Skip to main content

Not all girls in video were taken in April 14 raid, some relatives say

By Stephanie Busari, Lillian Leposo and Laura Smith-Spark, CNN
May 13, 2014 -- Updated 2121 GMT (0521 HKT)
  • NEW: Government spokesman says 77 girls abducted from Chibok school identified
  • Some in Chibok take security into their own hands, conducting night patrols
  • Relatives say some of the girls shown may have been abducted in earlier incidents
  • Ex-negotiator says Nigerian government has no choice but to talk to Boko Haram

Abuja, Nigeria (CNN) -- Who are the girls in that Boko Haram video?

The local governor says they're all from the Chibok boarding school raided by Boko Haram militants April 14. But some relatives say they don't see their daughters in the video, and believe some of the girls were taken in earlier abductions.

A spokesman for the Borno governor said parents, students and teachers have now identified 77 of the girls shown in the video, released Monday by Agence France-Presse, a French news agency.

"Remember, I also said that on face value, all the girls in the video are believed to part of the abducted girls, but Governor (Kashim) Shettima has insisted that the names of all the girls in the video be established and compared with school and security records," spokesman Isa Gusau said Tuesday.

"The comparison will be done tomorrow as (the) identification exercise continues through the night until every person in that video is named," said Gusau.

Earlier, Shettima had said that relatives had identified just 54 of the girls. Shettima said he met with families of the kidnapped girls earlier Tuesday in Borno state's capital, Maiduguri, at which time the families identified some of their girls.

Shettima said the others also attended the school, but he did not explain how he knew that.

CNN has not yet received confirmation from any parents that their daughters were among the girls shown in the video.

Nigerians take security into own hands
Witnesses to terror
Exclusive interview with kidnapped girl
Police in riot gear block a route in Abuja, Nigeria, on Tuesday, October 14, during a demonstration calling on the Nigerian government to rescue schoolgirls kidnapped by the Islamist militant group Boko Haram. In April, more than 200 girls were abducted from their boarding school in northeastern Nigeria, officials and witnesses said. Police in riot gear block a route in Abuja, Nigeria, on Tuesday, October 14, during a demonstration calling on the Nigerian government to rescue schoolgirls kidnapped by the Islamist militant group Boko Haram. In April, more than 200 girls were abducted from their boarding school in northeastern Nigeria, officials and witnesses said.
Nigerians protest over kidnapped schoolgirls
Photos: Nigerians protest over kidnapped girls Photos: Nigerians protest over kidnapped girls

Some relatives also told CNN that more than 50 parents of girls abducted last month watched the videos in the Mbalala district and also in Chibok, and didn't see any of their daughters in the crowd.

That's not necessarily surprising -- the video shows about 100 girls, not the full 276 abducted from Chibok by Boko Haram.

But the relatives interviewed by CNN -- an uncle of one of the girls who escaped and the parents of two missing girls -- said they believe the video also shows some girls abducted as much as two years ago.

The confusion is significant because the video had been hailed as proof that at least some girls in the Chibok abduction -- the object of international search efforts -- were alive and well. Such proof would be a crucial part of any possible negotiations that could lead to the release of the girls.

"I think we've got to be realistic," CNN analyst Frances Townsend said Tuesday on "New Day." "Even in a negotiation, because of the large number of captives, you are unlikely to return all approximately 300 girls to their families and reunite them healthy, safe and well."

Questions remain

Negotiate or fight?

Shehu Sani, a former negotiator between Boko Haram and the government, has called for Nigerian authorities to negotiate with the girls' Islamist captors, and he said they may have to embrace the unpalatable option of a prisoner swap.

"There are two ways to which you can get these girls free," Sani told CNN's "Connect the World" show.

"The first is to use force, and the second is through dialogue. The use of force is not an option for now in the sense that nobody knows where these girls were kept.

"And even if you know, these girls have been embedded in with the insurgents who are heavily armed. And any attempt to rescue them will be putting their lives in further danger."

The director of a Nigerian government information ministry, the National Orientation Agency, said all options, including negotiations, are under consideration.

Map: Nima Elbagir's route to Chibok  Map: Nima Elbagir's route to Chibok
Map: Nima Elbagir's route to ChibokMap: Nima Elbagir's route to Chibok
New video allegedly shows Nigerian girls
New video allegedly shows Nigerian girls
Nigerian girl escapes from Boko Haram

The Nigerian government has negotiated with Boko Haram for the release of kidnapped girls before, CNN terrorism analyst Paul Cruickshank said.

Last year, the militant group won the release of some 100 of its imprisoned members after reaching an agreement to return about a dozen kidnapped girls, Cruickshank said.

Girls' lives 'more important'

Cruickshank warned that dealing with Boko Haram will just invite more such abductions, but Sani, a human rights activist in northern Nigeria, said authorities have little choice.

"I believe that the lives of these girls is more important to us than the insurgents that have been in detention. And we have nothing to lose if we send the insurgents and we can swap them with these girls back," he said.

The man purporting to be Boko Haram leader Abubakar Shekau appeared to open the door to such a resolution.

"By Allah, these girls will not leave our hands until you release our brothers in your prison," he said.

If not, they'll be sold as slaves, he said.

Rights groups have accused Nigeria of using heavy-handed tactics such as illegal searches, torture and extrajudicial killings to crack down on the militants.

Military response to allegations

Amnesty International said last week that Nigerian military commanders failed to act on advance warnings about the terror group's raid on the school.

On Tuesday, Maj. Gen. Chris Olukolade, a spokesman for the Nigerian military, said authorities often are warned of likely attacks on towns and villages.

"In a day, you can have up to 1,000 of such claims. More than three quarters of it turns out to be frivolous," he said, stressing that no warning has ever been ignored.

"In the case of Chibok, the first one that was taken to be credible was one that came for our troops on patrol who (were) noticing what was going on and observing that it was getting much beyond their level (and) sent for reinforcement," the spokesman said.

Olukolade also addressed why some people in Chibok, feeling abandoned by the government, have taken security into their own hands and started night patrols.

"One element in this operation has been to cooperate with the locals," said Olukolade, defending the military against those who say it's not doing enough.

International assistance

U.S. and British officials are working with the Nigerian government to gather intelligence and decide what to do next.

The United States is flying manned military surveillance flights over Nigeria in the hunt for the girls and their captors, Pentagon spokesman Col. Steve Warren told reporters Tuesday.

It is also sharing commercial satellite images with Nigeria, two senior Obama administration officials told CNN's Elise Labott.

China and France are helping in the search as well. Israel plans to send a team of counterterrorism experts to help, Nigerian President Goodluck Jonathan's office said this week.

The road to Boko Haram's heartland

Opinion: Nigerians right to be wary of U.S. intentions

Stephanie Busari and Lillian Leposo reported from Abuja. Laura Smith-Spark reported and wrote from London. CNN's Antonia Mortensen and Isha Sesay contributed from Abuja; Faith Karimi contributed from Atlanta, and Nima Elbagir contributed from Chibok. Journalist Aminu Abubakar also contributed to this report.

Part of complete coverage on
October 9, 2014 -- Updated 1653 GMT (0053 HKT)
Arwa Damon meets two young orphans, now in Niger, whose mother died years ago -- and whose father was killed in a Boko Haram attack in Nigeria.
June 10, 2014 -- Updated 1041 GMT (1841 HKT)
A small river marks the border between Niger and Nigeria -- a shallow divide between security and the horrors of Boko Haram.
June 10, 2014 -- Updated 0959 GMT (1759 HKT)
CNN's Arwa Damon reports that U.S. sources now believe Boko Haram insurgents may be hiding on the islands of Lake Chad.
June 5, 2014 -- Updated 1915 GMT (0315 HKT)
Isha Sesay talks to journalist Aminu Abubakar who says approximately 500 people have been killed in northeastern Nigeria.
June 4, 2014 -- Updated 1007 GMT (1807 HKT)
A policeman stand beside children holding as members of Lagos based civil society groups hold rally calling for the release of missing Chibok school girls at the state government house, in Lagos, Nigeria, on May 5, 2014. Boko Haram on Monday claimed the abduction of hundreds of schoolgirls in northern Nigeria that has triggered international outrage, threatening to sell them as
Police in Nigeria's capital Tuesday made a U-turn, saying a ban on protests in support of the more than 200 girls kidnapped in April does not exist.
May 27, 2014 -- Updated 0636 GMT (1436 HKT)
A top Nigerian official claims to know where the missing schoolgirls are located, as Arwa Damon reports.
May 26, 2014 -- Updated 2100 GMT (0500 HKT)
Arwa Damon reports on Nigerian schools sitting empty as residents live in fear of Boko Haram.
May 21, 2014 -- Updated 2311 GMT (0711 HKT)
A large part of northern and central Nigeria is now at the mercy of intensified attacks by Boko Haram, and the group seems to be embarking on a new phase of its campaign.
May 21, 2014 -- Updated 1402 GMT (2202 HKT)
Half of a yellow sun poster
It's one of the most important Nigerian stories to hit the big screen -- yet the director says Nigeria's bureaucracy is purposely preventing its release.
May 19, 2014 -- Updated 1151 GMT (1951 HKT)
Opinion: The media turns Boko Haram into 'superstar monsters' -- which is exactly what they want.
May 13, 2014 -- Updated 1224 GMT (2024 HKT)
CNN's Nima Elbagir speaks with the mothers of two missing Nigerian schoolgirls.
May 12, 2014 -- Updated 1318 GMT (2118 HKT)
With fear in her eyes, a young woman tells CNN's Nima Elbagir, the first journalist to visit Chibok, how she fled gun-toting Islamic extremists.
April 11, 2014 -- Updated 1039 GMT (1839 HKT)
Over the last 20 years, the narrative on the African continent has shifted from Afro-pessimism to Afro-optimism.
May 8, 2014 -- Updated 1125 GMT (1925 HKT)
Women in repressive countries are fighting back against injustice, writes Frida Ghitis.
March 4, 2014 -- Updated 1346 GMT (2146 HKT)
Biyi Bandele, who recently directed Oscar nominated Chiwetel Ejiofor in "Half of a Yellow Sun," discusses his remarkable journey.
October 22, 2014 -- Updated 1024 GMT (1824 HKT)
From regular people to celebrities, here are some of the people participating in the movement.
April 11, 2014 -- Updated 0933 GMT (1733 HKT)
Nigeria woke up to a brand new economy, apparently. But the country are suffering and its people responded with a hiss.
April 7, 2014 -- Updated 0900 GMT (1700 HKT)
At 23, many people around the world are still at university -- at that age, Gossy Ukanwoke had already started one.
April 18, 2014 -- Updated 1623 GMT (0023 HKT)
Oprah, if you're reading this, for goodness sake return this woman's calls.
Are you in Nigeria? Share your thoughts on the schoolgirls' kidnapping, but please stay safe.