cut taxes and to lift those in need out of poverty. It would reduce the country's share of the UK's debt burden and bring back skills and manufacturing eroded by Margaret Thatcher's deeply divisive policies there three decades ago.

    What's more, with Britain often challenging its European neighbors on policy, Scotland would like its own dialogue with the international community, saying it aims to join the United Nations and NATO should independence be won.

    A noble cause for sure.

    But just like Burns's famous poetry, the plot is rich in idealism and light on practicalities, for many of Scotland's pro-independence arguments are based on the assumption that it would be granted automatic membership to a few key clubs without having to wait in line.

    One is the Bank of England, the other the European Union, and neither is sending Scotland a welcome message.

    Britain's chancellor has ruled out allowing an independent Scotland into a shared monetary union.

    This means that if the nation were to keep the pound as its currency, Scotland would have no control over interest rates and no central bank to bail out its large financial services sector.

    And for those pro-independence Scots who thought adopting the euro could be a solution, European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso appears to have scotched those plans as well, asserting Scotland would have to go through the whole rigmarole of EU accession first and may find its path blocked by existing member states, fearful of their own separatist movements like Spain.

    Whether Barroso is right, or as some former EU officials have declared, wrong, the roadmap for Scotland's independent state after a potential "yes" vote is so convoluted that some of the country's biggest businesses have already begun to draw up contingency plans.

    Standard Life, with more funds under management than the size of Scotland's entire economy, has become the first major firm to consider upping sticks and heading south should the sovereignty of its homeland be restored, in an action that could put 5,000 jobs under threat.

    Burns was right in saying gold was key to his country's future. But today "black gold" also comes into the equation.

    After years of alleged shoddy stewardship of Scotland's oil and gas reserves by Britain's central government, pro-independence campaigners reckon the country would be more effective at managing its own resources, keeping profits in a windfall fund that could be used to top up the budget where necessary.

    The UK prime minister David Cameron, however, is adamant those offshore wells would be best served by the "broad shoulders" of Britain and to prove the point he's committing money -- some 300 millions of dollars of it -- to recover 4 billion barrels lost in production.

    But let's not cry over spilled oil for Scotland! There's plenty at stake for the rest of the UK should Scotland choose to go it alone. And while the referendum has been presented as a binary choice, it's not a zero-sum game.

    The dissolution of the Union would have a profound effect on the both parties' clout on the world stage at a time when the EU is seeking a major free trade deal with the United States.

    Surrendering large swathes of Scottish industry would make a mockery of Britain's plans to double its exports -- many of which coincidentally are headed for Germany -- to 1.6 trillion dollars by 2020 and throw businesses with branches on both sides of the boundary into disarray.

    So, if it's fair to say pro-independence Scots are not too clear on why their realm would be more prosperous alone, why continue to fight for freedom?

    Scottish separatism has as much to do with protecting the region's ancient cultural history and reviving auld allies as it does with managing the country's books.

    And an independent Scotland could affect the UK's entire defense strategy, opening up an unpredictable flank at its northern extremity in the very place where Britain currently houses its nuclear deterrent.

    The web of interests, at times, seems so interminable and the complexities surrounding Scotland's choice so hard to grasp that even the country's own politicians are now weary of talking in hypotheticals, not to mention the 16-year-olds who have been granted suffrage just in time.

    The truth is the fortunes of Scotland and England are now woven together more tightly than the finest Campbell Tartan.

    And when it comes to Scotland and its role within the UK, it's the trade ties that bind, even if the talk risks tearing them apart.

    More from Nina dos Santos: Can culture heal East-West rift?

    More from Nina dos Santos: Does being a psychopath make you more successful?

      The Business View

    • Nina dos Santos

      Insight from Nina dos Santos

      Nina dos Santos is a news anchor and correspondent based in London. She is the host of CNN International's show The Business View.
    • An Iraqi worker adjusts a control valve at the Daura oil refinery on November 5, 2009 in Baghdad, Iraq. Iraq and a grouping of U.S and European oil companies Exxon Mobil Corp and Royal Dutch Shell PLC signed a $50 billion contract today to develop the West Qurna oilfield, two days after the Iraqi South Oil Company signed a technical service contract with Britain's BP and China's CNPC to develop the Rumaila oilfield. The Iraqi government is trying to attract foreign investment, especially in the oil sector, in hopes of reviving its war-torn economy. Iraq has the third largest oil reserve in the world but it is producing way below its potential. (Photo by Muhannad Fala'ah/Getty Images)

      Usually, airstrikes, rebels seizing control of oil fields and refineries, plus a severe refugee crisis are a recipe for market panic. So why are Iraq oil prices stable?
    • A Russian woman shops at a supermarket in Saint Petersburg on August 7, 2014. Russia retaliated against tough new Western sanctions, banning most food imports from the United States and the European Union and threatening to block flights over its airspace. The tit-for-tat moves further heighten tensions between Russia and the West over the conflict in Ukraine, where heavy shelling was reported in the rebel-held eastern city of Donetsk. AFP PHOTO / OLGA MALTSEVA (Photo credit should read OLGA MALTSEVA/AFP/Getty Images)

      Europe's deteriorating relationship with Russia has hit the region's growth, even before new food sanctions begin to bite.
    • Russia's President Vladimir Putin attends a meeting in his Novo-Ogaryovo residence outside Moscow, on July 24, 2014.

      Russia's beef with the west has escalated after the country banned foods from a host of Western nations including the U.S., Australia, Canada and those of the European Union.
    • German Chancellor Angela Merkel (top R) and Russian President Vladimir Putin chat as Ali Bongo Ondimba (bottom L) and Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban look on during the second half of the 2014 FIFA World Cup final football match between Germany and Argentina at the Maracana Stadium in Rio de Janeiro on July 13, 2014.

      For months, the West has struggled to take a strong stand against Russia for its incursion into Ukraine. Now, its facing the reality that it will need to suffer too.
    • Colin MacDonald Provan walks his dog Colleen down Glasgow High Street past a Yes referendum campaign billboard On May 20, 2014 in Glasgow, Scotland.

      Are Scotland and England better together or apart? Nina dos Santos explores the long relationship ahead of Scotland's vote for independence.
    • Newly elected Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan waves at supporters from the balcony of the AKP party headquarters during the celebrations of his victory in the presidential election vote in Ankara on August 10, 2014.

      Turkey's Recep Tayyip Erdogan has made history as the country's first directly elected president but his ambitious economic plans could be scuttled by the region's volatile geopolitics.
    • Supporters of the Turkish Prime Minister and Presidential candidate wave Turkish flags during a rally on August 3, 2014 in Istanbul. Tens of thousands of supporters of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan on August 3 massed in Istanbul for his last big rally in Turkey's largest city one week ahead of presidential elections. AFP PHOTO / OZAN KOSE (Photo credit should read OZAN KOSE/AFP/Getty Images)

      Turkey's economy, fattened with foreign investment during its boom-times, has stalled amid warnings its model is unsustainable.
    • People hold Ukrainain flags and placards reading 'We request the breach of the Mistral contract' (C) and 'No to the Mistral contract' as they demonstrate in front of the French built Vladivostok warship to be sold to Russia, on June 1, 2014 in Saint-Nazaire, western France. The demonstrators protested against the sale of the Vladivostok and Sevastopol warships, two Mistral class LHD amphibious vessels ordered by Russia to the STX France shipyard located in Saint-Nazaire. AFP PHOTO / JEAN-SEBASTIEN EVRARD (Photo credit should read JEAN-SEBASTIEN EVRARD/AFP/Getty Images)

      The West has slapped stringent sanctions on Russia in response to the downing of Malaysia Airlines Flight 17. But is it still doing trade with Russia in weapons?
    • Vantablack designed by Surrey NanoSystems absorbs 99.96% of all light. It however will not be the solution to the creating the world's ultimate slimming black dress! A dress made out of this material would render the curves and contours of the human body invisible and would leave the wearer looking like 'two dimensional cardboard cut-out.'

      Forget the new black. This is the real black. You can't see it, or figure out its shape, it's the darkest material in the world.
    • Jibo robot is designed to be an organizer, educator and assist family members. CNN's Maggie Lake met him and says she was impressed with his skills.
    • An Iraqi worker adjusts a control valve at the Daura oil refinery on November 5, 2009 in Baghdad, Iraq. Iraq and a grouping of U.S and European oil companies Exxon Mobil Corp and Royal Dutch Shell PLC signed a $50 billion contract today to develop the West Qurna oilfield, two days after the Iraqi South Oil Company signed a technical service contract with Britain's BP and China's CNPC to develop the Rumaila oilfield. The Iraqi government is trying to attract foreign investment, especially in the oil sector, in hopes of reviving its war-torn economy. Iraq has the third largest oil reserve in the world but it is producing way below its potential. (Photo by Muhannad Fala'ah/Getty Images)

      Iraq produces 3.3 million barrels per day and has the world's fourth-largest oil reserves. But the current crisis is putting all this in danger.
    • Valves of gas pipe-line are seen in the gas station not far from Kiev on March 4, 2014. The European Union will help Ukraine pay the $2.0 billion it owes to Russian gas giant Gazprom, a top official said Tuesday, as part of an aid package reportedly worth more than one billion euros. AFP PHOTO/ ANDREY SINITSIN (Photo credit should read ANDREY SINITSIN/AFP/Getty Images)

      The gas standoff between Russia and Ukraine could have a knock-on effect on Europe. Explore this map to find out why is the EU nervous.