Skip to main content

Friend or foe? India's Narendra Modi an unknown quantity abroad

By Ravi Agrawal, CNN
updated 10:50 PM EDT, Mon May 26, 2014
  • India's new prime minister has promised citizens growth and prosperity
  • What's less clear is how Narendra Modi will approach foreign policy
  • Modi has wasted no time connecting with other foreign leaders
  • In the past India's foreign policy has been more about continuity than change

Editor's note: Ravi Agrawal is CNN's New Delhi Bureau chief and was formerly senior producer of the network's "Fareed Zakaria GPS." Follow him on Twitter: @RaviAgrawalCNN. The opinions expressed in this commentary are solely those of the author.

New Delhi (CNN) -- Indians want their version of the American Dream. Even the Chinese Dream will do. And so they have voted for a man who promises more for less: more development and growth, with less government and red tape.

For India's 1.27 billion dreamers, their new Prime Minister Narendra Modi is a known commodity. His simple mandate is to do for India what he has done for the north western state of Gujarat in the last 12 years: conjure up Chinese-levels of growth and prosperity.

But for Modi's counterparts in Washington, Beijing, and Islamabad, India's new leader is considered a wildcard. Will he be aggressive, or a dove? What is his foreign policy? Does he have a vision for India's place in the world?

Can India's new PM deliver?
Will Modi be India's Putin?
How will Narendra Modi change India?

There's very little to go on. Modi has never addressed foreign policy at length; Indian campaigns rarely involve debates on world affairs. Few in New Delhi seem to have a clear sense of his plans. When I spoke with Arun Shourie, a former Indian minister now being touted as a top candidate to head the finance ministry, I got a telling response: "Anyone who says they know Modi's plans, doesn't really know anything. The ones who know won't talk."

So let's start with the few signals we've received from the man himself.

Reaching out to neighbors

Modi has certainly begun with a flourish, scoring a coup in getting his Pakistani counterpart to attend his swearing-in.

On Monday, Nawaz Sharif became the first Pakistani Prime Minister in history to attend an Indian prime minister's inauguration.

The two men were photographed exchanging a firm handshake. Modi later tweeted that Sharif had "shared some very emotional things" during their meeting. He elaborated with a story about how Sharif's mother became emotional when watching Modi's mother offering him sweets. (Read the series of tweets here)

Modi's Twitter account also highlights his early attempts to strengthen ties with his new counterparts. After his election, he announced to his 4.38 million followers congratulatory messages from U.S. President Barack Obama, Israel's PM Netanyahu, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, France's Hollande, Russia's Putin, as well as leaders from New Zealand, Fiji, Qatar, Afghanistan and more.

Japan got an especially lavish mention: "Personally, I have a wonderful experience of working with Japan as [Chief Minister of Gujarat.]," Modi tweeted. "I am sure we will take India-Japan ties to newer heights." Japan's PM Shinzo Abe follows only three people on Twitter -- Modi, of course, is one of them.

Twitter diplomacy is not just about rhetoric -- there have been some early results, too. Sri Lankan President Mahinda Rajapakse tweeted Sunday: "As a goodwill measure on the occasion of @narendramodi's swearing-in, President instructs officials to release Indian fishermen in custody."

None of the above sheds light on what kind of vision Modi has, but it is indeed a refreshing marker of proactive engagement -- the opposite of India's foreign policy in years gone by. In an excellent essay in Foreign Affairs last month, Manjari Chatterjee Miller described how Indian foreign policy in the last 50 years has been characterized "more by continuity than by change" -- irrespective of the party in power.


Anyone who says they know Modi's plans, doesn't really know anything. The ones who know won't talk.
Arun Shourie, former Indian minister

India's relations with major powers have stayed stable. Broadly, there are two reasons behind this trend. One is India's historic pledge of "non-alignment": the country's first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru founded the global Non-Aligned Movement, a group of states agreeing to not align with major powers. The other reason is India's neglect of foreign policy planning from the very top: civil servants get little-to-no instruction from the prime minister's office, and so have great levels of autonomy and wield significant power. The result is no clear vision from New Delhi, and a general stasis in India's relations with the world. It has often been pointed out that India has fewer diplomats than Singapore, a country with a population 1/250th the size of India's. India has consistently punched below its weight despite aspiring to be a global player.

Will Modi change these trends? Again, it is difficult to read his mind. But turn again to what Modi has actually said. The writer Dhruva Jaishanker points out that Modi has repeatedly stated that foreign policy begins at home. This is not to suggest that Modi will be insular. Instead, his relations with other countries will be driven by business needs and a sense of realism -- perhaps similar, in theory, to China's relations with South Asian and African states.

Many writers and commentators have expressed fears about Modi's foreign policy on two main fronts. First, that he will channel his brand of pro-Hindu nationalism into friction with Pakistan. Second, that he will use his prior history with Washington -- Modi's U.S. visa was revoked in 2005 over a never-before-used religious freedoms act -- as a reason to snub the world's biggest economy. On both fronts, we have no way of confirming those fears just yet. But with each passing day, we are witnessing an evolving Modi, a realist whose goal is to grow India Inc. and do business with anyone -- at home or abroad -- who can help achieve that goal.

Modi's real test will be whether he can bring a longer-term vision to India's foreign policy planning. Will he keep New Delhi non-aligned? Will he pivot further East? Will he help fulfil Obama's prediction that India and the U.S. will form the 21st century's defining partnership?

Only Modi knows the answers. But if Indian foreign policy has so far not been driven by the prime minister's office, I think we can now expect that strange quirk to change. For better or worse, Prime Minister Modi will take charge.

Part of complete coverage on
updated 2:21 AM EDT, Fri July 18, 2014
In an ambitious plan to upgrade urban India, Prime Minister Narendra Modi says he will build 100 "smart cities" across the country.
updated 7:39 AM EDT, Thu July 17, 2014
A few weeks ago, a young boy tied to a Mumbai bus stop barely received a glance from passersby. Now, he has a home, thanks to a local NGO.
updated 8:02 AM EDT, Tue July 15, 2014
When a 14-year-old girl was pulled from her home and raped, police revealed the assault was ordered by the head of her village council.
updated 6:49 PM EDT, Thu July 10, 2014
If you believe the mood here, India is going to be the next China, the new frontier of global growth.
updated 3:58 AM EDT, Tue July 8, 2014
Decrepit constructions that don't conform to safety codes are a big problem in cities and towns across India.
updated 1:27 PM EDT, Fri July 11, 2014
When Raju the elephant was rescued after being shackled and abused for five decades, the story and picture of him "crying" went viral.
updated 12:09 PM EDT, Thu July 3, 2014
The tall cylindrical concrete structures hold solar powered machines that look and function like an ATM. Instead of cash, they dispense water.
updated 8:27 PM EDT, Mon July 7, 2014
Despite not having a national team in the tournament, many Indians have caught World Cup fever. Mallika Kapur reports.
updated 10:33 AM EDT, Mon June 23, 2014
An Indian grandmother tells CNN's Mallika Kapur why she tied her grandson to a bus stop.
updated 10:12 PM EDT, Wed June 18, 2014
India has a rape crisis -- but it will take a broad effort to change it.
updated 8:04 PM EDT, Mon June 16, 2014
Could certain spices help you live longer? CNN's Dr. Sanjay Gupta reports from Delhi, India.
updated 3:25 PM EDT, Tue June 10, 2014
CNN's Mallika Kapur takes a look at the push for change in India after another brutal rape has shocked the nation.
updated 9:24 AM EDT, Tue May 27, 2014
Is there a historic opportunity for peace and understanding between the two nations?
updated 11:10 PM EDT, Mon May 19, 2014
What will Narendra Modi's India look like? Likely less inclusive and less secular, say analysts.
updated 10:50 PM EDT, Mon May 26, 2014
India's new leader is considered a wildcard. Will he be aggressive, or a dove? What is his foreign policy? Does he have a vision?
updated 12:00 AM EDT, Mon May 26, 2014
For incoming Prime Minister Narendra Modi, securing India's energy needs over the next decade ranks among his greatest challenges.
updated 3:38 AM EDT, Fri May 16, 2014
Narenda Modi's track record leaves some worried about the future, writes Sunny Hundal.
Varanasi was a battleground in the elections. It's also holy ground for Hindus, a last stop for the dying.
updated 3:57 AM EDT, Thu May 15, 2014
CNN's Ravi Agrawal says China gets things done; India invents ways not to.
Decades ago, she was attacked at a rural police station, and her landmark case awakened India. What happened to her?
updated 2:18 PM EDT, Mon May 5, 2014
The spread of polio constitutes an international public health emergency, the World Health Organization declared Monday.
updated 6:03 AM EDT, Thu May 8, 2014
Air quality in most cities that monitor their pollution levels exceed what the World Health Organization deems as safe.
updated 11:07 PM EDT, Sun April 6, 2014
In India, many see George W. Bush as a better friend than U.S. President Barack Obama, says Ravi Agrawal.
updated 10:47 AM EDT, Tue April 29, 2014
Sitting cross-legged at her office desk, Abhina Aher expounds on what it means to be trapped in the wrong body.