Skip to main content

Controversial inflight device: Should the Knee Defender be banned?

By Karla Cripps, CNN
September 6, 2014 -- Updated 0042 GMT (0842 HKT)
What are the most annoying habits on airplanes? A series of seat recline skirmishes has passengers talking about the aggravations of air travel. Click through the gallery of 20 top irritants. What are the most annoying habits on airplanes? A series of seat recline skirmishes has passengers talking about the aggravations of air travel. Click through the gallery of 20 top irritants.
HIDE CAPTION
20 rudest things people do on planes
20. Abusing overhead bin space
19. Taking ages to choose a movie
18. Compulsive leg-shaking
17. Boarding ahead of group number
16. Babies crying
15. Getting huffy when you leave seat
14. Yacking on cell phone
13. Bringing aboard stinky food
12. Loud talking
11. Establishing armrest hegemony
10. Poaching shared middle seat
9. Coughing, sneezing, germ sharing
8. Playing games with sound on
7. Wielding huge suitcases as carry-ons
6. People behind trying to disembark first
5. Cutting fingernails
4. Baring feet
3. Hogging toilets
2. Reclining seat
1. Kicking seat-back
<<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
>
>>
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Knee Defender blocks passengers' ability to recline their seats
  • Recent fight aboard United Airlines flight calls into question whether such devices should be allowed
  • Incident sparks yet another debate over in-flight etiquette and whether passengers should recline

(CNN) -- You've been up since 3 a.m.

After dealing with long check-in lines, long security lines and long faces from flight attendants even unhappier to be on that plane than you, your 6 a.m. flight finally lifts off.

Knee Defenders cause in-flight fights
Man who used Knee Defender speaks out

"I'm just going to recline my seat and catch a couple of hours of sleep before we land," you think as the pilot switches off the seatbelt sign.

But wait. What's happening?

This device caused an in-flight fight

Despite pushing that little round silver button and digging your heels into the floor, your seat refuses to budge.

You've just been blocked by the Knee Defender.

The 2003 invention of 6'3-tall American Ira Goldman -- "I was tired of being bumped in the knees by reclining seats" -- the Knee Defender is a small pair of plastic clips that attach to your lowered seat-back table, locking the chair in front of you in place so the passenger can't recline.

Proof of its contentiousness came out this week when United Flight 1462 from Newark to Denver was forced to divert to Chicago's O'Hare airport after a fight broke out between two passengers over one's use of the device.

Despite the passengers getting kicked off the plane, the story has led to a boost in sales of the Knee Defender, with the website even crashing under the weight of all that curiosity.

MORE: Legroom fight diverts flight

Is the Knee Defender even allowed?

The U.S. Federal Aviation Administration says it hasn't banned the device as it doesn't have an impact on passenger safety.

But most major U.S. airlines, including United, do prohibit its use.

It's a similar situation elsewhere.

Both Air Canada and Calgary-based WestJet prohibit the Knee Defender, with the latter singling out the device on its website.

"You are not permitted to attach any unapproved device to any part of your seat or any other part of the aircraft," says WestJet.

"Some examples of unapproved devices include knee defenders, seat belt extensions and booster seats."

Same story in Australia, where carriers Qantas and Virgin have reportedly banned the device.

"The use of knee defenders or similar device would be in breach of our conditions of carriage (14.2 (b)(f)) which are available on our website," a Virgin Australia Airlines spokesperson told CNN.

"The safety and comfort of our guests remains our highest priority."

Singapore Air told CNN the crew would manage the use of the Knee Defender by customers on a case-by-case basis.

"We are reviewing the use of the device, though we have not received any feedback from our customers," said an airline spokesperson.

In the case of this week's United inflight battle, the flight attendant reportedly told the man to remove the Knee Defender device, but he declined.

The female passenger then threw water in his face.

The inventor is adamant that buyers should be considerate of other passengers when using the device, which costs $21.95.

Users of the device are even advised to print the Knee Defender courtesy card, which explains to the passenger in front of them that their legs are so long their knees will be banged if the flier's seat is reclined.

"If you would like to recline your seat at some point during the flight, please let me know and I will try to adjust myself and my Knee Defender so that it can be done safely."

MORE: Airplane scuffle spurs Knee Defender sales

To recline, or not to recline

The incident has brought to the fore the usual comments on plane etiquette.

Some say such devices infringe on passenger rights.

Simply put, if an airline allows offers a reclining mechanism -- and some low-cost carriers don't -- then tough luck for the fellow behind you.

If he/she doesn't like it, they should cough it up for an upgrade or request a front row seat upon booking, citing their long legs or an injury that requires extra room to stretch out.

In the case of United Flight 1462, the pair was seated in the Economy Plus section, which provides passengers up to five inches of extra legroom.

Others say passengers need to be respectful of fellow fliers.

MORE: Doh! 20 biggest travel mistakes

"I don't think any of the seats should be able to recline in economy," commented David Cleland in our article on the United dust up.

"I have tried to work with someone in front of me reclining and bouncing around. It really is infuriating. I have tried to ask the person in front of me to please not recline...I might have just spit in their coffee by the reaction I received."

Then there's the issue of flight time. Is it really necessary to recline your seat on a two-hour daytime flight? How about a red-eye cross-Atlantic journey?

Others -- including Knee Defender inventor Goldman -- blame the airlines for pushing us to the brink by taking away all our space.

So how would you react to being told you could only recline your chair a distance designated by the person behind?

Should airlines do away with reclining seats altogether?

Share your thoughts on the issue in the comments section below.

MORE: Airline squeeze: It's not you, 'it's the seat'

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
August 19, 2014 -- Updated 1514 GMT (2314 HKT)
Airlines and airports are going high-tech to reduce your time in line.
August 26, 2014 -- Updated 0115 GMT (0915 HKT)
Ever wondered what it takes to get that movie to your inflight screen? This special report details who, what and how much it takes to bring you the best in IFE (we'll explain).
July 30, 2014 -- Updated 1835 GMT (0235 HKT)
Takeoff on one of Airbus' new A350WXB test planes is a strangely quiet experience.
August 12, 2014 -- Updated 0906 GMT (1706 HKT)
Cars, craft beer, yetis? Since when did in-flight purchases get so strange?
July 17, 2014 -- Updated 1426 GMT (2226 HKT)
CNN takes a look at the new car-plane hybrid that brings affordable recreational air travel to the masses.
July 17, 2014 -- Updated 0339 GMT (1139 HKT)
It is the world's busiest route and there are few lengths airlines won't go to in the hopes of getting a piece of the action.
July 16, 2014 -- Updated 2136 GMT (0536 HKT)
Cathay Pacific was pronounced the world's best airliner of the year at the industry's leading awards ceremony in Farnborough on Tuesday.
July 11, 2014 -- Updated 0221 GMT (1021 HKT)
It's not some miserable dystopic movie scene about class polarization, it's a real thing that could arrive soon.
June 30, 2014 -- Updated 1253 GMT (2053 HKT)
Latest model of aircraft affectionately known as the Queen of the Skies gets the red ribbon treatment, but jumbo jets are facing tough times
June 12, 2014 -- Updated 1409 GMT (2209 HKT)
Aviation industry execs say they must focus more on customer experience.
June 5, 2014 -- Updated 1559 GMT (2359 HKT)
Could air passengers of the future could board planes via personal transport pods?
June 24, 2014 -- Updated 1723 GMT (0123 HKT)
A passenger is suing an airline for flying him to the wrong continent, and other surprisingly common destination mix-ups.
July 3, 2014 -- Updated 1657 GMT (0057 HKT)
Dreading airport security, lost luggage or that middle seat? These travel headaches could be a thing of the past by 2024, according to a new report on the future of travel.
June 24, 2014 -- Updated 0800 GMT (1600 HKT)
Fancy stripping off before a flight and getting sweaty with fellow passengers? Finnair think you might and is backing its idea with a sauna in its new airport lounge.
July 14, 2014 -- Updated 1526 GMT (2326 HKT)
This month, a young aviatrix will honor the woman she was named after by flying the same route made legendary in 1937.
ADVERTISEMENT