Opinion: Turkey's Teflon politician targets top post

Supporters of Recep Tayyip Erdogan wave Turkish flags during a rally on August 3, 2014 in Istanbul.

Story highlights

  • Karabekir Akkoyunlu says Turkey has excessively centralized political architecture
  • That has allowed those who attain control of the state to force their will on the entire population, he writes
  • He says Erdogan understands power and pursues it like no other politician in Turkey's modern history

In less than a week, Turkey will hold its first direct presidential election, yet the mood about the country can hardly be described as electric.

This is strange given the usual excitement around elections in Turkey, the historic importance of this poll, and the exceptionally high level of socio-political tensions in recent years.

Besides the summer heat and the Muslim fasting month of Ramadan, the relative lull might be explained by the widespread anticipation that Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, candidate of the ruling AKP, will emerge triumphant from the ballot box, in either the first or the second round.

Erdogan understands power and pursues it like no other politician in Turkey's modern history.

Karabekir Akkoyunlu

He has a tightening grip over all key state institutions, save perhaps the Constitutional Court. He also has a deeply emotional relationship with his followers, who rally around their leader more passionately as he faces stiffer opposition to his increasingly personal rule.

This is how he has survived massive anti-government protests, a damaging feud with former Islamist allies and a high profile corruption scandal, an appallingly mismanaged industrial disaster and successive foreign policy debacles -- latest being the abduction of 49 Turkish diplomats and consulate workers in Mosul by ISIS militants, whose rise some critics attribute in part to the AKP government's open border policy for jihadis fighting in Syria -- all in the space of a year.

This might also explain the somber mood around many of his opponents, who seem to believe that having come so close to realizing his long standing ambition of becoming Turkey's first popularly elected president, Erdogan will not let the opportunity slip.

But the lull should not overshadow the critical importance of the election.

To be sure, an Erdogan victory would amount to no less than regime change for Turkey.

It would mark the most crucial step yet in its decade-long transformation from an imperfect parliamentary democracy under military tutelage towards a "plebiscitarian democracy" -- characterized by a powerful executive, a weak or compliant legislative, and a charismatic leader-follower relationship that is periodically reaffirmed in general elections and referenda.

One would be mistaken to think of the presidency, under Turkey's existing parliamentary system, as a ceremonial post that would deprive its occupant of the executive powers of a prime minister. Turkey has had ambitious presidents, such as Turgut Ozal (1989 -- 1993) and Ahmet Necdet Sezer (2000 -- 2007), whose influence was checked by hostile lawmakers or meddlesome generals. A President Erdogan wouldn't face these obstacles: his party controls the parliament and the military has been tamed through EU-backed reforms and two highly politicized court cases.

The current constitution, drawn up by the military junta in 1982, gives the head of state significant authorities, which Erdogan would push to the limit by invoking the "national will" he claims to embody; a claim that would be further reinforced and personalized in the event of his election.

Where would this scenario leave those who feel increasingly alienated, stifled and marginalized in Erdogan's new Turkey? Another electoral loss would be sure to further dispirit those who hoped to see some change to the political status quo after the Gezi protests of last summer.

Erdogan criticizes Egypt's approach to Gaza
Erdogan criticizes Egypt's approach to Gaza

    JUST WATCHED

    Erdogan criticizes Egypt's approach to Gaza

MUST WATCH

Erdogan criticizes Egypt's approach to Gaza 08:20
İhsanoğlu: No need for tension in region
İhsanoğlu: No need for tension in region

    JUST WATCHED

    İhsanoğlu: No need for tension in region

MUST WATCH

İhsanoğlu: No need for tension in region 05:40
Demirtaş: Turkey needs fundamental change
Demirtaş: Turkey needs fundamental change

    JUST WATCHED

    Demirtaş: Turkey needs fundamental change

MUST WATCH

Demirtaş: Turkey needs fundamental change 05:03
Akyol: We need rational foreign policy
Akyol: We need rational foreign policy

    JUST WATCHED

    Akyol: We need rational foreign policy

MUST WATCH

Akyol: We need rational foreign policy 05:58

But in defeat, there might be a valuable and necessary lesson. The two main opposition parties -- the secular republican CHP and the nationalist MHP -- have formed an informal coalition for the sole purpose of posing a numerical challenge to the AKP's relative majority, with anti-Erdoganism being their chief unifying cause.

Party leaders have handpicked candidates and determined election strategies with minimum public consultation. Only a handful of people were involved in the selection of Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu, the former secretary-general of the Organization for Islamic Cooperation, as the two parties' joint candidate for presidency.

Predictably, this uninspiring, ultra-pragmatic, top-down tactic came short in the local elections (even when one takes into account the allegations of voting fraud, the AKP remains the clear overall winner) and risks failing in the presidential one. More importantly, this style of politics is inimical to the grassroots, democratic and pluralistic vision that the "Gezi spirit" has aspired to capture.

Whatever the outcome of the presidential election, those who wish to see this vision transformed into reality would be better served by focusing on the long term process rather than short term gains, and on building organizational capacity at the level of local politics instead of obsessing over the control of state institutions in Ankara.

Success in local politics paves the way for success in national politics, as Turkey's political Islamists have shown time and again over the past two decades. But a true democratic transformation also requires devolution of political authority.

Since its foundation as a republic 91 years ago, Turkey's excessively centralized political architecture has allowed those who attain control of the state to force their will on the entire population.

The machinery that repressed ethnic minorities and pious Muslims in the past is now alienating non-practicing Muslims, Alevis, LGBTI members and other social and political minority groups who do not fit in with Erdogan's vision of an overtly religious neo-liberal Turkey.

Only a well-organized movement that takes its strength from local politics and stands for pluralism, decentralization and democratic rights and liberties of all citizens can break this vicious cycle of suppression and alienation.

Read more: Soma disaster threatens Turkey's fragile social contract
Read more: Opinion: Striving for 'sameness' Turkey stifles progress

        Turkey

      • Presidential candidate Selahattin Demirtas and member of Turkey's main pro-Kurdish party, People's Democratic Party, speaks during a campaign rally on Tuesday, July 15, in Istanbul.

        Turkey votes for president

        Turks are heading to the polls this weekend to vote for their first directly elected president. This is what you should know.
      • Supporters of the Turkish Prime Minister and Presidential candidate wave Turkish flags during a rally on August 3, 2014 in Istanbul. Tens of thousands of supporters of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan on August 3 massed in Istanbul for his last big rally in Turkey's largest city one week ahead of presidential elections. AFP PHOTO / OZAN KOSE (Photo credit should read OZAN KOSE/AFP/Getty Images)

        Defterios: Erdogan's aspirations

        How Erdogan performs if he wins the election will determine if Turkey can restore its luster as an engine for growth and a regional political force.
      • Turkey's Prime Minister and presidential candidate Recep Tayyip Erdogan addresses nomadic Turkish groups in Ankara, Turkey, on Wednesday, August 6.

        Opinion: Teflon politician

        Turkey will hold its first direct presidential election, yet the mood about the country can hardly be described as electric.
      • Caption:Turkey's Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan delivers a speech in front of posters of himself (R) and Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, the founder of modern Turkey, during a meeting of ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) at the party headquarters in Ankara on June 25, 2014. After three terms as prime minister -- the maximum allowed under the Justice and Development Party (AKP) rules -- Erdogan has made no secret of his ambition to seek the presidency in the August 10, 2014 election, the first time Turkish voters will directly elect the country's head of state. AFP PHOTO/ ADEM ALTAN (Photo credit should read ADEM ALTAN/AFP/Getty Images)

        What stifles progress in Turkey?

        Turkey's mainstream culture is deeply suspicious of "difference" -- be it cultural, ethnic or sexual, author Elif Shafak writes.
      • ctw intv orhan pamuk_00061618.jpg

        Orhan Pamuk, the voice of Istanbul

        Nobel Prize-winning author Orhan Pamuk is neither afraid to confront the human condition in his novels, nor his country's past and political present.
      • ctw full intv erdogan gaza turkey egypt_00045220.jpg

        Talking to Turkey's Erdogan

        Turkey's Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan talks about the situation in Gaza and his country's relationship with Qatar.
      • A woman supporting Turkey's Prime Minister cheers and wave Turkish and AK Party (AKP) flag during an election rally in Istanbul on March 23, 2014. Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan rallied hundreds of thousands of supporters on Sunday, dismissing accusations of intolerance by Western and domestic critics. 'I don't care who it is. I'm not listening,' he said to cheers. AFP PHOTO/BULENT KILIC (Photo credit should read BULENT KILIC/AFP/Getty Image

        Is leaving Turkey an option?

        Binnaz Saktanber recently moved back to Turkey after spending a decade abroad. How does she feel about the return?
      • exp ctw turkey İhsanoğlu_00002001.jpg

        Ihsanoglu: No need for tension

        CNN's Becky Anderson speaks to leading opposition candidate Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu about upcoming Turkish presidential elections.
      • Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan (R) and his wife Emine Erdogan (L) greet the crowd from the balcony of the Justice and Development Party headquarters in Ankara, Turkey on March 31, 2014. Turkey's Premier Recep Tayyip Erdogan claimed victory for his Islamic-rooted party in Sunday's key local elections and warned his foes they will 'pay the price' for plotting his downfall. AFP PHOTO / ADEM ALTAN (Photo credit should read ADEM ALTAN/AFP/Getty Images)

        Erdogan with local elections

        Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan dominated debates leading up to Sunday's local elections, even though he wasn't on the ballot.
      • A view of a computer screen showing a digital portrait of the Turkish Prime Minister and text reading 'Yes we ban' on a laptop computer screen, in front of graffiti in Istanbul, on March 27, 2014. Turkey banned video-sharing website YouTube today, having blocked Twitter a week earlier after both were used to spread audio recordings damaging to the government, local media reported. The move came hours after the release of an audio file on YouTube, purporting to be of a security meeting in which top government, military and spy officials discuss a possible scenario for military action inside Syria. AFP PHOTO / OZAN KOSE (Photo credit should read OZAN KOSE/AFP/Getty Images)

        Turkey's Twitter ban lifted

        Turkey's ban on the social media service Twitter has been lifted, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's office said Thursday.
      • Music, rhythm and belief united

        Turkey banned the the Mevlevis -- or "Whirling Dervishes" in 1925 but has since eased restrictions, allowing public worship.
      • Istanbul skyline

        My love affair with Istanbul

        CNN's Ivan Watson has lived in Istanbul for 12 years, using the city as a base for covering news in the Middle East and Asia.