Walking The Walk
Lieberman's faith has been so central to his life that even his
political foes know to respect it
By RICHARD LACAYO
It was almost exactly two years ago, at that moment in the
Lewinsky matter when Bill Clinton was making his sweatiest dodges
about "inappropriate" behavior, that Bill Bennett, the saturnine
Republican, phoned Joe Lieberman, the deeply religious Democrat.
For several years Lieberman had been Bennett's partner in a fight
against Jerry Springer, blood-spurting video games, Marilyn
Manson and the general run of rap lyrics. Now Bennett wanted
Lieberman to speak to Clinton. "You need to tell him to resign,"
he said, "because you're Nathan."
Nathan? Bennett, a devout Roman Catholic, knew that Lieberman, an
Orthodox Jew deeply immersed in the Bible, did not need to be
reminded that Nathan was the prophet sent by God to upbraid King
David for inappropriate behavior with Bathsheba. "I thought
[Lieberman] was the closest thing in the Senate to an Old
Testament prophet," says Bennett.
So does Al Gore. That's one reason Lieberman found himself in
Nashville last week being introduced by Gore as his running mate.
Quite a stretch from four years ago, when Lieberman spoke at the
Democratic Convention but was wrongly introduced as a Senator
from New Jersey. There's a funny political symmetry at work this
year. The Republicans threw a Democratic Convention, all about
compassion and tolerance and inclusiveness. Now the Democrats
have a vice-presidential candidate who talks about God as eagerly
as any evangelical Republican. Lieberman describes himself as an
"observant Jew." Those are words that just begin to describe how
thoroughly he tries to match his understandings of the world to
his understandings of the Bible. Lieberman is not only the first
Jewish vice-presidential candidate but also an Orthodox Jew--or
"Modern Orthodox," to use the term that describes Jews steeped in
biblical studies yet, more than the ultra-Orthodox, inclined to
believe in living thoroughly in the here and now.
The world doesn't get more here and now than a presidential
campaign. So the next few months will go beyond merely testing
how well Lieberman can conduct a full campaign when he can't ride
in a car or talk on a telephone on the Jewish Sabbath, which runs
from sunset Friday to sunset Saturday. What will really be tested
is what happens to Gore's campaign with the addition of a man
like Lieberman, a Democrat who was happy to mention God more than
a dozen times in the first minute of that Nashville rally. Gore
really did gamble in his choice of running mate. Simply because
he's Jewish, Lieberman could be too Jewish for the anti-Semites.
And simply because he's so fervently religious, he could be too
religious for some parts of the Democratic vote.
"Religion is what drives the man," says Rabbi Barry Freundel,
Lieberman's spiritual adviser in Washington. "His religious
values shape the way he functions as a Senator." But if Lieberman
possesses the tragic sense that's one of Judaism's hard-earned
cultural gifts to Western civilization, he has managed to
subordinate it to an all-American contentment. "I grew up in a
multiethnic, multiracial, multireligious community, and I was
lucky," Lieberman told TIME last week. "I cannot remember a
single instance of anti-Semitism in my youth. That undoubtedly is
why I'm so optimistic about the country and about people judging
me fairly."
Lieberman's piety has made him so attractive to Christian
conservative leaders that not even Jerry Falwell could find a bad
word to say about him last week. Dan Coats, a former Republican
Senator from Indiana and an evangelical Christian, has been a
good friend of Lieberman's since the time in 1991 when the two
men found themselves seated together as part of a congressional
delegation on an overnight flight to Kuwait. When dawn broke,
they discovered they shared similar morning rituals. Lieberman
read from the Torah, Coats from the Psalms. "Our faith," says
Coats, "is the common denominator to finding common ground."
Lieberman's easy resort to the language of faith does not go down
so badly with some of the most liberal Democrats either. "We've
conceded too much of the values debate," says Minnesota Senator
Paul Wellstone. "I think you move people based on their sense of
right or wrong, and that gets back to core values. And that's
Joe's strength." But some of the Democratic Party's big Hollywood
donors, the ones who are expected to reopen their checkbooks at
the convention in Los Angeles this week, are not so sure. It was
Lieberman, after all, who with Bennett handed out "Silver Sewer"
awards, booby prizes for the media companies that produced the
skankiest cultural merchandise.
You don't have to be religious to hold Jerry Springer and Marilyn
Manson in contempt, but it's especially easy to see how
Lieberman's fight against them grows out of his religious
scruples. It's harder sometimes to be sure how Lieberman decides
which other issues are ones that his beliefs compel him to act
upon. In his new book, In Praise of Public Life, he complains
that society has gone too far in "normalizing" divorce. But his
earlier marriage ended when his first two children were barely
teens. And while he has said he believes life begins at
conception, he remains pro-choice on abortion.
In an op-ed piece in the Wall Street Journal last week, Michael
Medved, a conservative radio host and film critic who is an
Orthodox Jew, denounced Lieberman for saying on Larry King Live
that abortion is a "matter of personal judgment. And like
everything else in Judaism, ultimately it's up to each of us to
decide what we think is right." By no means, Medved said, and
accused Lieberman of trying to adapt his Orthodox faith to the
squishy moral relativism that he thinks is abroad in secular
society. "On abortion, gay rights, integrated barracks for male
and female soldiers, and a host of other issues," Medved wrote,
"Lieberman's political positions undeniably diverge from Orthodox
Jewish teaching."
And while Bennett may compare him to an Old Testament prophet,
Lieberman could be a reluctant one, even during the Lewinsky
matter. When he made his now famous speech on the Senate floor
denouncing Clinton's behavior as immoral, he stopped short of
calling for the President to resign. And when the issue of
removing Clinton from office finally came before the Senate,
Lieberman voted against it. Maybe he knew that the prophet
Nathan, after condemning King David in the most ferocious terms,
assured him that God would not take his crown or his life.
Bennett shrugs. "[Lieberman] got as close as he could."
Though Lieberman's faith has deepened over the years, he was
Orthodox from birth, the eldest of three children raised in a
devout household in Stamford, Conn., where his father owned a
liquor store. In high school, he was so observant that although
his classmates voted him king of the prom, he wasn't there to
take his throne beside the queen that night--the prom was held on
the Jewish Sabbath.
Lieberman arrived at Yale in 1960, where he eventually became
chief editor of the Yale Daily News. Three years later, while
working as a summer intern in the Washington office of
Connecticut Senator Abraham Ribicoff, he met his first wife
Betty. They had two children--Matt and Rebecca--but by 1981 their
16-year marriage was over. In his book Lieberman writes that
while there was "no single reason" for the failure of the
marriage, "some of it was related to the fact that I had become
much more religiously observant ... And there is no doubt that some
of it was caused by the demands my political career put on our
private life."
His political career moved fast. Not long after he graduated from
Yale Law School--student and then family deferments kept him out
of the Vietnam draft--he decided, as everybody had always expected
he would, to run for office. (At Yale they called him "Senator.")
He was elected first to the Connecticut state legislature, which
required him to knock off a maverick fellow Democrat in the
primary. An early shot at Congress was a bust; he tried for it in
1980, when Ronald Reagan's coattails suffocated Democrats
everywhere. But two years later he was elected state attorney
general, which gave him the chance to make a name for himself on
consumer issues. By 1988 he was ready for the Senate race, in
which he beat Lowell Weicker, Connecticut's most famously
independent Republican.
By that time he was five years into his second marriage, one that
friends say confirmed him in his impulse to become more
observant. Hadassah Lieberman's father was a rabbi in
Czechoslovakia. Both her parents were Holocaust survivors. A
graduate of Stern College, the women's school of Orthodox Yeshiva
University in New York City, she helps raise money for women's
health care in Israel and keeps a kosher household, with separate
plates for meat and dairy dishes. The Liebermans met in a very
old-fashioned Jewish way: through a matchmaker. "Religion centers
me," Hadassah told TIME last week. "It makes me prioritize my
life. I know there is something out there, and we feel humbled."
All the same, just days into the campaign she is already wary of
appearing too pious. "There are a lot of people who find their
centering in various ways," she says. "I'm not suggesting it has
to be through God. I'm saying that's what works for us. And we'll
share that with the whole country."
If Lieberman is elected, his observance of the Sabbath would not
have to interfere with government duties. Jewish law permits
exceptions in some cases. He is prohibited from riding in cars
on that day, and there are many stories of his walking long
distances in Washington to cast important Senate votes on a
Saturday. (He and Hadassah once walked miles in the rain to
attend the wedding of his driver.) "If you have an opportunity
to help people on the Sabbath, that overrides the normal
prohibitions," he told TIME. "When I was [Connecticut] attorney
general, they always knew on a holy day they could call me for
decisions or ask me to sign papers."
But there's no dispensation for purely political events, so
Sabbath campaign appearances are out. Lieberman was not present
when Connecticut's state Democratic Party met on a Saturday in
1982 to nominate him for attorney general. His observance of the
Sabbath may have cost him four years earlier, when he failed to
attend the party convention, then lost in a contest to be
nominated as lieutenant governor, a loss some say was due in part
to his absence from the hall. The prize went to William O'Neill,
who went on not only to be elected but also to assume the
governorship when Ella Grasso died in office.
Early last Monday morning, soon after Lieberman and his wife
heard on television that he had been chosen as Gore's running
mate, they joined their daughter Hana and Lieberman's
85-year-old mother Marcia around the breakfast table. Lieberman
offered a homemade prayer in Hebrew. "We thank God for this
miracle upon us, through a wonderful person like Al Gore and
through God's will." The family repeated the prayer in English,
says Marcia, "just so we could hear it again. God was smiling on
us." If the smiles keep coming and if the Gore-Lieberman ticket
wins, it will be interesting to see how the new Vice President
deals with the problem of his own Inauguration, which is
required by the 20th Amendment to the Constitution to occur on
Jan. 20. Next year, as it happens, that date falls on a
Saturday. --Reported by Ann Blackman, Jay Branegan, Elaine
Shannon and Karen Tumulty/Washington
|