CNN TV
SCHEDULE ANCHORS REPORTERS CONTACT US
Inside the Middle East
January 10, 2009
Posted: 1852 GMT

gaza24

 

–By CNN Producer Jomana Karadsheh

 

AMMAN, JORDAN – Even without turning on the news, you hear about Gaza every day and almost everywhere in Jordan.

 

Support for the Palestinians in Gaza has been huge in the Kingdom that is home to the largest Palestinian refugee population in the world. From aid drives to large demonstrations and blood donations, people here are doing what they can to show solidarity with the people of Gaza.

 

This Saturday afternoon I walked into my hairdresser's shop in Amman. She, like more than half of Jordan's population, is of Palestinian origin. The first thing I saw when I walked in was the pictures of wounded Gazans on one of the Pan-Arab TV news channels she had on.

 

As most women in the place went about what they were doing, one old lady sat by the TV gazing at the images and mumbling to herself.

 

I sat close to her sipping on my Turkish coffee, trying to understand what she was saying, but with women chatting and the sound of blow driers and the TV in the background, i could not make what she was saying. I couldn't help but stare at her, there was something about the sadness in her eyes that was different than what i'd seen in other Jordanian eyes since this conflict began.

 

A few minutes later the images of two children crying with blood streaming down their faces ran on this channel- her voice got a bit louder and i could kind of hear what she was saying "Ya Allah... Ya Allah" – Arabic for "Oh God... Oh God".

 

She looked at me and asked where I was from, I said Jordanian and asked where she was from, "I am from Gaza" she said with great sadness in her voice. The old lady explained that she is a Palestinian-Jordanian, but most of her family is in Gaza.

 

"We know of one relative killed so far... Wallahi (By God) I am always watching the news to hear what neighborhoods have been bombed so i can call and check on my family," she said while still staring at the TV.

 

"You know how cold it is there now? They have no windows, all the glass was shattered...they have no heating.. yesterday i called to check on them and different members of the family had gathered in one place, you know how people feel safer in groups... they have no heating so they were breaking down wooden doors in their homes and burning them for heat. There were about 60 of them and about 25 loaves of bread as a meal for the whole day, so everyone was eating a little bit," she said choking back her tears.

 

As she slowly got up to leave, the old lady blamed it all on world leaders, especially Arab leaders, and said if it were up to the people, this would not be happening.

 

 

The voices on the streets of the Jordanian capital for the past week have mostly called for the expulsion of the Israeli Ambassador in Amman and cutting diplomatic ties with Israel. But at one demonstration we covered last Sunday there were more extreme calls.

 

Thousands of men, women and children carrying the banners of the Muslim Brotherhood, the curbed Islamic movement in Jordan, marched in a protest towards the country's parliament.

 

Women covered from head to toe and children waving small green flags of the movement were repeating the men's chants calling for car bombs to hit Tel Aviv and more rockets to strike Sderot.

 

In their thousands these demonstrators called for Jihad, martyrdom and blood to avenge the deaths in Gaza.

 

Although I had covered previous protests in Jordan over the Iraq war, these mass calls and the anger on the streets was the first time I had heard this many people here calling for extremism.

 

Despite the fears of this current crisis only breeding more extremism and violence in the long run, there are many who remain moderate, but a lot of them see little hope for peace anytime soon in this region.

 

One of them, a Palestinian-Jordanian who, like many Palestinians, has never visited his family's birthplace said to me: "They think they will destroy Hamas? What they are doing is creating a hundred other Hamas."

Filed under: Gaza •Hamas •Israel •Jordan


Share this on:
Laura   January 10th, 2009 7:17 pm ET

Such a pity that you only see and report your own version of the truth. There is so much that you don't acknowledge to yourself nevermind your readers. Try learn and teach a little real history, not your version, and you might be able to see what the real causes of the Gaza and 'Palestinians' are. Only then is it possible for you to be a 'grown-up'. At the moment all you are doing is ensuring that every new-born Palestinian will be trained to murder and maim. For this purpose you need to have your own country? You don't need your own country; all you need is flags, guns, rockets and plenty of land to bury all the uneducated masses.

Beny   January 10th, 2009 7:17 pm ET

Very kind of Jordanians, especially remembering how in 1979 they massacred 25,000 Palestinians. Now they call us "murderers".
Hypocritical, innit?

"In their thousands these demonstrators called for Jihad, martyrdom and blood to avenge the deaths in Gaza."

Yeah, and Jihad has helped them a lot throughout the years, has it? It is that Jihad that brought the Israeli tanks on them in the first place, and they want to KEEP IT UP?!

P.S. Israel is giving Jordan 50 billion gallons of water each year as part of the peace treaty. I suggest this changes.

Fawad Ali   January 10th, 2009 7:17 pm ET

Massacre should stop

Fawad Ali   January 10th, 2009 7:19 pm ET

IN GAZA, Israeli soldiers are killing children like animals

Fawad Ali   January 10th, 2009 7:20 pm ET

They are not allowing Media, isn't that enough "Israelis are doing everything to hide their crimes and trying their best to falsely implicating Palestinians for things they have not done"

Beny   January 10th, 2009 7:21 pm ET

This "massacre" will stop the rockets stop permanently. And that includes Israeli control of smuggling tunnel areas.

You want this massacre to stop? Turn to Hamas. They brought it on Gaza and their stubbornness against stopping arming themselves and bombarding Israeli towns is what keeps this up.

Fawad Ali   January 10th, 2009 7:23 pm ET

Media is barred,

UN is attacked,

Resolutions have been ignored,

And thousands of people have been killed and mutilated ,

What happened against Jews 60 years ago, is happening against Muslims right now,

it’s very unfortunate that the US again is sitting on the sidelines and watching the worst

blood is red   January 10th, 2009 7:40 pm ET

I agree with Mr. Obama that is not acceptable to attack with rockets his home where his daughter sleeping. (His statement when he was visiting Israel) But I was expecting from him to have the decency to coming out and make the statement that is also unacceptable to attack by airplane and helicopters and with any other means for retribution the houses of others. ISRAELI OR PALESTINIANS for that matter.
When Georgia bombed South Osetia the world condemns the Russian response like an aggression in disproportion with the size of the Georgia attack to the Osetians. Now the retaliation of the Israelis against Hamas rudimentary rockets is clearly disproportionate to the extreme. Peace in Middle East is not possible when Israel attack and kill civilians with the approval of the USA and when the Arabs use the Palestinians for political gains!
U.N Resolutions only good for the invasion of Iraq. What about numerous resolutions against Israel?
Not Nuclear weapons for Iran. What about the nuclear weapons of Israel?
Shame, Shame!
We know already Bush but we not expecting
Double standards from you to MR .OBAMA

Beny   January 10th, 2009 7:42 pm ET

Fawad,

For everyine that cries when Israel "violates a UN resolution", where were you when Hamas violates the Children's Rights resolutions:

Indoctrinating hate and war in schools

Using the same schools as launching pads

Sending 14-year-olds to blow up at checkpoints

Dragging kids around to defend themselves, (a.k.a. USING THEM AS HUMAN SHIELDS)

This video shows it all and there are many more examples.

Or do children only have rights when you want to bash Israel?

Beny   January 10th, 2009 7:48 pm ET

HOW ABOUT THIS VIDEO? HAMAS ADMIT TO USING HUMAN SHIELDS:

Peter   January 10th, 2009 7:48 pm ET

Israel is a terrorist State. It doesn't want peace, neither with Hamas or Fatah (PLO – Arafat organization), nor with any other Palestinian organization.
Israel says it has a right to exist – but not like that.
Israel controls the entire economic infra structure down there, it controls all the water rights too.
Israel builds a fence around Gaza and stealing more land of the Palestinians. They turned Gaza into a Warsaw Ghetto.
Their arguments for this massacre are nothing but fake and the whole world knows it, except the Media which is controlled by Jews.
Israel was founded in 1948, before that there has never been a State of Israel.
Palestine has a right to exist they should have their own state.
Israel should be internationally isolated and they should give all those Billions back to the US that the APAC funneled out for them.

Beny   January 10th, 2009 8:03 pm ET

And NOW tell me why all these needless deaths

salutmiddleeast   January 10th, 2009 8:04 pm ET

@Fawad
why you are saying such things that you have not even only one evidence for it?
please say resonable things this is not a entertainment blog!!!
you said "Israelis are doing everything to hide their crimes and trying their best to falsely implicating Palestinians for things they have not done"
it is very funny that you said "it is enough that they are not allowing media there" for your expression.
and it is also very funny that you said "And thousands of people have been killed and mutilated"!!! I surprised when you said "mutilated"what is your evidence for your remark?
does anyone wandering there and mutilating people? did you said this?It is your opinion?

JEFF GORDON   January 10th, 2009 8:05 pm ET

WAR IS THE LAST RESORT IN AN UNTENABLE SITUATION.ISRAEL HAS THE RIGHT TO DEFEND IT'S BORDERS,IT'S TOWNS HAVE BEEN UNDER A BARRAGE OF MISSILES FROM HAMAS FOR MANY YEARS.THIS HAS LEFT THOUSANDS OF CHILDREN PERMANENTLY EMOTIONALLY SCARRED.WAR IS NEVER A PRETTY SIGHT IT IS CRUEL ,AND ALWAYS CLAIMS INNOCENT VICTIMS.BUT TERRORIST ORGANISATIONS DO NOT UNDERSTAND DIPLOMACY,ESPECIALLY THOSE WHO'S AGENDA IS THE DESTRUCTION OF ISRAEL AND ALL WESTERN VALUES.'WE ARE LIVING IN A CRAZY WORLD ONLY WHEN ALL PEOPLES ARE DEDICATED TO PEACE WILL WAR BECOME AN ANOMALY AND THE WORLD BE BALANCED.

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 8:06 pm ET

and CNN helps hamas by double talk reporting:

"The Israelis have been bombing hundreds of underground tunnels between Gaza and Egypt, contending that Hamas militants smuggle arms through them as well as supplies.

CONTENDING???????

CNN, where did they get the Grad rockets from, with the trucks supplying food and fuel from Israel?/

CONTENDING

or did some jounalists bring them in when they still went in to pity the terrorists?

CNN, you are hypocrits. I still remember when you reported that "an alleged terrorist boarded an Israeli bus and blew himself up killing 23 passengers of the bus"

alleged terrorist? what could he have been? a plumber? a teacher? a shoemaker? a taxi driver?

shame on you CNN, you do not report, you editorialize

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 8:08 pm ET

"And thousands of people have been killed and mutilated "

mutilating dead bodies is a muslim sport

it was done in jenin to the two soldiers who were lynched

it was done in Mumbai to the rabbi and his wife

salutmiddleeast   January 10th, 2009 8:10 pm ET

But I am strongly opposite with killing innocents there.

Rod   January 10th, 2009 8:12 pm ET

"All of the Palestinians must be killed; men, women, infants, and even their beasts." This was the religious opinion by Rabbi Yisrael Rosen, director of the Tsomet Institute, a long-established religious institute attended by students and soldiers in the Israeli settlements of the West Bank.

This is what is happening now! with American TAX Money

Beny   January 10th, 2009 8:13 pm ET

Hey Dan! Take over for me, will ya? It's 10 pm here and I have a big week starting tomorrow. So I abandon you to these liars. Good luck.

laila tov

Raj   January 10th, 2009 8:14 pm ET

It is a pity and shameful how this one sided conflict is allowed to continue and the world just watches. We all know that the militants are no match for a superior army. Now if there was oil in Gaza, we the ‘Western Powers’ would have been there on day-one, justifiably, insisting on human rights.

There is no justification for Hamas to attack innocent Israeli’s via rockets and human martyrs nor is it justifiable for a self proclaimed super power in the region to pound the innocent civilians enclosed within a small area through planes and tanks. Having Supported Obama, it is very sad that he has not shared sentiments as per how the innocent children, women and men feel when planes bomb their homes. You can't kill many innocent civilians to catch a few criminals. Where is the justification for that?

American foreign policy perhaps! Or was it the colonial divide and conquer mentality of the British Rule that continues to aggravate conflicts around the world? Let’s hope for the best after January 20th.

blood is red   January 10th, 2009 8:17 pm ET

Bastards! YOU learn from your teachers the NAZI.
The use of heavy artillery and tanks ,also air force bombing ,to places where civilians are living in ratio 4.000 people or more to square kilometer is targeting consciously CIVILIANS , KIDS, WOMANS and. ELDERLY That is the last present of the Bush administration to ISRAEL Politician because of the elections .
I am not Arab I am not Jew I am not living in Gaza .I AM HUMAN AND disgusted by THE USA DOUBLE STANTARDS. Enough make use of THE Holocaust (trade mark) to abusing others!

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 8:19 pm ET

"Israel will exist and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it, just as it obliterated others before it"

from the hamas charter

this is whatt hamas wants to do, kill the jews, and ROD supports them

Rod supports murder of civilians (as long as they are jewish, of course)

Rod supports the destruction of a sovereign state by suicide bombers, grad rockets, lynch etc

Rod supports oblteration by islam

what a nice man, this ROD

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 8:20 pm ET

beny

lama ata choshev she ani lo baaretz?

Ali   January 10th, 2009 8:22 pm ET

Israel is acting as a bully, not listening to UN resolutions, International calls, Aid and Huminitarian organizations to stop targeting civilians. CNN finaly admitted that Israel was the one who broke the truce with Hamas. It is amazing the difference between CNN International and the CNN broadcasting in the USA, the media in the US is very bias, unlike the one in Europe.

thanks.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 8:22 pm ET

Hi All

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 8:23 pm ET

linda

what's up?

Linda   January 10th, 2009 8:25 pm ET

I was on the other blog, but Mohammed was trying to fight with me, why I don't know, so I came over here. Evidently he has not read my blogs to even see what I am about. Whatever!

Linda   January 10th, 2009 8:26 pm ET

I posted this on the other one, but it warrants being posted here too.

Here is a tid bit of info I came across.
The UN reports(if you choose to believe it) that the United States is the biggest contributer of aid to Gaza. According to them, this fact gets lost in the shuffle because the money is given through the UN.
Here are a couple of other organizations that the United States gives aid to Gaza.

america.gov and usaid.gov
I tried to post them with the links, but I guess they are moderating postings with links now

Linda   January 10th, 2009 8:28 pm ET

Hey Rod,
Are you going to speak to me today?

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 8:29 pm ET

rod is on this one, but he is awfully quiet now (see above)

beny just signed off

haled maashal, from his safe haven in damascus just said
Hamas would agree to a ceasefire on four conditions: The Israeli offensive must halt, the IDF must withdraw from Gaza, the blockade must be lifted, and the crossings opened.

in other words, they can continue terrorize israel as long as they want

we"ll see about that

Rod   January 10th, 2009 8:32 pm ET

I am against killing all civilians Jews and Arabs Hamas Does not Represent all Muslims and you all know that they cannot destroy Israel they Know it and Everyone Else does

OK so what do you say about this

UN levels war crimes warning at Israel
Killing of 30 people in Gaza when army shelled house full of evacuees ‘has all hallmarks of war crime’, says high commissioner for human rights

Navi Pillay, the UN high commissioner for human rights, singled out the killing this week of up to 30 Palestinians in Zeitoun, south-east of Gaza City, when Israel shelled a house where its troops had told about 110 civilians to take shelter.

Pillay, a former international criminal court judge from South Africa, told the BBC the incident “appears to have all the elements of war crimes”.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/jan/09/gaza-palestinians-israel-evacuees-zeitoun

Now if Hamas is the problem why kill civilians you put in a house as a Shelter. this really explains the Hamas Charter ! or this is justified by it?

Linda   January 10th, 2009 8:33 pm ET

Hi Rod

Meh   January 10th, 2009 8:38 pm ET

"Killing of 30 people in Gaza when army shelled house full of evacuees ‘has all hallmarks of war crime’, says high commissioner for human rights"

Putting amongst those evacuees Hamas terrorists and using that house as a launching pad also has all the hallmarks of a war crime, normal logic (that I trust more than "high commisioner") says.

Rod   January 10th, 2009 8:38 pm ET

Linda,

Hello, I am a mature person. so i talk to everyone.
I really want you to understand that those warmongers are harming Humanity more than anything else.
those people who are blindly supporting this massacre show there hatred to humanity and lack of respect to human life.

They can distribute their hate everywhere but people of reason will never condone this killing. It is just the criminals who do and we have some here that they are very apparent to those who have common since.

This is a very unethical crime that is happening against humanity.

Meh   January 10th, 2009 8:40 pm ET

and the links beny gave about child abuse, using them as shields to protect the Hams, they don't show 'war crimes'?

it is undoubtably a crime, and used for war on israel. i call it a war crime of the worst degree

Linda   January 10th, 2009 8:40 pm ET

Well Rod,
You do not have to correspond with me, but I will tell you that you were very unfair to Nona last night. American Jew and I were both trying to tell you that you mistaked her for someone else's comments. You would not acknowledge that, and it was not fair.
Even though we disagree on many points, you have been fair. I hope you apologize to her when you see her online next.

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 8:41 pm ET

You don’t need your own country; all you need is flags, guns, rockets and plenty of land to bury all the uneducated masses."

Laura.
..may be you dont need your country too. maybe you need another holocaust the same holocaust that you are inflicting on the Palestinians.
as I said before Israel is creating more Hamases and it does not look good for Israel.

as for uneducated People that you want to bury. the Palestinians are more educated than the Jews if you are stupid not to know that then you are an uneducated person and your words tell us how Ignorant you are.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 8:41 pm ET

rod,
This is a very unethical crime that is happening against humanity.

You are correct.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 8:43 pm ET

Hi Solomon,
Nice to see you

Meh   January 10th, 2009 8:45 pm ET

"those people who are blindly supporting this massacre show there hatred to humanity and lack of respect to human life. "

take a look in that video beny gave about hamas admitting use of human shields and tell me now who has no respect for human life.

i understand they have no respect for the lives of israelis, but do they not have respect for the lives of their own brothers?

it seems that the only thing that hamas and their supporters DO respect is death. they are proud to die in order to kill.

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 8:49 pm ET

"HOW ABOUT THIS VIDEO? HAMAS ADMIT TO USING HUMAN SHIELDS

:Beny.

It does not say any thing about taken children as human shields it is your fabricated Jewish translation that is saying that.
if you are stupid not to know how the Palestinians thinks about their homeland and the sacrifices they are willing to give to that homeland then wait and see the results in the next few weeks and months.

Rod   January 10th, 2009 8:50 pm ET

I was going to without you asking actually I came to see her.

But it was disappointing to see that some are condoning the killing and justifying stuff that are done. the pictures are clear the reports are clear. I do not think hamas has the sympathy of the media it is the media that is showing what is happening on the ground. I remember 7 or 8 years ago they interviewed one Aljazeera guy and they asked him why you keep showing the atrocities of the palestinians people and them being bombarded by airplanes the guy simply said " we show everything that is happening, if the Israeli airplanes are dropping flowers instead of bombs we will show it too"

it made sense to me.

we just cannot dismiss everything that is happening and keep supporting this massacre. look for example at this guy who says hamas was in the house that the Israeli military has evacuated people into and bombed this is why it was bombed? that is a very logical explanation because we are all retarded and every American person out there is a RETARD! they will buy it.

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 8:50 pm ET

Hi Linda nice to see you too.

Meh   January 10th, 2009 8:51 pm ET

Solomon,

"the Palestinians are more educated than the Jews"

I can argue that, but it will slide into racism which i don;t want. I'll just say that all the palestinians are educated for is death for the sake of allah.

p.s. funny to see you call linda, a biology (professor or PhD?), uneducated, while everything you have ever posted here flows from the keyboard of someone who probably replaced history lessons with Qasam-shooting field days.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 8:55 pm ET

Rod,
I am so glad to hear you were coming to see her, She was very upset. I knew you were a big man :)
I think there is so much propaganda coming out of both sides, through the press, that no one knows what to believe. Call me stupid, but there is so much human suffering on all sides, and that is what I would like to focus on.
We have to stop the suffering! and you are so right, no one can support a massacre.
And please don't say that every American person is a retard and will buy it, because there are plenty of us on here that won't.

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 8:56 pm ET

"And NOW tell me why all these needless deaths"

Beny .

if you are trying to rewrite a new history of the Middle east without success of course. is it hard for you and your Zionist faccist brothers to fabricate translations of vedeos .

Rod   January 10th, 2009 8:58 pm ET

Linda,
I tell you last night, I went to bed and i was feeling a very Horrible feeling.
I just imagined this little kid who fed his 2 siblings who were dying from their wounds and could not be evacuated for 4 days because the IDF bombed the house they were in and won't let Red cross in.
I thought if i was that child what would I do 4 days with my mother. sibling and other peoples corpuses.

If he was an american child or a Israeli child hit by hamas you will see the pictures all over the place. ( he does not need that)

To tell you the truth if I was him I would have preferred to die. I thin death in that instance is more merciful than the Horror.

Muhamad Ali   January 10th, 2009 8:59 pm ET

Some of Israel’s most blatant critics have written that for every Israeli killed, about a hundred Palestinians were killed. A half-truth is worse than a lie, but this is not even a half truth. This is deception. Because months and years of rockets fired at a civilian population are not a matter for bloody accounts. It is a nuisance that no country, neither Syria nor Sweden, would tolerate. It is a provocation that requires a tough response. And if we are already going for bloody accounts, we should do the overall math. We can suffice with just the accounting in the Arab-Muslim world.

So, since the establishment of the State of Israel, close to 12 million Arabs and Muslims have been butchered, most of them by Arabs and Muslims. Israel’s “contribution,” since its establishment, is 60,000, and that includes all the wars and the two Intifadas. In other words, half a percent.

And more importantly, the confrontation is not between Hamas with its rockets and Israel. The confrontation is between Hamas, as one of the entities that compose radical Islam, and the free world. Its declared goal is to establish a world Islamic caliphate as part of an anti Semitic ideology that also calls for the annihilation of the Jews. Explanations will follow. And since political Islam has already annihilated millions without any announcement, we should take it seriously when there is an announcement about annihilation.

Is Hamas part of the global Jihad? Section 7 of the Hamas Covenant explains that it is not a local movement, nor even a national movement. The heading is “The global nature of the Islamic resistance movement.” And later, “Because the Muslims are spread throughout the entire world, the movement is global.” To remove any doubt, Dr. Yunis Al Astal, a member of the Palestinian parliament, one of the senior Hamas officials, who served as dean of the faculty are of Shariyah and chairman of the Islamic Law Department at Islamic University, stated that "We Will Conquer Rome, and from There Continue to Conquer the Two Americas and Eastern Europe."

Is this a movement that calls for the annihilation of the Jews? That is what is written in a continuation of the same section. “The messenger (Mohammed) said, “The Muslims will fight the Jews and the Muslims will kill them, until the Jew hides behind the stones and the trees, and then the stones and the trees will say, ‘Oh, Muslim, Abd Allah, there is a Jew who is hiding, come and kill him.” And this is in addition to blaming the Jews for all the wars in the world, for world domination, etc.

The problem is not with quotes from the sources. After all, even Judaism has Rabbi Shimon, who said, “The best gentile is a dead one.” But that did not become the foundation for any movements. Certainly not for a government party. To the contrary. There are innumerable interpretations explaining the circumstances of that statement and its lack of relevance. Not so with Hamas. The old imperative has become a practical instruction. And the Hamas leaders leave no room for doubt.

Sheikh Muhsin Abu Ita stated on the Al Aqsa channel that “The annihilation of the Jews is a wonderful blessing.” Dr. Ahmed Bahar, acting speaker of the Palestinian parliament stated that “the Jews are cancer, and they and the Americans should be destroyed to the last person.” According to the Palestinian constitution, this man, Bahar, will become the head of the Palestinian Authority if Abu Mazen ceases to function. Dr. Al Astal made clear that the annihilation order is a matter for our time and not for the future, and that "we are sure that the Holocaust is still to come upon the Jews".

The book by Dr. Matthias Kuntzel, “Jihad and Jew-Hatred,” elaborates on the annihilation ideology of radical Islam, including among Hamas. We have not yet succeeded in imparting this awareness to the world. It is still not too late.

There is no logic in madness

The most symbolic event occurred in Iraq. A Shi’ite suicide bomber carried out his attack during a Sunni demonstration of identification with Hamas. A bit confusing, no? After all, this Shi’ite terrorist was supposed to be serving Iranian interests. Iran, as we know, is the country that aids Hamas. And even the battle cries of the demonstrators contained the common denominator of the Shi’ites and the Sunnis: burning Israeli flags and calling for its extermination. So why commit suicide there, of all places? Who was he working for? What exactly was he trying to achieve? Against whom was he protesting? Don’t look for answers, because we are dealing with madness. And any attempt to find some logic is doomed to failure.

Slaughter for the sake of slaughter

Samuel Huntington – the prophet of the Clash of Civilizations – died. He was wrong. There is primarily another war, of political Islam against Muslims. And, in effect, it is not a war. It is one-sided slaughter in which the radicals slaughter others, and the others have no idea of how they might have sinned. Women and children who were butchered in villages in Afghanistan and Algeria by the Taliban or the Islamic Front were not collaborating with the West.

It was slaughter for the sake of slaughter. Just like the hundreds of Indians in Mumbai, among whom were 44 Muslims (far more than the Westerners or Jews) who were massacred by other Muslims. Exactly like hundreds of Muslims who are slaughtered by other Muslims in innumerable suicide attacks in Pakistan,.

But there is a small addition. In the case of Muslims, 95% of the protest from Pakistan through Um el Fahem to Londonistan, is in favor of the radical Muslims. Muslims in favor of those who are massacring them. Like the demonstrators in Iraq. The fact that they came to demonstrate for Hamas and against Israel did not help them. They, too, were worthy of slaughter. We have already said that there is no logic. We reiterate it.

Israel is defeating itself

Lately, when the prevarication mills (the “industry of lies”) began working at full steam on the bitter fate of the refugees in the Gaza Strip, who once again were forced to experience violence, the Cinematheque in Tel Aviv screened the film, The Forgotten Refugees, by director Michael Grynszpan. The film has already been shown in many places around the world, including in the U.S. Congress, but not on any channel in Israel.

The film deals with the Jewish communities in Muslim countries – a million people at the end of the second world war – who were forced to leave or expelled with an enormous amount of property expropriated. They became refugees, primarily in Israel.

The Nakba occurred because the Arabs rejected the UN proposal, and because they declared a war of annihilation on Israel. The Nakba of the Jews in Islamic countries, in contrast, occurred without a reason. The Jews of Morocco or Yemen or Iraq or Egypt did not declare any war. But despite that, in some cases, in Iraq and in Libya, dozens of Jews were slaughtered.

There is no "progressive" academic who does not inflate the Dir Yassin episode. But the slaughter of Jews by Arabs is never mentioned. Most of them arrived with absolutely nothing. They lived in immigrant camps. But they were not perpetuated as an open wound, as refugees, like the Palestinians.

Israel, for reasons that are hard to understand, has never played the card of the Jewish refugees. The story of the forgotten refugees could have been the unequivocal Israeli response to the issue of the Palestinian refugees. After all, the right of the Jewish refugees to reparations is far greater than the right of the Palestinians.

The former suffered and were forced out, despite the fact that they started no war and declared no annihilation. The latter did. So the Jews, and only the Jews, have the right to reparations. Those who do not succeeded in executing their plots of annihilation have no right to reparations. There is no historical precedence for an aggressor who turns himself into a victim. Such an absurdity has never existed, nor will it. Even in this matter, Israel has defeated itself in the propaganda battle. And here, too, it is not too late to rectify the error.

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 8:59 pm ET

p.s. funny to see you call linda, a biology (professor or PhD?

Meh
. there are thousands of PHD;s that are uneducated in politics.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 9:03 pm ET

Rod,
and unfortunately that child will have to live with that horror for the rest of his life. It breaks my heart.
I am so sorry you went to bed with that on your mind. I read that as you were leaving.
I think, no matter what anyone's stance is, that it is effecting people in such profound ways, even half way around the world.
what a shame that this is the world we live in.
Are you feeling any better this today?

Rod   January 10th, 2009 9:04 pm ET

When i said everyone is a RETARD i was sarcastically saying it not affirming it. American people are smart people. They do not believe the Israeli Military and Political Propaganda.
You know everyone in their heart know that the one who is killed is not the aggressor.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 9:05 pm ET

Solomon,
I don't work anymore, so I am just Linda. I don't get online and try to boast about my education. I do research on my own for Autoimmune Diseases now, for my own personal treatment.

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 9:08 pm ET

Meh.
.I was just reading todays Guardian.this is part of what they are saying

The Palestinians are among the most thoroughly educated people in the world. For decades, Palestinian society – both at home in the West Bank and Gaza, and scattered in the diaspora – has put a singular emphasis on learning. After the expulsions of 1948 and after the 1967 occupation, waves of refugees created an influential Palestinian intelligentsia and a marked presence in the disciplines of medicine and engineering across the Arab world, Europe and the Americas

Rod   January 10th, 2009 9:09 pm ET

What i am after is that they should not kill Palestinian civilians for the Elections ( women, and kids should not be massacred). It is about the elections in February more than anything else.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 9:12 pm ET

Rod,
I am against the killing of women and children too. I have so many questions about it though.
I am not sure what the reasons are for all of this on BOTH sides. I think is goes deeper than just land, open boarders, etc, on the side of Hamas, and I also wonder if there is more to it on the Israel side. There is so many factions to this, and I'm not sure either side is willing to admit it.

Rod   January 10th, 2009 9:25 pm ET

Linda so sorry for your condition.
let me tell you what i was thinking about what we do.
I was a very outspoken opponent for the war on Iraqi civilians.
I said million and million times this war was for oil, personal hatred to Saddam and has its religious motives ( the extremist religious establishment in the united states)

the results over 30 war lords controlling the streets in Iraq. 1.2 million Iraqis killed, 7 million displaced 80% of them are women and children under 12. we lost over 4 thousand of our young men and women. and over 30 thousand casualties. Spent 1 trillion dollars on this war and we are going into depression not even recession as they tell us.

What if this one trillion dollars were spent on healthcare , energy and healthcare related research.

We would have created millions of jobs in research. we would have contributed to humanity like no other nation in history did. we would have created a new class of researchers that no other country in the world will have. and the economy would have been in the best shape is ever been and for many decades if not centuries.

NIH spends around 28 billion dollars onhealthcare research each year. can you imagine what a trillion over 5 years would have done?

Akiva   January 10th, 2009 9:26 pm ET

Israel did sed death ... and will havarest it !

i am so sure about!

erywhere in the world people begin to hate jews!
and the world is boiling!
all know US is supporting jews !
CNN is very at the side of israel ... also if it is very hard to keep that side

at other places the leaders try to tranquilize the people
but so much people are going crazy ... and many leaders, who will not act, and so also support israel, will also have to feel the pover of theyr own population! ... politics are going out of controll!
and all people know only one thing ... its because the jews !

allready today i saw jews, so stupid to shout against all muslims, and what they did earn! they were attaked :(
they had to run for life! :(

and that allready in europe !

thats what israel is calling peace!
thats what isral is calling "change of reality"

well done ... the cownt down at israel has bn startet by israel it self
so is it that what the jews are choosen for by god?
choosen to die ?

well done thanks ... now we must hide !
well done !
thanks

brandon360   January 10th, 2009 9:29 pm ET

The idf needs to start the third stage, just heard they got masri today that s.o.b deserved what he got, wish they could take mashal out, its amazing how they talk so big when there miles away comfy in syria.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 9:35 pm ET

Rod,
Your money equation is correct. We could have done so much more for humanity if we would have spent that money differently.
As far as why the United States went to war with Iraq, I am sure that there are many reasons,even as an American, that we will ever know.
I so hate the number of everyone that has died in that war. I will also tell you that I reserve to voice an opinion on whether it was right or wrong to go into Iraq because I do not have all of the facts, and our soldiers are on the ground there. Until every soldier is back home, I will not criticize it. Also as an American, I hope to think that our government has more information than I do.
This is my point about this war, the people in the situation have more information about it than I do.
With that being said, dead is dead, and it is forever.

Thomas   January 10th, 2009 9:36 pm ET

The Palestinians need to decide which way they want to go.

1.) Let Hamas run their Government and do away with the Palestinian Authority. – with this option there will never be peace. Both sides will fight till the other is the victor. Iran who uses Hamas and Hezbollah as a proxies much prefers this way.

2.) Give the Palestinian Authority full control and do away with Hamas. – Without this option the Palestinians will never have a lasting Negotiated peace leading to their own state. Because you can be sure that Europe and the U.S. will never let Israel be destroyed.

As it stands now the Palestinians are divided. And that will lead to no future except death and misery. Hamas will continue to attack and Israel will continue to respond.

racasel   January 10th, 2009 9:38 pm ET

The only way for this war to stop is to have one of them get wiped out. Hamas do not understand reasoning. They will kill people without any conscience and now that they are losing, the cry holocaust and masacre for the good people to stop and they can re-arm to get back and again start killing good people. Their God is not helping them because He knows they are doing something bad to others.

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 9:39 pm ET

well done thanks … now we must hide !
well done !
thanks

and hide you should, akiva

Rod   January 10th, 2009 9:43 pm ET

linda did you really watch the video that American Jew keeps posting?
i know it is long but it is worth watching. I watched it myself twice and sent it to many of my friends. it tells you how things started.

This Gaza massacre is about the Israeli elections.

you know why i refuse the idea that Hamas is the problem ( because Hamas was established by Shin-bet or at least supported by them in 1987. and the problems did not start in 1987 nor was the palestinian people living better before 1987.

Lets for one sec believe that the Palestinians are humans ( not animals like the world have treated them for over 60 year).
what do they want
1- Freedom (The right for self determination and a State that is fully functional not a big prison that is controlled by another state)
2- Security
3- Opportunity

they were not given any of this. actually as time passed they got less and less of all of these.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 9:46 pm ET

Rod,
Yes I watched it, and the one you kept posting too. Sometime that is why it takes me some time to respond, I am watching them, or saving them to watch later. I was up until 3am this morning, catching up on the things I had not had time to watch.
They the way, I believe that the Palestinian people are humans. And they should have Freedom, Security, and Opportunity

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 9:49 pm ET

Killing women and children will not win a war but it will create more hate and more resistance to occupation..

this is part of an article in the times today.

Fighting an enemy they cannot see

In the Zeitoun neighbourhood, the Givati brigade commander, Colonel Ilan Malka, was realistic about what could await his soldiers. “Hamas ran away but didn’t disappear,” he said. “They are waiting for us.”

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 9:49 pm ET

linda,

"I believe that the Palestinian people are humans. And they should have Freedom, Security, and Opportunity"

i can agree to this as long as it does not mean that israel cannot have the same

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 9:51 pm ET

the times.

About 800 Palestinians have been killed, many of them civilians, and more than 3,000 injured, but the main fighting force of Hamas was unhurt and lay in wait for the Israelis in Gaza City and the refugee camps in the north and south of the Gaza Strip.

The Israelis have found an enemy well dug in. In recent years, especially in the last six months of the unofficial ceasefire, Hamas has constructed hundreds of miles of tunnels in urban areas.

Karon   January 10th, 2009 9:52 pm ET

I've been watching all of the reports of the situation in Gaza and the one question that seems to fail to come up is this...... Is this another Jenin? Around 3000 rockets were fired into Israel from Gaza in 2008. Would the US have responded just as Israel has? I would say probably yes. The world outcry however is because of the reports of large numbers of civilian deaths. Do we forget about the false reports regarding the deaths in Jenin? It seems so. The reports coming out of Gaza are from the Palestinians. Why is it that the world too easily sides with the large number of Muslims without considering the position of the Jews, yet the world says the US is always behind Israel. Lets question the word of the terrorists for once rather than assuming that the Israelis are always wrong.

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 9:53 pm ET

"Killing women and children will not win a war but it will create more hate"
I can only agree:

May 2, 2004

An Israeli woman in her eighth month of pregnancy and her four daughters were killed this afternoon when two terrorists opened fire at Israeli cars traveling on the Kissufim-Gush Katif road in the Gaza Strip. Soldiers shot the terrorists dead, but only after an explosive device at the scene detonated, wounding three soldiers, two of them with moderate-to-serious injuries.

The victims of the attack were identified as Tali Hatuel, 34, and her daughters Hila (11), Hadar (9), Roni (7) and Merav (2). Tali’s husband was not in the car at the time of the attack, ynet reported. The Hatuels lived on the Gush Katif settlement of Katif.

The Hamas terrorist organization claimed responsibility for the terror attack, Channel Ten television reported. Palestinian sources said, however, that the attack was a joint effort of Islamic Jihad and the Fatah’s Popular Resistance Committees, media sources reported.

Police said the terrorists hit Tali Hatuel as she drove, causing her car to swerve from the road, then approached the car and executed her and her children at close range

sonya   January 10th, 2009 9:53 pm ET

how sad that anyone would think that the killing of innocents is justified, to kill 2 hamas militants in a nearby school it is now ok to sacrifice 50+ innocent lives, and those kids besides their dead mothers my heart bleeds for you and what kind of future you may have, and to think that the israelis think this is self defence? go figure

Linda   January 10th, 2009 9:59 pm ET

dan,
i can agree to this as long as it does not mean that israel cannot have the same

I agree

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 10:00 pm ET

for the pro Israel posters here .

did the Nazis do such things.

the Guardian.

n the current offensive, Israel began attacking Gaza's educational institutions immediately. On only the second and third day of air attacks last week, Israeli planes wreaked severe damage in direct strikes on Gaza's Islamic University. The main buildings were devastated, destroying administrative records, and, of course, ending studies. The Ministry of Education has been hit twice by direct hits from the air.

The Saturday of the ground invasion was the day on which most students in Gaza sit their end-of-year examinations. In the majority of cases, these had to be abandoned, and it remains unclear whether they can or will be sat again. Other schools were also attacked – most notoriously the UN establishment in the Jabaliya refugee camp where at least 40 people were massacred on Tuesday.

Rod   January 10th, 2009 10:01 pm ET

Linda,
although I have strong beliefs for humans rights and against wars. I do not intend to force my opinions on people and did not want you to agree or disagree with that war.

I support the troops too. My support is that they should not have been endangered in the first place. And my support should extend to bringing them back safe.

If you research things you will find the systematic campaign that was made for that war. Even when Colin Powell made his statement in the UN I analyzed it and found it was not convincing. This administration made over 935 lies to take us to war ( I am not Rep of Dem, I am Independent ). it is just sad that we went to a war based on lies

http://projects.publicintegrity.org/WarCard/?gclid=CKzfnuj_hJgCFSCcnAodHBBDDA

Linda   January 10th, 2009 10:03 pm ET

Solomon,
I ask this question will all due respect. Were you at this educational facility? Do you know, with your own eyes, if there were arms being stored there, Hamas fighters there, or if someone was firing from that facility?
I try not to speculate.
Thanks

Linda   January 10th, 2009 10:04 pm ET

hey Rod,
I'm and independent too!

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 10:06 pm ET

linda

the islamic university had a weapons lab inside, just as the mosques were used to store grads

this has been proven by pictures which show many secondary explosions after the initial hit. what exploded, holy books? rockets were seen to raise from the mosques after bombardment. or wre they books??

this makes them legitimate targets

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 10:07 pm ET

and linda, the videos are available that prove my above facts

dan perman   January 10th, 2009 10:09 pm ET

linda

i am off

bye sweet lady

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 10:11 pm ET

Linda.
this is not a speculation this is fact.

the Zionist propaganda want to tell the world that the Palestinians are not Human exactly like the Nazis tried to dehumanize the Jews in the second world war.

we have seen picture minutes after Israeli attacks on Mosques no arms if the TV station on the ground say there was no arms and if the UN say that Israel was lying about Palestinian fighter at schools.

Linda
if you dont believe people on the Ground how can you believe liars that are bombarding these sites from miles away?

Linda   January 10th, 2009 10:12 pm ET

Dan,
I lead that question with, "with your own eyes".
It was rhetorical, that is why I said, "I try not to speculate"
i see the pics and reports from both sides, that is my point.
I know what makes something a legitimate target. :)

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 10:13 pm ET

ant brain.
can you show us these picture or admit that you are a liar.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 10:14 pm ET

Solomon,
I am not arguing that the facilities where hit, Please re-read my question.

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 10:16 pm ET

"I know what makes something a legitimate target"

Linda.
tell us but please dont speculate without any proof.

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 10:19 pm ET

Linda
I have a question for you if an Israeli soldier is in his house with his children does that make it a legitimate target for Palestinian resistance?

Rod   January 10th, 2009 10:20 pm ET

I will give solutions that will work. and these are not my ideas.

Israel will be smart to consider one of these too options. If israel think about a military solution to this conflict they are wrong. They did for 60 Years and did not work. I do not think it will ever work and we do not need to wait another 60 years to realize that.

1- One State solution where palestinians have equal rights to all israelis including the right to vote. no land confiscation and no Expelling of palestinians. A state that recognizes the rights of all of its citizens and treats everyone as equal.

2- A two state solution that the Palestinians will have there own fully functional state not a big prison that is controlled by the state of israel, divided by settlements and palestinians have not right in their own land. this means that they will control their borders and will be responsible for them, control their land, control their seas and sky. and the palestinians have the right to their own land.

I think the second solution is more convenient to the state of Israel. but
My problem is that we do not even want to give them this. we will keep killing them and have our best killed. War will not bring peace, Justice will.

sonya   January 10th, 2009 10:22 pm ET

the israeli army has lied so many times you wouldn't know what to believe from them or their government, i also wonder how high the death rate has to be before they stop?

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:23 pm ET

Greetings all

Victor   January 10th, 2009 10:24 pm ET

It is painful to see the images of suffering and dying children. I feel for them and hope that this offensive stop as soon as possible.

However, something's been bugging me. How come is it that no one heard much about the rocket attacks on Israeli towns prior to the current events? We know that some Israelis have been killed by the rocket attacks – I'm yet to see a report on them. It's pretty odd considering that the media does have unrestricted access to these victims, while we are being flooded by images from media-restricted Gaza.

And the protests across Western Europe – are they spontaneous?
Everyone is angry with Israel, but is anyone thinking about the invisible hands fuelling this rage?

Rod   January 10th, 2009 10:25 pm ET

American Jew hey

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:26 pm ET

I am speehless with furor and disbelief at what I see and hear on Gaza.

Today, for the first time I am speechless but am glad to see the worldwide protests

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 10:26 pm ET

Lida.
please dont think that Iam attacking you I do respect you.I know that you support Israel that is fine too I support Palestinians I hope it is fine with you too.

any human that is put in the situation that the Palestinians are in will react the same.they are an occupied people they are fighting for their freedom

no difference between the Palestinians and the Dutch and French resistance against the Nazis

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:26 pm ET

For the first time today, tears and anger

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 10:28 pm ET

Linda I am sorry the mistake in the name was not intended.

jeff   January 10th, 2009 10:30 pm ET

why do the palestinians support the non stop provcative rocket bombing of israel? hmm?? like pres elect obama said, "if anyone was shooting rockets at his house, he'd do everything in his power to stop them" by the way i think peter is very biased and I even wonder if he has a nazi heritage?

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 10:31 pm ET

American Jew Hello

"For the first time today, tears and anger"

I know you are against this from day one.
whats about today. why for the first time.

Professor   January 10th, 2009 10:32 pm ET

Hello Everyone...:)

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:32 pm ET

Works both ways, Jeff.

If anyone was dropping tons of bombs on my house, I'd do everything in my power to stop them...

a very human reaction on both sides

Rod   January 10th, 2009 10:33 pm ET

American Jew welcome again I feel the same. I saw a little girl who had her two legs amputated. very beautiful girl. she was smiling they asked her what do you tell other children around the world.
She said I want them to know That I am a child just like them.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:33 pm ET

Hi Professor and Rod!!

Professor   January 10th, 2009 10:34 pm ET

AJ,

I have been shedding tears since day one.... I know how you feel.... I have not been able to sleep at night... thinking about those children and their mothers.

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 10:36 pm ET

Hi Linda, AJ, Solomon and Rod,

I haven't heard any good news today ... have you?

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 10:37 pm ET

away for 30 minutes.

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 10:37 pm ET

Oh, sorry. I missed you Akiva, so Hi!

Rod   January 10th, 2009 10:38 pm ET

Lynne no "no good news"

Rod   January 10th, 2009 10:39 pm ET

more than 860 killed and 3600 wounded 400 of them in serious condition. more than half of them are women and children.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 10:39 pm ET

Solomon,
you wrote:
I know that you support Israel that is fine too I support Palestinians I hope it is fine with you too.

When did I say I was on the side of Israel?

Professor   January 10th, 2009 10:40 pm ET

Has anyone here seen the pics of the Orthodox Jews in New York demonstrating against the Israel?

Linda   January 10th, 2009 10:42 pm ET

Hi, Lynne!
Hi A J!
Hi Professor.
I stepped away for a minute

Rod   January 10th, 2009 10:43 pm ET

Prof,
many Jews are against this but those are not the ones who are in power.
it is an Election game.

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 10:43 pm ET

Hi Professor!

Rod,
Did you see the headline from the Independent? Wonder if all this is true ...

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/massacre-of-a-family-seeking-sanctuary-1297577.html

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:44 pm ET

Solomon,
Anger all along, but it has been building up inside me for two weeks now.

Final Redemption   January 10th, 2009 10:45 pm ET

Muhamad Ali,

Your pst is brilliant! May I have permission to copy and paste it to another blog where the anti-Israel lobbyists could do with some great reading material?

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 10:45 pm ET

Prof,

No, I have'nt seen the pics of the NY Orthodox Jews. You have a link ... or the channel?

Final Redemption   January 10th, 2009 10:46 pm ET

Muhamad Ali,

Your post is brilliant! May I have permission to copy and paste it to another blog where the anti-Israel lobbyists could do with some great reading material?

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:48 pm ET

I saw a small boy crying in terror as bombs dropped and it just hit me hard!

Linda   January 10th, 2009 10:49 pm ET

Lynne,
I looked at your link. What a horror story. If this continues, it will put Steven King out of business. and I am sure there are more stories like this that people have not been able to tell

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:49 pm ET

When it gets too difficult to take in, at least I can break away, unlike them over there who must endure 23/7!!

Professor   January 10th, 2009 10:50 pm ET

Someone sent them to me in an email... is there a page I can upload them to so you can all see them?

I am not sure of the original source though...

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:50 pm ET

24/7 I mean

Professor   January 10th, 2009 10:53 pm ET

I also has a real video clip from a cell phone that someone took in Gaza after one of the Israeli ciminal attacks on Gaza.

I can upload that too.... so you guys can see it.

Anyone who will not cry after watching this video clip is not a human.

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 10:54 pm ET

Sad yes
But the fighting to eliminate Hamas must continue

Bill   January 10th, 2009 10:55 pm ET

Muhamad Ali –

Loved your post! It really puts the conflict into a proper perspective. Israel (and the entire western world) needs to defend itself against constant attacks from Islamic terrorists who seem to be supported by the majority of Muslims. The Muslims don't seem to realize that they are far more likely to die at the hands of these Islamic terrorists than the Jews.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 10:55 pm ET

Hi Nick!

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 10:57 pm ET

Hey Linda!
Whats happening,

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 10:58 pm ET

Bill,

Yes, an excellent post by Muhamad Ali. I never understood Muslim killing Muslim. For some reason, I thought that it was not allowed.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 10:59 pm ET

This is a day when I cannot tolerate the constant black and white reasoning that is used to justify this horrible conflict

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 11:00 pm ET

AJ,

To me, there is no B&W, only shades of gray. I'm just sick of all the killing.

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:01 pm ET

I agree with Bill, Their praised terrorist organization uses children as shields, the Israelis don't wrap the sides of their tanks with their citizens for armour.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:01 pm ET

Say it again, Lynne

When on the ground, there is no reasoning...only terror

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:02 pm ET

me too lynne

Professor   January 10th, 2009 11:02 pm ET

Muhamad Ali,

There is a blatant lie in your post that other liars in the Israeli Administraton, Israeli Embassies and Israeli supports have used to.... by saying this is not a between Israel and Hamas only but between the Free world and Hamas....

I think we all have the seen the Free World speaking against Israel all the way from the US and South America to Australia passing by Europe and the Arab world....All spoke with one voice....

Long Live Palestine and Israel needs to stop its crimes against the Palestinians..... Even in Turkey the latest friend Israel has added to its small list of friends.... we saw how they welcomed the Israeli basketball team with shoes kassam rockets falling on their heads.... ;)

Akiva   January 10th, 2009 11:03 pm ET

cnn if you tell us about new hama rockets
why you dont tell about new israel weapons?

mahmoud jboor   January 10th, 2009 11:03 pm ET

update now: as usual israelies ignored their promise attacking another school of the UN killing more innocent people !!!
as for massacres no.s are mounting :
total: more than 855 deaths...( 275 child , 100 women, 70 elderly ,6 aid worker, 4 journalist...)!!!!
regard jomana report i want to say bluntly that we don't trust israelis after this holocaust ..!!
to Beny : there will be no peace with a terrorist state !!!!!!!!...

Professor   January 10th, 2009 11:04 pm ET

Nick-Canada,

Ofcouse Israelis don’t wrap the sides of their tanks with their citizens for armour becuase they use Palestinian children.

Akiva   January 10th, 2009 11:08 pm ET

cnn ... always talk about war with weapons...
what is with war without weapons?

psycho war maybe ?
no food?
deny others?
embargos to others?
...?

maybe thats important too

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:08 pm ET

Fighting militarily will not stop Hamas or Israeli govt as last 60 years have shown

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:08 pm ET

A J,
How are you feeling today? Did you get the knots out of your neck and shoulders?

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:11 pm ET

Nah, Linda, but thanks for asking. Power chair Warrior #2 at your service

BRINS NOT BRAWN!!

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:11 pm ET

BRAINS NOT BRAWN!! I MEAN

6ftRabbit   January 10th, 2009 11:12 pm ET

I don't get the whole "Protest" thing. It's obvious and stated many times, that Islam wants to "win"; ie be supreme on the planet. Ok. So do other cultures, nations, etc. So what's the problem? One side or the other will win. I hope it's not Islam. Sharia is not my idea of a good legal, philosophical, or political/religious system. As for this nebulous "Peace" that everybody is screaming about, I have to ask; "Peace on whose terms"? Not Islams if I have anything to say about it.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:13 pm ET

I'm sorry to hear that AJ, I was thinking of you when I woke up. I was hoping you were feeling better. If you are like me, all of the stress sure takes a toll.
Power chair warrior #1 responding with Love :)

Akiva   January 10th, 2009 11:13 pm ET

israel will pay that !!!

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 11:14 pm ET

AJ,

The vicious circle goes on. I have been very afraid for the Gazans, but now after reading about all the protests everywhere, I am afraid for the Israelis, too. It appears that more and more moderates are losing their minds over this. Israel might succeed in wiping out most of Hamas and stopping the rockets for a while, but I don't think they will see by whom and from which direction the next is coming from. It won't be from any "terrorist group".

Is the Mayan calendar correct?

I had a dream years ago. My nephews were quite small at the time. I was sitting in a dim room on the floor with 2 grown men I recognized as my nephews, and a young woman. I kept saying we must stay together, away from the windows, and pray. I have never forgotten this, and the dream was 38 years ago! A premonition of things to come?

I don't know.

Professor   January 10th, 2009 11:14 pm ET

6ftRabbit,

Remind us not to take your openion on that matter then... ;-p

Rod   January 10th, 2009 11:15 pm ET

Lynne, I saw the article. Yes this happened it is very sad.

American Jew look at this:

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/massacre-of-a-family-seeking-sanctuary-1297577.html

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:16 pm ET

Very, very difficult to stay centered with this imbalance.

But I continue to call for recognition of the humanity of ALL in this mess.

Sop the violence, destruction and murder on both sides now!!

This is getting absolutely nowhere...just creating years more of the same BS

Akiva   January 10th, 2009 11:16 pm ET

as israel say ... hamas are hiding behind civilians
so its very logical that civilians have to pay for that

very good legitimation by israel !!!!!!!!!!
what is that?

they wanna get peace ... they wanna help these poor civilians which gt abused by hamas .... so its logical to kill these civilians ... so they get saved !!!!!!!

how stupid are we ?

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:18 pm ET

No winners 6ft!! NONE!!!!

sonya   January 10th, 2009 11:20 pm ET

if they bring down hamas which is unlikely, can you imagine all the people with all the new hatred towards israel! violence is not the answer, you want peace you don't kill anything and everything that moves in Gaza, human rights for all humans that includes the palestinians!

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:21 pm ET

Lynne,
The Mayan calendar is suppose to be. That means we will be here for less than 4 more years. I was just at some Mayan ruins in Sept. and our guide was 1/2 Mayan. He said that the world has the meaning wrong.

Akiva   January 10th, 2009 11:21 pm ET

CNN whole europe get crazy not only argentina and egypt !!!!!!!!!

in europe jews allready have to pay!!!!!
jewish shops get taged as jewish ... they put poster on them
people boycott jews around the world

jews have allready to hide again for life

and USA is still supporting that?
thanks condoleza thanks bush ... thanks israel!!!!!!!!

Rod   January 10th, 2009 11:23 pm ET

Lynne
Extremism is not an Islamic problem only and it is not new.
actually everyone forgets the first suicidal incident that killed many people was sone by Samson and was praised in the bible and tora and he was an israelite

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:24 pm ET

Thanks Rod and Lynne for referemce o Independent article.

No need to convince me of the horror faced by these folks.

It justs gets worse and worse. I am fully ouytraged

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:25 pm ET

Linda, what did theMayan say?

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 11:26 pm ET

Linda,

What did your guide say? I was in Tulum a couple of years ago - first time in about 25.

The old ones are gone.

Rod   January 10th, 2009 11:26 pm ET

American jew how long did you live in Israel?

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:26 pm ET

Long live Israel, Long live Canada, Long live America, I would fight for all three, I am speaking as a youth, don't think that there is one person who was young during 9/11 that would ever support a terrorist organization or a people that support this terror by electing them to run their land. I am speaking of future leaders in this country. Half the wars you all talk about happened before I was even born. I have only had enough time in my life so far to learn about Canada and the States. Thus far most American youth only know of 9/11 as something significant that happenend war wise in there life. There is such a hate for Islamic terrorists in the youth of these nations anyone standing for them does not stand a chance. I was going to a High School in the south suburbs of Chicago when 9/11 went down. I have never seen anything like the unity of Americans in a time of tragedy where it affects everyone. It was a beautiful. I remember driving around with a friend on that sad eve, and already just about every car on the road had an American flag waving out the window. Fire engines and Police cars driving around with many flags and lights flashing as to show support to our fallen. Every house had its family on the front lawn standing and burning candles. There was not a church in the whole of the country that was not full, and it was not sunday niether. The next day there was not a single car without a flag. Everyone was so Patriotic, Everyone. This is what the youth of are nation saw that night. Good luck getting their vote all you Hamas supporters, Good Luck

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:26 pm ET

Life AS WE KNOW IT may end but not life itself?

Certainly murderous idealogies need to end!!

Akiva   January 10th, 2009 11:26 pm ET

CNN all your sources or most your sources are in israel!
you tell us what they are telling you !
they are in war ... they not only tell the truth !

be carefully with all what comes out of israel !
they allready have lied much at us and alleardy it is proofed!
be carefully with what they wanna let you tell us !

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:28 pm ET

A J,
I feel the same way, I am outraged also, and since I refuse to say that I denounce one side or another, people have tried to pull me into arguments. I ask you, is this helpful? I am outraged at both sides and ALL of the killing and fear. We have to remember, even people, In BOTH countries, that have not been killed or injured, are seeing and hearing horrible things, living in horror. This is unexceptable to me.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:29 pm ET

Lynne,
I was in Tulum too. Loved it! He said that it will be the beginning of a new era, not the end of the world.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:31 pm ET

It is all unacceptable and unworkable, yes.

It gets harder to stay 'objective' tho

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:33 pm ET

I agree with you A J,
On one level, I see it one way, on another level, I see it the other. Remember, I was a Paramedic, I see it with much different eyes than most. My eyes are very sad, and I'm getting angry.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:33 pm ET

AND LONG LIVE PALESTINE, NICK.

DOWN WITH IDEALOGY ON BOTH SIDES THAT IS KILLING ALL.

Exscuse my sreaming there folks
:) smile

John   January 10th, 2009 11:34 pm ET

I have finally found the American Al-Jazerra magazine.

Ted must be proud.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:34 pm ET

bad spelling day...

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 11:34 pm ET

Nick,

I am old, and I have found hate breeds hate. This is not good. It's a waste of energy and productive time. It makes you old before you get there chronologically.

I have lived in the ME (Tehran) and in Mumbai. I remember ordered blackouts in Mumbai in 64-65 because the Indian gov't saw that war was inevitable, and how afraid people were.

After 911, I saw a lot of people in churches. But I saw these same people desecrating mosques desecrated and attacking other people because they thought the others were terrorists. I'm sorry, but Seikhs are not terrorists ....

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 11:35 pm ET

Linda,

Perhaps to get to the new era, we as humans must wade through blood?

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:36 pm ET

Long live a Palestine not run by Terrorists!

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 11:36 pm ET

Israel is using White Phosphorus bombs in Gaza and khan younis This is in violation of international laws or conventions. according to a Norwegian doctor who treated Palestinian civilians today in hospitals in Gaza.

.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:36 pm ET

Rod, I lived in Israel 2 years and have been back and forth many times

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:37 pm ET

Nick,
Very well spoken, about what the young people saw on 9/11. My son was 12. We had just been to NYC a few months before. He did not know exactly what was going on when he came home from school that day. When I told him, and he saw it on TV, the color washed out of his face, and he said, "mom, I'm glad we weren't there today." I cry as I type. We very well could have been. And many people were, people that we know.
People terrorizing people have to stop.
Imagine the people in Gaza and Israel right now.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:38 pm ET

Long Live an Israel not run by Zionists!

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 11:38 pm ET

another school was hit by Israeli forces in Gaza. 50 wounded and some dead in this attack.

adele   January 10th, 2009 11:38 pm ET

Asma-al Assad could have been comparing her life with that of many people in many parts of the world, take Zimbabwe, to name but one, of the many, yet they receive very little exposure. The humanitarian situation in Gaza, which is given such exposure is constantly placed on the heads of the Israelis. Why? Are the Israeli children not allowed to grow up in peace? Must they live in constant fear and the threat to their lives by the daily rocket attacks on their cities. What other country defending itself, is required to stop the offensive to allow the opposition to use the humanitarian efforts to re-arm and continue their rocket attacks? Asma- al Assad and the many demonstrators should see the position from the other side. Allow Israel to live in peace, stop the rockets.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:38 pm ET

Lynne,
You could be right, I know those people over there are right now.

Professor   January 10th, 2009 11:39 pm ET

Nick-Canada,

How would you like it if Russia, China or Cuba want to decide for you who should be running the government in Canada?

Damien Blackley   January 10th, 2009 11:39 pm ET

A terrorist is one who seeks to promote their own cause. Does this not make both Israel and HAMAS a terrorist.

If Israel is not a terrorist for defending their people, than those who belong to the military wing of HAMAS are freedom fighters.

Is it only Israel that has the right to take land from the Palestinians. Does not the Palestinian have the right to fight fire with fire.

The time has come for HAMAS to take a peaceful path and Israel to return all land taken from the Palestinians since 1967 and for these people to have East Jerusalem as their capital.

Israel and Saudi Arabia have one thing in common, when oil is longer needed do they honestly think the US will care what happens to them,
I think not.

Now is time to take action, which will give both sides the right to live in peace as neighbors.

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 11:39 pm ET

Solomon,

When was this? Please post us links ...

While this might be a little off target, is all well with you today?

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:40 pm ET

Linda that almost made me cry.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:40 pm ET

Well said Linda!

And how many 100s of violations of int'l law does that make now, Solomon?

Professor   January 10th, 2009 11:41 pm ET

Long Live Palestine.... with their freedom of choice.... ;-p

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:41 pm ET

Akiva you are one sick puppie

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 11:42 pm ET

Lynne.

it was on the news few minutes ago.

I am fine thank you.

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:45 pm ET

The mythological idealogy of Zionism and the idealogy of extremists like Hamas MUST die out to make way for the human reality (humanity) of social justice, peace and equality for the Palestinian and Israel people.
-perspective of an American Jew

“Changing society does not require us to forget or revise the past, and living together does not require us to abandon our identity, culture, and history, even in the context of a bitter and bloody conflict”
-Ali Abunimeh, Palestinian-Americazn

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:45 pm ET

I don't want to make anyone cry, but peoples lives are at stake, while we blog and people protest. What can we do in the entire world, to stop the violence? You see, I am a mother, a mother who loves her son, country, and world, I love humanity and I do not want to see it destroyed. I am a Sister, Wife, Aunt, and Daughter. Do I have to bury my family or friends, or do they have to bury me, just for the sake of ideology? Don't we all have common ground?

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:47 pm ET

YES! Damien, I agree!!

Professor   January 10th, 2009 11:47 pm ET

Freedom fighters who fight their occupation throughout the history has been called terrorists by the occupying forces. They always are praised as heros by thier people and others specially after their people gain their freedom and get rid of the occupation.

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:47 pm ET

Professor
If your saying the Palestinans have the right to vote whoever they want they do. Which they did, hence evrything thats going on. If we voted for Barrack and he starts launching rockets into Russia, I'm sure the people of America (women, children) would feel the retaliation.

Bill   January 10th, 2009 11:49 pm ET

I find it odd that many people don't seem to know the difference between fact and opinion.

"I know that mosque didn't have weapons in it." Really? Were you there? Did you thoroughly inspect the mosque just before it was hit?

"Israel is targeting UN Aid personnel." Really? Did you see it happen?
Were you there? It turns out that yesterday's killing of a UN aid truck driver was done by snipers, not an Israeli tank shell. The wounded were evacuated to an Israeli hospital. They had gunshot wounds. Another Jenin-type response?

And my favorite, "Israel is targeting innocent civilians!" Really? Were you there when Israeli commanders gave the orders to shoot innocent civilians? Can you read the minds of all the Israeli soldiers who are risking their lives firing at cowardly terrorists who are admittedly hiding among civilians? Those soldiers have nothing better to do than kill some women and children instead? Such arrogance! If Israel was systematicallt targeting civilians, they why should they have a truce everyday to let them get necessities? Why should they let in humanitarian aid? Are women and children dying? Yes. We have all seen the evidence on BOTH sides. Does that establish a fact that Israelis are targeting them? Absolutely not.

We are all entitled to our opinions. If you have no real evidence supporting your opinions, then they are not facts. No matter how fervently and emotionally you believe your opinion, it is not a fact.

Unless you have facts – you don't know the truth and you are taking a cheap shot by calling other people liars/criminals/etc until you do.

How come I never hear an apology when these people are proven wrong by the facts?

Just my OPINION...

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 11:49 pm ET

Solomon,

No wonder I missed it. I don't have the TV on a news channel ... was becoming too depressed without seeing anything to be hopeful for.

Nick,

You might think Akiva is a sick puppy, but occasionally there are words of wisdom in his/her posts.

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:49 pm ET

America isn't about to elect Osama,

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:50 pm ET

Professor,
I see Freedom Fighters as the people that were on Flight 93 on 9/11. Those people fought and took that plane down, in the middle of a field, knowing they would not survive, but to save more lives.

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:50 pm ET

Depends who's listening

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:51 pm ET

Linda, great question

My answer, yes we are ALL human

It is a humanitarian issue!!

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 11:51 pm ET

Linda.
beautiful words but is the US listening?the senate and house unanimously support Israel action in Gaza.I need your comments.

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:51 pm ET

Bill,
I said the exact same thing.
Were they there, did they see it with their own eyes?

Lynne   January 10th, 2009 11:53 pm ET

Linda,

I think all people can find a common ground, it's just that they are to pig-headed to build on it when they find it. They just can't seem to let go of bygones. I think you're father's family could be an example to us all (if I correctly remember your posts earlier this week).

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:53 pm ET

Solomon,
I hope everyone is listening!

Professor   January 10th, 2009 11:53 pm ET

Nick-Canada,

I and everyone on here now see what kind of common sense you have.... :)

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:53 pm ET

Linda
Right on, these are the things that help me sleep well at night. We have an army, but we have even a bigger army of every American who cares for every American

American Jew   January 10th, 2009 11:54 pm ET

Facts and opinion don't count for nuthin' at ground zero
reason just does nit apply as your kid lies dying besside a dead o=parent

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:54 pm ET

Yes, Lynne,
I also had that discussion (my fathers family) on the next blog down, today. P
Pig headedness gets you know where.
We all need to build on it, you are so right

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 11:55 pm ET

I dont know what the Palestinians have to do with the terrorist act of Nine Eleven.
Pro Israel posters keep repeating that .

Professor   January 10th, 2009 11:55 pm ET

Linda,

Thats good for you....

I have a broader definition of freedom fighters.... ;)

Linda   January 10th, 2009 11:56 pm ET

Solomon,
No one said they did, it was a totally different conversation

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:56 pm ET

Akiva
Jesus told the murderer and the theif that today they will be with there Father in heaven, sorry for name calling, there is still hope for even you.

Solomon   January 10th, 2009 11:58 pm ET

Bill.

oh I did not know that you were there after these buildings were bombed. maybe you should give us some proof of your allegations.

Nick-Canada   January 10th, 2009 11:59 pm ET

Solomon
You must look at the larger picture here, this is ultimatley a war against the west.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:00 am ET

Solomon,

Bush and the US media kept repeating the same words.... until as we all know.... when a teacher asked the young children at her classroom Who is behind 9/11 attacks they replied "Iraq".

Israel want people (specially young children) to believe that Palestinias are behind 9/11 so they grow up as Israeli supporters.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:01 am ET

hey Nick
Those pirates were killed after getting the ransom. They are going to talk about it on FOX.
Sorry for the change in subject, we were discussing it last night

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:04 am ET

Solomon, For what it's worth, here email I sent to my congressional rep this a.m.:

Greetings Rep. ....,

As a constituent of yours and a member of the Jewish community, I was VERY disappointed to learn this morning that you voted for resolution 34.

Shame on you!

I voted for you because you presented yourself as a candidate for CHANGE. The USA cannot continue its blind support for Israel's despicable killing policies against the Palestinian people.

The funds blindly poured into Israel for over 60 years could have been and can start being used for our own citizens' welfare, instead of towards war machinery to kill those in other countries.

The USA has outrageous debt and a desperate need for health care in this country, which I thought was your priority!

The funds you voted to go to Israel's disproportionate war could be used for saving our children's lives, instead of killing Palestinian children's lives!

What in the world happens to you politicians once you get elected?!

Your vote for the continued blind support for Israel is a vote against humanity.

Diplomacy is the only way. It is a HUMANITARIAN issue. History shows this path has never been extensively tried between the Israelis and Palestinians–ever! Certainly what has been tried up to now has not worked!

I hope you change your tune.

Yours Truly,

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:04 am ET

"You must look at the larger picture here, this is ultimatley a war against the west."

Nick-Canada.

may be you should explain to us why is it a war on the west.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:05 am ET

I find it somewhat strange when people (anyone) says what other peoples intentions are. Or what they think, or why someone does something if they don't tell you their intentions.
Professor, when you say "Israel wants people to believe", who in Israel are you referring to?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:06 am ET

Oh man... I still have not received my pay check for being on this blog.... does anyone know what is the delay?

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:06 am ET

Nick,

I must respectfully disagree with your war against the west hypothesis. For now, most Arab nations see US policy as one-sided. They do have a good case in my eyes, but that is only my opinion. I really did expect some disaster on our soil way before 2001. Since the US does not even appear to listen, and likes to assign blame, our gov't has created a monster (or many monsters, if you will). There are evil people in the west, just as we are seeing evil people in the middle east creating problems and wars. It takes two to tango, you know.

Thomas   January 11th, 2009 12:06 am ET

The Palestinians need to WAKE UP!

Hamas will never be able to get you your own state. Why? because there is absolutely no way Israel is going to be defeated. How many wars is it going to take for you to figure this out? If you want peace get rid of the extremists. Stop brainwashing your kids to become suicide bombers. Negotiate with Israel instead of launching rockets. Israel blockades Gaza for one reason and that is to protect it's citizens. Where has Hamas gotten you so far? more death and misery?

Sos   January 11th, 2009 12:07 am ET

Nick-

I never heard of a Canadian who support killing and spread hatred to Islam as much as u r .

Stop putting Canada name on this shit, u here 4 many days now stop this shit.

Bloggers he speak on his name and Canada got nothin to do with it .

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:08 am ET

A J,
Great Letter.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:09 am ET

American Jew.
God bless you this is to show that it is not between Jews and Arabs but between Zionists and Arabs.

I dont know if you have seen the thousands of Jews that were demonstrating against the Killings in Gaza in Australia and Europe..

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:10 am ET

Wow,
Why are you all ganging up on Nick? His opinion is just as valid as anyone else's

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:11 am ET

Solomon,
There are demonstrations all over the world, on both sides. Do you think they will accomplish anything?

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:12 am ET

Yup, many of my friends are out there today in my city, Solomon.

Wish I couldve been there, but my protest continues here at CNN's Blog Wars–bad spelling and all
:)
Power Chair Warrior #2

BRAINS NOT BRAWN!!

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:12 am ET

Good night everyone.... Let me know where you hear anything about my paycheck.... its really unreasonable for me to spend 24/7 on here and not get my paycheck yet.... Don't you all agree with me?

Talk to you romorrow.... only if I get my paycheck.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:13 am ET

Hamas will never be able to get you your own state. Why? because there is absolutely no way Israel is going to be defeated

Thomas.WOW.

Only God will not be defeated. if you know any thing about History you will find out that every one that lived by the sword died by the sword.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:13 am ET

Thomas,
Good point.
There are so many people with so many views, I find myself agreeing with a lot of what most people have to say.
How about the rest of you?

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:14 am ET

Nick are you still here?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:14 am ET

Linda,

Wow... there are demonstrations all over the world on both sides?.... You are a joke. really.

charles brundage   January 11th, 2009 12:14 am ET

I worry that someone will supply the religuous fanatics in gaza with chemical or biological weapons and Israel will level it in response. It's just too close quarters for any mistakes.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:15 am ET

AJ,

I echo Linda.

Now to repeat myself:

"Throughout the long and bloody struggle of Jew and Arab for dominance in Palestine, each crying fiercely: "This land is mine"- except for the brief reference in the Report of the Royal Commission (hereinafter referred to as the Peel Report) and the little evidence, written and oral, that we received on this point-the great interest of the Christian World in Palestine has been completely overlooked, glossed over or brushed aside.

We, therefore, emphatically declare that Palestine is a Holy Land, sacred-to Christian, to Jew and to Moslem alike; and because it is a Holy Land, Palestine is not, and can never become, a land which any race or religion can justly claim as its very own.

We further, in the same emphatic way, affirm that the fact that it is the Holy Land, sets Palestine completely apart from other lands, and dedicates it to the precepts and practices of the Brotherhood of Man, not those of narrow nationalism.

For another reason, in the light of its long history, and particularly its history of the last thirty years, Palestine cannot be regarded as either a purely Arab or a purely Jewish land.

The Jews have a historic connection with the country. The Jewish National Home, though embodying a minority of the population, is today a reality established under international guarantee. It has a right to continued existence, protection and development.

Yet Palestine is not, and never can be, a purely Jewish land. It lies at the crossroads of the Arab world. Its Arab population, descended from long-time inhabitants of the area, rightly look upon Palestine as their homeland.

It is therefore neither just nor practicable that Palestine should become either an Arab State, in which an Arab majority would control the destiny of a Jewish minority, or a Jewish State, in which a Jewish majority would control that of an Arab minority. In neither case would minority guarantees afford adequate protection for the subordinated group.

A Palestinian put the matter thus: "In the hearts of us Jews there has always been a fear that some day this country would be turned into an Arab State and the Arabs would rule over us. This fear has at times reached the proportions of terror . . . Now this same feeling of fear has started up in the hearts of Arabs . . . fear lest the Jews acquire the ascendancy and rule over them."

Palestine, then, must be established as a country in which the legitimate national aspirations of both Jews and Arabs can be reconciled, without either side fearing the ascendancy of the other. In our view this cannot be done under any form of constitution in which a mere numerical majority is decisive, since it is precisely the struggle for a numerical majority which bedevils Arab-Jewish relations..."

http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/angch01.asp

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:15 am ET

Solomon,
Is it worth all of the death and horror to try and defeat Israel?

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:16 am ET

Linda.

Yes they will. if the American people are seeing what the rest of the world is seeing we will have change.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:16 am ET

Professor,
Why am I a joke?
I am watching it as it happens. Who do you think one side is screaming at to, on the other side of the street?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:17 am ET

Linda,

Its worth every drop of blood to eradicate every occupation off this earth.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:18 am ET

Prof,

We enjoy your input. Forget the check ... it's only paper, anyway 8)

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:18 am ET

Linda,

becuase there is no comparison.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:19 am ET

Solomon,

I hope you are right. I agree, things must change to let everyone live in peace.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:20 am ET

Lynne,

but thats not fair.... one of the members of the terrorist cells run by Brandon said that I am getting a lot of money for being here... well i still have to see the first pay check.... How much do you all get paid? What is a lot?

Thomas   January 11th, 2009 12:21 am ET

Hamas will never be able to get you your own state. Why? because there is absolutely no way Israel is going to be defeated

Thomas.WOW.

Only God will not be defeated. if you know any thing about History you will find out that every one that lived by the sword died by the sword.

It is true Solomon, and since you use God as a reference the very existence of the state of Israel is a miracle of God. and it doesn't matter if you are Jew or Christian the same scriptures of both say that God will intervene to save Israel. What we are seeing now are simply the birth pains of what is to come.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:22 am ET

Prof,

I'm not getting paid for being here. Does that mean I can get unemployment checks????

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:22 am ET

One State solution here, Lynne!

This Peel Report was from 1938-9, correct?

I agree neither should 'rule' or control the other

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:23 am ET

Professor,
Then if you think I am such a joke, you should not read, nor take into consideration anything I say.
I'm not hurt by that, but I don't resort to mudslinging towards you for not agreeing with something you say.
I'll take the High Road.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:23 am ET

"Is it worth all of the death and horror to try and defeat Israel?"

Linda.

the question should be.
is it worth it for Israeli Politicians to kill hundreds of Palestinians for the sake of an election?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:23 am ET

Lynne,

what a great idea... lets check with Brandon.... or any member of his terrorist cell. They might know the answer to that question... it would be good if I can collect on that too. I know it will not be alot but better than nothing.... hehe

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:25 am ET

Oh and Lynne,

This was by creat their biggest lie i think.... but what's new?... I think we got used to them by now.... LOL

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:25 am ET

Professor, I wish!!

I need the $$, SSDI just doesn't cover...always 'more month at the end of the moey'!

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:26 am ET

Ah Thomas,

And consider the possibility that the Torah, the Bible, and the Qu'ran may be the same tales as Greek and Roman mythology?

I myself believe in the miracle that the wise one lives in all of us, we just have to listen for the voice.

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:28 am ET

Wonderful wisdom, Lynne

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:28 am ET

Prof,

Occupation: Certified Professional Blogger

Think that would work?

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:29 am ET

Thomas.
I am sorry I did not Know that you are one of those crazies.that think that God is locked in a room and the Keys are in their pockets
. I am not sure that you understand what I meant by that but that is OK

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:29 am ET

Can I get some too Lynne and Prof?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:30 am ET

Linda,

Have you seen how many countries are in chaos right now becuase of this?....

Have you seen the numbers in all those countries?...

How can you even mention the two in the same sentence?

There is no comparison....

The same there is no comparison between what Israel has done to the Palestinians over the past 60 years and what the Palestinians have done to Israel over the last couple of years when they started using the rockets.... You cannot equate the two and say this is a war between two countries..... this is a war crime inflicted by an occupier on the occupied.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:31 am ET

Solomon,
I am interested in the answer to that question also

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:32 am ET

AJ,

If I remember correctly, the Peel Report was 38-39 sometime. I have it as a pdf, but will have to find a link.

I was just trying to remind everyone that both Muslims and Jews living in the ME have their fears, and that a solution was presented a long time ago. Everyone involved was just too intent on their own agendas to pay any attention and build a viable solution.

See what happens when you don't think of your brother, and only of yourself?

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:32 am ET

My card will say:

Blog Wars–war of words professional
CERTIFIED PROFESSIONAL BLOGGER (CPB)

BRAINS NOT BRAWN

Power Chair Warrior #2

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:32 am ET

AJ and Lynne... woooo hoooo

Lets go for it... I like it...

Good night all... hope to talk to you tomorrow maybe we will get an answer to our question by then.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:35 am ET

Professor.
. actually when the Intifada was going on some pro Israeli bloggers at the time were saying Stones are weapon they can kill.
even stones is not allowed to be used by Palestinians.

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:35 am ET

Right on, Lynne!

One state solution will hopefully one day become a reality.

Affirm it!!

It was 38-39.

Fear is at the coreof all the insanity...

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:36 am ET

G'night Professor!!

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:36 am ET

Linda.
the death and destruction is done by Israel not by the Palestinians.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 12:38 am ET

what was the question prof so i can give you the answer

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:41 am ET

G'night Prof.

AJ, I like your card.

Solomon, the "death and destruction" finger pointing is senseless, in my book. Question: is Hamas composed of Palestinians, or are they a group from another ME country? If they are Palestinian, I believe that they also share in the shame of the situation.

I'm a pacifist. I believe that there is enough of everything to go around if people will just grasp the concept of sharing.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:41 am ET

Oh, Okay Solomon

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:43 am ET

American Jew
. actually we were talking about this yesterday I think Linda and myself.I said maybe that Crazy Ghadafi was right when he said let it be one state and that state will be called Isratine they can live together one man one vote like south Africa they can make arrangments so that the Jews will feel safe maybe he was right..

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:44 am ET

Im being censored–the IDF is preventing my posts!

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:46 am ET

I still agree with Isratine, Solomon

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:49 am ET

Solomon,

A lot of what Ghadafi has been saying in recent years is making sense.

See, leopards can change spots (if they want to!)

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:49 am ET

Lynne.
it is not finger pointing it is the truth. Israel is an occupying power the whole world decided that including the US.Israel will not leave these territories ,Palestinians have the right as an occupied people to resist that occupation in every possible means according to International law.

now tell me who is responsible for the death and destructions?

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:50 am ET

i am BEING CENSORED!

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:52 am ET

I HIGHLY REOMMEND

‘One Country,’ book by Ali Abunimah, Palestinian-American, and son of 1948 Palestinian refugees

EXCELLENT BOOK. $8.00 FROM AMAZON.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:52 am ET

Linda.
you are a wonderful lady. I support that too.it might be a dream but all realities start with a dream.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 12:54 am ET

Lynne.

do you know that Ghadafi personal guards are women?

Linda   January 11th, 2009 12:55 am ET

I'm glad we can end on a positive note, Solomon
I better get off of here for the night, my fellow bloggers. I have to make dinner.
Have a great evening, I will probably check back tomorrow.
Peace to ALL!

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:55 am ET

3X I have tried to post a small paragraph and 3X nada,

Big Brother is onioring us folks

Someone is terrified of words

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:56 am ET

monitoring

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 12:58 am ET

Solomon,

I am not denying Palestinians the right to resist in their territory. What I would say, however, is 2 wrongs do not equal one right. I would consider lobbing missiles at Israeli civilians against international law.

Israel is a fact of life, sanctioned by the UN. It is not going to go away. If the "freedom fighters" focused on the occupation forces (IDF) within their 1967 territory, and not resorted to blowing themselves up in civilian areas, I think that it would give the struggle more legitimacy. I also think that Israel should not be building the "Jews only" roads and protecting settlers with the military. If Jewish people want to live outside Israel, fine, but do it legally through the Palestinian authorities.

I just don't want to see innocents of either side caught in the cross-fire. Since at this time a one-state solution does not appear to be an option, the Palestinians should become a nation immediately. I remember Arafat threatening to declare the state unilaterally. Beats me why he didn't do it...

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 12:58 am ET

Im outta here too folks. I need to rest my neck.

A new language: Portuguese:

boa noite good night

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 1:00 am ET

Solomon,

No, I didn't know Ghadafi's personal guards are women. Do you know why? I would find it fascinating to know why a man would chose women protectors and not men.

Bero   January 11th, 2009 1:01 am ET

The mossad is great . How much do they pay you all? I hope it's well paid because you are all selling your souls to the devil. You're not even interesting anymore so you can have this site to yourselves. However, it doesn't change the fact. This is genocide and th Isreali government and the Israeli people are going to have to answer for it sometime in the future.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 1:02 am ET

See ya later, Linda and AJ.

Solomon, looks like you and I are the only ones left. Want to dance?

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 1:04 am ET

Hi Bero,

Really??? The Mossad is here?

Take cover ....

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 1:04 am ET

Lynne.

nice post I agree 100%.
only one thing need to be explained

the Palestinian state did not happen because Arafat was killed by Sharon .
this murderer Sharon did not want a Palestinian state.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 1:06 am ET

Lynne. sure if you can teach me.

Bye for now.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 1:07 am ET

Solomon the wise,

From what I was reading at the time of Arafat's death in France (God rest his soul), there were allegations of Israeli poisoning. These allegations were never proven by the French, or anyone else.

However, nothing would surprise me. It was an Israeli who assassinated Rabin.

Michael   January 11th, 2009 1:07 am ET

I feel bad for the innocent but I completely back what Israel is doing. These Hamas pigs hide behind civilians and shoot their rockets at Isreal. Hamas and their ilk are cowards, that shoot people in the back while standing behind a child, then bitch when Israel blows up the child. If Muslims don't want everyone else in the world to step on their collective neck, they better clean their own house.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 1:09 am ET

Solomon,

Take care. Hope to see you again soon. I too shall leave and seek food.

m kroll   January 11th, 2009 1:17 am ET

Hamas is a group of irresponsible murderers bent upon killing its own people. Firering rockets into another country indiscriminately is asking for retaliation. Hamas reaps what they have sewn. A two state solution has been offered time and again; it requres acceptanceby a responsible government not a band of terrorists with a rockets.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 1:20 am ET

Michael,

I agree that Hamas are cowards, abd I agree that suicide bombing and other terroristt tactics are cowardly. But I still feel sorry for the Muslim world because innocent people are being used as pawns by extremists who site them as their cause but do not really care about them. It is too bad that a few people are spoiling an entire group.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 1:25 am ET

m kroll,

It;s true that Hamas is reaping what they sow. It is too bad they are hiding behind innocent people and dragging them into it.

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:28 am ET

"Beyond the door
There's peace I'm sure.
And I know there'll be no more...
Tears in heaven ..."
(Eric Clapton)

Greetings and saluations to all lovers of peace!

Joan   January 11th, 2009 1:29 am ET

hi Nona

EdM   January 11th, 2009 1:30 am ET

Here are some things I have a tough time dealing with. Maybe you all can help.

There is so much condemnation of Israel for violating UN resolutions. I never hear any condemnation of the Arab nations violating 181, not accepting the two state solution in 1948, attacking Israel in 1948, and continuing wars, cross-border attacks, suicide bombings targeting civilians, economic boycotts, teaching hate, the Khartoum 3 NOs, re-arming Hezbullah, etc. Why is it OK to knock Israel for violating resolutions but not knocking the Arabs for doing the same thing especially (but not only) re: 181? Seems to me you either knock them both or just forget about the UN resolutions. Of course, once you knock the Arabs re: 181, you accept the 2-state solution which puts you at odds with Hamas and some other Arab regimes, as well as accepting the role of the Arabs in causing (yes, causing) the refugee problem, Israeli control of the West Bank (recall Jordan controlled it before 1967 and did not create a Palestinian state since that would have implied accepting 181’s 2-state concept and Israel got it when Jordan attacked Israel in 1967), etc. So, I believe those who favor eliminating Israel not bring up UN resolutions at all and those who favor the 2-state solution bring them all up, starting with 181 and the Arab rejection. Anything in between seems rather hypocritical, double standard, whatever the going term is. Correct?

According to CNN’s short summary of Gaza facts, three-quarters of Gaza is used for agriculture. Hamas has built over a hundred tunnels for smuggling things from Egypt to Gaza. Is it really believable that they could not have built underground storage for the weapons in the ¾ of Gaza that is unoccupied, or fired their rockets from unoccupied areas? Instead it seems they have intentionally stored and fired from well-populated areas. This seems to me like asymmetric warfare, intending to either deter attacks on their forces and weapons or use the resulting civilian casualties for PR. The counter to that seems to me to be international outrage at Hamas putting its civilian population at risk. But I see little of that. By the way, I am appalled and feel tremendous empathy for the folks who are just trying to live their lives and are in Gaza. They should not be subjected to such enormous misery, death, injury, destruction, etc. But I see the cause as all sides, including the international community for not condemning little actions that ended up leading (predictably) to this crisis. Address the little actions before they lead to blood, which seems to be about all the media report. This kind of asymmetric warfare is very hard to counter. True?

Speaking of the tunnels, couldn’t Hamas have used them to smuggle in food, fuel, medicines, etc instead of rockets and explosives for mortars? In fact, couldn’t Iran, or whoever is supplying the arms, have furnished these? By the way, wouldn’t the smuggling be not required if Hamas were not openly committed to annihilate Israel?

Is it warfare? We have Hamas openly stating its goal of annihilating Israel and then demanding that Israel provide it electricity, fuel, food, etc. Truces we get for a while but enduring peace remains elusive. How can the world expect that there will be peace between two entities when one wants to annihilate the other? That seems like the one is declaring it is in an ongoing state of war with the other, whether there is a truce for re-arming or not. Sounds like war to me, whether hot or cool; remember the “Cold War”? And if it is, “war is hell’, said by a man well versed in the horrors of war.

Most of the Israelis I’ve met want to live in peace. Some want roughly the 1967 borders, some want much more. But mainly they want to live in peace. The path to that peace seems conceptually simple to me: remove the threat to Israel’s existence as homeland for the Jewish people, as described in 181, create a Palestinian state living in peace with Israel, as described in 181, and have the two interacting for the benefit of each other, as described in 181. We came close to this in the late 1990s and early 2000’s, before Intifada 2. I have seen Israeli Jews and Israeli Arabs living very well together, socializing, doing commerce, receiving medical care at hospitals, etc. If lives are the most important, let all the nations of that area teach peace and show Israel on the maps they use to teach their children. Otherwise, let some Arab and Muslim leaders continue their diatribes of hate of Jews and the existence of ‘The Zionist Entity’ with the goal of annihilating ‘the Zionist Entity’ from the world. But don’t be surprised by the outcomes of the latter path; it’s wars, killing, and destruction, aka ‘The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse’. True?

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:31 am ET

Hi Joan! Thanks for the welcome!

Rod   January 11th, 2009 1:32 am ET

Nona hi there
I am sorry for yesterday.

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:32 am ET

By the way, it's nice to see some voices of reason here!

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:33 am ET

Oh, Rod. Thank you for your apology. That really means a lot to me.I accept it with much joy!

Rod   January 11th, 2009 1:34 am ET

I just came and I am glad to see you. I came earlier and wished i saw you.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 1:35 am ET

If we have only voices of reason, there will be no debate. The reasonable people would have solved this a long time ago/

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:38 am ET

awww, thanks Rod! That is very sweet of you and I really appreciate it.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 1:38 am ET

Bill Clinton said that one of his biggest regrets form his presidency was that Yassar Arrafat walked away from the best peace deal he would ever get. Yet someone on this blog accused Sharon of murdering him becasue he was going to accept a peace deal.

Doesn't make sense.

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:41 am ET

Someone said Sharon murdered Clinton? Or Arafat? OK whatever – that kinda makes me laugh.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 1:41 am ET

ok guys look at this. I went and researched History that we forget and I am not Condoning any suicide killing
But that was a story that was praised wasn't it
AboutBibleProphecy.com

Samson

Samson, a member of the tribe of Dan, was one of the Judges of Israel. He Judged Israel for 20 years. Samson's mother received a visit from an angel, who told her she would give birth to an unusual son, a Nazirite, and not to cut his hair. Samson had great strength, he killed a lion with his bare hands, and later killed 1,000 Philistines with a jawbone of a donkey. He had romantic encounters with three Philistine women.

He fell in love with one of the women, Delilah. The five leaders of the Philistine nation went to Delilah, and demanded that she find out from Samson what made him so strong, so they could subdue him. She eventually found out it was because his hair had never been cut. While asleep, Samson's hair was cut off. Losing his strength, he was captured by the Philistines, who gouged out his eyes, and made him grind grain in prison.

Later, the Philistines stood Samson in the center of a temple during a celebration, his hair had now grown back. Samson was placed between the two main pillars of the temple. He asked God to strengthen him one more time "so that I may pay back the Philistines for the loss of at least one of my eyes." Then Samson pushed against the pillars with all his might. "Let me die with the Philistines," he prayed.

The temple crashed, killing more Philistines at the time of his death, than during his entire lifetime. His brothers brought him back home and buried him between Zorah and Eshtaol, where his father, Manoah was buried. The story of Samson is found in the Book of Judges, chapters 13-16. The name Samson means "Little Sun."

Joan   January 11th, 2009 1:44 am ET

No Arafat. Clinton is still alive.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 1:44 am ET

So suicide killing ( actually the first suicide killer in history was Samson who was an Israelite) and guess who were killed?
Again i am against it wherever it comes from

Joan   January 11th, 2009 1:45 am ET

Rod,

What does Samson have to do with anything??

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:46 am ET

Yeah, I know Joan. But both prospects sound equally absurd to me.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 1:46 am ET

ok Arafat did not sign the deal. i researched it and actually there are books about it. but anyway ( i think it might have been the best deal israel is willing to give) but there were things that he could not accept. and really it was not a good deal from their side. he got the blame for it but even people who were involved came out and said that the
The americans and Israelis were as guilty as Arafat.

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:49 am ET

Why do you think it wasn't it a good deal from their side, Rod?

Joan   January 11th, 2009 1:49 am ET

Nona,

Yes, it's absurd, ut that is the kind of thinking we're dealing with.

Nick-Canada   January 11th, 2009 1:50 am ET

No Rod you can clearly see he is retaliating against the first terrorists

Rod   January 11th, 2009 1:51 am ET

I do not say That somson has to do with anything. I saw that people claim suicide bombing on Muslims ( i am a jew) but the history says otherwise.
I am against killing of anyone by any means.
Anyway muslims are not brainwashed people as we like to show. and about 87% of the people who committed suicide attacks in Israel had lost relatives in israeli attacks. the issue is attacks and counter attacks and it is not good for anyone, because it is a vicious cycle that will never end until people who have sanity interfere and take a lead.

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:52 am ET

I love Bible study. I'm looking at Judges 13-16 now. Doesn't sound like your web site is giving the whole story based on your synopsis, Rod.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 1:53 am ET

Rod, "The americans and Israelis were as guilty as Arafat.' What do you mean by guilty??

Rod   January 11th, 2009 1:53 am ET

Nick good that you brought that up. This is exactly what Hamas is saying "these are retaliations against the State of Israel terror".

Ryan   January 11th, 2009 1:54 am ET

dan perman you are a racist. you say and i quote "mutilating dead bodies is a muslim sport" why do you have to contribute to the idea that all muslims are terrorists? WHAT DO YOU HONESTLY KNOW OF MUSLIM TRADITIONS AND BELIEFS. YOU CAST A BLANKET OF HATRED ON AN ENTIRE RELIGION BECAUSE OF THE ACTIONS OF A FEW. BY YOUR WAY OF THINKIN IT WOULD BE OK TO SAY ALL BLACKS AND HISPANIC PEOPLE ARE MURDERERS AND DRUG DEALERS BECAUSE OF THE FEW OF THEM THAT ACTUALLY DO THESE THINGS. WHY DON'T YOU ACTUALLY LEARN A BIT ABOUT THE PEOPLE WHOSE LIVES AND WAY OF LIFE YOU ARE RUINING WITH YOUR COMMENTS INSTEAD OF JUST POSTING OPINIONS WITH NO FACTUAL INFORMATION TO BACK THEM UP

Rod   January 11th, 2009 1:55 am ET

Joan,
Guilty in not making the agreement work.

There were one main issue. and many other details but since i was not there I cannot say everything.
The Right for Palestinians to Return was the main issue.

cubfan   January 11th, 2009 1:57 am ET

The only way to prevent Hamas from multiplying is to let the IDF kill or capture all of them in Gaza, only then can there be peace in Gaza. The pathetic UN has only enabled Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran by picking the Islamic terrorist’s side for decades. It is about time the UN and their anti-Semitic views are not allowed to butt into Israel’s right to defend its self. Hamas has bought this destruction to Gaza and the Palestinians lost the right for sympathy when they went to the polls and voted for the destruction of Israel. They have brought the wrath of God upon themselves by being evil.
Fortunately for the IDF, there is no force in the Europe that has the fortitude to commit troops in a military conflict so Israel could basically march all the way to Tehran without any real resistance unless the US would step in to stop them. The gutless French and the rest of Europe have lost all credibility to attain a cease fire with their cowardly actions in the Iraq war. The IDF know the French are all talk and cowards.

Nona   January 11th, 2009 1:57 am ET

Isn't Israel saying these attacks are in response to Gazan rockets?

Joan   January 11th, 2009 2:00 am ET

Rod,

I still don't get it. Samxon killed himself and others. Does that make it right? Who cares who did it first ? That doesn't make it right. And just becasue one person does something stupid, it doesn't mean other people should imitate it. THe point is, as far as I know, Muslims are the main perpetrators of suicide ombing, a deplorable and futile practice.

Not many people want a suicide bomber. or anyone who supports suicide bombing as their neighbor. If you disagree with them they might blow themselves up in your house.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 2:00 am ET

Nona,
This is why I put the reference so that it is not my word. but anyway
what i was aiming at is that we really should not allow this to continue there are many lives affected. I think they should forget about the past and look for the future what is past is past.
end the occupation two functional states. no atrocities and the deal is done. actually both palestinians and israelis are so soart and if they work together they will do so well.

rusty   January 11th, 2009 2:02 am ET

I agree that it is horrible what is happening in Gaza. It may even get worse in the coming days. Israel is indeed being brutal in their actions. But it all starts with Hamas, a racist, terrorist organization, lobbing rockets into Israel, storing weapons in their Holy sites, and digging tunnels from those Holy sites in order to get more weapons. Their people live in squalor, and all they want is more, and more weapons to use against a neighbor much more powerful than they are. It's insane. Israel has made concessions in the past, which were only answered with more missiles, suicide bombers, and car bombs. That is why the borders are closed, and the the tanks are rolling. Pray for the innocents on BOTH sides, but please be honest, this problem all starts with Hamas.

Nona   January 11th, 2009 2:05 am ET

Rod:

"I think they should forget about the past and look for the future what is past is past. end the occupation two functional states."

I agree 100%, with the exception of "end the occupation." There IS NO occupation, that's just rhetoric used that means "wipe Israel off the map and end the existence of Israel."

That's why Hamas is against a two-state solution. They see any existence of Israel in the region is an "occupation." It's not a military term with them; it's an euphemism for ideological beliefs that they're committed to.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 2:08 am ET

Does anyone think Hamas can help the people of Gaza???

Rod   January 11th, 2009 2:08 am ET

joan I said at least two times that i disagree with Samson and other suicidal bombers.
so i do not need to put it between every one word i write (go read my post. )
I am a human rights activist and cannot condone killing suicide or not.
the only thing is that we in the western world think this guy was sitting playing Video games and suddenly he has an idea about going and getting the virgins. that is not true. there are roots to all of this. there is hatred that stems from oppression.
watch this video if you like it is long but though provoking
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2451908450811690589&ei=BdMbScX5OafcqAOF1NHGBw&q=occupation+101

the problem is the violence will continue as long as there are retaliations from both sides.
which makes me sad cause the ones who pay the price are the Civilians mostly women and children.

cubfan   January 11th, 2009 2:09 am ET

To win the PR battle the IDF needs to annihilate Hamas. Until this goal is accomplished Hamas has won and the UN would have left Israel in a situation where the citizens of Israel will be forced to tolerate another decade of missiles until Israel is forced to Nuke radical Islam from mother earth. The relatively small amount of civilian casualties is a small price to pay for an unconditional surrender by Hamas and an opening towards real and sustainable peace between the Israelis and the Palestinians.

Hopefully the IDF is ready to embark on the final battle for Gaza city so they bring an end to the terrorists and their Godless missile attacks on the innocent people of Israel.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 2:13 am ET

i guess nona we have to disagree on the occupation i am sure you did not watch the video if you did then you will know what occupation means http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2451908450811690589&ei=BdMbScX5OafcqAOF1NHGBw&q=occupation+101
i am jut asking you to spend the hour and half on it. there are many historians and rigghts activists mostly jews in it. so give your self that chance to see their perspective
Actually all the world considers the isreali presence in Gaza West bank and golan heights as occupation not only me. even to day it is still called Occupation.

I am not the spokes person for hamas so i do not know about their agenda but what i know if the occupation ends Hamas will not be there
i have to go friends are home
Yall take care

Joan   January 11th, 2009 2:15 am ET

I don't think that suicide bombers are just suddenly wanting to go get the virgins. And I know there is hatred, but who is helping these people understand that hate only desrtroys the hater. People like Hamas are using this hatred and somehow right minded people need to work toward turning this hatred into positive energy.There is no excuse for hatred.

Nick-Canada   January 11th, 2009 2:16 am ET

Joan
Absolutly not, in any way

Nona   January 11th, 2009 2:16 am ET

What is Hamas?

Ron, I just gotta ask you ... do think the USA should negotiate with al-Qaeda? My heart breaks for the Palestinian people, but sympathy for Hamas and sympathy for the Palestinian people are two different things. People are getting killed and suffering in Afghanistan because of the Taliban too, but nobody's suggesting that the Afghans and the Taliban are the same thing, even though they're sypathetic to the Afghani people.

Nick-Canada   January 11th, 2009 2:18 am ET

Hamas means Islamic resistence movement

Nona   January 11th, 2009 2:20 am ET

I've indeed watched part of the video, Rod. And so far, I'm going to accept Hamas's definition of the "occupation" over the video's. Intelligent people can disagree. Hamas is basically the al-Qaeda cell whose mission is to wipe Israel off the map and the words and actions of Hamas demonstrate how seriously they take that mission. The Palestinian people have a basic human right to live in peace and dignity, but so do the Israeli people.

How exactly do you deal with people who are repeatedly asked to stop firing rockets at your citizens and to stop training them for suicide attacks on you when they refuse to honor your requests? Keep talking while they fire rockets and send boys and women with suicide vests into your cities?

Nona   January 11th, 2009 2:22 am ET

Leaving? Oh sorry to see you go Rod. Good night Ron.

Nick-Canada   January 11th, 2009 2:23 am ET

Nona
I hear ya

Nona   January 11th, 2009 2:28 am ET

I know Nick.

He means well. He really wants peace and hurts for the suffering of the people caught in the crossfire. I think he has a hard time accepting that people can actually be so hell-bent on destroying a tiny country that they'll put their bombs in schools and mosques, and their children in harm's way. And I can understand that. It's incomprehensible to sane human beings.

I am getting sick of that video being pushed on everybody. I've watched part of it and it's interesting, but it's not the Holy Grail.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 2:29 am ET

got to go. Thanks all, bye

Nona   January 11th, 2009 2:33 am ET

Bye Joan! Come back soon!

Sarah   January 11th, 2009 2:42 am ET

War crimes.....

This discussion is beyond ridiculous. For one. Hamas Is a Terrorist organization....forget about being democratically elected. It's one or the other. You cannot hold Hamas to one standard and expect them to be held to another. THAT IS THE UN< WORLDS PROBLEM. WHO IS THE UN?!!!!
Second. Hamas is a elected gov't. hold them up to OFFICIAL Standards and diplomatic tactics.
So you either hold them as a legitimate GOV'T entity or you don't. AND if you go to war against them THEN DON"T BE SO Um, erm, yeah well, the civilians got in the way. WHO"S a civilian if its' a TERRORIST Group AND NOT a GOV't? ah, but it's all of them, Right?

It's one or the other folks, make up you mind, but remember which ever way you move it has consiquences.

Nick-Canada   January 11th, 2009 2:43 am ET

Nona
All this time I really did'nt, I looked it up in the Canadian Wikepedia and it also says that Hamas is listed as a terrorist organization by Canada, the European Union, Israel, Japan, and the United States, and is banned in Jordon. Australia and the United Kingdom list only the military wing of Hamas a terrorist organization. The United States and the European Union have both implemented restrictive measures against Hamas on an International level

Nona   January 11th, 2009 2:47 am ET

Interesting, Nick. I was reading the Hamas charter the other day but took a break when I came to the part about the Rotary Club and Freemasons conspiring to poison the minds of Palestinian women.

Martin   January 11th, 2009 2:48 am ET

Where were these protesters when Mumbai massacre was taking place?

Nick-Canada   January 11th, 2009 2:52 am ET

Nona
really

Nick-Canada   January 11th, 2009 3:01 am ET

Well I gotta go, I'll probably be back later

Nona   January 11th, 2009 3:10 am ET

Yeah Nick – really! Cya soon!

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 3:11 am ET

i am sooooooooo sad!!!!!!!
what will bring this war to all the innocent jews?

how is israel making peace to innocent jews ?
its soooo sad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Academic boycott welcome, says Jewish professor
http://www.nationalpost.com/scripts/story.html?id=1158893

UK anti-semitism 'surge' since Gaza attack
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/uk-antisemitism-surge-since-gaza-attack-1229111.html

Ontario union calls for ban on Israeli professors
http://www.nationalpost.com/story.html?id=1144758

Roseanne Barr blasts Israel as 'Nazi state'
http://www.wnd.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=85126

Jews Attacked As Gaza Conflict Spreads To Europe
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/01/06/jews-attacked-as-gaza-con_n_155551.html?show_comment_id=19467922

Italian politicians condemn anti-Israeli boycott
http://www.euronews.net/en/article/09/01/2009/italian-politicians-condemn-anti-israeli-boycott

not all jews are israelis!
not all jews support this holocaust!

Israel do you hate the jews?
Israel cant you remember the pain?
Israel why do you let the innocent jews suffer because the new Israeli holocaust?
Israel have you forgotten hystorical.files.wordpress.com/2008/02/dontbuyfromjews.jpg ?

thanks you israel!
thank you for killing all his civilians
thank you to kill all this innocent babies
thank you
thank you!

bring peace stop this genocide at Gaza!

(by the way... i all ready saw such shit at shops... thank you israel!... go on and "change reality" ... thank you)
:( :( :( :(

barham   January 11th, 2009 3:28 am ET

Martin,
You protest to try stop the further continues act of killing by Israeli forces, no use of protesting for a thing already been done! are you smart enough to understand?

you dont protest for the 250 children already burned alive in GAZA thanks to bombs made in USA, but you protest to try, maybe your protest will help stop the Israeli lust for blood, maybe save a girl from burning alive, what if you know that 250 cats burned alive, how would you feel? how would you feel if your sister burned alive?

Beth Brighterman   January 11th, 2009 3:33 am ET

CNN's coverage is disgustingly anti-Israel. Hamas ( and by proxy,Iran) are getting their terrorist teeth knocked out – and deservedly so. This is a war, not a tennis match. Israel can use anything in its arsenal. Hamas should take a lesson from the playground bully – don't pick on someone who can beat the sh_t out of you. As for the so-called innocent civilians – in every poll taken the Gazans overwhelmingly support rocket attacks on Israel and kidnappings. Yes, I hope the Arab world is watching this. Notice how Iran's other proxy in Lebanon really can't stand the thought of getting another spanking like they got in '06.
PROUD to be PRO-ISRAEL!!

Sheila   January 11th, 2009 3:37 am ET

Pleasseee stop the war , its the most stupid thing men can ever do.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 3:46 am ET

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
thank you

Martin   January 11th, 2009 4:01 am ET

You didn't elaborate to my very simple question barham,
Where were these protesters when Indians were slaughtered in Mumbai 4 weeks ago?
Or when 12000 or so atrocities committed by the Religion of Peace since 911 took place, including bombings, beheadings, honor killings, mutilations, child abuses etc etc. Judging from the number of people the organizers can muster, rallying a protest condemning any of those incidents can't be difficult.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 4:10 am ET

Beth Brighterman,

Glad to see you are fueling this WAR which is leading to more killing of people on both side , me too i am glad to see more pro Israel like you who will help Is (no Real) Israel to dig its own grave, you can use my shovel for free.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 4:14 am ET

Martin,

Did you see any of this of what you mentioned has a Gazan hand on it, or just because they are Muslims, u want to rally all terrorist acts on their shoulders.

Nona   January 11th, 2009 4:23 am ET

The headline on this entire post is stupid: "Gaza: The Arab World Watches." Note to CNN: Um, the ENTIRE world watches, not just the Arab world.

The headline on the previous post is stupid too: "Gaza: Aids Resumes." It makes it look like an outbreak of HIV is resuming. CNN is too sloppy to proofread for typos.

Not a comment about the war, just a comment about the competence of whoever edits this blog.

Saudi   January 11th, 2009 4:30 am ET

.

Don't bather!

http://www.5cense.com/Africa/pics/04_Sleeping_camel.jpg

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 4:32 am ET

Beth Brighterman.

Yes the Arab world is watching and pay back is coming soon.you will see shortly that Israel even if Hamas is defeated which will not happen will face hundreds of Hamas very soon it is not about Hamas it is about Israeli terrorism and occupation.

Martin   January 11th, 2009 4:33 am ET

You missed my point, Hunk. My point is:

How could muslims miss 12000+ chances to condemn any act of terrorism commited by fellow muslims with such ferocity and passion as this one.

Om-Zubayr   January 11th, 2009 4:38 am ET

Humans need to wake-up, why do we fight each other for land, for control and power... but no one will live forever and the land stays here. Why do we kill each other in wars and genocides in order to show how strong a group is and how a weak another. I see that being strong is not by possessing the latest arms of destruction and military techniques, but it's how genuine you can be towards humanity. How many lives you save and how many people in need you help.
The jewish people suffered from the holocaust and felt how bitter and unjuste to kill people especially kids. Why do they make the palestinians kids go through the same destiny.
The life is a gift from God, no one has the right to take it except him.
I don't know if it is worthed to submit this comment because the killing machine is still taking life of hundreds everyday and no one care.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 4:43 am ET

Martin,

No . i didnt miss the point. reread it

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 4:53 am ET

"atrocities committed by the Religion of Peace since 911 took place, including bombings, beheadings, honor killings, mutilations, child abuses etc etc. Judging from the number of people the organize"

Martin
was Christianity responsible for the atrocities of the Nazis and the faccist
and the communists?

Is Christianity responsible for Rowanda Bosnia the Killings of the natives in north America and Australia.?

is Christianity responsible for Jim Jones and timothy M'cveigh?
this is all done by Christians.

if not and it is not. then Shut up.

Jo Bloh   January 11th, 2009 4:56 am ET

I would trust a Israely army report over a western media or UN offcials word any time. The facts are the Israely's don't target civilians, and Hamas does.

This is simple logic from a tactic point of view, less civillian causaltys good from a PR point. The moral of the story is if Hamas stopped hiding under the womens dresses and childrens beds and came out and fought like real men then there wouldn't be so many dead.

But I guess the fight would be to short then

Bill   January 11th, 2009 5:16 am ET

Hunk – Maybe you have forgotten. Of the 167 known terrorist organizations, 164 of them are Islamic. This means that virtually all of the terrorists in the world are indeed Muslim. So, when an atrocity is committed by a terrorist, it is virtually certain that the atrocity was committed by a Muslim. Most often, it kills more Muslims that non-Muslims or whoever the target of the day is.

Not all Muslims are terrorists, but virtually all terrorists are Muslim. Heard that before?

It's time for Muslims to take responsibility for their actions instead of trying to dispute the overwhelming evidence against them. Change will only come from within. Short of killing every Muslim on the planet, there is no military solution.

The civilized world will continue to defend themselves against Islamic terrorism piecemeal. If the world ever gets organized against terrorism and terrorist supporters, Muslims may become an endangered species unless they change their ways and their aspirations on world domination.

Flying Giant   January 11th, 2009 5:19 am ET

Jo Bloh – you are a hundred percent right.

Sickning to see all the people on here justifying terror. "The christians did it too" blabity blabity blab. terrorists are morons.

barham   January 11th, 2009 5:26 am ET

Jo Bloh,

So your prefer the integrity of Israeli army over the integrity of the world? maybe the whole one big terrorist group, and Israeli murderers are the only humanitarian in the world by their act of continues killing of Palestinians since 60 years. maybe you are just a reflection of them, a mental racist terrorist? maybe you dont know because no terrorist would think he is a terrorist.

Martin,

Who said Muslims dont condemned terrorism acts? how do you know that? they always do, such as any other country condemn these acts. look back in the news at Mumbai explosions, you will see it's being condemned by all muslims, and non muslims.
but i repeat, Indians are slaughtered in that day, nothing can be done to stop it, protesting is useless! if they continued to be slaughtered everyday by Pakistan for example, you would see by now millions of demonstrations against Pakistan embassy to try stop their attacks, wont you?

and if you interested in protesting against the religion of peace for whatever your reason, you can go to the Saudi embassy, they are the first sponsors for it, but i cant understand what is the relation between all what you said and the Israeli occupation conflict?

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 5:26 am ET

Jo Bloh and Bill.

did you read my post why dont you defend your selves as Christians before attacking others .

if you are Zionists then I dont blame you for what you are saying because you are raised as haters and racists I dont expect a thief to admit his theft.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 5:34 am ET

Bill.

I will not ask your same questions , as where you there and what really happened ... but i ask .... equating actions happened on the world to actions happening on the ground is like running forward .... which what you are doing right now .

Answer me now :

Why the IDF didn’t send a a group of soldiers backed with tanks and take those lunching the rockets from top of a school , they don't have choppers ….. or a sniper or Gatling cannon on a an Abbachi that could finish the job and save life of people taking refuge from 11 days of war.

Saudi   January 11th, 2009 5:40 am ET

The Palestinians have to wait;
Arabs are busy chasing what interests them most at this time!

See this
http://saudisolutions.org/arabs-busy-chasing-this.zip

Beny   January 11th, 2009 5:41 am ET

Akiva,

Are you a Neturei-Karta guy? Because someone who pretends to be Jewish yet harbors a deep resentment to Israel, hate that came long before this war and will burn long after it, hate at the mere fact of Israel's existence, I'm seeing you as one of those Jews that don't think Israel is allowed to exist because it "halts the coming of Messiah".

btw You really think Jews are being attacked in Europe because of this war? And before this war Jews weren't attacked?! Jews are attacked because of anti-semitism, whatever the excuse might be.

"thanks you israel!"

Yes. You should thank us. Cause when the next round of pogroms will come to Europe just as they did before, and Israel will open it's gates to disgusting you where no one else will, you will be incredibly glad that we exist.

Bill   January 11th, 2009 5:44 am ET

Solomon – Sorry, teaching hatred and racism to little children is only done by Muslims. As far as I have seen, Christians and Jews do the opposite, they teach their children love and tolerance.

Beny   January 11th, 2009 5:44 am ET

Hunk,

Your question was already answered and repeating will help you naught. I will answer one last time:


“Why the IDF didn’t send a a group of soldiers backed with tanks and take those lunching the rockets from top of the school ”

So you want us to sacrifice our own lives to save the people Hamas is sacrificing?!!

Nice logic you’ve got there: Hamas sacrifices children, and we need to sacrifice ourselves to save them?

We avoid them if we can, but I still care more for the IDF soldier than for the Palestinian who wants me dead.

Besides, tell me of ONE SINGLE COUNTRY that wouldn’t have flattened Gaza from the first Kassam. The fact that we’re even going there on foot instead of flattening Gaza like YOUR country would have done, shows how we want to avoid civilians, despite Hamas’s greatest efforts.

barham   January 11th, 2009 5:45 am ET

Bill, wrote

"Maybe you have forgotten. Of the 167 known terrorist organizations, 164 of them are Islamic"

From where did got this information? what is your reference please?

because here is 4 internationally defined terrorists organizations which are non Muslims, enough to show that you are making up fake numbers.

Red Brigades
Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia
Revolutionary People's Liberation Party-Front
Real Irish Republican Army

Is that the way you always lie when you write on blogs?

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 5:47 am ET

Beny,

“So you want us to sacrifice our own lives to save the people Hamas is sacrificing?!!”

That is the point …. IDF has no moral ground that’s why its :

Morally unacceptable and is a burden to the people of the world to side with Israel.

Moral ground is non negotiable , my enemy will never dedicate to me but I act on my own moral ground.

Beny   January 11th, 2009 5:50 am ET

NEWSFLASH:

With Palestinians dying all around him, Mashaal sits in his comfy bunker and says THAT THEY WILL NOT AGREE TO A UN PEACEKEEPING FORCE. Who's prolonging the war now?

I thought, as a government, Hamas ought to do maximum to stop its people from dying, but in fact, HAMAS REJECT WHAT EVEN ISRAEL AGREED TO

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3653889,00.html

Bill   January 11th, 2009 5:50 am ET

Hunk – The first part of your post made no sense, so I can't comment on that. If the cowardly Islamic terrorists of Hamas were launching rockets from on top of a school, then any civilian casualties are the responsibility of Hamas, not Israel. Launching attacks from civilian areas is a war crime. Again, not having been there myself, I can not speculate of what could have been done or might have been done.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 5:51 am ET

Beny,

It make me wonder if any of these atrocities ever happened to Jew or maybe these numbers are not correct.

This is the only question that's on everybody mind all over the world , if these things really happened ... why you allow them to happen on your hands ...

Rod   January 11th, 2009 5:51 am ET

Barham,
Good job all that information Bill copied and pasted is fabricated information.
The terrirists are the ones who want to "Nuke the Palestinians"
they are living a good life and just hate humanity. they want more killing because their life is based on hatred and blood shed and want more.

Martin   January 11th, 2009 5:52 am ET

Barham' logic: "Indians are slaughtered in that day, nothing can be done to stop it, protesting is useless"
So maybe Israel should just nuke Gaza so nothing could be done about it too? And there was only one muslim country that condemned the massacre in Mumbai: Pakistan.

Solomon: you wont believe it how many times angry muslims suddenly call me a christian simply because I criticize them. And funny you mentioned world war 2 since at that time, the highest authority in Palestine, Grand Mufti of Jerusalem Iman al Husayni was allied with Hitler. His Ganjar troops were very active at exterminating Jews in Bosnia. And he personally ordered a ship filled with Jewish children that arrived in Palestine to go back to gas chambers in Europe.

Beny   January 11th, 2009 5:52 am ET

Hunk,

Oh and Hamas are really moral, are they?

Givati guys saved a whole building in Gaza that was wired to explode on all the families there. The building was wired by Hamas.

Who's immoral here?

Keys   January 11th, 2009 5:53 am ET

jeez benny – U R re talking to retards as if they're half as smart as my cat. You have the patience of Job.

We r behind u and ur countrymen in stopping these terrorist thugs!

Beny   January 11th, 2009 5:57 am ET

Rod,

"The terrirists are the ones who want to “Nuke the Palestinians”
they are living a good life and just hate humanity. they want more killing because their life is based on hatred and blood shed and want more."

Thank you for descibing HAMAS so accurately. They would nuke the Palestinians too, if they had the chance, just as long as it kills Israelis in the process.

"they want more killing because their life is based on hatred and blood shed "

"What is your most lofty aspiration? DEATH IN THE NAME OF ALLAH"

"we form a human wall around the Mujhadeen to protect them and say to the Zionist enemy: WE DESIRE DEATH LIKE YOU DESIRE LIFE"

The first from an interview with a 5-year-old. The second is a speech by a Hamas official

Bill   January 11th, 2009 5:58 am ET

Hunk – A moral argument from a terrorist supporter? Are you kidding me? You think that it is moral for the Islamic terrorist group of Hamas to have started shelling innocent Israeli civilians? You think it is moral for Hamas to hide behind women and children? You think it is moral for Islamic terrorists to desecrate mosques by storing weapons and ammunition there? You think it is moral for Islamic terrorists to spend all their billions of dollars on weapons to attack Israeli civilians while letting their own people starve and continue to get handouts from the UN for 60 years? You think it is moral for the Islamic terrorists to steal UN aid, food, and fuel for themselves? You think it is moral for Hamas to be holed up safe in bunkers while the civilian population gets killed in the crossfire?

I agree, moral ground is not negotiable and you have absolutely none.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 5:58 am ET

Bill,

"cowardly Islamic terrorists"

Kindly replace Islamic with Jews and you will have the answer .

That action require ball and guts and these characteristics is not there at all on any member serving on IOF ( Israel Occupation Forces), its cheaper to kill a school children 257 of them up to now .

Do you have a moral ground there .... NO you are as good as the terrorist you are fighting which equal U with them . YOU ARE A TERRORIST as well.

Beny   January 11th, 2009 6:00 am ET

Thanks Keys. Let's hope this will end soon and both Gaza and south Israel will be free of Hamas terrorists. Amen and good luck to our Givati guys.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:00 am ET

"Yes. You should thank us. Cause when the next round of pogroms will come to Europe just as they did before, and Israel will open it’s gates to disgusting you where no one else will, you will be incredibly glad that we exist"

Beny.
What a joke you are..the Pygmy outlaw state of Israel will do all this? you are the protector of Europe now?

I can see defeat in your words and I dont blame you after all the Killing of children and women you are still going to be defeated you will see your Israeli defeated forces IDF out of Gaza and the west bank soon .

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:02 am ET

Beny .

how many Children did your outlaw Israeli defeated forces kill in Gaza today ?

Bill   January 11th, 2009 6:04 am ET

Rod -

I didn't copy and paste anything, let alone fabricate it. Fabrication is more a Muslim thing than mine. Muslims are encouraged to lie to "infidels" or anyone who is not the "right kind" of Muslim. That is pretty obvious in these blogs. Truth seems to be an alien concept to the terrorist supporters.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 6:05 am ET

Bill,

Beny,

Its like getting drown to the head on the sand.... you are both pulling each other down .... its no ground for arguments its never right or wrong when it comes to morality .... do you want me to define that to you both ..

Its shame if we keep on discussing it from the right or wrong angel .

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:06 am ET

Beny.

I think the count down already started for this terrorist state that is called Israel. Zionists like you have no Place in Palestine.Jews and Arabs can live together without the filth of Zionism.

blood is red   January 11th, 2009 6:10 am ET

The other time an Israeli political leader said.
You can give nothing to Palestinians, because they never stop asking for more!
Make me laugh .Hear is what Israelis do!

Just to know the truth from the man who support the creation of ISRAEL

Washington DC, USA, Friday, July 11, 2003

Harry Truman’s Forgotten Diary 1947

Writings Offer Fresh Insight on the President

By Rebecca Dana and Peter Carlson
Washington Post Staff Writers

“THE JEWS, I find are very, very selfish,” President Harry S. Truman wrote in a 1947 diary that was recently discovered on the shelves of the Truman Library in Independence, Mo., and released by the National Archives yesterday.

Written sporadically during a turbulent year of Truman’s presidency, the diary contains about 5,500 words on topics ranging from the death of his mother to comic banter with a British aristocrat. But the most surprising comments were Truman’s remarks on Jews, written on July 21, 1947, after the president had a conversation with Henry Morganthau [sic. Morgenthau], his Jewish treasury secretary. Morganthau called to talk about a Jewish ship in Palestine — possibly the Exodus, the legendary ship carrying 4,500 Jewish refugees who were refused entry into Palestine by the British, then rulers of that land.

“He’d no business, whatever to call me,” Truman wrote. “The Jews have no sense of proportion nor do they have any judgement (sic) on world affairs. Henry brought a thousand Jews to New York on a supposedly temporary basis and they stayed.”
Truman then went into a rant about Jews:

“The Jews, I find, are very, very selfish. They care not how many Estonians, Latvians, Finns, Poles, Yugoslavs or Greeks get murdered or mistreated as D[isplaced] P[ersons] as long as the Jews get special treatment. Yet when they have power, physical, financial or political neither Hitler nor Stalin has anything on them for cruelty or mistreatment to the under dog. Put an underdog on top and it makes no difference whether his name is Russian, Jewish, Negro, Management, Labor, Mormon, Baptist he goes haywire. I’ve found very, very few who remember their past condition when prosperity comes.”
Yesterday, those comments startled scholars because Truman is known as a president who acted to help Jews in postwar Europe and who supported recognition of Israel in 1948, when his State Department opposed it.

Cheers

Bill   January 11th, 2009 6:10 am ET

Hunk – It seems I am fighting a battle of wits with an unarmed man. The best you can do is call me names? What a brave and intelligent person you must be!

Israel is defending itself and its citizens against Islamic terrorism. The Islamic terrorist cowards of Hamas are trying to maximize the number of civilian casualties by hiding among civilians. When civilians inevitably get killed, you start crying. You are so easily manipulated by the terrorists. Instead of being angry at the ones who put the civilians in danger, you get mad at the ones who are defending themselves against Islamic terrorist aggression.

Gee, I pity you. What a sucker!

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:12 am ET

Beny.

Read what your brother is saying.

The Lord shall return their deeds on their own heads, waste their seed and exterminate them, devastate them and vanish them from this world. It is forbidden to be merciful to them. You must send missiles to them and annihilate them. They are evil and damnable.”

It is easy to imagine these words being uttered by a Nazi leader in Germany some 60 years ago, or by a proponent of apartheid in South Africa just a decade ago. In reality, however, these blatantly racist and inflammatory words were spoken just a few weeks ago by Israeli Rabbi Ovadia Yosef. He was, of course, speaking about Arabs—during a widely broadcast sermon marking Passover,

Bill   January 11th, 2009 6:14 am ET

Hunk – As a terrorist supporter, you can have no meaningful position on morality. You consciously support an immoral cause. No amount of talking can change that fact. You can make no case to absolve yourself. Islamic terrorism is immoral. You support Islamic terrorism. It is that simple.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 6:15 am ET

Beny,
you know who established or help establish Hamas?
if you do not know it is the Shin-Bet. if they did not establish it they at least supported it when PLO was a terrorist organization.

"After all, it is no secret that it was the Israeli government which set up Hamas to start with. When I once asked a former Shin-Bet chief, Yaakov Peri, about it, he answered enigmatically: “We did not create it, but we did not hinder its creation.”
For years, the occupation authorities favored the Islamic movement in the occupied territories. All other political activities were rigorously suppressed, but their activities in the mosques were permitted. The calculation was simple and naive: at the time, the PLO was considered the main enemy, Yasser Arafat was the current Satan. The Islamic movement was preaching against the PLO and Arafat, and was therefore viewed as an ally."
this is from The Article "Molten Lead" by Uri Avnery

So may be Israel made Hamas to justify all the killing as i see happening now?
We all need to think about this possibility

Bill   January 11th, 2009 6:18 am ET

blood is red -

Just old anti-semitism from a newer anti-semite.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 6:19 am ET

Bill.

This is called "intellectual insolvency" that's when you run out of reasonable logic to reinforce your position, and this kind of Sewage words coming out of you show your true value, if there is any.

I pity you

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:19 am ET

"We must cleanse the country of Arabs and resettle them in the countries where they came from," head of the Yesha Rabbis Council, Rabbi Dov Lior, declared Monday, adding that,

Beny
Just like your father this cousin of yours

, the Rabbi who wants to transfer the indigenous Palestinians from their own land was probably born an Austrian, German or Hungarian passport! He certainly wasn't an Israeli because there was no Israel then!!.

barham   January 11th, 2009 6:20 am ET

martins depth of thinking
"So maybe Israel should just nuke Gaza so nothing could be done about it too? And there was only one muslim country that condemned the massacre in Mumbai: Pakistan."

yes nothing could be done! could protesting return them alive? no. you could only just nuke Israel then.

and please dont say lies just for the sake trying proof your point, really it will dramatically effects you credibility in anything else you write!! you said the only muslim country condemned the massacre in Mumbai is Pakistan??? all the arabic countries condemned it, Egypt, Jordan, Morocco, Tunis, Saudi, even Iran condemned it for your info!!! really what is the point from lying to prove your point? are you here to try know the truth, or to feed and be fed lies?

Calli   January 11th, 2009 6:22 am ET

" ..these blatantly racist and inflammatory words were spoken just a few weeks ago by Israeli Rabbi Ovadia Yosef. He was, of course, speaking about Arabs—during a widely broadcast sermon marking Passover."

Solomon, Passover was not a few weeks ago.

Are you a deliberate liar, or just an ignorant one?

Calli   January 11th, 2009 6:25 am ET

Rod –

You know who helped establish the Taliban?

The USA.

That doesn't mean they're still not hell-bent on destroying those who supported their founding.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 6:26 am ET

Ok guys Enjoy your Cyber Wars.
I am leaving
Hope Peace prevails
Someone must stop this Massacre
Peace Salam Shalom

barham   January 11th, 2009 6:28 am ET

Bill,
why still you didnt tell me from where you got the 164?

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:36 am ET

calli
Passover is not just this year there was a passover last year too .
you can not come with a better defense?

do you want me to give you the link?

Rod   January 11th, 2009 6:39 am ET

Well Calli then you guys can't have it both ways. Israel created hamas and now they are punishing and the palestinian people because of Hamas.

the same thing for the US and Taliban. If the US established Taliban they should compensate all who suffered from Taliban.
you just cannot Establish two terrorist groups put them behind civilians and then massacre the civilians to root out what you established.

This is not a lab with Experimental animals. these are humans.
Even Experimental animals have protection boards.
This Genocide experiment is a new thing.
it is even beyond a crime against humanity.
nite all
Hope peace prevails

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:41 am ET

Calli here is another one.

Israeli rabbis call for killing the Arabs
7/28/2001

The Israeli rabbi Munir Lao haled the killing of Palestinian children and youth by the Israeli settlers. He explained that the Jewish ethnic group supports and backs the killing of the Palestinians.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 6:45 am ET

Any body is having any thing on Chass ? i think they have same methodology like Hamas if not worse .... hope my spelling is correct.

Bill   January 11th, 2009 6:47 am ET

Hunk – Sewage words? I guess that what it would taste like if you ever spoke the truth. LOL. Pathetic.

Calli   January 11th, 2009 6:54 am ET

I would like you to tell me where this rabbi Munir Lao is located and the name of his synogogue or university. i see several reports of his supposedly saying that in Jew-hating libelous arab press but there is no other indication he even exists when i do a quick Internet search of him. From what i can tell it just is a claim that appears to have fabricated the existence of this rabbi.

Where is this supposed rabbi? what is the name of his university or congregation? what country is he located in in? what city?

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 6:55 am ET

Bill,

Its the other way round ... idiot

Bill   January 11th, 2009 6:58 am ET

Barham -

Why should I even bother now? The truth obviously means nothing to a terrorist supporter. If I can produce the evidence, you'll claim that it is not credible – standard Muslim practice for obfuscation of the truth. You get stuck on the minor details and miss the message entirely.

The message was that Muslims need to clean house. If you keep supporting Islamic terrorism, it will eventually cause a worldwide backlash that will destroy Islam and most of its practitioners.

Israel, by itself, has enough firepower to destroy all of the Muslims in the Middle East. The USA has even more. This great bulk of this firepower is not used because we value life, even the lives of those who continually attack us. But there are limits. If Israel ever truly feels threatened, I would not want to be her enemy, nor would I want to be anywhere within 2000 miles. If the USA ever felt really threatened, no place on the planet would be safe.

You can keep poking the bear, but it's not a good idea.

Bill   January 11th, 2009 7:02 am ET

Hunk – I guess this just shows what you are a hunk of.

Calli   January 11th, 2009 7:03 am ET

On the other hand, I can certainly document the preaching of Hamas cleric Muhsen Abu 'Ita preaching the annhilation of the Jews of "Palestine" as "a blessing."

Bill   January 11th, 2009 7:10 am ET

Oh well, time for bed.

Go IDF! Clean up all the Islamic terrorist scum and their supporters!
It is good vs. Islam time and the forces of good are winning.

Good night all.

David Freeman   January 11th, 2009 7:14 am ET

Dear Beny,
It is petty to hear half truths from Beny..this is the classic “cause and effect trick” designed to confuse the American readers of what actually happened first..lol..
Beny, You have neglected to inform the readers ..the cause of the rockets from the militants (Hamas).. the truth is (which I am sure you are aware) is the collapse of the ceasefire agreement between Israel and the militants..

Why did the ceasefire collapse?

The ceasefire agreement called on Israel to gradually open the Gaza crossings (Gaza is under siege for over 2 years) and in return the Militants agreed to stop firing their homemade rockets into Israelis. Israel did not honor their part of the agreement. Hamas had offered to renew the ceasefire if Israel reopened Gaza's border crossings. The strip had been sealed by Israel in an economic siege aimed at toppling Hamas. The blockade has brought the territory near economic collapse.

Many of us (Americans) do not understand that Israel is illegally occupying other people’s land according to Security Council Resolution 242 in Nov, 22 1967.

blood is red   January 11th, 2009 7:15 am ET

Bill

Using the crap anti- semite you only show how poor youarguments are.
“The Jews, I find, are very, very selfish. They care not how many Estonians, Latvians, Finns, Poles, Yugoslavs or Greeks get murdered or mistreated as D[isplaced] P[ersons] as long as the Jews get special treatment. Yet when they have power, physical, financial or political neither Hitler nor Stalin has anything on them for cruelty or mistreatment to the under dog. Put an underdog on top and it makes no difference whether his name is Russian, Jewish, Negro, Management, Labor, Mormon, Baptist he goes haywire. I’ve found very, very few who remember their past condition when prosperity comes.”
Yesterday, those comments startled scholars because Truman is known as a president who acted to help Jews in postwar Europe and who supported recognition of Israel in 1948, when his State Department opposed it.

Calli   January 11th, 2009 7:15 am ET

Sure gets quiet when you start asking jihadist liars to back up their false claims with actual evidence, huh? They've gone to hide in a baby's crib or under their daughters' skirts.

Gnite Bill.

blood is red   January 11th, 2009 7:19 am ET

For you Bill who is anti-smite and who is barbaric antidenoctatic and color blind ? Blood is red!
Speak Out NowWhy They Want to Fire Ward Churchill »Protesting Norman Finkelstein’s Tenure Denial; or, Academic Freedom Declines across the U.S. – Part II
By marcy/مارسي newman/نيومان
Ads by Google
Academic Jobs
Find latest academic jobs, career advice & email alerts at CareerOne!
http://www.CareerOne.com.au

June 26, 2007 03:36 PM

By Terri Ginsberg

NEW YORK

As U.S.-backed military actions in the Middle East become increasingly destructive, with thousands of Arab and Muslim civilians dead at the hands of allied troops in Afghanistan and Iraq, and Palestinians suffering to an unprecedented degree under brutal Israeli occupation, scholarly intellectuals have become increasingly vocal in their criticism of attempts by pro-Zionist and neoconservative spokespersons to pressure government bodies and educational institutions to curb opposition and suppress dissent regarding such actions.

Nearly three weeks have passed since one such intellectual, Norman Finkelstein, an Assistant Professor of Political Science at DePaul University in Chicago, was denied tenure by that school’s University Board on Tenure and Promotion. The decision to deny Finkelstein tenure was upheld by DePaul’s president, the Rev. Dennis H. Holtschneider, despite a majority (9-3) recommendation by the departmental tenure committee and a unanimous (5-0) recommendation by the Personnel Committee for the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences. Additionally, Mehrene Larudee, Assistant Professor of International Studies at DePaul, was denied tenure ostensibly for having publicly supported Finkelstein in his tenure bid when it was challenged externally by Alan Dershowitz, a Harvard law professor whose bestselling Zionist screed, The Case for Israel, Finkelstein effectively deconstructed and discredited as pseudo-scholarship in his acclaimed study, Beyond Chutzpah: The Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History. In 2005, Dershowitz attempted unsuccessfully to block the publication of Beyond Chutzpah by making concerted appeals to California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger that the book was anti-Semitic and laced with Holocaust denial. Amidst furious public and scholarly outcry in support of the book’s publication, the Austrian-born actor-turned-politician ultimately refused to heed those appeals on grounds that their implications stood to jeopardize Finkelstein’s academic freedom.

In the three weeks since Holtschneider’s autocratic move, protests in favor of Finkelstein’s and Larudee’s reinstatement have erupted on the DePaul campus as well as across the U.S. and internationally. Immediately following public announcement of the tenure denials, DePaul students staged a sit-in at their school’s executive offices (and were evicted upon threat of expulsion). These students subsequently presented Holtschneider with a 700-signature petition requesting Finkelstein’s and Larudee’s reinstatement. They have since began a hunger strike, now in its second day, at the DePaul University Student Center to continue “to express the seriousness of their distress over the curbing of academic freedom, as university administration has largely ignored the concerns of students and faculty” (student Media Advisory, June 22, 2007, http://normanfinkelstein.wordpress.com/2007/06/23/depaul-students-fast-for-academic-freedom/ ).

blood is red   January 11th, 2009 7:31 am ET

Who is Anti-Semite BILL?

On June 8, 1967, US Navy intelligence ship USS Liberty was suddenly and brutally attacked on the high seas in international waters by the air and naval forces of Israel. The Israeli forces attacked with full knowledge that this was an American ship and lied about it. Survivors have been forbidden for 40 years to tell their story under oath to the American public. The USS Liberty Memorial web site tells their story and is dedicated to the memory of the 34 brave men who died.

The Attack

After surveilling USS Liberty for more than nine hours with almost hourly aircraft overflights and radar tracking, the air and naval forces of Israel attacked our ship in international waters without warning. USS Liberty was identified as a US naval ship by Israeli reconnaissance aircraft nine hours before the attack and continuously tracked by Israeli radar and aircraft thereafter. Sailing in international waters at less than five knots, with no offensive armament, our ship was not a military threat to anyone.

The Israeli forces attacked without warning and without attempting to contact us. Thirty four Americans were killed in the attack and another 174 were wounded. The ship, a $40-million dollar state-of-the-art signals intelligence platform, was later declared unsalvageable and sold for scrap.

The Cover Up

Despite a near-universal consensus that the Israeli attack was made with full knowledge that USS Liberty was a US Navy ship, the Johnson administration began an immediate cover-up of this fact. Though administration officers continued individually to characterize the attack as deliberate, the Johnson administration never sought the prosecution of the guilty parties or otherwise attempted to seek justice for the victims. They concealed and altered evidence in their effort to downplay the attack. Though they never formally accepted the Israeli explanation that it was an accident, they never pressed for a full investigation either. They simply allowed those responsible literally to get away with murder.

In an ongoing effort to reveal the truth about the attack, the USS Liberty Veterans Association has filed with the Secretary of the Army in the manner prescribed by law a detailed, fully documented Report of War Crimes describing the circumstances of the attack on our ship and evidence that it was a crime under international law. In accordance with international law and treaties, the United States is obligated to investigate the allegations. So far, the United States has declined even to acknowledge that the report has been filed. The full text of the report can be found at http://www.gtr5.com/evidence/warcrimes.pdf

Anti-Semitism and the Anti-American Apologists

The USS Liberty Memorial web site abhors the racist and extreme positions taken by antiSemitic, Holocaust denial, conspiracy theorist and other such groups which often seek to identify with us and to usurp our story as their own. We have no connection with and do not support or encourage support from any of these groups including National Alliance, National Vanguard, The New Order, National Socialists, The French Connection, Liberty Lobby, American Free Press, Republic Broadcasting, AFP's Liberty Radio Hour, or other such groups. We wish harm to no one and encourage social justice and equality for everyone; we seek only accountability for the criminal acts perpetrated against us and can do that without help from hate-mongers.

On the Israeli side, the group of pro-Israel, anti-American critics of our story, while small, persists in launching loud, vicious ad hominem attacks on anyone who attempts to discuss the deliberateness of the attack. These anti-American apologists refuse to discuss the facts of the case. Instead, they rely on propaganda and charge anyone who questions the Israeli position with being antiSemitic.

For detailed and authoritative accounts of the power and influence of the pro-Israel lobby, please see The Israel Lobby and US Foreign Policy by Mearsheimer and Walt and The Pro-Israel Lobby by Edward Herman.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:46 am ET

http://switch3.castup.net/cunet/gm.asp?ClipMediaID=3271371&ak=null

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:49 am ET

Hamas sniper and explosives layout revealed

On Thursday (Jan. 8), the Intelligence Corps Officer-in-Chief, Brigadier General Yuval Halmish, revealed a sketch by Hamas that details on the deployment of explosives and Hamas forces in the Al-Attara neighborhood in the northern Gaza Strip. The map was found during Paratrooper Brigade forces operating in the northern Gaza Strip and was translated from Arabic during the operation. It describes, among other things, the location of explosive devices and firing positions in the middle of the civilian population in the dense neighborhood, which endanger the life of the civilians. “That’s what Hamas has been doing throughout the entirety of the operation – perversely using civilians as human shields,” says Brig. Gen. Halmish.

The map shows that snipers are positioned at the entrance of the A-Tawil mosque and in the mosques next to it and describes the directions the snipers are aiming. It indicates that explosives are planted in the entrances of civilian homes. Hamas operatives are divided into three fighting areas throughout the neighborhood, colored blue, red and green. Throughout these area IEDs, (improvised explosive devices), barrel explosives, explosives, explosives against humans and anti tank explosives are planted.

In addition to that, the map also shows an explosive device planted next to a gas station – the detonation of the device would significantly damage the surrounding area. “The important point is the disregard for human life in using entrances civilian homes,” explains Brig. Gen. Halmish. “They booby-trapped the entrances of civilian houses with explosives put close to them; the objective is of course to hit our forces but a local explosion also damages the houses of the civilians and causes great damage, and likely killing civilians.”

Brig. Gen. Halmish also adds that Hamas prevents the distribution of the IDF's cautionary leaflets that ask the civilian population to leave their houses, saying, “Although IDF forces make every possible effort not to harm civilians and only target Hamas members and terror operatives, Hamas prevents these things.”

The forces also discovered a booby-trapped doll at the entrance of a building, which, upon detonation, pulls the surrounding people into an underground tunnel. This, in other words, is an attempt to hit or kidnap soldiers.

“This is done all the time,” explains Brig. Gen. Halmish. According to him these findings testify to Hamas’s military development, notably their network of underground tunnels that IDF forces constantly uncover. The results of the operation are good nevertheless, says Brig. Gen. Halmish. “There are a lot of casualties on the Hamas’s side, and great damage in their infrastructure. Because of Hamas, a number of uninvolved people were hit; for instance at the UNRWA school Hamas was firing rockets from – the terrorist organization keeps using the civilian population in the manner.”

Beny   January 11th, 2009 8:26 am ET

Rod you blithering idiot,

You found one lousy article about how we supposedly "established Hamas", and went right on to bash Israel, completely ignorant of facts. More or less how you acted ever since you started posting here.

We did not support Hamas, let alone establish it. We refrained from going after them because we had bigger problems to deal with. To remind you, Arafat's days were marked with so many suicide bombings, I'm not sure there are enough virgins for all that. I myself luckily escaped two.

Compared to what the PLO were doing in their time, Hamas were kittens.

Dan,
I don't get it. You gave an address in New York, and then wondered why I think you are not "baaretz". So where do you live?

mahmoud jboor   January 11th, 2009 8:49 am ET

update mornining sunday:
total victems: 875
injuries :3700
idf fighters using yellow phosphoros weapons causing burns and doing strange symptom on human body ....also making harm to immune system .!!! they are fighting people defending their land !! and in the same time it look like they are testing leat hal effect !!! gazan are used for weopon expriments ...shame on israel &US administration !!!!!!!

miriam   January 11th, 2009 9:01 am ET

Of course more than half of Jordanians are Palestinian.

Jordan was also part of British Mandatory Palestine and it was with the establishment of the Mandate that the population started to be refered to as 'Palestinian'. Before that they were Arabs living in a province of Syria (not to be confused with modern day Syria) within the Ottoman Empire.

In 1948, when Jordan annexed and occupied the West Bank, the remaining part of Mandatory Palestine that could have become a Palestinian state became Jordan and ceased to exist as a seperate political entity.Therefore the increased sector of Jordanian society originated from the West Bank Arab population, minus the Jews who were transferred out.

miriam   January 11th, 2009 9:09 am ET

Mahmoud,

Israel fights following international laws applicable to war situations.

If phosphorous symptoms are found on victims they probably originated from the target where they were being stored.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 9:11 am ET

Harry Truman left the White House with a lower approval rating than George W Bush will. I see some people keep on quoting Truman. Wonder why, since most people thought that he was a useless sob?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 9:12 am ET

beny

natati et haktovet hayeshana sheli

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 9:14 am ET

Please see the link below. It will explain more of what Hamas's true intentions are. See especially Artical 13: Peaceful Solutions.
http://www.palestinecenter.org/cpap/documents/charter.html

Dr.T.Jayasinghe   January 11th, 2009 9:24 am ET

Sri Lankan air force using Israeli Kafir jet attack the terrorists without killing a single civilian.Israel supplied all the equipment and training to Sri Lanka. Why cant the Israeli air force avoid civilians while using much more advanced air crafts and equipments?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 9:25 am ET

jonas,

don't bother, I put the charter up many times already, no response so far from the israel bashers

mahmoud jboor   January 11th, 2009 9:44 am ET

Miriam......
tell me when israel obeyed international law ?!!!go watch TV reports &pictures and reports coming from International org.s !!!! to say phosphorous source from targets on the ground ....No way ..if this the case are we going to blame hamas for all the hell israeli bombardement ....be honost and fair ...crime is cristle clear !!!

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 9:59 am ET

Dan,
I have noticed that the Islamic terrorist lovers, murderers of millions of innocent men, woman and children, avoid proof of Islamic atrocities and double standards like the plague. I also notice that many non Muslims are talking to the extremist bigots about peace and harmony and that these murderers are appeasing them big time. Even going as far as calling them love, darling and other terms of endearment. It also seems as if some of these poor soles are actually lapping it up. Where I come from there is an old saying: "Beware of your Muslim extremist friend, his brother is a suicide bomber and won't mind blowing your family to pieces"

miriam   January 11th, 2009 10:06 am ET

The IDF is the army of a sovereign state who obeys international law.
She is fighting against a terrorist organization which obeys nobody but their terrorist leaders.

Most of the workers for the international organizations are local residents from all factions of Palestinian society, including Hamas. Even UNRWA admits that it employs Hamas members.

Most of the foreign workers in Gaza are there on a mission, not just to help Gazans, but to also encourage the demise of Israel. They admit it openly.

Don't tell us that the reports coming out of Gaza are honest and fair. Many are false and fabricated. How many people have you seen on camara complain about Hamas? If they are Fatah they have been murdered by Hamas (numbers in the 100s that are included in the total tally) otherwise they know the consequences.

Hamas is 100% to blame for Israel's actions.

Saudi   January 11th, 2009 10:19 am ET

miriam wrote " Hamas is 100% to blame for Israel’s actions.
"

You are an inclosed shelfish shell sealed tight with steel clamps containing only one thing inside of you " israel is right and everything else in the univers is wrong mworthless with no value at all! ".

Beny   January 11th, 2009 10:19 am ET

Mahmoud,

What you say of "phosphrous" and "illegal" brings me back to stupid ignorant accusations regarding the use of uranium and how we supposedly "poison" their land.

Yes. We do use phosphorous lighting bombs in our arsenal, and so does every army in the world, from Russia to Chile to Syria. These do not burn anyone simply because they do not reach the ground- they combust very quickly and luminiscently high above. Believe me, I know the chemistry of it.

What is banned under international law is shooting such phosphrous on people. That NO-ONE does. We don't. US doesn't. NO ONE does. Maybe Hamas would, if they had such bombs.

After all, they have no qualms about suicide vests in tightly packed buses.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 10:22 am ET

The True Story?
My neighbor hates me, he is not really sure why he hates me, but he thinks it has something to do with religion, and after all, his people has hated my people for thousands of years. His people also convince him that he should kill me and all my people, and that it should be his only mission in life. And don’t worry, they say, that if he killed me, and got killed in the process, he would get a great reception in heaven.
He starts sending his people over to my house to try and kill me. Sometimes I catch them but sometimes they manage to kill some of my people. I then decide that I would build a wall around his property to keep his killers away from my property and people. But, nice guy that I am, I decide that I will let some of his less murderous people come over to my house to work and earn some money. I allow some of his people to come to my school and university. I also supply him with medical equipment, electricity, food, etc… All this, in spite of the fact that he is still telling everyone that he wants to wipe me and my people from the face of the earth.
But my murderous neighbor is ungrateful. He builds tunnels to abduct my people and to smuggle in rockets. He steals the food and medical equipment that I send to his people and distributes it only to his cronies. He takes the money, given to him by people from all over the world to build schools, hospitals and roads for his people, and spends it on guns and rockets.
My neighbor, in his endless wisdom, then decides to fire the smuggled rockets over the wall onto my property, hoping to really piss me off and perhaps kill some of my people. I ask him nicely to stop firing the rockets as this action will certainly make me angry. I even ask some of his family members to speak to him and warn him of the consequences of his actions. But he doesn’t listen and carries on firing the rockets.
After eight years of constant bombardment, my people are tired of living in shelters and they ask me to do something about our neighbor who is obviously out to kill and maim them. By this time I am really angry. I tell him that I have an army, navy and air force and that if he didn’t stop the rockets I was going to let him have it! But my neighbor, flush with false bravado and drunk with visions of greatness decides that his God will surely give him victory over me and my people.
He decides that he has succeeded in making me angry and tells his cronies to increase the number of rockets that they are firing over the wall, just to rub it in. By this time I decide to call my air force in and to take out his rocket jockeys. We manage to send many of them to the great firing range in the sky where they are each given 72 unfired rockets. However, some rocket jockeys hide in holes, behind their mothers and some even book into a 5-star hotel in Damascus. Some rocket jockeys, however, continue to lob rockets onto my property. I again warn my neighbor that if he doesn’t stop, I will send in my army. My neighbor again ignores me and tells the rocket jockeys that they must aim better, hit a school full of godless children, and they must use the new rockets that they were given by their friends from that great, nuclear armed, Islamic republic.
He calls all his mighty warriors together and tells them
“Brave warriors, I have a cunning plan. Go find as many woman and children as possible, take them to schools, hospitals and other public buildings, herd them together, then hide under the women’s burqas, but don’t let any impure thoughts cross your mind! Wait until the children can see the godless IDF arrive, they must jump up and down and shout “Kill the infidel!” You must then jump out from underneath the women’s burqas, if you aren’t stuck, shout at the top of your voices “Allāhu Akbar”, shoot your guns wildly in the general direction of the IDF and run away. Be sure to leave the woman and children behind. The godless IDF will then blow up the building, killing the women and children. Get the children to play on the roof tops, in the middle of the war zone, with helicopter gunships in the air. The gunships, looking for our brave snipers, will mistake the children for snipers, shoot missiles and kill the children. With some luck, our booby traps will explode and kill many women and children. Our western trained reporters will immediately make gruesome videos of the dead and dying women and children, of crying fathers and brothers, and send these videos to the gullible media. Before you can say “Jesus is dead” the videos will appear on CNN, BBC, Sky and Al Jazeera. They will, without our help, find a Muslim extremist brother to deliver his rhetoric with the videos. The result will be great for us as every gullible, Arab, bleeding-heart liberal; housewife and anti-Semite will believe our trick and will immediately phone all the useless politicians all over the world. The useless politicians will run to New York, shout at how awful the murderous Israelis are, beat their breasts, make plans, draw up resolutions, and then go home to sip Johnny Walker Blue Label, paid for by the tax payers. It will be a major publicity coup for us, the Islamic terrorist network. We will look like angels, and people will forget about the millions of innocent people our esteemed network has murdered in India, Pakistan, Bali, Thailand, Indonesia, USA, UK, Spain, Darfur, Nigeria, Morocco, Egypt, Afghanistan, Iraq, Israel, Palestine and others. Go forth, brave warriors, let our cunning plan start!”
I decide that enough is enough, and send in my army.
My neighbor’s cunning plan is working very well. He is still firing his rockets over the wall; his brave warriors are still hiding under the women’s burqas and allowing women and children to get killed. Every useless politician has been to New York and back and is sipping JWBL, paid for by tax payers. Everyone is shouting at how awful the Israelis are and the murderous Islamic terrorists look like angels.
Yes, the truth is sometimes stranger than fiction!

Beny   January 11th, 2009 10:27 am ET

And before you want to bring Israel before the Hague for "crimes against humanity" (I'm sure our existence is a terrible crime, but I'm not going to let anyone punish me for it), how about bringing Hamas to trial for massive violations of Children's Right's?

mahmoud jboor   January 11th, 2009 10:37 am ET

you are launching another war on the net !! be honest and fair.......///
i am refering to reports pub. by Human rights watch........
let israel accept international media to go inside gaza......
updates: innocent victem numbers rise with clock : now 879 murdered by cawored israeli + the aid from US..!!!!!!!!

mahmoud jboor   January 11th, 2009 10:54 am ET

Beny....... i am telling you the continious announcments declared by doctors in al shifaa hosp. examining the bodies of children...i see my self these spots in their bodies as if they are hit by guns....you can see circules of burns......

Professor   January 11th, 2009 11:06 am ET

Jonas,

Lies lies lies.... its not your neighbor who hates you becsause of religion.....

Its the occupied who hates their brutal bloodthirsty occupier.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 11:09 am ET

Its the occupation stupid...

Professor   January 11th, 2009 11:13 am ET

The war criminal currpt politician Olmert is saying that they are closs to completing their mission....

What mission? are they waiting to kill 1000 innocent unarmed civilian Palestinian children, women and elderly?

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 11:21 am ET

Professor
You must be naive or just plain stupid. If the Israelis wanted to target civilians, the IAF could level Gaza City and kill 100,000 people in one day. Do you really think that if they were deliberately targeting civilians that there would be anything left of Palestine? What could Israel possibly gain from killing UN truck drivers? If they wanted to kill truck drivers they would send a couple of helicopter gunships and blast the whole convoy to kingdom come. If they wanted to target schools, why not use one 1000 pound precision guided bomb and leave a crater where the school used to be. I have never seen such a controlled war in all my life! Every John Doe, and his dog, is shouting war rules at the Israelis. For every Palestinian killed, someone is demanding an independent investigation. Disproportionate response! What absolute media sponsored rubbish? It's the war stupid!!

miriam   January 11th, 2009 11:25 am ET

Mahmoud,

Can you also see whose bullets are inside the poor child's body?

Do the red circles say, "from Israel with love"?

Perhaps they haven't made up that story yet.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 11:31 am ET

Jonas,

What you wrote only prove your naivety and stupidity.

Its the Occupation stupid.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 11:34 am ET

Professor?
No, Professor? It seems that it is you stupid!

miriam   January 11th, 2009 11:34 am ET

Prof,

There was no 'occupation' in 1948.

blood is red   January 11th, 2009 11:35 am ET

Enough with the excuses!
Israelis never wish for, or permitted a self-governing Palestine because when that happened, not any valid excuse for the JEWS to control them! Or stop them breeding.
Palestinian extremist don’t want peace or democratic state, because if people are free to choose then the fanatics be beaten. Fear is always a better tool to control people minds.
Arabs rulers from undemocratic and never elected governments, use the Palestinians to implemented their politics and help the religious fanatics.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 11:36 am ET

Jonas,

Is Hamas a ligitimate government democratically elected with an organized Army or is it a group of terrorist?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 11:36 am ET

CNN/NYr:PENTAGON CAN STRIKE IRAN W/IN 24HR OF bUSH ORDER-WAR
uk.youtube.com/watch?v=nw_okL8PpX0

World war III has begun!
uk.youtube.com/watch?v=mc4Am0feY74

Putin to Bush: "Hands Off Iran"
uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-q3OEqrQ244

Who should ATTACK Iran? Israel or the U.S.? WHAT THE ....?
uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-LZeLNEd6EQ

kick out Clinton because of a blow-job

and keep bush because he will start war where ever he can!!!!!!!!!
keep israel away from the list of terror organisations because they only wanna messup with the whole world whyle we all know they gain nothing!!!!!!!!!!!

USA USA USA USA USA
Israel Isael Israel Israel

USA and israel is so smart!!!!!
what a jocke you do of yourself ????????

God save russia ... they keep minimal peace with a optional nu-clear strike against US and EU

how stupid are we ?
better a nu-clear blow-job by bush then a levinscy blow-job by clinton
god save ya all

mahmoud jboor   January 11th, 2009 11:42 am ET

miriam : there is no use chatting with you ....You are BLINDE..you cannot see and understand but those crazy , stupid murderers ...so i will continue my comments for the sake of informing normal american citizins, not the solderes enjoying crime and holocaust...!!!!!!

miriam   January 11th, 2009 11:48 am ET

Blood is red says Israel never permitted self-government for the Palestinians.

Prof says that Hamas is the legitimate, democratically elected government.

Which is it guys?

What I see is a terrorist organization who the majority of Gazans voted into power, and who consequently destroyed Gazan society, slaughtered the opposition and turned every home into a weapons store and tunnel terminal.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 11:49 am ET

Miriam,

you are so stupid you cannot even read....

I was posing a question....

miriam   January 11th, 2009 11:56 am ET

Mahmoud,

I'm not blind. I can see very clearly.
I can see the truth and I can see the lies.
I don't believe everything on TV etc because I come from a society that has learnt to critically analyse. Not a society that follows the indoctrination that is called education and believes the disinformation that is in fact propoganda.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 11:58 am ET

Critically analyse?

Well, analyse this stupid.

miriam   January 11th, 2009 11:58 am ET

Prof,

A rhetorical question.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 12:00 pm ET

i guess miriam is the same as linda :))
so well educated

i cant beleve she was in school :))

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:01 pm ET

I was not asking a rhetorical question.... see how stupid you are?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:05 pm ET

Akiva,

yes miriam went to school... (IOF) Kindergarten.

Ronnie   January 11th, 2009 12:07 pm ET

As a human,it is confusing to see US supporting Israel's attack and asked India not to attack Pakistan after giving all evidence about the mumbai attack. I think Russia attacked its neighboring country,showing almost same reasons like Israel.(Harboring and supporting terrorism movement against Russia)and I think Russia was wrong and also US and other major countries too. If we don't support Palestinians freedom movement, how we can support Tibet people. I am not supporting Hamas rocket attacks on Israel soil but as per Jimmy Carter, Hamas was ready to stop firing rockets if Israel allow food and other supplies to Gaza. But Israel said "no" to 100% quota because it will strength Hamas. So they told Hamas they will allow a small percentage.(as per CNN interview) If Jimmy Carter's words are true, if shameful for the world to support Israel.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 12:13 pm ET

Professor?
Is it a trick question? I actually don't rate Hamas at all. However, if the people of Gaza elected Hamas, without intimidation, as their government, then they are brainless. If they knew that the people whom they elected were stupid enough to fire rockets at their neighbor, who has the 5th largest army in the world, then they are brainless. If they knew that the people whom they elected were going to get them killed, then they are brainless. If they elected a government whose charter states that they don't believe in peace talks and that Jihad is the only way, then they are brainless. Does it really matter if Hamas was elected democratically or not? But, I don’t think the people of Palestine knew what they were letting themselves in for when they elected Hamas, or the election was rigged. I also don’t think that the people of Palestine will elect Hamas again, especially after Hamas murdered the Fatah members!

miriam   January 11th, 2009 12:13 pm ET

Prof,

It's people like you who claim Israel is blood-thirsty, aiming to kill civilians and believe all the propaganda out there, who also believe that Hamas is the legitimate, democratically elected government in Gaza.

If you believe then, that Hamas is a terrorist organization why don't you condemn their methods and support the effort to rid southern Israel and Gaza of their reign of terror.

If you believe that the problem is the occupation why did the Arabs initiate the war in 1967 before there was what is known as 'the occupation' even though Egypt and Jordan were already occupying those regions?

Why did the Arabs reject the 1947 UN Partition Plan and prefer to destroy Israel?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 12:16 pm ET

CNN what is wrong with you?
are we stupid?

your journalist girl at the israelian side talk about the poor traumatisiced israelians
traumatisized by rockets from hamas

whats about the gazans ?
traumatisized by the israelian food embargo?

do you think we all did visit US schools?
so you think bush did drive down the education system of the whole world?

how stupid are we???????????

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:21 pm ET

Miriam,

No not really it what the Israeli hostory shows....

Stop your critical analysis please because only garbage is coming out...

The UN has no right according to its charter to:

1. Create a religious based State (Jewish only)

2. Give someone's land to someone else.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 12:24 pm ET

mahmoud jboor,
It's very rich for any Arab to refer to the holocaust seeing that the Arab nations were amongst Hitler's greatest supporters. Perhaps you and some of your brothers will miss out on the 72 virgins in heaven and be lucky enough to land up with your hero adolf in hell. perhaps you and Akiva, who seems to be obsessed with bj's, can share a bj in hell!

Professor   January 11th, 2009 12:31 pm ET

Akiva,

Everytime I want to give the Jews the benefit of the doubt and say that all the old sterotypes given to them can't be all true but they always prove me wrong. Liars liars liars.... expect the good few I know similar to AJ who can stand up prowdly and criticise the wrong doing of A zionist racist Israel.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 12:35 pm ET

Professor?
Why don't you answer any of the questions that many people have been asking you for days now? Why don't you stop telling lies as we have caught you many times? You have made many statements and have been asked many times to prove it and the best you have ever come up with is some video from YouTube. You are an imbecile! The answer to your question is clearly stated in my reply.

harvey   January 11th, 2009 12:36 pm ET

Just heard from a mate of mine who attended the rally in support of Israel in Trafalguar Sq.
Tens of thousands turned up.
Peaceful rally.
No flags burnt, nothing hurled at the police.
No policemen scuffled with, knocked senseless. No shop windows smashed.
People made their point. Discussed the issues and didn'tspew poisonous hatred...
Well done UK....makes me proud of my English Heritage and come on Tottenham (AKA the Yid Army).
Y

harvey   January 11th, 2009 12:41 pm ET

Clayton...please more argument and less abuse dear boy...you do your cause no favours with your prolific obscenities...

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 12:43 pm ET

miriam

do you talk about how you can see lies?
do you talk about how you analyse information?

are you jocking to us ?

shall we laugh now about you?

clayton   January 11th, 2009 12:44 pm ET

HA HA HA harvey, U ARE A PIG's ASSHOEL

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 12:45 pm ET

update
a little girl has lost two legs and a small boy is blind. Frankly, i have never seen a war like this. are israelis human beings like us? answer me, please because i dont get anymore.

harvey   January 11th, 2009 12:45 pm ET

Clayton,

Have a valium. Calm down. Realise this is an emotive subject. But all these expletives...not good for your blood pressure. Make a sensible coherent point. This is supposed to be a discussion....

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 12:48 pm ET

where is this free world eveybody promotes? where is it? A SAVAGE WAR THAT HAS NO PRECEDENT AND THE DEMOCRATIC FREE SOCIETIES ARE WATCHING. IS THIS DEMOCRACY? LIBERTY? FRATERNITy?

tarig   January 11th, 2009 12:48 pm ET

The True Story?
My neighbor hates me, he is not really sure why he hates me, but he thinks it has something to do with religion, and after all, his people has hated my people for thousands of years.

yet again another person proving his ignorance. in a time where the entire world greeted jews with distain the only race of people that welcomed them, that allowed them control of all religious locations and gave them complete freedom of religious expression were muslims after the ousting of romans in jeruselem (if you dont believe me look it up although i doubt you will, your ro busy listenin to what others make up and talking crap that has no basis). you want to know why arabs hate you, its because the jewish state doesnt respect our religious rights, you make every attempt to bring down one of the holiest locations for muslims world wide, you deny us access to it, and then you expect us to be happy with it.

You must be naive or just plain stupid. If the Israelis wanted to target civilians, the IAF could level Gaza City and kill 100,000 people in one day. Do you really think that if they were deliberately targeting civilians that there would be anything left of Palestine?

jonas

and face an uprising of 1.5billion people. there are other ways to kill a society, like turning their land into the largest open air prison.

have noticed that the Islamic terrorist lovers, murderers of millions of innocent men, woman and children, avoid proof of Islamic atrocities and double standards like the plague.

again jonas (sorry mate dont mean to attack you and if you look at my other posts you will see am not defending hamas)

where is the double standard here. american policies towards iraq resulted in the death of more than half a million people, is that not a terrorist act? the bombing of a pharmaceutical factory in sudan lead to the deaths of over a million people in the years that followed, is that not a terrorist act? why do you avoid mentioning these amongst others (look at what happened in nicaragua, chile, haiti the list is almost endless, why is it that when its carried out by westerners its not classed as a terrorist act?)

killing women and children is wrong, i wont call it a terrorist act because one mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter (george washington was a terrorist in his time). but what almost everyone on this blog is doing is wrong, if a comment isn't anti-semetic its islamaphobic (although muslims dont seem to be as sensitive and dont question the level of racism in some remarks). jonas you yourself say "proof of Islamic atrocities", i am a muslim, is what i am saying in anyway advocating terrorism? why classify an entire religion because of what a certain few do? islam is a religion that most muslims today dont understand (which is a pitty) and if they do rarely follow (including myself, although in my case as in many its liquor not murder). you want to question the action of so called terrorist groups, i request that in the future you refer to them by the name they call themselves, and not the broad classification of islam, its an insult to the rest of us. as i have said over and over, people should stop taking sides, it solves nothing everyone is wrong, its war, both sides have commited atrocities, probably on purpose, but saying one is right and the other is wrong is ignorant. the greater aggressor can be in no doubt to anyone, but no one here seems to want to know the truth, you all seem to be happier listenin to what is said by your peers and accepting it as fact. try educating yourselves on the history of the region, on western policies towards the arab world, on the true nature of islam (and judaism and christianity for that matter) not what some racist wants the world to think about it. then and only then will any of you have the right to question what is happening in this region. all of you should stop insighting hate, its not going to help it will only make things worse (proffessor and miriam im talking to you aswell – the world belongs to us all and only when we realize this can there ever be any chance of peace and prosperity). miriam you say your not indoctinated by society, well i am sorry love but you are, your taught to hate the rest and look after your own, its clear in your comments. i am sorry but that is the worst form of indoctrination. and clearly you do listen to the news because you are just repeating what isreali media says (and i am yet to see substantial proof of this – dont mention repeat explosions after a bombing, anyone with half a mind knows that when a building is bombed more than one is dropped on it). everybody in this world needs to wake the F up, your all pawns taking this world to disaster and none of you realize it. if you dont believe me just look at this blog, its not about religion or race anymore, its just one side against the other, the world is splitting in two and if it keeps going this way WW3 wont be nation against nation, it will be brother against brother. education is the key, not what you learn in school but what you teach yourselves!!! sorry for blagging on, i just had a lot i wanted to say.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 12:51 pm ET

CLAYTON
harvey is afull time blogger; he does not sleep. this is a full time job for him. he is paid by the criminal band of israel . you are just waiting your time with him. he is here because israelis want him to be here.

harvey   January 11th, 2009 12:52 pm ET

Gosh, Clayton, you're scraping the academic barrel a little bit here. Can't say I'm blown away by your witty reposte. Which part of your brilliant, academic argument am I supposed to be impressed with?

Just a gentle hint. Try using spell check before you submit your comment. Might help you with your spelling. I think there's no hope for the grammar, dear boy. I'll limit myself to one correction. Don't want to bore everyone.

By the way you spell HOLE thus.
See if you get it right next time....

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 12:53 pm ET

harvey
how much money do they give you, you and linda and the bunch of liers?

harvey   January 11th, 2009 12:54 pm ET

Clayton!!!!
By Jove he got it.
In his comment to Akiva full of his normal academic gravitas he spelt HOLE correctly. Well done or Mazel Tov as we Jews say. Let the bells ring out!

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 12:55 pm ET

professor
you what they told me yesterday (and harvey was there too).they told me : we colonised yoiu in 1967. this is the dynamic of history; go and look for another country. you see their logic. isnt that pathetic?

harvey   January 11th, 2009 12:56 pm ET

Mohammed,

I'm so ridiculously wealthy, I do this as a mere past time...

miriam   January 11th, 2009 12:58 pm ET

Mohammed,

Israeli children have been losing limbs and suffering horrific injuries for years as a result of rocket attacks. Why do you think Israel's responding?

I suppose the news channels you watch never showed that.

Prof,

In 1948, every other religion had a state of it's own. The Jews had been annihilated and thrown out of country after country for generations. The decision to create a Jewish state was made long before the European Holocaust.

It made sense to most of the international community, excluding the Arabs, that the Holy Land was the logical location for obvious reasons that only racist, anti-Jewish bigots didn't agree with.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 12:58 pm ET

jews have always been problematic to humanity and its high time we found an exceptional solution. the situation , with the degree of the atrocities, has become unbearable.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:01 pm ET

miriam
we arabs and muslims can no more tolerazte what you do to our brothers and sisters in palestine. be sure that we have entered a new era in this long conflict and that what is coming wil be either you or us insha llah.

Fawad Ali   January 11th, 2009 1:01 pm ET

Akiva U R an Israeli ASS

Professor   January 11th, 2009 1:02 pm ET

Miriam,

A new lie... as if you were living in 1948 and we were not....

Go ahead and list for me each religion and the country please....

Fawad Ali   January 11th, 2009 1:02 pm ET

Guys stop dirty talk

miriam   January 11th, 2009 1:03 pm ET

Mohammed,

I hear an open call for genocide.

Prof,

Rabbis never said that. It is the Moslem Imam's interpretation of the Koran's description of the Jews.

Fawad Ali   January 11th, 2009 1:04 pm ET

There are good Israelis and bad Israelis just as good and bad arabs, unfortunately currently Israel is under Bad Israelis control

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:04 pm ET

people were right about you throughout history. nobody ha sliked you. you have become acceptable only when you formed your lobby in the US. nOW THE US is falling down; who will support you? i will the first to take your intestins out of your bodies, prophets killers.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 1:05 pm ET

Hi Akiva, Prof. Ya'll are up early.

To the rest of you, whom I haven't met yet, good morning!

A definition of terrorism is the systematic use of terror. Just what is terror? According to the Meriam-Webster dictionary (and I am going to use the old c/p here:

ter·ror
Pronunciation: \ˈter-ər, ˈte-rər\
Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English, from Anglo-French terrour, from Latin terror, from terrēre to frighten; akin to Greek trein to be afraid, flee, tremein to tremble — more at tremble
Date: 14th century
1: a state of intense fear
2 a: one that inspires fear : scourge b: a frightening aspect c: a cause of anxiety : worry d: an appalling person or thing ; especially : brat
3: reign of terror
4: violent or destructive acts (as bombing) committed by groups in order to intimidate a population or government into granting their demands
synonyms see fear

OK, so a terrorist is something or somebody acting with the purpose of causing an intense state of fear in another person, group, gov't, etc.

I have not found a universal definition of terrorism that has been agreed on by everybody, although most definitions of terrorism include the commonalities of acts intended to create fear, perpetrated for an idealogical goal, and disregard and/or target non-combatants. Aspects of terrorism include violence, psychological "warfare", deliberate targeting of non-combatants, disguise (such as blending in with the ordinary populace), and unlawfulness. In 1988, the US Army found over 100 definitions of terrorism, and found that the concept was controversial because some gov'ts use the definition to delegitimize political opponents, resulting in state-sanctioned terrorism.

I believe that the definition of terrorism depends on the person or group's interpretation of the word. I don't think that one can understand terrorism until they have "walked the mile in the other's shoes". Yes, it's terrorism to the Israelis, because the suicide bombings, rocket lobbing, kidnapping, and explicit expression and commitment to the destruction of Israel causes fear in the Israeli population. Yes, it's terrorism to the Palestinians, not knowing when the shooting between Hamas and the IDF will start and the bombs will fall, the state-sanctioned assassinations, the restriction of movement, not knowing when your home is going to be declared illegal and bulldozed, when you will be arrested because you talked to someone in passing in the street and are now considered a terrorist. It's terrorism when you are deprived of food and medical assistance, no matter whose "fault" is causing the situation (and there's enough blame to go around!)

See what I'm getting at? It's hard to open communication lines and change opinion when you are terrified.

So I suggest that we all be a little nicer to each other, less insulting, and try to understand differing viewpoints.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 1:05 pm ET

Akiva,
It's strange that so many Arabs send their children to schools in the USA and UK. Why? Is it maybe because the standard of education is higher in the west? Is it perhaps because their children, especially girls, have more choices in the west? I have an idea that the western countries would prefer it if you kept your kids at home. Why do so many Arabs live in the west? Perhaps freedom has something to do with it. I think GWB went to the Hamas School of Arab Logic.

Fawad Ali   January 11th, 2009 1:06 pm ET

Akiva,

please watch CNN USA, CNNI is different
dont blame entire CNN

But I think CNNI is free and unbiased

Professor   January 11th, 2009 1:08 pm ET

Miriam,

I attended lecturs in Jewish synagogues myself and heard it in my own ears... so don't what they say and what they do not say.

harvey   January 11th, 2009 1:09 pm ET

I am agog and aghast at the amazing, blinding display of rhetoric emanating from Clayton. Trying to combat such a dazzling display of debating skills is indeed an exercise in futility...

I think Bhorat (and by the way Clayton he is an imaginary character played by Sasha Baron Cohen another nice Jewish boy) does better arguing for Khazakstan than you do for whatever you are trying to argue for...

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:09 pm ET

if we ar emonkeys, then, they are what?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 1:10 pm ET

Fawad Ali

CNN international all the time is at the side of israel!!!!!!!
CNN international allways say us what israelians are telling them!!!!!!

this while Arab journalist are in Gaza !

but the smart CNN cant find a way to put theyr journalist into Gaza
if they bring something out of Gaza its from Arab chanels

it smells !!!!!!!!!!!!

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 1:11 pm ET

Fawad Ali

do you think CNN is free?????
are you a american?????????????
... i hope you were a bit ironic :D

Professor   January 11th, 2009 1:12 pm ET

Hello Lynne,

its good you started with the definition of Terror...

Terror as you identified it can be by a group of individuals or by a State. right?

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:13 pm ET

jonas
you talk about the west as if israel ie part of the west. let me tell you this: israel is part of neither the west, nor the east. it is not classified within any human category . watch the news and judge by yourself.

clayton   January 11th, 2009 1:14 pm ET

Professor terror=======60 years of existence of Israel

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 1:15 pm ET

CNN

why you give fascists a media platform
such as this guy who talk about "hamastan"
CNN
the international world map calls this place Gaza!!!!!!!!!!

keep such fools at home !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:17 pm ET

miriam
of course yes i call explicitely for your extermination.

miriam   January 11th, 2009 1:18 pm ET

Prof,

Jews and Arabs lived in the land in 1948.

You obviously didn't understand the Rabbi's lecture or you are telling one big lie.

Fawad Ali   January 11th, 2009 1:18 pm ET

Akiva,

I appreciate, but unfortunately we got some dirty mouths here, just try to ignore them........I am just talking about CNN, in western media, CNN coverage is really good compare to others.

But I am really disappointed you don't see that way

harvey   January 11th, 2009 1:19 pm ET

Mohammed,

Delighted t hear that you are attending lectures with us Jews at Jewish synagogues. Did you engage in debate? Did you bravely stand up and preach your views of tolerance and understanding? Your vision of humanity creating a better world and celebrating diversity of cultures?

Pray do tell more? I'm sitting on the edge of my seat waiting for the saga of "Mohammed goes to Synagogue" to unfold.

Which synagogues exactly and where....?
Forgive my doubting you, but every time you have been asked to substantiate any of your rhetoric with hard evidence, you aren't able to.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:19 pm ET

you saw the definition of terrorism. we are in jewish classroom. lol

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 1:22 pm ET

"jews have always been problematic to humanity and its high time we found an exceptional solution."

straight from Mein Kampf by Adolf Schickegruber Hitler

now we know what you think and you dare denying that you are a full blown antisemite?

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:22 pm ET

harvey
you are wrong. i did not mention any synaguogue now. check what you say. you have been awake for so long. go and sleep harvey. we were talking yesterday. i slept and you arer still awake. this sis bad for your health old man.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 1:24 pm ET

Miriam,

What?.... your comment does not make any sense....

What do you understand from a comment such "Arabs are subhumans"?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 1:24 pm ET

akiva

yeah, the hamas terrorists build grad rockets by themselves, they did no get them from iran, right??

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 1:24 pm ET

Prof,

I think that "terrorism" is anything that anyone or any group does that creates a state of intense fear and anxiety in another person or group. We sit here, relatively safe (well, perhaps not from Big Brother), accusing. What do we know ... we are well-fed, have access to necessities despite the economic situation, can come and go as we please, etc. There are no bombs going off.

Yes, terrorists can be a group - examples include Hamas, Jewsish settlers attacking Palestinian farmers, Palestinians attacking Jews. Yes, terrorists can be a country - examples are extrajudical killings, depriving one person of basic human rights – the numero uno right in my book is safety (ex. Zimbabwe). It depends on the person feeling "terrorized".

I think the key to solving terrorism is understanding what it is that is causing the fear. Then we, not as countries, religious groups, political arms, etc., but as humans, must work together so that none of us feels afraid.

Fawad Ali   January 11th, 2009 1:25 pm ET

Akiva,

'patience', World will see good side of the US under next admin

hopefully, support to Israel will be cut down,

and Iran will no longer be the beneficiary of the mistakes in the middle east

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 1:25 pm ET

Fawad Ali
what you see at CNN USA ... i only get CNN international
and here its total propagande

they try to force a war against Iran now
to hide about the genocide by israel!!!!!!!

and what they let talk fascists as this wallstreet-boy Brett Stevens at the international CNN?
he call gaza "hamastan"
even the israelians dont do so and still speack about Gaza

CNN take this fascist offf!!!!!!!!!

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 1:26 pm ET

"miriam
of course yes i call explicitely for your extermination"

q.e.d.

antisemite!!!

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 1:27 pm ET

dan perman
israel is not terrorist because they get rocketa and more from USA???
are you kidding?

harvey   January 11th, 2009 1:30 pm ET

Dan,

I'm going to leave Mohammed the tolerant, Akiva the understanding, Clayton the obbjective and all their disciples to you now.

Send me an e mail if any of them mangage to make a valid argument. In fact just send me an e mail if they're spelling improves.

Am off with my kids to pack some parcels for the folks being rocketed in Sderot.

Meanwhile Shalom to you all (including the the afore mentioned peace loving gang).

harvey   January 11th, 2009 1:31 pm ET

Dan,

I'm going to leave Mohammed the tolerant, Akiva the understanding, Clayton the obbective and all their disciples to you now.

Have total faith in your ability to manage 'em.

Send me an e mail if any of them mangage to make a valid argument. In fact just send me an e mail if they're spelling improves.

Am off with my kids to pack some parcels for the folks being rocketed in Sderot. Tell Mohammed I'm off to count my millions!

Meanwhile Shalom to you all (including the the afore mentioned peace loving gang).

Professor   January 11th, 2009 1:31 pm ET

Lynne,

So, can you call all people in the history of the world who fought against an occupation that ended in getting their indepence and removing the occupation acts of terrorism?

I do not want to start lising all the heros in the histroy that led resistance to occupation.... are they all terrorist?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 1:32 pm ET

akiva

answer the question instead of evading it, as usual

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 1:32 pm ET

CNN
what is this guy giles kepel talking about "niggers" ???
you bring up the next fascist?
CNN are you doing nazi propaganda ... where did you find this guy ???
in the KKK????

are you crazy????

harvey   January 11th, 2009 1:35 pm ET

Oh by the way Mohammed there is a deliberate grammar mistake in my last message. Spot it and I'll be very impressed. It will give you something else to think about apart from your vile prejudices and hatred.

Farewell and well done again all those tens of thousands who demonsrtrated peacefully in Trafalguar Square in London in support of Israel.

Got to run...

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 1:35 pm ET

dan perman
proofe me that hamas get rokets by iran when you are talking about that as a fact!
and dont let me bring official numbers of what USA is supporting israel with weapons and money !!!

that we have proofed later

mackawee   January 11th, 2009 1:38 pm ET

There is huge loss among childeren. Hamas fighters are among the population in Gaza. Why does Israel uses the air force. Why dosen't it send the troops into Gaza and fight one to one. Surely there will be less loss among civilience.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 1:38 pm ET

CNN sorry about giles kepel

the seems to be right ... was very objective
maybe ha has choosen some wrong words when he wqas talking about "nigers"
but the rest was very objective :D

gratulation :D

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:39 pm ET

dan
you are again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:43 pm ET

harvey
they’re spelling improves. is this good spelling? HAAAHAAA

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 1:44 pm ET

Prof,

To the power that were getting kicked out, yes. They did not want to lose power, and that created fear. But on the other hand, history is country/country or recognized state/state. It has been acknowledged on the boards and by the world that Palestine is neither a county nor a state, so what is the land of Palestine called? They have an elected government, but no world-recognized name.

Following the same, since there is no world-recognized country of Palestine, and (according to some Zionist views) the land occupied by the Palestinians rightly belongs to Israel, a case could be made as action designed to protect the public, with the benefit of getting rid of political opponents with a little bit of good old-fashioned ethnic cleansing thrown in.

One can use history and loosely worded definitions of terrorism to make a pretty good case for either side.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:48 pm ET

HARVEY
Another mistake:
Farewell and well done again all those tens of thousands who demonsrtrated peacefully in Trafalguar Square in London in support of Israel.

a run-on sentence.This is what we call a basic sentence fault.
By the way , we may make mistakes, not errors, because of the pressure of communication. However, I think you do not evn make a difference between a mistake and an error. If you happen to do , can you define what is a mistake and what is an error.

mackawee   January 11th, 2009 1:48 pm ET

Israeli investigation said that the attack on UN school was by mistake????

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 1:48 pm ET

akiva

answer the question, who could have given hamas grad rockets (if you know what grads are)

tarig   January 11th, 2009 1:49 pm ET

poor souls, all of you, unwilling to come to common terms for a greater good and more determined to point blame and make racist comments (except for lynne, good on you love, i wish there were more people like you in the world, an educated soul not indoctrinated by the views of those around you, but instead able to form your own based on what you have learnt). i am now certain that WW3 is coming, and you know what everyone in this blog is on the side of evil except for lynne (yes the aethiests, the jews and the muslims). your all racist fools who need a good kicking.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:52 pm ET

Harvey
Another error:

Oh by the way Mohammed there is a deliberate grammar mistake in my last message. Spot it and I’ll be very impressed. It will give you something else to think about apart from your vile prejudices and hatred.

The correct form:
Oh! by the way, Mohammed, there is a deliberate grammar mistake in my last message. Spot it and I will be very impressed. It will give you something else to think about apart from your vile prejudices and hatred.
1- put terms of address between commas.
2- i'll belongs to spoken discourse.

haaaaaaaaaaahhhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhaaa

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 1:52 pm ET

Mackawee,

The Israelis said that the shells that fell on the UN school were meant for a target 30 yards away. Toward the end of the article.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090111/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_israel_palestinians

Professor   January 11th, 2009 1:54 pm ET

I want everyone to read Lynne latest comment....

Lynne,

stop playing with the words.... country... not country....

The fact is the fact A piece of land known as Palestine since the ancient history with people on it called Palestinians being occupied by a Israel. So, we have an occupier and an occupied.... we have a State Army the occupier using heavy weapons against the occupied and a small number of the occupied using primitive weapon to resist the occupation.... so we have Israeli terrorist State against future heros.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:55 pm ET

i think that we should fill these blogs more. As you see, israelis are everywhere spreading lies and defending theundefendable. Try to spread the word among people that you know. We have a just cause and we have to defend it and show to the world the ugly face of israel, the rapist.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 1:57 pm ET

tarig

WWI3 was begun years ago ny muslim terrorists, culminating in 9/11, Bali, Mumbai (where the bodies of the rabbi and his wife were severely mutilated by those heroes)

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 1:58 pm ET

lynne
do you want us what infants' killers say or what? Do you believe criminals in your ordinary life?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 1:59 pm ET

so where do the gards come from?

anyone?

icecream for the first with the correct answer (hint: not from lichtenstein)

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 2:01 pm ET

Prof,

As you see, it's all a matter of interpretation on both history and semantics. And a question of domination, since we as humans have not evolved past the concept of domination.

Things are never B&W, only shades of gray.

tarig   January 11th, 2009 2:03 pm ET

please dan for my sake, i have not refered to isrealis as terrorist because i dont believe in pointing the figer of blame, i am a muslim i request that you dont insult me and place muslims in the broad category of terroists (read my earlier post). as for 9/11 any right minded person could see the it is against the laws of physics for a building to free fall like that unless the core was destroyed. the official explanation is the heat melted the core from the top down – funny the first thing i learnt in physics class is that heat rises. bali and mumbai were evil acts i agree, but both sides are doing the same, the only way this will end is if we as humanbeings stand against ALL acts of evil, again refer to my earlier blog for some examples. pointing the finger will not work.

mackawee   January 11th, 2009 2:05 pm ET

lynne, 30 meters. whoops. That makes all the innocent death a legitimt military target. Will you inform me about the distences inwhich civelience can find a safe shelter inside Gaza.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:05 pm ET

tarig

nothing is further from my mind than insulting you
i just pointed out the fact that these, and other acts of terror, were carried out by muslims and that terror is WW3

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 2:06 pm ET

Mohammad,

I'm quite sure I do not understand you

"do you want us what infants’ killers say or what?"

As far as criminals - the US makes liberal use of the insanity plea. What to believe? I believe in fairness and equal opportunity. If you deliberately target people you don't know, who have not done anything to you, the targeting is a criminal act. Period.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:07 pm ET

mackawee

any place in gaza from which no rockets are being shot

you tell them which places these are, will you?

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 2:07 pm ET

Tarig,
I don't support the war in Iraq and I don't like George Bush. I also never attack moderate Muslim people and have absolutely nothing against them. In fact, I believe that moderate Muslims are very much the victims of Muslim extremism. I believe that freedom of religion is a fundamental human right. Hamas is a terrorist organisation by their own admission. I hate terrorists and there are far more Islamic terrorist organizations than any other.
In Palestine I believe Hamas is responsible for the death of the woman and children. All they had to do was stop firing the missiles. They refused. I don't blame the Palestinian people, only Hamas. If Hamas cared about the lives of the Palestinian people, they would have tried anything to prevent an Israeli attack.
My biggest problem is with extremist Muslims who are now spewing lies and propaganda against Israel, while their hands are dripping with blood. I never said everyone else in the world is innocent and only Muslims are evil. My original question was why are Muslim extremist trying to claim the moral high ground, and are getting away with it, while they have killed hundreds of thousands of innocent people, all over the world. There are many evil people, from all religions, in this world. But, to me a terrorist is someone who threatens my life and the life of my family on a constant basis. The only people, who do this, are Islamic terrorists.
I see many Muslim people singing the praises of Adolf Hitler and the holocaust on these pages. Only the most vile, despicable and evil people will support Hitler and I'm sure that they will be punished, severely, by God. I don’t know who these people are, but if they are not extremists, then they ought to be.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 2:09 pm ET

Lynne
I mean ,w e don't believe what the israeli say to justify their killing of children in the UNRWA school because they are terrorists: they kill children, wommen, doctors, etc... with cold blood. Nobody trust them.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:09 pm ET

Lynne,

There is no shade of gray in here as you like to pretend....

Its in Black and White and very clear to me and to millions of demonstrators all over the word supporting the Palestinians....

Its the occupation stupid....

Beny   January 11th, 2009 2:09 pm ET

Linda, Debs, Chernor, where are you? I open this post and there is only an onslaught of ignorance, stupidity , well-done lies and pure hatred. I pity Dan, Miriam, and Harvey – they are overwhelmed by this avalanche of stupidity here.
I'm losing hope.

Mohammed,

When you start attacking people for their spelling, or exclaiming stuff like we Jews harassed Hitler (I'm sure our existence caused him headaches, as it does to you), that's when I know that not only is there no discussing with you on a normal, intelligent level, there is also no arguing with you, seeing how you evade every question and fact we throw at you, and keep repeating the mantras you were brainwashed with.

Same goes for False Prof., Akiva and Salmon. Go ahead, keep preparing that oven you promised Dan and leave this blog alone.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:11 pm ET

where do the hamas terrorists get their grads from?

nobody knows, but you dispute that they came from iran?
cowards

tarig   January 11th, 2009 2:12 pm ET

ok but again dan i refer you to my earlier blog, why speak out against these evil acts carried out by people who claim to be muslims, and not refer to the countless other acts of so called terrorism that have been carried out in nations throughout the world? the greatest sponsor of so called terrorism is the US govt. you only need to look at what has happened in south america for the past 50 years to see that. were these acts carried out by muslims? i am saying that if we want the world to be a better place we cant point the finger at only one group, especially when that group are merely products of their society, and not question the actions of other groups just because were are affiliated with them. its time we question everything, not just that which is carried out against "us".

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:13 pm ET

welcome beny

i looked in kimmelman directory but could not find you

Maria   January 11th, 2009 2:14 pm ET

Mohammed and all people of good will on this forum:
I think we should live those provokators without their jobs.
Don't give them satisfaction and stop writting. Bojkot them.
There is so many ways to defend the human writes.

I would like to say that we can do anything and in the same time we can make the differece.
We can pray to GOD. He can do everything, everything no mather if somebody like it or not. He is the LORD of the world and belive me HE IS LISTENING and HIS patience is running out righ now.
I'm praing all the time for those innocent people and for all who have not heards of stone.

For those who has the fosssilles instead of the heards I pray GOD will break them, defrease them with HIS LOVE which is the most powerfull weapon in the universe.

Remember praing can do miracles – miracles which can change the most contaminated hearts.

Spreading lies and heatred is futaile.

Love will prevail!!!

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:15 pm ET

Jonas,

thats what Israel brought on to you... what don't you apply what you preach?....

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 2:16 pm ET

Ok Benny
As far as criticizing spelling is concerned, Harvey criticized us and I only responded by pointing to a basic difference between errors and mistakes. The other issues you mentioned (angrily) are debatable too.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 2:16 pm ET

dan perman
grad rockets where they come from ?
tell us ... proof us!
don theory ... bring official numbers and documants... post us links?
but valid links!

unitl you cant proof that something comes from where ever its not a fact!!!!

and do we have to proofe you what kind of stuff and how many of thet stuff, the USA gave to Israel?

dont trap yourself !

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 2:17 pm ET

Mackawee,

I cannot reconcile what constitutes a legitimate military target in the small, densely populated area. Buildings labeled "HAMAS Headquarters", HAMAS Bomb Works", etc. do not exist. What is probable is that things of evil are going on, possibly in the same apartment building as folks having nothing to do with these ... not sure what to call them, or underneath buildings (all the tunnels, one wonders). In this instance, I don't believe in sitting some distance away shelling. Too many things can go wrong, and too many innocents can get killed. In my mind, urban warfare requires mano-a-mano in order to protect as many innocents as possible.

When a shell is falling, I don't believe there is any safe distance, because event "smart" bombs and shells are not 100%

tarig   January 11th, 2009 2:20 pm ET

Remember praing can do miracles – miracles which can change the most contaminated hearts.

maria

not when your praying for the destruction of a race of people, it will backfire in that case. grow up, your right to defend your own but praying for a religion to be destroyed is the most ignorant thing i can think of. if you knew anything about the history of religion you would know that muslims and jews are cousins, we (muslims) descend from Ismael, and jews descend from Isaac both the sons of Abraham. would you wish death upon your cousin? if you do your sick, we all have the God given right to life, and judgement is in Its hands only, not mine, not yours and not anyone elses on here.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:21 pm ET

Beny,

This blog for people who have little brain and want to discuss the Israeli attack on Gaza....

you do not belong here.... so you can leave this blog if you like to discuss Darfur or any other topic.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 2:21 pm ET

Maria
This is what they are looking for. I join this plog to respond to the lies they try to spread. Unfortunately, many people in the western world believe them; that's why, we should attempt to correct the situation. Few minutes ago, Benny told me that he owns this blog and that he does not want us here. You see the strategy: they wand poeple to believe them without having recourse to &a second opinion. Jews have been operating this way for decades. Now that we are alive and kicking , they have become to turn into aggressive creatures (because they are not human beings).

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:21 pm ET

professor

as always you are evading the question

suit yourself, ignoramus

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:23 pm ET

Lynne,

good point.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 2:24 pm ET

Benny and Dan
we are sub-humans and you are the favorite people of god .You own "the truth". I suggest you leave this blog and let us discuss.

tarig   January 11th, 2009 2:25 pm ET

Too many things can go wrong, and too many innocents can get killed. In my mind, urban warfare requires mano-a-mano in order to protect as many innocents as possible.

lynne

again spot on. but it will never happen for the simple fact that the person who has nothing to loose is the person you fear most. palestinians have nothing to loose, it wouldnt be wise from an isreali point of view to fight them face to face. you got to look at the wider picture, in the words of cubfan a little colateral casualties is worth it, especially if the alternative is placing your soldiers in an un-winable situation. sick i know, but accurate, its the way of the world, has been since the time of sun tzu.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 2:26 pm ET

Mohammad,

I do not believe in the killing of innocents, either, and to injure a child is the greatest crime of all in my book.

Is there any way at all to get people talking to each other, even in light of great tragedy? Is there any way at all to put vengeance aside?

Prof,

For all I enjoy our discussions, I just don't know what to say to you. For me, the human side of this tragedy is shades of gray. Both Israelis and Palestinians are suffering greatly, and at this moment, the degree of suffering is greatest for the people of Gaza. The only thing that is B&W is that people must get past all the differences in opinion, find the commonalities, and use this as the foundation to construct a beautiful piece of architecture.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 2:26 pm ET

Everybody here
i suggest you buy as many ovens as you can.

Maria   January 11th, 2009 2:30 pm ET

I don't wish death anybody. I did not say anytnig like that !!!!!
I think you have problem with your imagination.
Go to a doctor mayby it is not to late for you :)

And please don't put the words which I didn't said in my mouth next time bacaus I will report that.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:30 pm ET

Lynne,

I enjoy this discussion as well....

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:30 pm ET

mohammed

i deeply appologize if our telling the truth upsets you so much

try valium

eddie carter   January 11th, 2009 2:31 pm ET

I suggest that the Arabs start thinking in positive and constructive mode. Peace would immediately bring prosperity and improved quality of life to all in the region.
Israel cleared Jenin of terrorists [albeit condemned by the world] and now it is a peaceful and thriving town.
we withdrew from Gaza so there was no excuses for indiscriminate rockets attacks seeking to kill as many Israelis as possible.
in the name of peace several thousands of israeli citizens were uprooted and taken out of Gaza – STOP THIS NONENSE OF JIHAD AND MORE BLOOD! So far the biggest losers have been the Palestinians who were denied statehood by their brothers in Eygpt and Jordan and have been offred this by Israel!!
GET REAL – ISRAEL WILL NOT GO BACK TO PRE 67 CEASE FIRE LINES – NEVER RATIFIED AS RECOGNIZED INTERNATIONAL BORDER.

ISRAELI SCHOOL CHILDREN ARE NOT TAUGHT TO HATE LIKE IN THE HAMAS KINDERGARTENS.

the israeli army is made up of Jews, Druze, Beduin, Chirkassim, Christian Arabs and even a few Moslem ones. A model of co-existence and camradie
best wishes to all
eddie carter

EdM   January 11th, 2009 2:31 pm ET

Here are some things I have a tough time dealing with. Maybe you all can help. It's a repeat of Jan 11 0130 blog entry but I'm still looking for comment.

There is so much condemnation of Israel for violating UN resolutions. I never hear any condemnation of the Arab nations violating 181, not accepting the two state solution in 1948, attacking Israel in 1948, and continuing wars, cross-border attacks, suicide bombings targeting civilians, economic boycotts, teaching hate, the Khartoum 3 NOs, re-arming Hezbullah, etc. Why is it OK to knock Israel for violating resolutions but not knocking the Arabs for doing the same thing especially (but not only) re: 181? Seems to me you either knock them both or just forget about the UN resolutions. Of course, once you knock the Arabs re: 181, you accept the 2-state solution which puts you at odds with Hamas and some other Arab regimes, as well as accepting the role of the Arabs in causing (yes, causing) the refugee problem, Israeli control of the West Bank (recall Jordan controlled it before 1967 and did not create a Palestinian state since that would have implied accepting 181’s 2-state concept and Israel got it when Jordan attacked Israel in 1967), etc. So, I believe those who favor eliminating Israel not bring up UN resolutions at all and those who favor the 2-state solution bring them all up, starting with 181 and the Arab rejection. Anything in between seems rather hypocritical, double standard, whatever the going term is. Correct?

According to CNN’s short summary of Gaza facts, three-quarters of Gaza is used for agriculture. Hamas has built over a hundred tunnels for smuggling things from Egypt to Gaza. Is it really believable that they could not have built underground storage for the weapons in the ¾ of Gaza that is unoccupied, or fired their rockets from unoccupied areas? Instead it seems they have intentionally stored and fired from well-populated areas. This seems to me like asymmetric warfare, intending to either deter attacks on their forces and weapons or use the resulting civilian casualties for PR. The counter to that seems to me to be international outrage at Hamas putting its civilian population at risk. But I see little of that. By the way, I am appalled and feel tremendous empathy for the folks who are just trying to live their lives and are in Gaza. They should not be subjected to such enormous misery, death, injury, destruction, etc. But I see the cause as all sides, including the international community for not condemning little actions that ended up leading (predictably) to this crisis. Address the little actions before they lead to blood, which seems to be about all the media report. This kind of asymmetric warfare is very hard to counter. True?

Speaking of the tunnels, couldn’t Hamas have used them to smuggle in food, fuel, medicines, etc instead of rockets and explosives for mortars? In fact, couldn’t Iran, or whoever is supplying the arms, have furnished these? By the way, wouldn’t the smuggling be not required if Hamas were not openly committed to annihilate Israel?

Is it warfare? We have Hamas openly stating its goal of annihilating Israel and then demanding that Israel provide it electricity, fuel, food, etc. Truces we get for a while but enduring peace remains elusive. How can the world expect that there will be peace between two entities when one wants to annihilate the other? That seems like the one is declaring it is in an ongoing state of war with the other, whether there is a truce for re-arming or not. Sounds like war to me, whether hot or cool; remember the “Cold War”? And if it is, “war is hell’, said by a man well versed in the horrors of war.

Most of the Israelis I’ve met want to live in peace. Some want roughly the 1967 borders, some want much more. But mainly they want to live in peace. The path to that peace seems conceptually simple to me: remove the threat to Israel’s existence as homeland for the Jewish people, as described in 181, create a Palestinian state living in peace with Israel, as described in 181, and have the two interacting for the benefit of each other, as described in 181. We came close to this in the late 1990s and early 2000’s, before Intifada 2. I have seen Israeli Jews and Israeli Arabs living very well together, socializing, doing commerce, receiving medical care at hospitals, etc. If lives are the most important, let all the nations of that area teach peace and show Israel on the maps they use to teach their children. Otherwise, let some Arab and Muslim leaders continue their diatribes of hate of Jews and the existence of ‘The Zionist Entity’ with the goal of annihilating ‘the Zionist Entity’ from the world. But don’t be surprised by the outcomes of the latter path; it’s wars, killing, and destruction, aka ‘The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse’. True?

Beny   January 11th, 2009 2:32 pm ET

Lynne,

"I think the key to solving terrorism is understanding what it is that is causing the fear"

I believe the key to "solving terrorism" is understanding that here, at least, it simply won't work. When Hamas shoot rockets, they get a painful reaction. When Arafat the terrorist put on a facade of peacefulness in 1993, he managed to squeeze the harmful Oslo pact out of us. Even if you want to destroy Israel, you can only do it with slowly nibbling at more and more of what Israel gives away, than a head-on attack with no chance of compromise.

As for what is causing the fear. I understand that it's much easier to hate the soldier at the checkpoint than the terrorist who sends your son to "paradise as a Shahid".
It's a shameful reality that all the wars the Palestinian leaders waged on us, from 1948 and 1967 when they threw away everything the world gave them just to destroy us all, up to now when they drag the Palestinians into another war for our destruction that is only causing everyone (and especially them) pain and grief, and then use them as human shields.

All these wars turned the Palestinians into a hungry, desperate and, as you said, fearful people, whom it is very easy to turn against a common enemy and prolong the fighting, even if it achieves nothing and makes them even more desperate. Until the Palestinians free themselves from such leadership, from Husseini to Hamas, I pity them.

What Hamas is doing is like waving a baby and throwing it at a chair. Sure the baby suffers more than the chair and I pity the baby no less than you do, but that's hardly reason to blame the chair!

tarig   January 11th, 2009 2:33 pm ET

mohammed, i am a muslim, i see whats happening, i know your angry just like the rest of the arab world, but is racism really the way to fight them? "they are not human beings". who are you to judge them, when did you become Allah, its not your right to make assumptions and fight fire with fire. water is the only way to put out a blaze. try showing them the error of their ways, try pointing out books that can help them understand what is wrong with the world, although based on your comments your more the problem than the solution. dont insult them and place yourself on a peddlestool of knowledge. fight with the mind, revert to the teachings of the Quran, if we wernt so premature to want to fight the entire worlds public opinion would be against this zionist regime, but muslims are the worst enemy of Islam. its not time to pick up the sword yet, maybe that time will come soon, but were not there yet.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 2:35 pm ET

Lynne
You have got to be kidding. Talking is a structured activity and it is rule-governed. One of its basic ingredients is readiness. Can we talk with people whose army does not stop from killing humans, grass, and stone all day and all night without the slightest ado. Do you want us to believe in the crap called "dialogue of religions", "dialogue of civilizations", or the "the unity for the meditteranean". Even the most optimistic people in the arab world have started to reject the idea. Readiness has to^pass through stopping inhumane massacres and introducing rulers and propounders of this unjust war to the penal court in Lahaye.
If you believe in radical solutions, answer this question and show me your good will:
Will you accept expelled refugees in 1948 to return back to their land. This is the essence of the conflict between usand you.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 2:38 pm ET

http://www.anis-online.de/mediendatenbank/palestiniana/p/map4.jpg
???

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:38 pm ET

Lynne,

during the last Israeli attack on Genin, a female jewish rabbi started an online discussion forum that was very productive... unlike this blog here which is a forum for people to express their anger only.

She invited intellectuals from the differnet faiths and it was mandatory for everyone to post a self introcuction as their first comment. So, everyone knew who exactly they are talking to....

Here people hide behind nicks that are meaningless and sometimes don't make sense.

As a moderator she sets the first topic for discussion and we did not move to another subject until we exhasted the first topic and documented the results.

I wish we could do that again.... instead of wasting time here.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 2:39 pm ET

Benny
are you using copy and paste because you repeat the same text everyday.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:40 pm ET

professor

you want proof for what

your antisemitic ravings on this blog did not prove anything, you demnding proof for verifyable facts does not prove anything save you being an ignoramus

and that is a fact that needs no further proof

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 2:40 pm ET

Tariq,

I might also add that in this age of "body-counting", many people view the collateral casualties as one more count. Dehumanized, sanitized war, I think. In many cultures, if you seriously believe in something, you should be willing to die for it. In the absence of a draft, I think this is what most militaries are based on. Otherwise, why would one join up?

The downside is that as innocent collateral damage adds up, the winner of the numbers starts to lose the world-wide PR war. If the military casualties start adding up, you lose the PR war on the home-front. A catch-22. What to do? Keep the support of your people, or view innocents as expendable? Like the Titanic, do you keep people off the lifeboats so you are comfortable and have plenty of room, or do you take on as many as you can without sinking? Do you leave people you name as underclass locked up below decks because there aren't enough lifeboats to go around? Survival, coupled with morality, does have it's own dilemmas.

Interesting that you reference Sun Tzu. I believe that his writings also include the concept of (paraphrased) not fighting battles you can't win. I think that current tactics and strategies at this moment have not created a winnable situation for either the Israelis or Palestinians.

M. Issero   January 11th, 2009 2:41 pm ET

To The American Liberal Media, (CNN, MSNBC, NBC, ABC...)
Please stop being the propaganda arm for Hamas by spotlighting how many babies are killed by the Israeli forces in this Gaza War.
If Osama Ben Ladin was in a home with his family and it would be unfeasible to separate him from his children would we bomb his house let's say from an air drone?

How many children did the U.S. kill in Afghanistan ?
(a war that received universal approval)

How many children did we kill in Japan with 2 Atomic bombs after we were attacked in Pearl Harbor? How many German children did we kill when we fought Germany when we carpet bombed cities such as Dresdin?

Why won't you constantly remind your readers or viewers that it's a deliberate strategy of Hamas
to embed themselves in the midst of or behind civilians when they shoot their rockets over to Israel? Why won't you point out that that is the only strength that the Hamas terrorists have because otherwise their whole force would be annihilated in less than an hour?

How can you be so manipulated by such evil people who promote the glory of being martyred for the sake of their "religion"? How can you be so manipulated by barbaric people who serve up their children to be with Allah so that they can perpetrate their hate upon the peaceful people of Israel (who have made peace with their neighbors in Egypt and Jordan and strive to do the same with the Palestinians)?

Why don't you shine the spotlight on Hamas for persisting to shoot rockets over to Israel by the hundreds and won't stop now and agree to stop for all time? What would you do with a neighbor who attempted to murder you and your countrymen and took their own citizens hostage to hide behind?

Please be responsible with your coverage because a lot of people are comparing Israel with barbarians and it couldn't be further from the truth. Even just for its own survival Israel would never engage in indiscriminate bombing because it relies on the good will of the world. Israel indeed deserves the will of good people all over the world because the radical element that consists in Hamas is the same that bombed Mumbei, London, Spain, Kenya, New York, Washington and is killing helpless people in Darfur. The good people of the world need to unite against EVIL and not be divided and conquered by particular propaganda schemes.

Thank you,

A Citizen

mahmoud jboor   January 11th, 2009 2:41 pm ET

now at these momements ///.....MORE evidence of idf using WMD or WHD like white phosphrous and alethal weopon (US) called : D I M E !!!!!!

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:43 pm ET

mohammed

your extremely smart comments delight me

did you take the valium yet?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:45 pm ET

Edm,

deal with it.

Maria   January 11th, 2009 2:45 pm ET

Taric forgive me but you misunderstood me I don't pray for any destrucion of anybody or anybodys religion.
I'm a Katolic and I would like you to know that I also belive that only GOD is entitled to handle of life an death.
That's why I'm writing on this forum.
My GOD is the same as yours ALLAH and I condem the massacre which Israel is doing.
My heart is with Gazans write now!

Maria   January 11th, 2009 2:46 pm ET

I send this for all of you:

Prayer at sunrise

I will obey any of thy stern judgements,
I will bow down before thy power.
But protect me, o Lord from contempt,
Guard me Lord from hatred.

For thy art an immense good,
Which cannot be expressed by any word.
So protect me from hatred,
And spare me from contempt.

May happen what thou resolve,
Thy will be done.
But deliver me from hatred,
Spare me from contempt, o Lord.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:47 pm ET

Dan,

I did not request any proof from you.... becuase I know you cannot give any... I will only request a proof from someone who I know can provide it. But you are irrelevant.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 2:48 pm ET

dan perman

i was asking you for proofings by the way :)

your so stupid ... cant you read names?
stop druging your self
its not good for your health and special not for your brain

and i was asking for a proof because you try to sugest that iran is arming the hamas

so dont suggst ... proof it !

and i will proof what USA has gaven to Israel ...
al the money from US to israel
all the weapons from US to israel

i will bring you official numbers and papers from the US gov about how they support israel
i will bring you official reports from different countries and organisations about the support by US to israel

so if you are only here to suggest your theories ... leave
al you are posting turny bad to israel
as your letters last time
you allways do frindly fire to israel and your so stupid that you cant see it
and you call people ignorant?

your a so very smart guy!

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 2:51 pm ET

Mohammad,

"i suggest you buy as many ovens as you can."

That comment was distasteful, injurious, and downright uncalled for. Please sir, postings such as these lend little to the discussion.

Now for all, I have a question:

When I view photos taken from areas of intense fighting (such as Africa and in the past Serbia/Bosnia/Croatia), the children and very old appear to be in very bad condition, the women slightly behind them, but the young men warriors very well fed.

Why is that?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:51 pm ET

maria,

did you condemn the lynching in ramallah?

did you condemn the murder of the pregnant mother and her four daughters by close range headshots, of which hamas bragged?

did you condemn the shhoting of 10 months old shalhevet paz by an arab sharpshooter in the arms of her father?

did you? or did you just wake up 15 days ago and know nothing about history?

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 2:52 pm ET

israel has an existencialist crisis. It needs to assert itself as a democracy. At the same time, it needs to accomplish what it bstarted a long time ago, namely to finish finallizing its borders at the expense of its colonized neighbours. The two conflicting missions create an atmosphere of tension as israelis try to keep their embellished face to the west (internal democracy), and simultaneously attempt to find motives (like rocket launching) to exterminate a whole population. Well, Even if there were no rockets, Israel would have looked for another triggering factor. Remember that during the truce with Hamas, Israel has besieged (with the suport of the regime of Mubarak) gaza strip. Why? Because in the absence of options, Israelis know that Hamas will be obliged to use them in order to show to the world that there is a population that starve. My friend, we are not dealing with an ordinary enemy. He is trained, informed, and has a history of accumulation.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 2:54 pm ET

Professor,
You’re just a plain idiot. You don't understand anything, you cannot substantiate any of your claims, you make wild assumptions and you make very little sense. It's not difficult to see which of the people on this blog have any sense, and you are not one of them. You are not a good advertisement for wherever you got your education from.
Let me explain it to you nicely, I have never, but never, had my life threatened by a Jew or by an Israeli. But I live in constant fear of my life being snuffed out, at any moment, by a suicide bomber, Muslim extremist terrorist with an AK47 or a bomb.
I don’t live in Israel, but I have visited it several times, I have always been treated very well, and been given very nice bomb shelters to sleep in, just in case a Hamas rocket finds a target.
I was in Bali when the bombs exploded. Although I was far away from the explosions, I heard them and saw the results. These bombs, just in case that you were hiding in the desert, were planted by Muslim extremists.
In Kabul, I was 200m away from a bomb the exploded and killed three people and wounded many. This bomb, just in case you are interested, was planted by Muslim extremists, and killed and wounded only other Muslims.
If I said that I loved Muslim extremists, would you believe me or would you think that I was mad?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:55 pm ET

Amnesty Internationa and Human Rights Watch.... the two largest human rights organizations in the US/world have said that there is enough proof that the Israeli forces have committed war crimes in Gaza.

tarig   January 11th, 2009 2:55 pm ET

your right, rule number one of the art of war is that the best solution is to avoid war at all costs, but that rule becomes null and void once you are already in a state of war. the basic instinct of survival is ingrained in every human being, its our nature to do all we can to avoid death, but like you said Dehumanized, sanitized war, this is a direct result of the societies in which we are raised, look out for number one. i think you answered your own question when you said if you really believe in something you should be willing to die for it. i tell you now there isnt a muslim in this world who isnt ready to die for their religion (including myself provided that the attack being faced is genuinely directed at my religion and not a manipulation of elitists). if israelis really believe that the land is theres then the loss of soldiers (not civillians as this is purely and simply wrong) should be irrelevant to public opinion, the fact that it is not leaves a lot of questions for the jewish states persons to answer. the bottom line is life is valubale regardless of race religion or creed, but soldiers are so because they are willing to die to protect what they believe in, their deaths should be celebrated because they have done what few get the chance to do, live and die for what they believe in.

you say there is no winnable situation for israelis or palestinians, your forgetting the far reaching influence that this war has on the world. there are forces directing us to a war that will involve everyone, and, as has been foretold, this appears to be its beginning. the question you should be asking is is there any way to stop it before it leads to the destruction of humanity as a race? i personnal fear that there is not.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 2:56 pm ET

here is article 13 of the hamas charter

do i need to prove it, "professor"?

Article Thirteen

The initiatives, the so-called peace solutions, and the international conferences for resolving the Palestinian problem stand in contradiction to the principles of the Islamic Resistance Movement, for to neglect any part of Palestine is to neglect part of the Islamic faith. The nationalism of the Islamic Resistance Movement is part of its [Islamic] faith. It is in the light of this principle that its members are educated, and they wage jihad in order to raise the banner of Allah over the homeland.

"And Allah has full control over His affairs; but most people do not know." (Koran, 12:21)

From time to time there are calls to hold an international conference in order to seek a solution for the [Palestinian] problem. Some accept this [proposal] and some reject it, for one reason or another, demanding the fulfillment of some condition or conditions before they agree to hold the conference and participate in it. However, the Islamic Resistance Movement – since it is familiar with the parties participating in the conference and with their past and current positions on the issues of the Muslims – does not believe that these conferences can meet the demands or restore the rights [of the Palestinians], or bring equity to the oppressed. These conferences are nothing but a way to give the infidels power of arbitration over Muslim land, and when have the infidels ever been equitable towards the believers?

"The Jews will never be content with you, nor will the Christians, until you follow their religion. Say: 'The guidance of Allah is the right guidance.' But if you follow their desires after the knowledge which has come to you, then you shall have no protector or guardian from Allah." (Koran, 2:120)

There is no solution to the Palestinian problem except by jihad. Initiatives, proposals and international conferences are a waste of time and a farce. The Palestinian people is far too eminent to have its future, its rights and its destiny toyed with. As stated in the Hadith: "The people of Al-Sha'm are [Allah's] rod in His land. Through them, He wreaks vengeance on whomever He wishes among His servants. The hypocrites among them are not allowed to be superior to the believers among them, and they shall die in grief and distress." (Recorded by Al-Tabarani with a chain of transmitters to Muhammad, and by Ahmad [Ibn Hanbal] with an incomplete chain of transmitters to Muhammad which may be the accurate record, the transmitters in both cases being trustworthy – Allah alone is omniscient).

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 2:57 pm ET

Dan
I have noticed that people talk about Iran is if it were a devil. We are proud to have Iran as an ally. I prefer it to Egypt, jordan and saudi arabia. Who helped Hezbollah in its war against you?

Maria   January 11th, 2009 2:57 pm ET

Dan
I condem any Evil I know about but we are discussing the particular one right now. I will not go back to Adam and Eve now when innocent people are dying unless you proove thow choldren were responsible for the acts you listed.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 2:57 pm ET

Jonas,

coming from you.... I consider that a compliment... ;-p

tarig   January 11th, 2009 2:59 pm ET

well maria my sister (and i say sister because most people seem to forget that we are all one and the same, we are all brothers and sisters) i apologize for the misunderstanding, and i hope your prayers are heard for all our sakes.

Maria   January 11th, 2009 3:00 pm ET

Thanks from my heart my BROTHER :):):)

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:04 pm ET

Dan
Arafat and Abbas have been negociating with you for decades.What have they reached? Have Israelis applied any of theUN resolutions in vigor? Have you ever heard about a peace process that lasts fro ever?
The basic question that bothers you , DAN, is the question of refugees.
If you arte honest, answer the following and the bloggers here will judge whether negociations with israelis will be fruitful:
will you allow our refugees to return back to their lands?
N.B. tHESE REFUGEES HAVE BEEN EXPELLED WITH THE FORCE OF ARMS.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 3:09 pm ET

maria

i did not know that the crimes comitted by the palestinian terrorists were comitted during the time of adam and eve

for your information, the brutal murder of the pregnant mother and her four daughters was commited by hamas "heroes" in 2004. And Hamas afterwards bragged about the heroic deed.

and the Mumbai attack where muslim terrorists killed and then mutilated the bodies of a rabbi and his wife was only a few weeks ago. That's adam adam and eve too, right????

mohammed

first take your valium, then talk about the madman from teheran

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 3:13 pm ET

akiva,

you incite, you lie and you allege, but never prove anything

i have posted proof after proof which was diregarded by you and your antisemitic friends

i do not need to prove anything to hatemongers like you, you need to prove that your baseless allegations are true, which you cannot

Joan   January 11th, 2009 3:13 pm ET

mohammed,

Do you really think that Hamas rockets are the best way to show the world that people in Gaza are starving?? Have they not figured out that terrorism only alienates the world and turns it against them?? When will they wake up ?

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:14 pm ET

only this morning, The human rights watch spoksman said that israel uses internationally banned weapons: phosphoric gas and a new gas called IDiA (an american weapon never used before). This last gas burns houses and graa; it also kills palestinians by burning them without much affecting houses. This morning in the shifaa hospital in ghaza, doctors are appalled by the degree of burns. one of them said that once you touch the skin, your hand gets inside of the body of the poor patient. This is israel and this is the US. wHAT CAN WE SAY MORE ABOUT THIS ENEMY,

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:15 pm ET

Joana
give please another option.Please.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 3:15 pm ET

mohammed,

Do you think that goading Israel into a fight is a good way to feed the people of Gaza? Surely you know that after 911, noone will ever try to stop a country from retaliating to terrorism??

Maria   January 11th, 2009 3:16 pm ET

Dan

I know about some masacres of Christians in Irak and India too but I would never seek such revange like those massakre. I will never lower myself to that level because I'm different.
Those who are doing that becomming the Evel too.
If you are so innocent then cast the stone first ...
Your ancestors didn't how about you???

Joan   January 11th, 2009 3:17 pm ET

I guess dead people can't be starving any more.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 3:18 pm ET

Joan,
do you know who created Hamas?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 3:18 pm ET

dan

i disregarded nothing ... i only did investigations about what your postin and allways fount that you dont post facts
you post fake facts
you post pro israel stuff which is proofed by israel it self as wrong
you posted poropagande with no proof by israel

the only thing you are doing to israel is posting friendly fire!

try to use google and inform your self about what you post here !

are you choosen by god to be stupid?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 3:20 pm ET

maria

you see, the difference between jews and christians is that christians are supposed to turn the other cheek

i do not know any christian who does

you still refrain from condemning any of the terror acts carried out by palestinian terrorists, but still insist on condemning israel for defending herself

how noble of you!!!

Joan   January 11th, 2009 3:22 pm ET

mohammed,

Other OPtions:
use adi money for food instead of weapons
use aid money to build schools, hospitals, etc,
use the tunnels to bring in food not weapons
use your mindpower to plan for food rather than war
use your resources for positive things instead of fighing for power for your unscrupulous leaders
instead of acting from hatred and anger against your perceived enemies, act from good will towards your own people,
stop using your people for your own greedy aims and start helping them
etc., etc., etc.

try brainpower instead of useless rockets

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 3:22 pm ET

Hi Beny,

Sorry for delay, but your words had a way of making one think.

“Even if you want to destroy Israel, you can only do it with slowly nibbling at more and more of what Israel gives away, than a head-on attack with no chance of compromise.”

That, too me, is fear, as legitimate as any of the “Palestinian” people. The call for the destruction of Israel is an act of terrorism, as it is deliberately made to cause profound anxiety in every Jewish person. Now, and please pardon the analogy, but I can’t think of anything better since I work with rescued canines, a terrified and anxious animal will bite, even if you attempt to feed the critter. The critter just doesn’t know any better. The only way to get the critter to quit biting and overcome the fear is consistent kindness without pity (not to mention a pair of heavy leather gloves). I think that this situation is in play on both sides. Kindness and constant feeding is required on both sides.

Now, Oslo wasn’t perfect. There were a lot of issues, at least to me, that were going to come up and if people let it, start the vicious cycle all over again. I think that maybe Arafat and Rabin, as old men, were tired of fighting, and were agreeing to anything that they could agree on. The Roadmap the Quartet came up with is not perfect, but a starting point. One thing is sure, the people living there are going to have to make painful compromises and eliminate as much of each other’s fears as possible. And I do think that there are extremists on both sides that do not want peace, because peace threatens their very existence and power (ah, another fear).

What to do, Beny? I am more akin to a terrier. I will not let go of trying to at least get people talking to each other, and talking each other seriously. I am neither Jewish, nor Muslim, nor Christian, though I was raised Christian. I believe that the “great spirit” lives in all of us.

Maria   January 11th, 2009 3:23 pm ET

Peope are people whatever religion. There is no difference.
Yes I Insist :)

tarig   January 11th, 2009 3:24 pm ET

dan, if there is any proof of the fact that you know what israel is and has been doing is wrong its that you ignored my earlier post!! mohammed, proffessor do you wonder why the world calls us terrorists, your on here insighting hate of an entire religion. you want to defend your religion and you think isreal is attacking Islam (i agree but it is still unsubstantiated), then pick up a gun and go fight their soldiers, asassinate tzipi do something. oh thats right your to busy talking a tough game, you aint quiete ready to walk the walk. you cant convince them of their errors by attacking them, only by showing them. heres a few authors that might be of interest to you all, yitzhak loar, Tariq Ali, Noam Chomsky, eduardo galeano, ken loach, elet adnan. you people need to read before you talk. ignorance breeds anger and leads to unnecessary violence.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 3:25 pm ET

akiva

after you learn how to spell, try and read the hamas charter

oops, the hamas charter is israeli propaganda not a fact, sorry, akiva how could i be so stupid, i appologize

the lynch in ramallah never happened, israeli propaganda

the murder of the pregnant mother and her four daughters also never happened, hamas bragged about it afterwards, but that must have been a misunderstanding

and the rabbi and his wife butchered in mumbai are alive and well and live in tel aviv, it never happened, right?

don't you see that everybody is laughing at your ramblings?

Joan   January 11th, 2009 3:25 pm ET

Rod,

what difference does it make who created Hamas?

We are where we are today. who started what and when doesn't matter. what matters is who ends it and brings a reasonable life to their people.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 3:28 pm ET

Lynne hey there

tarig   January 11th, 2009 3:30 pm ET

am off to watch the footy, you people should listen to lynne more, shes the only one who makes any form of sense bless her.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:33 pm ET

The same gas (IDAI) has turned a small boy blind (see the news on aljazeer( and a small beautiful girl lost her two legs. Can you accept this cruelty?

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 3:33 pm ET

Tarig,
Don't get me wrong, because we are tolerant of all religions doesn't mean that we will sit down and wait until you think it is time to take up the sword. Threatening the rest of the world with a Muslim uprising doesn’t make us quake in our boots but more determined to snuff out Muslim extremism before it makes our lives more miserable. Also, you must not be so blasé as to think that all Muslims will be interested in an uprising. The Muslim world is not as united as you may think. There are a number of Islamic countries that would be very happy to see the death of Muslim extremism. Also many Muslim groups are too busy killing each other than to worry about anything else. Fortunately, we who are non-Muslims know that many Muslims groups preach the death of Christians, Jews, Hindus, Buddhists, and other religions that don't agree with them. It's a small matter of 7 billion others against the 1.5 billion Muslims.
Another myth is that the USA is the biggest terrorist in the world. By far the most people killed in South America were killed by fascist dictators and communist terrorists, their own people. Nothing to do with religion, pure politics.
More people have been murdered, hundreds of thousands of them, most of them Muslims, by Islamic terrorists in Darfur. Now equate that to Palestine and the IDF?

EdM   January 11th, 2009 3:34 pm ET

Here are some things I have a tough time dealing with. Maybe you all can help.

There is so much condemnation of Israel for violating UN resolutions. I never hear any condemnation of the Arab nations violating 181, not accepting the two state solution in 1948, attacking Israel in 1948, and continuing wars, cross-border attacks, suicide bombings targeting civilians, economic boycotts, teaching hate, the Khartoum 3 NOs, re-arming Hezbullah, etc. Why is it OK to knock Israel for violating resolutions but not knocking the Arabs for doing the same thing especially (but not only) re: 181? Seems to me you either knock them both or just forget about the UN resolutions. Of course, once you knock the Arabs re: 181, you accept the 2-state solution which puts you at odds with Hamas and some other Arab regimes, as well as accepting the role of the Arabs in causing (yes, causing) the refugee problem, Israeli control of the West Bank (recall Jordan controlled it before 1967 and did not create a Palestinian state since that would have implied accepting 181’s 2-state concept and Israel got it when Jordan attacked Israel in 1967), etc. So, I believe those who favor eliminating Israel not bring up UN resolutions at all and those who favor the 2-state solution bring them all up, starting with 181 and the Arab rejection. Anything in between seems rather hypocritical, double standard, whatever the going term is. Correct?

According to CNN’s short summary of Gaza facts, three-quarters of Gaza is used for agriculture. Hamas has built over a hundred tunnels for smuggling things from Egypt to Gaza. Is it really believable that they could not have built underground storage for the weapons in the ¾ of Gaza that is unoccupied, or fired their rockets from unoccupied areas? Instead it seems they have intentionally stored and fired from well-populated areas. This seems to me like asymmetric warfare, intending to either deter attacks on their forces and weapons or use the resulting civilian casualties for PR. The counter to that seems to me to be international outrage at Hamas putting its civilian population at risk. But I see little of that. By the way, I am appalled and feel tremendous empathy for the folks who are just trying to live their lives and are in Gaza. They should not be subjected to such enormous misery, death, injury, destruction, etc. But I see the cause as all sides, including the international community for not condemning little actions that ended up leading (predictably) to this crisis. Address the little actions before they lead to blood, which seems to be about all the media report. This kind of asymmetric warfare is very hard to counter. True?

Speaking of the tunnels, couldn’t Hamas have used them to smuggle in food, fuel, medicines, etc instead of rockets and explosives for mortars? In fact, couldn’t Iran, or whoever is supplying the arms, have furnished these? By the way, wouldn’t the smuggling be not required if Hamas were not openly committed to annihilate Israel?

Is it warfare? We have Hamas openly stating its goal of annihilating Israel and then demanding that Israel provide it electricity, fuel, food, etc. Truces we get for a while but enduring peace remains elusive. How can the world expect that there will be peace between two entities when one wants to annihilate the other? That seems like the one is declaring it is in an ongoing state of war with the other, whether there is a truce for re-arming or not. Sounds like war to me, whether hot or cool; remember the “Cold War”? And if it is, “war is hell’, said by a man well versed in the horrors of war.

Most of the Israelis I’ve met want to live in peace. Some want roughly the 1967 borders, some want much more. But mainly they want to live in peace. The path to that peace seems conceptually simple to me: remove the threat to Israel’s existence as homeland for the Jewish people, as described in 181, create a Palestinian state living in peace with Israel, as described in 181, and have the two interacting for the benefit of each other, as described in 181. We came close to this in the late 1990s and early 2000’s, before Intifada 2. I have seen Israeli Jews and Israeli Arabs living very well together, socializing, doing commerce, receiving medical care at hospitals, etc. If lives are the most important, let all the nations of that area teach peace and show Israel on the maps they use to teach their children. Otherwise, let some Arab and Muslim leaders continue their diatribes of hate of Jews and the existence of ‘The Zionist Entity’ with the goal of annihilating ‘the Zionist Entity’ from the world. But don’t be surprised by the outcomes of the latter path; it’s wars, killing, and destruction, aka ‘The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse’. True?

tarig   January 11th, 2009 3:38 pm ET

jonas, you misunderstood me i was being sarcastic, i was actually attacking prof and mohammed for their arogance. your right those killed in south america were by there own people, but who put these dictators in power, in the process usually overthrowing democratically elected govts. the us, its a known fact if you refer to some of the authors i mentioned earlier you will find plenty of references. as for darfur, i am from sudan its nothing to do with religion purely politics believe me. but yo like i said football time, good night or good day to all depending on where you are. jonas al get back to you tomorrow.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:38 pm ET

JOAN
OPEN THE PASSAGES IN ORDER TO DO ALL THESE THINGS.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:41 pm ET

TARIG
WE ARE IGNORANT AND YOU ARE AN OUTSTADING SCHOLAR. YOU ARE NOT SUDANESE. YOU ARE ISRAELI. WE KNOW THESE TACTICS. YOU MUST BE ONE OF THE STUDENTS OF DAN.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 3:42 pm ET

Joan ( I know your thoughts and I agree with you, How do we end this? )
However it does make a difference,
the State of Israel Blames all of this on Hamas. All the supporters of Israel Claim that hamas Charter is the problem.
When the state of israel is the one who created Hamas or at least supported it.

“After all, it is no secret that it was the Israeli government which set up Hamas to start with. When I once asked a former Shin-Bet chief, Yaakov Peri, about it, he answered enigmatically: “We did not create it, but we did not hinder its creation.”
For years, the occupation authorities favored the Islamic movement in the occupied territories. All other political activities were rigorously suppressed, but their activities in the mosques were permitted. The calculation was simple and naive: at the time, the PLO was considered the main enemy, Yasser Arafat was the current Satan. The Islamic movement was preaching against the PLO and Arafat, and was therefore viewed as an ally.”
this is from The Article “Molten Lead” by Uri Avnery

This is another Experiment of Genocide and Israel should be responsible for creating hamas and all the destruction and Killing of Palestinians using an excuse they created

Joan   January 11th, 2009 3:43 pm ET

mohammed,

if the people of Gaza would genuinely agree to stop the terrorism and disarm, aid would flood in from everywhere and Gaza could be the richest place in the world.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 3:43 pm ET

morning all!

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:44 pm ET

DAN
As usual, you avoid my question:
Do you accept the return of palestinians to the 1948 territory?
A tough question?HUH

Professor   January 11th, 2009 3:44 pm ET

They are interviewing a Israeli journalist now from Tel Aviv,

He said that there is no comparison between Hamas and Hizbullah....

Hizbullah was fighting from a soverign nation that is free and not under siege.... where Hamas is weak and fighting from Gaza that has been under siege for a long time...

Heh.... is that an admission that Israel is the one who broke the cease-fire way before Hamas fired the first rocket?.... and that keeping Gaza under siege for that long of a time is an act of war by itself?

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:46 pm ET

JOANNA
Whom are you fooling here?

Joan   January 11th, 2009 3:47 pm ET

mohammed,

A lot of people just ignore any crisis in the middle east It's not news. There is always a crisis in the middle east. So starting another crisis doesn't help. Yes there is lots of news coverage, but it is just the same old thing.Lots of suffering and innocent peole being killed.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 3:49 pm ET

Tarig,

An Isreali supporter hiding behind a nick.... nothing new to the tactics used by Israeli terrorist organizations....

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:49 pm ET

to joan
israel has an existencialist crisis. It needs to assert itself as a democracy. At the same time, it needs to accomplish what it bstarted a long time ago, namely to finish finallizing its borders at the expense of its colonized neighbours. The two conflicting missions create an atmosphere of tension as israelis try to keep their embellished face to the west (internal democracy), and simultaneously attempt to find motives (like rocket launching) to exterminate a whole population. Well, Even if there were no rockets, Israel would have looked for another triggering factor. Remember that during the truce with Hamas, Israel has besieged (with the suport of the regime of Mubarak) gaza strip. Why? Because in the absence of options, Israelis know that Hamas will be obliged to use them in order to show to the world that there is a population that starve. My friend, we are not dealing with an ordinary enemy. He is trained, informed, and has a history of accumulation.

Eric MacArthur   January 11th, 2009 3:50 pm ET

I don't understand all these protests? Why weren't they protesting to over 200 rockets that were sent into Israel by these "wonderful" people.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 3:51 pm ET

Rueters just announced that Israeli soldiers were fired on at the Golan Heights....

Kill them wherever you find them...

Joan   January 11th, 2009 3:51 pm ET

mohammed,

i agree that the passages should be opened, nut they are closed now and I can't do anything about that., especially if HAmas are firing rockets. Although I don't agree with constantly looking back, the passages have not always been closed. So, yes, open the passages if Gaza agress not to use them for weapons and sticks to it.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 3:53 pm ET

mohammed,

who are you fooling???

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 3:54 pm ET

Tariq,
As usual, you have made me think. And as usual, I believe you to be correct in Sun Tzu’s number one rule, although it’s been a long time since I have completely read the treatise. Must say it was extremely useful in change management in an office setting.

I agree that every life is valuable, regardless of race, religion, or creed. If you, as a Muslim, and every Muslim is willing to die for your belief, and every Jew and Christian die for his/her belief, well, that’s OK in my book. But does it mean that I, to defend my belief, must kill everyone who does not believe exactly as I believe? We all believe in the same God, are not our faiths willing to accept variation?

I have two very close friends whom I consider familial sisters. Although we have different faiths, many times we celebrate each other’s holy days with each other and pray together. This is good. There is a passage in the Bible’s new testament, I can’t remember which book, that says something to the effect that “God” doesn’t care how a person worships, it’s what in his heart that matters. When I read it, the passage just stuck in my mind. To me, this is tolerance, although my sister swears I am going to a very hot spot because I pray with my Muslim sister.

Yes, this war has a profound influence on the world, and eventually it will involve everybody. I am an optimist, as I said, I believe in the goodness in people. We can stop humanity’s head long rush into destruction if we, Muslim, Jew, Christian

clayton   January 11th, 2009 3:54 pm ET

LETS WIN IT

Professor   January 11th, 2009 3:55 pm ET

Occupied people will always resist their occupation.... with stones if they do not have any weapons but if they can smuggle weapons from anywhere then they will and its their right to do so....

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 3:56 pm ET

Tariq,

Think my post left off some. I meant to say

Yes, this war has a profound influence on the world, and eventually it will involve everybody. I am an optimist, as I said, I believe in the goodness in people. We can stop humanity’s head long rush into destruction if we, Muslim, Jew, Christian, Buddhist, Hindu, all others together, lead the way and set an example.

One of the disadvantages of using Word for spell check and grammar, since I am not a good typer.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 3:57 pm ET

Morning Lynne,
Well, said

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 3:58 pm ET

Professor?
Showing your true colors, aren't you? Go find some kids to hide behind quickly! I think your mother is looking for you.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 3:59 pm ET

Israel is and will never be ready for peace. The Saudi idea that was backed up by the whole arab league is simple: give us our land (ocuppied in 1967) and let the refugees return back to their lands and we will normalize all our relations with you. The answer, of course, was a big NNNOOOOOOOOOO. One of the excuses advanced is the fact that Hamas says in its charter " I will wipe Israel from the land" and that Hamas should acknowledge the existence of Israel.This is dumb from a political angle. Hams will not change its view without being given some signs of good will. When the arab league says we will normalize relations, we mean what we say and we say what we mean. Inn other words, we will solve easily the problem you have with hamas. Basically Hamas draws its force from its Arab environment. The bottom line is this: Israel can not accept any peace deal by negociations. Picture this with me: the reaction of their party chass in case an agreement is reached.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:01 pm ET

I never hide my color... I am with the oppressed against the oppressors throught out my life.... and Isreali soldiers are a fair target practice.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 4:02 pm ET

Linda good morning

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:02 pm ET

Morning Mohammed,
I wanted to ask you a question.
you wrote"
his is dumb from a political angle. Hams will not change its view without being given some signs of good will.

Didn't Israel leave Gaza a couple of years ago? Why was that not a show of good faith?

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:03 pm ET

jonas
sorry,to interfere, but what you say to prof. shows that you, like your country, really live an existential crisis. Either you are not of age or you suffer for a psycho problem. G OAND HAVE SOME SLEEP. WE DISCUSS HERE. WE DON4T INSULT PEOPLE WHO KNOW MORE THAN YOU DO.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:04 pm ET

Morning Rod,
How are you this morning?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:04 pm ET

Oh sorry I forgot to exclude the good refuznicks who refused to serve the Israeli expansionist agenda.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 4:04 pm ET

Robert Fisk: Why do they hate the West so much, we will ask

So once again, Israel has opened the gates of hell to the Palestinians. Forty civilian refugees dead in a United Nations school, three more in another. Not bad for a night's work in Gaza by the army that believes in "purity of arms". But why should we be surprised?

Have we forgotten the 17,500 dead – almost all civilians, most of them children and women – in Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon; the 1,700 Palestinian civilian dead in the Sabra-Chatila massacre; the 1996 Qana massacre of 106 Lebanese civilian refugees, more than half of them children, at a UN base; the massacre of the Marwahin refugees who were ordered from their homes by the Israelis in 2006 then slaughtered by an Israeli helicopter crew; the 1,000 dead of that same 2006 bombardment and Lebanese invasion, almost all of them civilians?

Rod   January 11th, 2009 4:05 pm ET

I am doing ok linda and you?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:06 pm ET

Linda,

becuase it kept Gaza under siege thoughtout that period. That is an act of war by itself....

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:06 pm ET

I have sleep eyes this morning, but doing fine, thank you

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:07 pm ET

Oh, I see Professor, Thank you for your answer

Joan   January 11th, 2009 4:09 pm ET

professor,

"occupied people will always resit their occupation ... it is their right"

Hmm, here we go with history and trying to justify the present with the past. guess what, the world changes, it doesn't stand still. I guess it's okay for you to embrace the change of the internet. Really, please stop with the ridiculous platitudes and start loking for change not more of the same!!!

Rod   January 11th, 2009 4:09 pm ET

Robert Fisk

"I've reported the excuses the Israeli army has served up in the past for these outrages. Since they may well be reheated in the coming hours, here are some of them: that the Palestinians killed their own refugees, that the Palestinians dug up bodies from cemeteries and planted them in the ruins, that ultimately the Palestinians are to blame because they supported an armed faction, or because armed Palestinians deliberately used the innocent refugees as cover."

Sarah   January 11th, 2009 4:10 pm ET

Akiva January 11th, 2009 1604 GMT

ABOUT White Phosphorus as a weapon! And Depleted Urainium?

How come I haven't seen this in US media? While US media keeps getting " biased" label...from people, why won't they tell the People in the west this? Oh, but I'm watching the wrong news? :(

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:10 pm ET

Rod,

Israeli massacres against Palestinians are countless no wonder the whole world developped hatred to Jews.... if Jews will not stand up against Zionist Israel they will never change how the world will look at them.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 4:11 pm ET

Mohammad,
In order to understand, I had to go back to the underlying factors causing the UN creation of Israel in 1946/1947/1948.

Judging from the Peel commission report (1937) and the Arab Office Report to the Anglo-American Committee, I see that one viable option is the single state solution where one group does not dominate another. If I believe in the solution as presented in these reports, I would have to say yes, refugees have the right to return.

There is one Jewish fear that must be solved, however, for this to be a reality. And I take this from the comments of the Arab Office Report:

“A Palestinian put the matter thus: "In the hearts of us Jews there has always been a fear that some day this country would be turned into an Arab State and the Arabs would rule over us. This fear has at times reached the proportions of terror . . . Now this same feeling of fear has started up in the hearts of Arabs . . . fear lest the Jews acquire the ascendancy and rule over them”

Sarah   January 11th, 2009 4:12 pm ET

er, reading? the wrong news? ...as I am one US who does read?...........;)

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:12 pm ET

Linda
the real question is :Why did israel move from gaza?
well sharon had aplan ; he realized that there is no need for keeping the strip and that the best solution is to leave it. By this step, he wanted to reach two objectives. The first one is the avoidance of casualties by resistance and the second is the creation of a tension between hamas and fattah on that territory. he knew that hama has the majority there and that if it takes control, we wii end up with two palestinian authorities.
The overall purpose is to leave no choice for Gazzans (by preventing food, medicine, and humanitarian aid) but to throw itself on egypt, while at the same time throwing the west bank on Jordan. and of coursr the scenario is still going on. now we hear of bringing peace keeping forces to the borders between gaza and israel. thjis means the end of the palestinian cause.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 4:13 pm ET

Sarah

because USA is manipulatin the west
because CNN is not a free press
because people are stupid and never ask what is going on in the world
because the west is censoring the same way as china

what answer you wanna choose ... take one of them

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 4:13 pm ET

Hey Linda,

Big Howdy! Just saw that you have arrived.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:14 pm ET

Joan,

Resisting occupation does not change by length of time.... read more of the history.... If you do not know your history then you do not have future.

You are welcome Linda... its my duty with pleasure. :)

Sarah,

Read Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch reports don't wait for the media to report it to you.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 4:14 pm ET

From the Article in the Independent :

"Israel claimed the bodies of children killed in a second Qana massacre may have been taken from a graveyard. It was another lie. The Marwahin massacre was never excused. The people of the village were ordered to flee, obeyed Israeli orders and were then attacked by an Israeli gunship. The refugees took their children and stood them around the truck in which they were travelling so that Israeli pilots would see they were innocents. Then the Israeli helicopter mowed them down at close range. Only two survived, by playing dead. Israel didn't even apologize."

the complete article
http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/fisk/robert-fisk-why-do-they-hate-the-west-so-much-we-will-ask-1230046.html

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:15 pm ET

Sarah,
Actually, I looked this up because of the constant posts on the subject of White phosphorous.. Here is a quote:
"One of the main uses of phosphorous shells is to create smoke and mask ground forces, which is legal under international law, but the chemical can be harmful if used in densely populated areas."

So this is the truth about White phosphorous.

Eric MacArthur   January 11th, 2009 4:15 pm ET

1. ISRAEL BECAME A STATE IN 1312 B.C., TWO MILLENNIA BEFORE ISLAM;

2. ARAB REFUGEES FROM ISRAEL BEGAN CALLING THEMSELVES "PALESTINIANS" IN 1967, TWO DECADES AFTER (MODERN) ISRAELI STATEHOOD;

3. AFTER CONQUERING THE LAND IN 1272 B.C., JEWS RULED IT FOR A THOUSAND YEARS AND MAINTAINED A CONTINUOUS PRESENCE THERE FOR 3,300 YEARS;

4. THE ONLY ARAB RULE FOLLOWING CONQUEST IN 633 A.D. LASTED JUST 22 YEARS;

5. FOR OVER 3,300 YEARS, JERUSALEM WAS THE JEWISH CAPITAL. IT WAS NEVER THE CAPITAL OF ANY ARAB OR MUSLIM ENTITY. EVEN UNDER JORDANIAN RULE, (EAST) JERUSALEM WAS NOT MADE THE CAPITAL, AND NO ARAB LEADER CAME TO VISIT IT;

6. JERUSALEM IS MENTIONED OVER 700 TIMES IN THE BIBLE, BUT NOT ONCE IS IT MENTIONED IN THE QUR'AN;

7. KING DAVID FOUNDED JERUSALEM; MOHAMMED NEVER SET FOOT IN IT;

8. JEWS PRAY FACING JERUSALEM; MUSLIMS FACE MECCA. IF THEY ARE BETWEEN THE TWO CITIES, MUSLIMS PRAY FACING MECCA, WITH THEIR BACKS TO JERUSALEM;

9. IN 1948, ARAB LEADERS URGED THEIR PEOPLE TO LEAVE, PROMISING TO CLEANSE THE LAND OF JEWISH PRESENCE. 68% OF THEM FLED WITHOUT EVER SETTING EYES ON AN ISRAELI SOLDIER;

10. VIRTUALLY THE ENTIRE JEWISH POPULATION OF MUSLIM COUNTRIES HAD TO FLEE AS THE RESULT OF VIOLENCE AND POGROMS;

11. SOME 630,000 ARABS LEFT ISRAEL IN 1948, WHILE CLOSE TO A MILLION JEWS WERE FORCED TO LEAVE THE MUSLIM COUNTRIES;

12. IN SPITE OF THE VAST TERRITORIES AT THEIR DISPOSAL, ARAB REFUGESS WERE DELIBERATELY PREVENTED FROM ASSIMILATING INTO THEIR HOST COUNTRIES. OF 100 MILLION REFUGEES FOLLOWING WORLD WAR 2, THEY ARE THE ONLY GROUP TO HAVE NEVER INTEGRATED WITH THEIR CORELIGIONISTS. MOST OF THE JEWISH REFUGEES FROM EUROPE AND ARAB LANDS WERE SETTLED IN ISRAEL, A COUNTRY NO LARGER THAN NEW JERSEY;

13. THERE ARE 22 MUSLIM COUNTRIES, NOT COUNTING PALESTINE. THERE IS ONLY ONE JEWISH STATE. ARABS STARTED ALL FIVE WARS AGAINST ISRAEL, AND LOST EVERY ONE OF THEM;

14. FATAH AND HAMAS CONSTITUTIONS STILL CALL FOR THE DESTRUCTION OF ISRAEL. ISRAEL CEDED MOST OF THE WEST BANK AND ALL OF GAZA TO THE PALESTINIAN AUTHORITY, AND EVEN PROVIDED IT WITH ARMS;

15. DURING THE JORDANIAN OCCUPATION, JEWISH HOLY SITES WERE VANDALIZED AND WERE OFF LIMITS TO JEWS. UNDER ISRAELI RULE, ALL MUSLIM AND CHRISTIAN HOLY SITES ARE ACCESSIBLE TO ALL FAITHS;

16. OUT OF 175 UNITED NATIONS SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTIONS UP TO 1990, 97 WERE AGAINST ISRAEL; OUT OF 690 GENERAL ASSEMBLY RESOLUTIONS, 429 WERE AGAINST ISRAEL;

17. THE U.N. WAS SILENT WHEN THE JORDANIANS DESTROYED 58 SYNAGOGUES IN THE OLD CITY OF JERUSALEM. IT REMAINED SILENT WHILE JORDAN SYSTEMATICALLY DESECRATED THE ANCIENT JEWISH CEMETERY ON THE MOUNT OF OLIVES, AND IT REMAINED SILENT WHEN JORDAN ENFORCED APARTHEID LAWS PREVENTING JEWS FROM ACCESSING THE TEMPLE MOUNT AND WESTERN WALL.

mackawee   January 11th, 2009 4:16 pm ET

Soory guys, but I can't help feeling that for most in Israel, they can get free from fear it self. There is alway cospercy against them. Everywhere and all the time others are against them. When will they break free. This fear is feeding hate. What will bring them peace, money,position or power. No one is against you. It's only you. They might think they are special, but they are not. They are humans just like you and me. It's is just the idea that they are special makes them in constant fear from others. Wake up and look what you are doing instead of talking about what have been done to you.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:17 pm ET

update: source Alkassam media source Aljazeera

Object: casualties inthe Israeli army
32 killed
41 sniped
305 injured

Sarah   January 11th, 2009 4:17 pm ET

I pick all of them...
But be sure to include not just CNN .....
:)

Rod   January 11th, 2009 4:18 pm ET

Eric MacArthur , GOOD FABRICATION, nice job

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 4:18 pm ET

Hi Rod,
I just scrolled up and found your greeting.
Hope you're having a good morning.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:19 pm ET

Wow Eric.... a list of lies that does not even deserve an answer.... What drug are you on?

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:19 pm ET

Is anyone here, that is so against Israel hitting schools with bombs, condeming Hamas for hitting a school in Israel with a rocket today? I am!

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 4:20 pm ET

Sahra

about the west ... special the US press
which is sooo freeeeee
and never manipulate ... never talk what some people wanna let them talk

la.indymedia.org/news/2003/04/47530.php
check this out
ask your self who is how free because of what in the west;)

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:24 pm ET

Linda,

No.... let me tell you why....

Israel claims superiority over Hamas.... not according to me but according to Israeli politicians....

So, if you have a superior army and the latest technology.... when you hit a school that means you were targeting it and you hit your target.... but when Hamas is using primitive rockets that they cannot aim well then if a rocket fell on a school that means it was hit by mistake and the school was not targeted..... How is that for an explanation? Using Israeli claims.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 4:24 pm ET

Mohammad,

Well, that's a legitimate hypothesis on Sharon's motives for withdrawal. I've posted earlier this that my hypothesis to Gazans' current suffering is politically motivated on both Kadima's and Hamas' agenda, and not for actual concern about the populaces they respectively serve.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:25 pm ET

Linda
they use a new gas called idia which burns the most exposed places in the body. watch aljazeear and you ll see one little boy who has become blind this morning a nd yesterday a beatiful little girl lost both of legs when she was playing on the roof of her house.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 4:25 pm ET

Professor,

You can't really be a professor if you think that history dictates teh future. Try looking forward instead of back. You can't turn the clock back. What's happening now is what matters. YOu can't even change that , you can only only change what happens tomorrow. And if you try to use history to change it how can you go anywhere but backward, which is impossible. Really, wake up!!!

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:26 pm ET

Professor,
Hitting a school is hitting a school. Either way, you are terrorizing, injuring, and killing children.
I am sad that you don't see that. If everyone is going to cry for the children, the Israeli children are just as much as children as the Palestinian children.

Sarah   January 11th, 2009 4:27 pm ET

Linda,

Ithanks, That was in the "foreign" report I read.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:28 pm ET

Eric
What are your sources? the Zionist booklet. By the way, I am jesus christ

mackawee   January 11th, 2009 4:28 pm ET

Eric MackArthur, Look again in the bibel and the tora. Look at the start by Abraham. We did he came from, his journy, the place he setteled and the people of the land he lived in peace with.

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 4:28 pm ET

Joan,

"Try looking forward instead of back. You can’t turn the clock back. What’s happening now is what matters. YOu can’t even change that , you can only only change what happens tomorrow."

Amen to that, sister.

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 4:28 pm ET

Words of Wisdom for today:

"Out beyond ideas of right-doing and wrong-doing, there is a field; I'll meet you there." Rumi, Persian Poet and Sufi.

harvey   January 11th, 2009 4:28 pm ET

Mackawee,

I live in Isarel and even now I am full of hope not fear.

It was hope that inspired us to give Sadat and Egypt land for a piece of paper recognising our right to exist and for the promise of peace (and thus decreasing our security.

It was hope that inspired us to do the same with Hussein of Jordan.

It was hope that acted as an incentive for Rabin and Peres to shake the hand of Arafat (ultimately Arafat turned his back on the peace process).

We still have hope in the goodness and kindness of people Arab and Jew everywhere to co-exist in peace.

I wrote yesterday about a program where Jewish and Palestinian kids play soccer together. Watching those kids play inspires me with hope for our future. We need to build together and we need to find like minded people and partners who believe in celebrating the diversity of our differences!

Thanks

I

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:29 pm ET

Mohammed,
I was talking about White phosphorus. Someone keeps posting about it and I found the truth,
Thank you for the additional info in Idia. I will research that

Sarah   January 11th, 2009 4:29 pm ET

January 11th, 2009 1619 GMT

Is anyone here, that is so against Israel hitting schools with bombs, condeming Hamas for hitting a school in Israel with a rocket today? I am!

Yes.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:30 pm ET

Linda,

when I see you crying for the Palestinian children I will show you my tears for the Israeli children. Until then prove to me that your concern with the Palestinian children is genuine and not just to play politics.

Eric MacArthur   January 11th, 2009 4:30 pm ET

I haven't seen any apology for the over 200 rockets sent into Israel before the Gaza incursion.

I would fight back just as Israel is.

Also, calling my facts lies doesn't make them that...

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:31 pm ET

Joan
You keep talking about forgetting the past and focusing on the future. well, you must have a problem with past; have you stolen something from someone and you want us to be amnesic about it. Well, in your dreams.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 4:31 pm ET

Professor,
Regarding rockets. Here you go mixing old and new and trying to explain things with it. How about: Hamas should take responsibility because they are firing blind. How irresponsible is that??

I also condemn Isreal's attacks, but, really, Hamas can't be so stupid that they don't know they are firing blind. That is absolutley no excuse!!!!!!

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 4:31 pm ET

Hey, hey, hi AJ,

Glad you're here. You disappeared early last night.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:32 pm ET

AJ,

nice choice of words.... I love that quote.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:33 pm ET

linda
you did not answer me about the sharon argument; i would like to have your opinion.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:34 pm ET

Professor,
I followed A J's lead yesterday, writing a letter to everyone in my government, to stop this was and find a way for peace. What about you? Prove to me you care

Professor   January 11th, 2009 4:34 pm ET

Eric,

they are lies even if we do not call them that... what a waste of air you are....

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 4:35 pm ET

AJ,

I also like your quote. We must all keep that in mind in our discussions. Maybe in our blindness we will stumble on mutually acceptable solutions.

I am glad of diversity.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:36 pm ET

Mohammed,
Sorry, I must have missed the post, I will scroll back up

Joan   January 11th, 2009 4:37 pm ET

mohammed,

I have done nothing wrong in my past that I want to forget. ON the other hans, people have done wrong to me. Did I spend my time and energy trying to bet back at them. No. I have always used my own resources to improve my own life. That takes everything I have, I have nothing left for futile revenge. I live comfortable in a life of my own making. Those who have taken things from me, or wronged me, well, I don't know how they are doing. It doesn't matter.,

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:38 pm ET

The use of the burning gas (IDIA) makes me wonder about the desire of the Israeli army to BURN. Has this to do with happended to them in Germany (although there scholars who deny its existence) ; i mean a kind of psycho sequels?

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:39 pm ET

Mohammed,
Ok, I found it, You said that Sharon had a plan. I'm sure he did, but I was not in his cabinet, and I don't think you were. I think you are speculating or listening to rumor

Maria   January 11th, 2009 4:40 pm ET

Joan

"Hmm, here we go with history and trying to justify the present with the past."

I'm sure that you would like to see Gazans as a history ...

How sad ...
I feel pitty for you.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:41 pm ET

Mohammed,
Can you please posts some links to them using idia, and reports about idia?
Thanks

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 4:41 pm ET

hi linda

if you scrol up you will find that you were accused by one of the israel bashers on being on some israeli or zionist payroll to spread lies and propaganda

i find that very funny

mackawee   January 11th, 2009 4:42 pm ET

harvey, I said most in Israel not all. Mr. Gedon from Haretz said that in Israel, they don't care about what happened at the other side, they only look at the numbers of solders killed at theit side. By the way he said that he is ashamed about what Israel is doing now in Gaza.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:42 pm ET

jOAN
For me, as a person you are not important; but the issue you discuss is. When I told you that you want us to forget about our past I MEANT that you have a problem with the past (israel) as if you have stolen something (palestine). I WAS NOT TALKING ABOUT YOU BUT ABOUT THE JEWISH STATE.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 4:43 pm ET

Professor,

You say taht occupied peole will always resist, and I assume you classify teh Hamas rockets as resistance. Really. how can it be resistance? The rockets are not 'resisting' anything. They are just inviting retaliation.They are totally ineffective as resistance.

Would you walk into a gas field with your children and light a match to protest the existance of teh gas field. That is not resistance that is stupidity.

Violent resistance againt superior power does not work.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:46 pm ET

Morning Dan,
Good to see you

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 4:46 pm ET

Hi all,

I see no one has answered my question

When I view photos taken from areas of intense fighting (such as Africa and in the past Serbia/Bosnia/Croatia), the children and very old appear to be in very bad condition, the women slightly behind them, but the young men warriors very well fed.

Why is that?

Now, this is going to seem pretty childish to all of you, but give me a break here.

My Siberian huskies have the attitude "C'mon in. I love all of you. Share my food, my toys, my comfortable spot on the couch. Scratch my belly, and I'll lick your face. But for goodness sake, let's just play".

I think that we all can learn from my huskies.

Speaking of huskies, it's time for our morning run. Be nice to each other, and "play siberian".

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:46 pm ET

Linda
By the way, DAN has not answered the question about the right of return demended by palestinians. When you talk to him, he will ask you about your opinion about a pregnant woman who was killed by someone. He repeats the same thing all the time. This is funny.

mackawee   January 11th, 2009 4:46 pm ET

harvey, I think that you have mentioned that Hamas didn't accept the arab peace inichative. I do'n't know about that. will you infor me more about it. Also ,did Israel accept it?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 4:47 pm ET

linda

mohammed finds it funny that hamas murdered a pregnant mother and her four daughters by headshoits and later bragged about it

this is the kind of people you try to take seriously

Joan   January 11th, 2009 4:49 pm ET

mohammed,

i know you do not care about me as a person. but the the issue is the same. you will not get rid of israel, so why waste so much energy trying. you are just wasting the future of yourself and your people, You say go ack to 1967. You can never go back, it is impossible. And even if the world did try, then why not go back further, and further, and further. Sorry, it's just not possible.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:49 pm ET

Linda
I have no links yet. I heard the news this morning from the commentary of an international expert in arms.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:50 pm ET

Mohammed,
Why are you telling me what DAN has not answered you

Men trying to get women into the middle of their fights, how typical!

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:50 pm ET

joan
We will see

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:52 pm ET

Dan,
Don't get me in the middle, I know who I can take seriously, and who I can not.
Thanks :)
I'm no fool

Joan   January 11th, 2009 4:52 pm ET

Got to go, bye everyone. And I wish you all peace and prosperity.

Eric MacArthur   January 11th, 2009 4:53 pm ET

The God of Abraham told him to cast the handmaiden and her child out.

He did!

If you have a problem with that then speak to the God of Abraham...

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 4:53 pm ET

linda
I mentioned you because he said that youll find only israel bashers (he keeps teeling me this). I DONT make you interfere in anything. I DONT NEED YOUR HELP.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:53 pm ET

Mohammed,
I just spoke to an expert on arms on the phone, he does not know what you are speaking about

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 4:54 pm ET

and i replied many times

no, the so-called refugees cannot come back to israel, there is no way israel will accept 4.5 mil (that is the number they use) supposedly the children, grand children and gret grand children of the so-called original refugees

they can go to the palestinian state under the two state solution

just as the germans from koengsberg, danzig and breslau left the refugee camps after two yeras and sttled all over germany, unlike the arab so-called refugees who are kept in refugee camps on purpose

Linda   January 11th, 2009 4:55 pm ET

Mohammed,
Then quit using me to try to make your point to Dan. Type to him directly.

EdM   January 11th, 2009 4:59 pm ET

eric,
Superb input, and response to these facts being called lies. If you get a chance, please see my input at 1534 GMT. Keep at it.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 5:02 pm ET

Oh so Dan now is the one who is making the decision for the refugees if they can or cannot go back?

harvey   January 11th, 2009 5:02 pm ET

Mackawee,

Mr Gedon from Haaretz is entitled to his opinion. We have free speech and we are allowed to disagree with our government. So good on him. With respect I disagree with him. But at least I can sit down and we can talk. Because his opinion is contrary to mine I do not prclaim that he is a closet Hamas member and therefore not worthy of a response.
My view is Hamas is deliberately waging a war at the expense of the very people that it purports to represent.
I totally reject that Israel is responsible for genocide. If we really wanted (God forbid) to wipe out the Palestinians we would have done it by carpet bombing Gaza. Our fight is with the terrorists of Hamas who quarter themselves in civillian areas and use hospitals and schools as their deadly bases replete with Human hostages.
At a rally in London today tens of thousands expressed their support for the action Israel is taking.
Please tell me, for the last several years we have been under constant, indiscriminate rocket fire by our neighbours. Our kids cannot go to school, our wives cannot do their shopping, our daily lives a constant siege of worrying when the next siren will sound and that you only have about 30 seconds to get to the nearest shelter.
We tried negotiation, we pulled out of Gaza, we tried a cease fire (that Hamas didn't keep to.
Finally we act...
Believe you me, I would really like to know if living with what we have lived with, how you would have reacted?
Thank you and please read this in line with my true hope. I would rather send my sons to play football with my neighbours than have to put up with my neighbours bombing me and than have to send my sons to stop them...
Thank you. And I still believe in hope...and I still believe that every person is important.
Again can we get back to celebrating the dignity of our differences.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:02 pm ET

SOME FINE QUOTATIONS/
-Perez: "the children of Gazza are enjoying the fresh air and the blue sky."
-Levni: "We don't say to the children of Gazza to leave Gazz, we tell them to go to safe places in Gazza".
-The coordinator of UNRWA:" There are no safe places in Gazza".
-The IDF spokesman:"We don't have any problem with the people of Gazza" (900 people dead most of whom are civilians).

Professor   January 11th, 2009 5:04 pm ET

EdM,

wow I did not realize that you were as stupid as Eric to believe that his lies are facts.... good to know that.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:06 pm ET

mohammed

you start to repeat youself

you showed your real ugly duisgusting face when you found it funny that hamas murdered a pregnant mother and her four daughters by headshots and later bragged about it

if you find that funny, then you are plain sick and should urgently seek medical help

mackawee   January 11th, 2009 5:07 pm ET

Eric, To begin with, the God of Abraham is my God. The handmaidn is the woman Abraham brought with him when he left Egypt. She has nothing to do with the people who lived in Palestina. You know the people Jashua first fought in Jerecho

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:08 pm ET

Linda
what is the name of this expert?

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:10 pm ET

dan
who said it was funny?this is typical; you change facts. I said it was funny that you repeat the same argument again and again.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 5:11 pm ET

Mohammed,
I was just being silly, just because you can type something, doe not make it true.
Get it?

harvey   January 11th, 2009 5:14 pm ET

Mackawee,

I am genuinely interested in your response?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:14 pm ET

mohammthis is not an argument, it is a fact'

are you ready to admit that?

as well as the lynching of the two soldiers in ramallah who made a wrong turn and the mutilation of their bodies?

i got more!!!!

Joan   January 11th, 2009 5:17 pm ET

mohammed,

what will i see ?

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:18 pm ET

linda
sorry no , i don't get it. This morning i hear the news in aljazeera talking about burnt patients with strange skin colors. then they interviewed someone (an american (i forgot his name) and they wrote an international expert in arms. He was the one to mention IDIA. i ll try to bring the sources in the next few hours.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 5:19 pm ET

if someone say...

"i would like to capture or kill "
is this a peacefull guy?
is he searching for peace?

ITME   January 11th, 2009 5:20 pm ET

Hi to ALL,

“We consider ourselves to be comrades in arms to the Palestinian Arabs in their struggle for the liberation of Palestine. There is not a single citizen in South Africa who is not ready to stand by his Palestinian brothers in their legitimate fight against the Zionist racists.” — Nelson Mandela
“I should much rather see reasonable agreement with the Arabs on the basis of living together in peace than the creation of a Jewish state. Apart from practical consideration, my awareness of the essential nature of Judaism resists the idea of a Jewish state with borders, an army, and a measure of temporal power no matter how modest. I am afraid of the inner damage Judaism will sustain — especially from the development of a narrow nationalism within our own ranks, against which we have already had to fight strongly, even without a Jewish state.” — Albert Einstein, 1932.
“My sympathies are all with the Jews…But my sympathy does not blind me to the requirements of justice. The cry for the national home for the Jews does not make much appeal to me…Palestine belongs to the Arabs in the same sense that England belongs to the English or France to the French. It is wrong and inhuman to impose the Jews on the Arabs. What is going on in Palestine today cannot be justified by any moral code of conduct. The mandates have no sanction but that of the last war. Surely it would be a crime against humanity to reduce the proud Arabs so that Palestine can be restored to the Jews partly or wholly as their national home.” — Gandhi, 1938

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:20 pm ET

talking about terrorist cruelty, all the suicide bombers used bombs filled with screws and metal balls to cause max human damage

heroes

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:21 pm ET

What do you want me to say?
this is bad but inevitable under occupation.

karl   January 11th, 2009 5:22 pm ET

I can not believe that all we hear is down with the USA and now you are upset that we sit on the sidelines......Want your cake and eat it too!
To bad, stop the rockets and and you wouldn't be in this situation. The real problem is you folks have been fighting each other before the usa was born , nothing we do or say will ever change the haterd that was there before we were even a country , try loving each other first and maybe you might get somewhere. And I dodn't see that happing.

harvey   January 11th, 2009 5:24 pm ET

Dan is correct.
Sadly it is a fact along with many other atrocities.
The challenge my friends is to stop swapping atrocity stories and recounting the terrible injustices done in history to both sides and to move on!
To build instaed of destroy.
Till we are willing to take a long hard look at ourselves...we won't move on.
I believe that the majority of the Israeli public want peace. I also believe that first of all the conditions in order to make that peace possible need to be put in place by both sides. That means both sides need to feel secure.
I know us sraelis are prepared to take a long hard look at ourselves, criticise our leaders. We did not choose this path of violence....our history shows that if the hand of peace is extended we will take it...Jordan and Egypt being the prime examples.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 5:24 pm ET

Mohammed
Sorry you don't get it.
As far as I am concerned, if you can not back it up, then I can not rely on the information. As far as anyone knows, without back up information, how do we know where those burns came from? For all we know, Hamas tried to mix up something, and it backfired. The leader of Hamas was speaking on TV this morning, and said himself, that the Hamas fighters were taking cover in homes of the Paleninstians. So Please send me your sources, when you have them
Thanks.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 5:24 pm ET

whahaha ... what a slippery guy at CNN ... he knows how to say nothing :)
good job CNN !

i laugh my ass of :) :D

Linda   January 11th, 2009 5:26 pm ET

Hello ITME, Welcome

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:27 pm ET

akiva

do you know how to shut up? or does your buddy professor for lies not allow you to?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 5:28 pm ET

The world must know that the Zionists have illegitimately seized the name Israel and have no right to speak in the name of the Jewish people!

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:28 pm ET

harvey the wealthy
Have you considered the mistake/error issue lol.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:28 pm ET

mohhammed

suicide bombing is inevitable?

gimme a break

ITME   January 11th, 2009 5:29 pm ET

Any one wanna comment on Nelson Mandela, Albert Einstein or Mahatma Gandhi above??

Professor   January 11th, 2009 5:31 pm ET

is Rabbi Dovid Weiss a self hating Jew?

akram   January 11th, 2009 5:31 pm ET

Damn! israel

fukin more then 850 innocent diet

bloddy creeps even using chemical bomb against innocent peoples fukin losers

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:31 pm ET

linda
Where did he say it? i want to check what the leader of Hamas said?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:32 pm ET

anyone wanna comment on the hamas charter?

anyone wanna comment on the fact that arab terror started before 1967, even long before 1948?

Tony Pate   January 11th, 2009 5:32 pm ET

How much longer with the US stand behind the kilings of children in Gaza? How much longer will the US support Israel in what is happening in hand of Israeli military fully supported by the US machines? When will the US wake up and see who the real instigator of the conflict...what the real causes are...and take a balanced approach? How long will the US keeps pumping $3 Billion of US tax money for killing the innocent children in Palestine? How many security council violations did Israel manged to get away with finally the last one in favor of Palestine....When When When will the US govt blindly stop supporting the terrorist Israeli regime and stand along with the rest of the WORLD in condemning the attrocities. Why is it ONLY the US government and many in religious rights condone the killings...is rest of the World opinion don't mean anything to US. HOW LONG WILL OBAMA BE SILENT? How much longer Palestinian children will suffer the horror of most hated country Israel now has become. DOES ISRAEL REALLY PRIDE UPON BEING THE MOST HATED COUNTRY IN WORLD?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 5:33 pm ET

"we did not know much about al quaida" ... wuahahaha
bush told us other things!!!!!!
he did know every fact!!!
what comes up now????

that hurts :))
cant beleve !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Linda   January 11th, 2009 5:35 pm ET

Mohammed,
They have been showing the clip on Fox News and CNN this morning

mackawee   January 11th, 2009 5:35 pm ET

Harvey, thank you for your response. Let me clarifiy one thing. I think that all palestinians have the right to resist. I don't agree with the way and method Hamas has chosen to resist. Yet I believe that this war could have been preventable. Even though I believe Israel has the right to defend it self, I don't agree with the way Israel has chosen. I think that you agree with me that we can always solves our problems peacefully. I'm specially horrified by the way this war has been conducted. I am intrested to discuss the prosbect of peace and the options available to achieve it.

akram   January 11th, 2009 5:35 pm ET

Died*

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:36 pm ET

dan
the things we see on tv give you a desire to blow not only yourself on these soldiers, but the blow the whole world.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 5:36 pm ET

Itme,
I'm not sure what comment you are looking for, but as for me, I take everyone's point of view into consideration

Maria   January 11th, 2009 5:37 pm ET

Yes Fawad

What did you expect ?
This is exactly the same as it was in 1939 when Hitler invade Poland.
There was a provocation too.
Civilians were attack from air as they were had to run and that was in Europe and whol world was watching that.
There was also propaganda about the Concentrations Camps.
They tried to cover that up. Even today some people dare to call that Camps in Poland as Polish Concentrations Camps.

Polish People whre helping Israeli people to escape from Gettos and mano of those brave people lost their lives becouse of that.

Then Polish soldiers were fighting all over the world to stop the Hitler and frankly they saved western asses many times.

Here we are again

akram   January 11th, 2009 5:38 pm ET

Israel should stop its unhumanatarian pathetic acts

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:39 pm ET

polish people were helping jews?

that is true, you only forget to say that they were a minority

Rod   January 11th, 2009 5:39 pm ET

Harvey,
you know the roots of the problem, don't you?
The occupation is. We all know that.
Hamas was created or at least supported by Israel. The Shin-Bet was behind their creation to rival the PLO. now Blaming the palestinians for something Israel wanted is non sense. this is genocide for people whom israel has been exploiting.

Israel knows Hamas charter and they supported them knowing it. now killing civilians because of the same charter is not an excuse.

the problem of the rockets did not start today. It started 10 years ago.
the total number of Israelis killed by rockets is 20 people ( everyone of them is very Important) in 10 years. Israel Killed over 850 people in 12 days. does that sound to you like a good response and a proportionate one.

I am sure you want peace as much as your palestinians neighbors.
Israel keeps lying to its people. the rockets were not why they went to war. they went to war because of the elections. Now we want to know how many innocent palestinians should be killed for the Israeli Election in February.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:40 pm ET

hams should stop its unhumanatarian pathetic acts

Maria   January 11th, 2009 5:42 pm ET

Dan
You have no idea what you talking about.
Go count the olive trees in Yadwashen (sorry I don't know how to spell that).
Then we will talk.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:42 pm ET

"you know the roots of the problem, don’t you?
The occupation is. We all know that."

another blatant lie

arab terror against jews is first documented in 1920,

it continued and was there before the "occupation" in 1967

so what nonsense, ROD

Professor   January 11th, 2009 5:42 pm ET

No Dan, we would like to talk about the Israeli terror that started in 1930s and continue until today.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:43 pm ET

Israel is and will never be ready for peace. The Saudi idea that was backed up by the whole arab league is simple: give us our land (ocuppied in 1967) and let the refugees return back to their lands and we will normalize all our relations with you. The answer, of course, was a big NNNOOOOOOOOOO. One of the excuses advanced is the fact that Hamas says in its charter ” I will wipe Israel from the land” and that Hamas should acknowledge the existence of Israel.This is dumb from a political angle. Hams will not change its view without being given some signs of good will. When the arab league says we will normalize relations, we mean what we say and we say what we mean. Inn other words, we will solve easily the problem you have with hamas. Basically Hamas draws its force from its Arab environment. The bottom line is this: Israel can not accept any peace deal by negociations. Picture this with me: the reaction of their party chass in case an agreement is reached.

Tony Pate   January 11th, 2009 5:44 pm ET

It is now very clear Israeli killings now be called war crimes and investigated by the world. How Israel created concentrated camps in Gaza very much like how it was done by Nazis. All supported by US tax dollars. Each one of us in the US pays for killing children in Palestine. It is time we ask the new president elect Obama to stop this maddness...stop veto of security council resolutions condemning Israeli killings and call for Israel to end the terroristic tactics and again join the Human race. Right now Israelis are acting as SATAN.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:44 pm ET

maria

i said there are some, but the majority did nothing, or even gave up jews to the nazis

maria, my parents were there, were you?

akram   January 11th, 2009 5:45 pm ET

dude hamas is fighting its nation fight which has been brudely undertaken by loser israel on the otha hand israel is provoking terrorism by doing terrorism.. by killin innocent peoples hamas fires the rocket in the area which has been occupied by israel..

and make a comparision from hamas rockets only 6 peoples killed nd in return israel killed more than 850 peoples and that show how physcotically retartd israel is.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 5:45 pm ET

"NEARLY SEVENTY YEARS ago, in the course of World War II, a heinous crime was committed in the city of Leningrad. For more than a thousand days, a gang of extremists called “the Red Army” held the millions of the town’s inhabitants hostage and provoked retaliation from the German Wehrmacht from inside the population centers. The Germans had no alternative but to bomb and shell the population and to impose a total blockade, which caused the death of hundreds of thousands.
Some time before that, a similar crime was committed in England. The Churchill gang hid among the population of London, misusing the millions of citizens as a human shield. The Germans were compelled to send their Luftwaffe and reluctantly reduce the city to ruins. They called it the Blitz.
This is the description that would now appear in the history books – if the Germans had won the war."

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:46 pm ET

DAN
Why dont israelis return back to the countries where they used to live in peace?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:47 pm ET

professor

since you have no clue, who cares what YOU like or don't like

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:49 pm ET

mohammed

why don't the palestiniansdreturn to the desert where they came from

SHIMON   January 11th, 2009 5:49 pm ET

HELLO

Professor   January 11th, 2009 5:51 pm ET

Dan,

Its the occupation stupid....

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:52 pm ET

Dan
where exactly in the desert?

Rod   January 11th, 2009 5:52 pm ET

the Nonsense is that the state of Israel Creates Hamas and supports them against PLO then kills Palestinians because of Hamas.

We have conducted the "Famine Experiment" ( Siege and Starvation)
now the "Genocide Experiment" in the State of Israel Labs, Gaza.
We should be so proud of our contribution to Humanity.
I am sure the US will benefit from these EXPERIMENTS!

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 5:53 pm ET

mohammed gharbawi
god question :D
i dont know ... wondering too :D
but dan cant answer it ... he is too intelectual and well educated to answer that :D ... so stupid :)

akram   January 11th, 2009 5:53 pm ET

dan

u seems to be sum pro israeli or sum israeli sycophant

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:54 pm ET

DAN
I HAVE BOUGHT AN OVEN YESTERDAY.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:55 pm ET

akram

pinglish not understand me difficult

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 5:56 pm ET

mohammed

then why don't you fire it up and stick your head inside

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 5:57 pm ET

AKIVA
he got his degree in a synagogue and they gave him a kappa as a certificate.

EdM   January 11th, 2009 5:57 pm ET

ITME
Not sure how Ghandi would have felt after he had to cave on the creation of Pakistan and the dislocation of around 8 million people to create a Muslim state that had never before existed to satiate Muslim demands for their own state. Maybe he would have had a different perspective after that experience. From Wikipedia: "Gandhi was vehemently opposed to any plan that partitioned India into two separate countries. An overwhelming majority of Muslims living in India, side by side with Hindus and Sikhs, were in favour of Partition[citation needed]. Additionally Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the leader of the Muslim League, commanded widespread support in West Punjab, Sindh, North-West Frontier Province and East Bengal[citation needed]. The partition plan was approved by the Congress leadership as the only way to prevent a wide-scale Hindu-Muslim civil war. Congress leaders knew that Gandhi would viscerally oppose partition, and it was impossible for the Congress to go ahead without his agreement, for Gandhi's support in the party and throughout India was strong. Gandhi's closest colleagues had accepted partition as the best way out, and Sardar Patel endeavoured to convince Gandhi that it was the only way to avoid civil war. A devastated Gandhi gave his assent." So it looks to me like he wanted people to live together in peace but the threats of violence by Muslims and Hindus over-rode that position that he had for his entire life. So, if we were to want to follow in Ghandi's way, non-violence is that way. Live together in peace.

akram   January 11th, 2009 5:57 pm ET

Dan

what?? :O

wieardo!

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 6:00 pm ET

youtube.com/watch?v=-pTX4d6B6_k
CNN: Who really broke the cease-fire Israel or Hamas

israel did lie to us?
what do they talk about?

Rod   January 11th, 2009 6:02 pm ET

Interesting article for all who want to learn more about israeli politics and their propaganda machine by an Israeli Writer:

"Almost all the Western media initially repeated the official Israeli propaganda line. They almost entirely ignored the Palestinian side of the story, not to mention the daily demonstrations of the Israeli peace camp. The rationale of the Israeli government (“The state must defend its citizens against the Qassam rockets”) has been accepted as the whole truth. The view from the other side, that the Qassams are a retaliation for the siege that starves the one and a half million inhabitants of the Gaza Strip, was not mentioned at all."

Uri Avnery
How Many Divisions?
complete article:
http://www.avnery-news.co.il/english/index.html

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 6:02 pm ET

Dan
In the booklet, they wrote it for people like you , i mean: **** (the four letters word).

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 6:03 pm ET

mohammed gharbawi
he got his ... what ? ... degree?
are you talking about dan and degree?
watch out TV are there not enough jockes :)
today is comey day or what?

Tony Pate   January 11th, 2009 6:05 pm ET

Palestinians are being killed not because of Hamas or because of rockets or hand-thrown rocks. Palestinians burn and bleed because they are the non-Jewish natives of that land. There is no other reason. Just like Jews in the past were killed for being Jewish. Palestinians today are killed for being the Muslims and Christians who hold historic, legal and even genetic title to that land.

Rod   January 11th, 2009 6:05 pm ET

Robert Fisk: Why do they hate the West so much, we will ask

"What is amazing is that so many Western leaders, so many presidents and prime ministers and, I fear, so many editors and journalists, bought the old lie; that Israelis take such great care to avoid civilian casualties. "Israel makes every possible effort to avoid civilian casualties," yet another Israeli ambassador said only hours before the Gaza massacre. And every president and prime minister who repeated this mendacity as an excuse to avoid a ceasefire has the blood of last night's butchery on their hands. Had George Bush had the courage to demand an immediate ceasefire 48 hours earlier, those 40 civilians, the old and the women and children, would be alive."

http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/fisk/robert-fisk-why-do-they-hate-the-west-so-much-we-will-ask-1230046.html

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 6:08 pm ET

update: source Alkassam media source Aljazeera

Object: casualties inthe Israeli army
32 killed
41 sniped
305 injured

Beny   January 11th, 2009 6:09 pm ET

The word "occupation" means a lot of different things.

To most Arabs it means Israel's existence.
That's what the Palestinians mean when they say they're fighting the occupation.
That's what Mahmoud and Solomon mean when they say "end the occupation".
I am really not in favor of ending that.

To most Europeans it means our military presence in the West Bank and control of the passes to Gaza. To that I say that if only you could have seen the HUGE number of suicide bombers trying to pass through those passes...
Calling THAT "occupation" is like calling a security line in an airport (which are needed thanks to you Muslim terrorists) as "occupation" of the airport.

Same goes for the West Bank. When you have a crime-ridden city you send policemen to patrol the streets. You impose a curfew and you arrest the criminals.
When you have terrorist-ridden cities like Jenin and Ramallah and others, you send soldiers to patrol the streets. Stop sending terrorists from there, we stop the arrests and patrols.

Once again I ask you: Describe the "occupation" you talk of. Don't give me links to propaganda videos, just say plainly what does the word "occupation" mean to you.

Nadeem   January 11th, 2009 6:11 pm ET

In my attempt to try to understand how on this blog many people are calling for more indiscriminate killing of Gazans, I came to some coclusions of my own. On one instance in earlier posts, I had a short discussion with Beny; "the IDF representative" on this blog and asked him if he thinks palestinian civilians deserve to die, and his answer was YES asking me not to be hasty to call him a "bloodthirsty Zionist". His justification to his conclusion was that gazans deserved to die because they support Hamas, and that Hamas brought this on them...

Of course, there are people like Beny on both sides of the conflict who are clearly blinded by some form of tribalism and continue to justify killings after 15 days of the attacks on Gaza. I ask you to check this article that explains how "Extreme emotional and cultural identification with one side leads people to believe that X is good when done by them and evil when done to them".

http://www.salon.com/opinion/greenwald/2009/01/04/terrorism/index.html

Nadeem, Lebanon

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 6:11 pm ET

akiva
yes dan

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 6:13 pm ET

linda its called "DIME". sorry

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 6:14 pm ET

Rod

a interessting link thanks :D

here one more ....
http://www.thehandstand.org/archive/december2005/articles/zionistmyth.htm
watch out around....
"Hebrew work for Hebrew workers"
is this how israel define peace ?
yeahhh peace love and seperaty :(

take a look at this
and dont compare it with hitler which did say "german work for germans"

israel ready for nuthouse?
flee from the nazis ... and after all the pain they do the same?

are these israelians choosen by god to be dumb?

Linda   January 11th, 2009 6:15 pm ET

Nadeem,
My answer would be no, they do not deserve to die.

Rod,
Thanks for the links, very interesting. I would also agree with the paragraph that speaks about propaganda, and not just on one side.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 6:15 pm ET

thanks Mohammed,
Now I can research it.

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 6:16 pm ET

see what happened to the palestinian child who talks now on aljazeera; he has become blind by an unknown gaz.

harvey   January 11th, 2009 6:17 pm ET

Rod,

I appreciate your points of view.
However, I live here and you don't. So perhaps my view point is a little closer to the ground.
The people of Sderot especially have suffered for years. They cannot live normal lives. The sirens have gone off consistently day in, day out. They cannot live under this intolerable strain. Obama when he visited too admitted that he would do everything possible to protect his family.
The government are reacting to the will of the people to live normal lives. The government have a duty to protect its citizens. At this point in time the electioneering is very much a side issue. Stopping the rockets is the main issue as far as we, the Israeli public is concerned.
We are not prepared to sit and be shelled at, while HAMAS seek and get further sophisticated weaponry to penetrate further and further into Israel. If we sit and do nothing they will bomb us with impunity. Truth is they don't care who they hit, maim, kill or wound.
Please include suicide bombings and all other acts of terror carried out by Hamas in your tally....you will find that many more of us have been slaughtered.
Frankly Rod, I would rather have your condemnations than your commiserations. We have to stop the rockets....

You may not like this answer, but it is the way I see things....Believe you me I wish there was another alternative than having to send our boys to war and our daughters in the army to help look after terrorised kids in bomb shelters...

Truth is Hamas bears root responsibility for all those Gaza deaths as it is deliberately waging war at the expense of the people it has a duty to look after and represent.

And please I am not interested in the past and who is to blame and justifications as to who did what. I am interested in the where do we go from here? Hopefully as I have expressed countless times on this blog to a lasting peace with recognition of everybodys right to live.

Meanwhile my boys go to war. And as an Israeli leader said I can forgive the arabas for killing our children but I cannot forgive them for making my children kill therir children. sadly there will be peace only when Hamas learn to love their children more than they hate us!

mohammed gharbawi   January 11th, 2009 6:19 pm ET

the american organization "human rights watch": Israel commits a crime against humanity.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 6:22 pm ET

Mohammed,
DIME is not knew, they have accused Israel of using this since 2006.
Here is info on DIME if anyone wants it.

Dense Inert Metal Explosive (DIME) is uniquely suited for Low Collateral Damage. It produces lower pressure but increased impulse in the near field. Far Field damage is reduced (no frags/ impulse rolloff). The lethal footprint can be tuned to precision footprint. Strike Weapon Scaling Tests were completed in August of 2004), and full-scale Mk-82 tests were in the planning stage as of early 2005. DARPA funded RPG defense system feasibility tests in January 2005, which were successful.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 6:27 pm ET

Cheney: Doesn't matter that we haven't captured bin Laden.
youtube.com/watch?v=BF9M-LwduXM

if someone is able to post the whole interview ... post it ... i am interessted ... because the rest what he is talking is ...

...cant explain... just crazy ... one part was...
"we did not know much about al-quaeeda"
this interview is so crazy i laugh my ass off
and i ask my self why did bush let all his soilders suffer in a war of which he had no clue about ? thats a bit a sader part :( but we have to think by oure seldf about ... i search the whole interview ...
if someone find it ...thats comedy pure!
post that :D

crazyyyyyy!

side lines   January 11th, 2009 6:33 pm ET

Recently a man shot his own 2 yr old son so he doesnt have to pay alimony. A mother microwaved 1 month old infant. A war veteran raped a 6 month old girl in Detriot. A man tried to rape 4 year old boy in front of his mother and then shot the victim's mother. All recent news. Where does all this happen? This happens in the most civilized country that is also one of the most richest countires on the planet earth. School shootings, school teachers having sex with minors, priests molesting children...kids sold for sex, the stories go on...the relevence of this is, that when the media talks about these criminals, they always bring out their past life history..how they were raised in broken families, cruel circumustances, mental illnesses etc etc... SO when a person blows himself up, why doesnt this same media bring out his past life history to analyse what circumustances lead to this horrible ending? If you are the one who has lost parents, kids, friends,a home, a limb,a reason to live life, and thus have absolutely NOTHING to loose, what are your options?

Beny   January 11th, 2009 6:34 pm ET


Nadeem,

WHEREVER DID I SAY THAT INNOCENT PALESTINIANS DESERVE TO DIE?! I DID NOT SAY THAT AND I DO NOT BELIEVE IT. They don't deserve to die and, despite Hamas's greatest efforts to the contrary, IDF is doing maximum to avoid such deaths.

Tell me of a Muslim or European country that warned civilians, gave them chance to escape even into Israeli hospitals (which Hamas won't let them).

Tell me of a single country that fought terrorism more humanely than we did.

99% of those deaths could have been avoided if Hamas had not used the poor Palestinians as human shields

"there are people like Beny on both sides of the conflict who are clearly blinded by some form of tribalism"

And there are clearly people like Mahmoud or Solomon or Rod who are blinded by the Hamas indoctrination and propaganda to the simple fact that Hamas are sacrificing the Palestinians on the altar of Israel's destruction. They themselves, in the Hamas-Fatah clashes that are continuing as executions to this day (30 executed last week), have killed more innocent civilians than Israel has.

THEY ARE THEIR GREATEST ENEMY. NOT ME.

They're bashing the Palestinians against the floor, and the whole world accuses the floor. Both ignorant and hypocritical.

As for the Palestinians electing and supporting Hamas, I am willing to forgive them if only because all the suffering Hamas brought on them. And also from understanding that without forgiveness one cannot move forward.
However, if they elect and support someone like Hamas AGAIN, I'm going to seriously wonder whether they have some sort of masochism.

Daren   January 11th, 2009 6:35 pm ET

The whole war is totally stupid. The egos of the 2 different groups of politicians are what is killing people on both ends. My heart specially goes out to the children who are the only victims in this war.

If i was a palestinian citizen and a parent in Gaza. I would have taken off my shoe and throw it at the next idiot who fires another rocket into Israel as it is not helping with the situation.

If i was an Israeli citizen. The prime minister will be rest assured that my Nikes will put him out cold as this whole act will only serve to breed more terrorist groups like Hamas.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 6:36 pm ET

isral say maybe the war will be soon over ...
why? ... maybe its over in the sime time as bush is over?
and then its peace there ?

are israelians really so smart?
after what they did ... where they think they will find peace???

jews attaked around the world .. jews boykott around the world
and they think if they kill whole gaza it will bring peace to israel?
and if they kill not all in gaza do they think after the pain there will come peace to israel?

the whole world USA excluded hate israel becaus this genocide
and they call it peace?

choosen by god to go in a nuthouse!

EdM   January 11th, 2009 6:37 pm ET

Professor:

You want to talk about Israeli terror that started in 1930? How about staring one year earlier with the Arab terror (see below)? Or, let's try to move forward in accordance with 181 and following UN resolutions, but starting with 181.

You claim Eric's statements are lies. All? Which ones? Let's start with the easy ones; are these lies? #6 JERUSALEM IS MENTIONED OVER 700 TIMES IN THE BIBLE, BUT NOT ONCE IS IT MENTIONED IN THE QUR’AN;? #8: JEWS PRAY FACING JERUSALEM; MUSLIMS FACE MECCA. IF THEY ARE BETWEEN THE TWO CITIES, MUSLIMS PRAY FACING MECCA, WITH THEIR BACKS TO JERUSALEM;? #17: THE U.N. WAS SILENT WHEN THE JORDANIANS DESTROYED 58 SYNAGOGUES IN THE OLD CITY OF JERUSALEM. IT REMAINED SILENT WHILE JORDAN SYSTEMATICALLY DESECRATED THE ANCIENT JEWISH CEMETERY ON THE MOUNT OF OLIVES, AND IT REMAINED SILENT WHEN JORDAN ENFORCED APARTHEID LAWS PREVENTING JEWS FROM ACCESSING THE TEMPLE MOUNT AND WESTERN WALL.? We can address the others but let's start with these since you seemed to claim they were all lies.

Arab terror pre-1930 examples:
"In September 1928, Jews at their Yom Kippur prayers at the Western Wall placed chairs and customary screens between the men and women present. Jerusalem commissioner Edward Keith-Roach, while visiting the Muslim religious court overlooking the prayer area, pointed out the screen, precipitating emotional protests and demands from the assembled sheiks that it be removed. Unless it was taken down, they said, they would not be responsible for what happened. This was described as violating the Ottoman status quo that forbade Jews from making any construction in the Western Wall area, though such screens had been put up from time to time. The British issued an ultimatum for its removal. When police officers in riot gear were then sent in, a scuffle took place with worshippers and the screen in question was destroyed.

The intervention drew censure later from senior officials who judged that excessive force had been exercised without good reason. Haj Amin al Husseini, the Mufti of Jerusalem, exploited the incident to distribute leaflets to Arabs in Palestine and throughout the Arab world which claimed that the Jews were planning to take over the al-Aqsa Mosque. One consequence was that worshippers not infrequently were subjected to beatings and stoning.[3]

By August 24, 17 Jews were killed in the Jerusalem area. The worst killings occurred in Hebron and Safed while others were killed in Motza, Kfar Uria, Jerusalem and Tel Aviv.

[edit] Hebron massacre
Main article: 1929 Hebron massacre
In Hebron, Arab mobs killed 65-68 Jews[9] and wounded 58. The lone British policeman in the town, Raymond Cafferata, was overwhelmed, and the reinforcements he called for did not arrive for 5 hours (leading to bitter recriminations). Hundreds of Jews were saved by their Arab neighbours, who offered them sanctuary from the mob by hiding them in their own houses[3] while others survived by taking refuge in the British police station at Beit Ramon on the outskirts of the city. When the massacre ended, the surviving Jews were forced to leave their homes[10] and were evacuated by the British,[3] while their property was seized by the Arab residents and occupied by them until after the Six Day War of 1967.[11]

This massacre had a deep and lasting effect on the Jewish community of Palestine.

[edit] Safed massacre
Main article: 1929 Safed massacre
In Safed, 18 Jews were killed (some sources say twenty) and 80 wounded. The main Jewish street was looted and burned."

Beny   January 11th, 2009 6:38 pm ET

And still no answer to my question about the "occupation"

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 6:39 pm ET

Back from breakfast...

Scanned this massive war of words today.

I like ITME's quotes from Mandela, Einstein and Ghandi. Worth reprinting as I enter today's ground field Blog Wars.

“We consider ourselves to be comrades in arms to the Palestinian Arabs in their struggle for the liberation of Palestine. There is not a single citizen in South Africa who is not ready to stand by his Palestinian brothers in their legitimate fight against the Zionist racists.” — Nelson Mandela

“I should much rather see reasonable agreement with the Arabs on the basis of living together in peace than the creation of a Jewish state. Apart from practical consideration, my awareness of the essential nature of Judaism resists the idea of a Jewish state with borders, an army, and a measure of temporal power no matter how modest. I am afraid of the inner damage Judaism will sustain — especially from the development of a narrow nationalism within our own ranks, against which we have already had to fight strongly, even without a Jewish state.” — Albert Einstein, 1932.

“My sympathies are all with the Jews…But my sympathy does not blind me to the requirements of justice. The cry for the national home for the Jews does not make much appeal to me…Palestine belongs to the Arabs in the same sense that England belongs to the English or France to the French. It is wrong and inhuman to impose the Jews on the Arabs. What is going on in Palestine today cannot be justified by any moral code of conduct. The mandates have no sanction but that of the last war. Surely it would be a crime against humanity to reduce the proud Arabs so that Palestine can be restored to the Jews partly or wholly as their national home.” — Gandhi, 1938

Linda   January 11th, 2009 6:41 pm ET

A J,
So glad you are back!
Wheelchair Warrior #1 here we go

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 6:42 pm ET

EdM

why was the arab terror ?
do you know ?
http://www.thehandstand.org/archive/december2005/articles/zionistmyth.htm
israel gave a good reason!

they did get the county and israel did say that they will respact co existence!
what was why the world gave this place to israel
and what did the jews?
kick the arabs out

and now you cry because what?
your own fault?
so go on and cry
go and learn about your people!!!!!!!!!

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 6:43 pm ET

Hi Wheelchair #1 from #2 ditto!
:)

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:49 pm ET

read and find out who broke the ceacefire.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/01/07/AR2009010702645.html

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 6:49 pm ET

Last week, I sent an email to the Israeli Prime Minister's office, protesting IDF bombardment.

I received a reply today, which I will share with the group.

To start off, the sentence that most came at me was:

'There is no humanitarian crisis in the Gaza Strip.'

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:51 pm ET

sorry it should be..Ceasefire

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 6:53 pm ET

"And still no answer to my question about the “occupation”

Beny.
why dont you give us a name of one country in the world that says there is no Israeli occupation.Just one

Beny   January 11th, 2009 6:58 pm ET

Akiva,

"and what did the jews?
kick the arabs out"

And look how easily you forget what led to this "kicking out" (partially they left voluntarily to come back when we're dead).

1947. UN partition plan. 60% of what the Jews got was arid desert. Yet we agreed because this was our only chance.

What did the Arabs do? An all out war for our destruction, starting with raiding villages and towns and ending with a full 5- country invasion!

Palestine- over which they are fighting so "valiantly" now, was given to them on a silver platter, and they threw it all away because they can't stand living next to Jews.

If I may quote you:
"and now you cry because what?
your own fault?
so go on and cry
go and learn about your people!!!!!!!!!"

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 6:58 pm ET

Solomon,
Iarae, of course!

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:00 pm ET

Sorry, spelling gobbldee goop there.

Israel, of course=one country that thinks not.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 7:00 pm ET

Solomon
which country say that in gaza is no occupation by israe???
i never heard about a country who told that there is no occupation!!!

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 7:04 pm ET

"1947. UN partition plan. 60% of what the Jews got was arid desert. Yet we agreed because this was our only chance"

Beny.

in 1947 Jews owned less than 6% of the land

ahmed   January 11th, 2009 7:07 pm ET

Look when I read all these comments it tills me no wisdom at all present in the world and from my knowledge of history and the natural development, beside, Israel is like a small island in the Islamic world, so its long term survival is a real question thought history of the Islamic role Jews were protected and given there rights, a vivid example was in Spain under Islamic role when Muslim were defeated in Spain not only Muslims were tortured but also Jews were brutally tortured so they flee to morocco for the safety under Muslim role ……
I believe that Israel a state is the gravest mistake ever done by Jews so they have no more friends when history takes its natural course and who knows the next super power nation will be ….
Even with what is happening know this will make Hamas stronger and Israel will loss again …..When you under estimate your opponent you loose …. Every thing is clear
Israel wants to bring Mr. Burgothy who is in Israeli prison to power as a Palestinian leader as lots of observers predicted so he will look as a national hero, it is bitty that the west and Israel play same games … just to a waken the Giant…

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 7:10 pm ET

Beny
are you running away why dont you answer?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:11 pm ET

IDF forces operating in Gaza on Sunday uncovered an explosive device rigged with a timer that hidden in a Palestinian school. A fuse attached to the explosives extended to a zoo located dozens of yards away.

The soldiers managed to neutralize the bomb before it went off. Numerous weapons, including RPG launchers, grenades and AK-47 assault rifles were found inside the school.

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:11 pm ET

Sure got quiet in here all of a sudden...

Beny   January 11th, 2009 7:11 pm ET

Comments are "awaiting moderation".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Qassam_rocket_attacks_in_Israel_in_2008#July

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 7:12 pm ET

Beny is reading a hoistory book now ;)
he learns now about his history ... so be patient with him

Free Palestine   January 11th, 2009 7:12 pm ET

For the people on here that are defending Israel. Israel defend itself? Does this sound like defense? Palestine doesn't even have an army, navy, or air force -they have nothing but people throwing sticks and stones trying to defend themselves. Israel has one of the most advanced military operations in the world. Can they not just kill Hamas if they wanted to. Does their great technology not allow this? Do they need to send in tanks, military planes, and a ground invasion against a country that doesn't even have a military?

This is not defense -it's an invasion and complete genocide. Israel is making up stories of Hamas -look at the numbers -what like 5 Israelis killed compared to 1000's of palestinians -1/3 of all whom are children.

Israel managed under US support to cover its humanity crimes and massacres done to palestinian whom were displaced and butchered over the past 60 years,as the jewish lobby influence the decision makers and media in the west,they portrait Hamas as a monsters not just people of no option except defending thier homeland.

They are draining the US economy and taxpayers money (3 billions $$ are the US donations to Israel each year) and they get unconditional aid in different forms.

USA STOP YOUR AID TO ISRAEL, THEN THE WORLD WILL BE A BETTER PLACE.

Beny   January 11th, 2009 7:13 pm ET

http://www.aish.com/jewishissues/middleeast/Myths_and_Facts_about_the_Gaza_War.asp

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 7:13 pm ET

dan perman

you forget to say that Israel saved the animals in the ZOO.ant brain

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 7:13 pm ET

Beny
"List_of_Qassam_rocket_attacks_in_Israel_in_2008#July"
do yout think that all this problems did start in 2008
are you kidding us?

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:14 pm ET

I have noticed that anytime I post references, they moderate.

They delete totally, without warning, quotes from books

Interesting, whoever 'they' are...

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:15 pm ET

akiva

how can you stand the smell of the crap coming out of your mouth?

Beny   January 11th, 2009 7:16 pm ET

For some reason I can't post a comment with more than one link because it's "awaiting moderation".

Hala, I could suggest a number of good programmers to fix this problem.

Nadeem   January 11th, 2009 7:16 pm ET

Beny,

What I asked you was "Do you agree with killing innocent civilians by the Israeli military as a punishment to Hamas launching rockets? "

Your answer was YES followed by a couple of lines of propaganda:
http://insidethemiddleeast.blogs.cnn.com/2008/12/27/gaza-airstrikes-worldwide-reaction/#comments

My conclusion and continues to be that you see Israeli people as superior to any other nation and that Palestinian life is less worthy than Israeli life. This is obvious by the way you equate the daily massacres committed in Gaza against civilians, the blockage on Gaza that has prevented Gazans access for minimum needs for life for 3 years (before the ceasefire was put in place). You equate this to rockets launched into south Israel by Hamas and other palestinian factions. Your answer to my question above seems that you even think that the life of around 900 palestinian deaths, half of which are women and children are of little significance compared to a single Israeli life ...

Check my link again:

http://www.salon.com/opinion/greenwald/2009/01/04/terrorism/index.html

and your earlier response to my question
"Do you agree with killing innocent civilians by the Israeli military as a punishment to Hamas launching rockets? "

Now judge for yourself if you are blinded by tribalism or not.

To put it in clearer terms as you will probably answer with the same Israeli propaganda that you have answered with (let's see) FOREVER..., here is a new question:

"Do you think that it is OKAY to KILL Gazan women and children indescriminately and endlessly till Hamas "Learn their Lesson" as your goverment calls it??

Nadeem, Lebanon

Linda   January 11th, 2009 7:16 pm ET

Hey AJ
I was checking on those DIME weapons that mohammed was talking about.
I'm back

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:16 pm ET

Thought I was the only one,

guess 'they' do it to all of us, Beny...

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:17 pm ET

solomon

you are right, the animals on four survived, those on two will not

Hamas Gaza is begging for a ceasefire

Beny   January 11th, 2009 7:18 pm ET

These links were an answer to the continuing lies that Israel violated the cease fire,

THAT IS NOT TRUE. ROCKETS RESUMED FALLING FROM DAY 1 OF THE "CEASE-FIRE" (when we ceased and they fired)

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:19 pm ET

moderate, that is...

Hi Linda, what are you referring to. I just got here and did not see DIME writing

old lady in the shoe   January 11th, 2009 7:19 pm ET

The Qur'an contains detailed instructions and examples of how to meet unbelievers. The first instruction is that they should be called to Islam; in fact, the Qur'an says you cannot wage war against unbelievers until you have preached to them. The second instruction is that if they do not convert to Islam, then, they must be fought. The third instruction is that if they surrender, or convert, then you must stop waging war. The final instruction is that if they do not convert or surrender, then they must be killed. This is the optimum route for Islamist expansion: A tidal wave of war, subjugation and conversion.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 7:20 pm ET

Beny

......are you stupid?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

you post infos od a jew site ... do you think thats objective information
or maybe stupid probaganda
do you think all the problems did start at On June 17, 2008,????????????????

on your jewish site the first point ....
CNN: Who really broke the cease-fire Israel or Hamas
uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-pTX4d6B6_k

do you beleve blindly all that jewish propaganda stuff???

do you wanna fool us ?
are you kidding?
are you choosen by god to be a fool?

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 7:21 pm ET

Beny.

do you want us to list the atrocities of Israel since 1948.it will take few days for people to read but I am willing to post them if you ask me to.

I will also publish Jewish terrorism in the thirties and forties Just ask Beny.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:22 pm ET

EdM

arab terror against jews is documented since 1920, not 1928

i have given the complete list dozens of times

never gotten any response from the jew bashers on this blog, the literate ones and the illiterate ones

Beny   January 11th, 2009 7:22 pm ET

Akiva,

"Beny is reading a hoistory book now "

Compared to someone who replaced his history lessons with Kassam-launching field days (or mindless indoctrination, if you're a Neturei-Karta guy like I suspect), I'd rather have my books over your rockets, thank you very much.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 7:24 pm ET

Aj,
Mohammed said that there was a news report, not in our country, that the Israeli army was using and NEW weapon called the IDIA. Well, he couldn't find any referrence to it. So I said I talked to a weapons expert on the phone, and he did not know what he was talking about. (I was just kidding) so when he questioned my about my phone call, I told him, just because you type something, doesn't make it true. Get it?
Anyway, he didn't get it and I asked him again for references on this weapon.
He came back about an hour later, with the DIME Weapon. It is not knew, I had already known about it, and I posted the info about that weapon. I haven't heard from him since.
I was gone, doing more research on it. If they are using it, I would say that would be the weapon they are using on the tunnels.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 7:24 pm ET

"you are right, the animals on four survived, those on two will not"

ant brain.

you mean those on two like you and the rest of the Zionists.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:24 pm ET

naturei karta are moderate compared to the idiot akiva

Nadeem   January 11th, 2009 7:25 pm ET

Beny,

What I asked you was “Do you agree with killing innocent civilians by the Israeli military as a punishment to Hamas launching rockets? ”

Your answer was YES followed by a couple of lines of propaganda:
http://insidethemiddleeast.blogs.cnn.com/2008/12/27/gaza-airstrikes-worldwide-reaction/#comments

My conclusion and continues to be that you see Israeli people as superior to any other nation and that Palestinian life is less worthy than Israeli life. This is obvious by the way you equate the daily massacres committed in Gaza against civilians, the blockage on Gaza that has prevented Gazans access for minimum needs for life for 3 years (before the ceasefire was put in place). You equate this to rockets launched into south Israel by Hamas and other palestinian factions. Your answer to my question above seems that you even think that the life of around 900 palestinian deaths, half of which are women and children are of little significance compared to a single Israeli life …

Check my link again and your earlier response to my question
“Do you agree with killing innocent civilians by the Israeli military as a punishment to Hamas launching rockets? ”

Now judge for yourself if you are blinded by tribalism or not.

To put it in clearer terms as you will probably answer with the same Israeli propaganda that you have answered with (let’s see) FOREVER…, here is a new question:

“Do you think that it is OKAY to KILL Gazan women and children indescriminately and endlessly till Hamas “Learn their Lesson” as your goverment calls it??

Nadeem, Lebanon

Eric MacArthur   January 11th, 2009 7:26 pm ET

As far as some saying "Why don't the Jews go back to where they were before WWII?"
It's because those countries at that time would not let them...This is why the U.N. acted to set them up in Israel.

Then in response various Arab countries would not let the Arab immigrants back to their respective homes. Now the Arab community use these simple people to poke at Israel.

I don't blame all Arabs for this problem nor many Israelis.

The fault does seem to be more with the Arabs though. They teach hate from a young age (it's in many of their constitutions.) And they use the least of their people to blow themselves up. They preach hate, hate and more hate.

All these defenders of this have lots of excuses of why they think it's okay.

IT"S NEVER OKAY TO TEACH CHILDREN HATE.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:26 pm ET

solomon

you are sooooooooooooooooo boring

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:26 pm ET

What does this weapon do, I dread to ask?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:28 pm ET

nadeem

do you agree to rocket fire from gaza for eight years now deliberately targeting civilians?

(I did not ask how many were killed, so sdon't start the numbers game with me, war is not a mathematical equation)

just answer the simple question

Rod   January 11th, 2009 7:28 pm ET

Harvey,
I understand that you want peace and I do want peace to for myself and my kids too. but lets be honest with ourselves first. do you really think this genocide will bring peace? I mean forget that we are jews and remember we are humans.

How can the state of israel expect peace with palestinians in Gaza when they besiege them, starve them and kill them. if you did not give it to them they will not give it to you. as simple as that.

"For 18 months Israel had imposed an unlawful blockade on the coastal strip that brought Gazan society to the brink of collapse. In the three years after Israel’s redeployment from Gaza, 11 Israelis were killed by rocket fire. And yet in 2005-8, according to the UN, the Israeli army killed about 1,250 Palestinians in Gaza, including 222 children. Throughout this time the Gaza Strip remained occupied territory under international law because Israel maintained effective control over it."

How in the world we expect them to not fight back. not to try to make our life miserable as we made theirs. we do not have to send suicidal attackers cause we have the F16 and Apache and we have probably the worlds 4th strongest military. if we were in their shoes we will storm them with suicidal bombers and rockets and everything we have. many of our leaders were terrorists when the Brits were seen as occupiers. The palestinians refuse what Moshe Yaalon, then the Israeli Defense Forces chief of staff, in 2002 said: "The Palestinians must be made to understand in the deepest recesses of their consciousness that they are a defeated people.". They want freedom something we have and refuse to give them with our current mindset.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 7:29 pm ET

AJ
Dense Inert Metal Explosive (DIME) is uniquely suited for Low Collateral Damage. It produces lower pressure but increased impulse in the near field. Far Field damage is reduced (no frags/ impulse rolloff). The lethal footprint can be tuned to precision footprint. Strike Weapon Scaling Tests were completed in August of 2004), and full-scale Mk-82 tests were in the planning stage as of early 2005. DARPA funded RPG defense system feasibility tests in January 2005, which were successful.

It has shrapnel in them and some people say that the shrapnel burns, killing the tissue around the site.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 7:29 pm ET

Eric,

So you think the UN has the right to take a land from the Palestinian and give it to the Jews right?.... is that what the UN charter give it the right to do?

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:30 pm ET

Linda,

I think I will come back later today or tonight when they open a new post and, with all due respect, the name callers, and rabid ragers are gone.

It is difficult to dialogue with this group.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 7:30 pm ET

Nadeem..

you are wasting your time with Beny. he was a soldier in the Israeli defeated forces in Lebanon for sure he did the same in Lebanon as his brothers are doing in Gaza.he will defend the killing of children he did that several times on this blog.

I love my beautiful Lebanon.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 7:31 pm ET

Yes AJ,
I agree, read my post above tho, first. Thanks :)

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:33 pm ET

here is your beloved washington Post, describing who broke the cease fire and, above all, when, so stuff it solomon:

Rocket Hits Israel, Second Violation of Gaza Truce
by MARK LAVIE
Washington Post
June 26, 2008

JERUSALEM - Gaza militants fired two rockets into southern Israel on Thursday, further straining a shaky, week-old truce as Israel kept vital Gaza border crossings closed in response.

Eric MacArthur   January 11th, 2009 7:33 pm ET

How do you take land from immigrants?

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:33 pm ET

Linda,
Still sounds terrible to me. Peace Loving terrorist that I am...is that an oxymoron?

Thanks for the info. tho.

Did you once say you had military background?

Beny   January 11th, 2009 7:33 pm ET

And how about Wikipedia? Is that a "propaganda" site too?

Compared to how you give me opinion articles, which hardly are proof...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rocket_and_mortar_attacks_in_Israel_in_2008

Linda   January 11th, 2009 7:34 pm ET

Aj
Yes, I come from and entire military family, many generations on my mother's side, and my husband too.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:35 pm ET

beny

go back to the lab, no reasoning with these "people"

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:36 pm ET

The 'tissues' around the site??

Do they mean 'tissues' as in people, lke collateral damage means people??

Rod   January 11th, 2009 7:36 pm ET

it is very interesting how the people who are blindly supporting this genocide conveniently use numbers when they need them and dismiss numbers when they don't.
Same thing goes for History. History is conveniently fabricated and used

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:38 pm ET

amercan jew

like you are not a jew, get it ??

Linda   January 11th, 2009 7:38 pm ET

AJ,
No the tissue around the site that the shrapnel hits, Low collateral damage meaning people, yes

Nadeem   January 11th, 2009 7:38 pm ET

Dan,

Your answer shows your tribal feelings that guide you to justify killings continuously .. You talk to me as if I support killing, well I don't whoever does the killing. But I have the reason to see that what is happening is Gaza is a targetting of a civilian population that has suffered from a blockage for three years and have no means to live a decent life and now is being killed indiscriminately after they have been starved. My view is that is it criminal not to condemn the massacres in Gaza and continue to justify them.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 7:39 pm ET

Eric,

I forgot that you are not even worth responding to.... go back to what you were doing.... no one is paying you any attention anyways.

Its the occupation Stupid...

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:40 pm ET

No, Dan I do mot get it...explain please?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 7:40 pm ET

what Israel is doing in gaza will go to the international court of justice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

livni and the rest of her terrorist group wil hang !

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:40 pm ET

not

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 7:43 pm ET

Beny

"_rocket_and_mortar_attacks_in_Israel_in_2008"

do you still thing that all problems have begun in 2008???????
and are you stupid !!
cant you watch a video???????????
CNN: Who really broke the cease-fire Israel or Hamas
uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-pTX4d6B6_k
are you blind ?
if you cant listen pull up the volume !!!!!!!!
whats wrong with you man?

EdM   January 11th, 2009 7:43 pm ET

Solomon: How much of the land was 'owned'? Wasn't the vast majority of the Negev basically barren but with nomadic Beduins, who are still there? What was the population density? Who 'owned' the land Tel Aviv was built on? How much of the land was 'owned' by Arabs and how much of that was included in what was to have been the Palestinian state?
And did anyone care about ownership of land when the Muslims forced the relocation of about 8 million people to create Pakistan? Seems like it was okay to force people to move to create a Muslim state then.
Anyway, looks like this blog is going nowhere. Land and war versus acceptance of 181 and peace. I like the India-Pakistan model roughly, two states at relative peace with each (if they could only settle Kashmir and control their own extremists. By the way, how does the Muslim population % in India compare with the Arab population % in Israel?). For most of the folks it seems like blame the other guy, my side is perfect, the other side is terrible rather accepting that both sides and the international community have been at fault at various times. All the rest is details diverting the thinking from how to get to peace without eliminating the existence of a Jewish homeland as defined in UN resolution 181, which is of course an option. Ever read 181; it's beautiful in its description of how the two states would live with each other. Drives me crazy when Israel gets knocked for violating UN resolution xxx but the Arabs are not for violating 181, which would have avoided the refugee problem, the subsequent wars, occupation, Gaza, and the next humantiarian misery in that area. I made my input in an earlier post (1534 GMT) but no comments on that so I'm signing off, Ed

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:43 pm ET

P=Obama has spoken again today on this conflict.

Souns like he will take a 'centered' approach.

Glad he said something...

Professor   January 11th, 2009 7:43 pm ET

Israeli murderers are on the loose....

Nadeem   January 11th, 2009 7:43 pm ET

Dan,

Further proof to your racism and tribalism what you just told beny:
go back to the lab, no reasoning with these “people”

You probably think I am less human than you do?

I rest my case.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:44 pm ET

linda

can i please know what you are discussing

accusations flew here that israel is using a certain type of weapon

proof? nada

so why is this discussed as if nobody knows whether it is true or not?

the rumors come from gaza

examples of arab lies during wars and operations:

1967: pictures of the oil raffineries in haifa burning were distibuted by syria, including films

it never happened, the films turned out to be from 1948

Jenin, a few years ago:

"500 civilians massacred" said Erekat

it turned out, from official palestinian sources that 54 died, 28 of which were NOT civilians

gaza operation, now:

100s of israeli soldiers killed by hamas

truth: a slight exageration, less than 10

so until you bing proof that israel used these weapons, i suggest that you tread very carefully

thanks linda

Eric MacArthur   January 11th, 2009 7:45 pm ET

I'm with you all the way EdM,

Thanks for trying :)

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:45 pm ET

I do not agree with Dan, so therefore I am not a Jew.

I sure terrify this dude, don't I?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 7:45 pm ET

Oh by the way guys.... today I finally got my first pay check from CNN blogs... for being here on the blog all day and all night.... :)

Did any of you got theirs?

Beny   January 11th, 2009 7:46 pm ET

Nadeem,

Let me ask you something, Do you think it is okay to explode in buses and mallsa nd shoot rockets aimed at as many civilians as possible, just to fight the "occupation" carried out by their "criminal governent"?

If you answer YES, then go meet your 72 virgins.

If you answer NO, then here is another question: do you think that a government should not do everything in it's power to defend its citizens against the aforesaid attacks?

If you answer YES, then you are contradicting yourself.

If you answer NO, you will arrive at the simple conclusion I am trying to bring you to.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:47 pm ET

nadeem

what ever you are, i don't give a sh*t, but don't put words in my mouth

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:48 pm ET

No Professor! I did not, I think they are waiting fr my credentials, I must prove I'm a Jew.

...as well as a wheelchair warrior CPB–LOL

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:48 pm ET

amercan jew

i am trmbling, can't you see goy?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 7:49 pm ET

Sure you do AJ.... LOL

Oh and Linda... why don't you listen to your boss?

Linda   January 11th, 2009 7:49 pm ET

Dan,
I did not appreciate Mohammed putting out accusations that Israel was using something they weren't. There is no such thing as a IDIA weapon. And to come back and change his story, and weapon, well, I was not letting him get away with that. He said they were using a CHEMICAL weapon called the IDIA, and they he said it was DIME, which is still not a chemical weapon
As far as I am concerned, you can not just through out anything rhetoric without backing it up. I researched it for everyone to know the TRUTH

Libra   January 11th, 2009 7:50 pm ET

My simple comment is, instead of deciphering the politics of nations to determine the causes of human injustices, why can't we just listen to the people who are actually living through this cruel depressions? No human deserves to die, suffer for their leaders incapability to reconcile their differences. And those leaders must keep the energy alive to solve what seems so difficult. In any state it is afterall, the people who will build their nation. Why do civilians have to suffer the unjust conquesences of political figures who simply can't get along? What a huge disgrace for humanity of any morality. When will human-beings regain their compassion towards human life? Are we that blind not to see or so dead not to feel? Everyone has their own translations of historical events and polical decisions making nobody wrong, everybody right. And civilians are being bombed as an attempt for anyone to give it just cause continues. This is where humanity has reached. What a depressing moment in civilization. Intelligence at its worse.

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 7:50 pm ET

How much do they pay, Prof?

What can I look forwaard to?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 7:50 pm ET

Beny

are you so intelectual that you can try to watch a video at youtube?
by CNN

CNN: Who really broke the cease-fire Israel or Hamas
uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-pTX4d6B6_k

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:51 pm ET

Akiva

"CNN: Who really broke the cease-fire Israel or Hamas
uk.youtube.com/watch?v=-pTX4d6B6_k
are you blind ?"

so the washington post is lying (see above)?

is that what you say?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:53 pm ET

linda,

thanks,

see what the prfessor calls me , I am your boss now

hahahahahahaha

Nadeem   January 11th, 2009 7:55 pm ET

Beny,

What conclusion???? There is no conclusion if you continue to deny that Gazan civilians are still being killed indiscrimantely and that IDF has prevented Red Cross to reach to starving palestinian kids holding on to their dead mothers..

Beny   January 11th, 2009 7:55 pm ET

Since I am NOT paid by Hamas to propagate here, unlike some other false academics here, and I have work to do, I'm gonna retreat to my humble abode and bid you all goodnight. Good luck Dan Harvey and others here, good luck to the citizens of Sderot and the soldiers at the front, may tomorrow will bring a sky free of Kassams and a Gaza free of Hamas.

I still want a description of the "occupation". For the last two hours my very simple question has been avoided. That's no way to propagate Hamas doctrina, Solomon and Akiva and false prof!
Before saying "it's the occupation, stupid" one should really look at what it means.

Au revoir

עם ישראל חי!

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 7:55 pm ET

linda

i would be honored though to be called your friend

Professor   January 11th, 2009 7:56 pm ET

Robert Fisk’s World: Wherever I go, I hear the same tired Middle East comparisons
On both sides of the Atlantic the experience has been weirdly repetitive
Saturday, 10 January 2009
It all depends where you live. That was the geography of Israel's propaganda, designed to demonstrate that we softies – we little baby-coddling liberals living in our secure Western homes – don't realise the horror of 12 (now 20) Israeli deaths in 10 years and thousands of rockets and the unimaginable trauma and stress of living near Gaza. Forget the 600 Palestinian dead; travelling on both sides of the Atlantic these past couple of weeks has been an instructive – not to say weirdly repetitive – experience.
Here's how it goes. I was in Toronto when I opened the right-wing National Post and found Lorne Gunter trying to explain to readers what it felt like to come under Palestinian rocket attack. "Suppose you lived in the Toronto suburb of Don Mills," writes Gunter, "and people from the suburb of Scarborough – about 10 kilometres away – were firing as many as 100 rockets a day into your yard, your kid's school, the strip mall down the street and your dentist's office..."
Getting the message? It just so happens, of course, that the people of Scarborough are underprivileged, often new immigrants – many from Afghanistan – while the people of Don Mills are largely middle class with a fair number of Muslims. Nothing like digging a knife into Canada's multicultural society to show how Israel is all too justified in smashing back at the Palestinians.
Now a trip down Montreal way and a glance at the French-language newspaper La Presse two days later. And sure enough, there's an article signed by 16 pro-Israeli writers, economists and academics who are trying to explain what it feels like to come under Palestinian rocket attack. "Imagine for a moment that the children of Longueuil live day and night in terror, that businesses, shops, hospitals, schools are the targets of terrorists located in Brossard." Longueuil, it should be added, is a community of blacks and Muslim immigrants, Afghans, Iranians. But who are the "terrorists" in Brossard?
Two days later and I am in Dublin. I open The Irish Times to find a letter from the local Israeli ambassador, trying to explain to the people of the Irish Republic what it feels like to come under Palestinian rocket attack. Know what's coming? Of course you do. "What would you do," Zion Evrony asks readers, "if Dublin were subjected to a bombardment of 8,000 rockets and mortars..." And so it goes on and on and on. Needless to say, I'm waiting for the same writers to ask how we'd feel if we lived in Don Mills or Brossard or Dublin and came under sustained attack from supersonic aircraft and Merkava tanks and thousands of troops whose shells and bombs tore 40 women and children to pieces outside a school, shredded whole families in their beds and who, after nearly a week, had killed almost 200 civilians out of 600 fatalities.
In Ireland, my favourite journalistic justification for this bloodbath came from my old mate Kevin Myers. "The death toll from Gaza is, of course, shocking, dreadful, unspeakable," he mourned. "Though it does not compare with the death toll amongst Israelis if Hamas had its way." Get it? The massacre in Gaza is justified because Hamas would have done the same if they could, even though they didn't do it because they couldn't. It took Fintan O'Toole, The Irish Times's resident philosopher-in-chief, to speak the unspeakable. "When does the mandate of victimhood expire?" he asked. "At what point does the Nazi genocide of Europe's Jews cease to excuse the state of Israel from the demands of international law and of common humanity?"
I had an interesting time giving the Tip O'Neill peace lecture in Derry when one of the audience asked, as did a member of the Trinity College Dublin Historical Society a day later, whether the Northern Ireland Good Friday peace agreement – or, indeed, any aspect of the recent Irish conflict – contained lessons for the Middle East. I suggested that local peace agreements didn't travel well and that the idea advanced by John Hume (my host in Derry) – that it was all about compromise – didn't work since the Israeli seizure of Arab land in the West Bank had more in common with the 17th-century Irish Catholic dispossession than sectarianism in Belfast.
What I do suspect, however, is that the split and near civil war between Hamas and the Palestinian Authority has a lot in common with the division between the Irish Free State and anti-treaty forces that led to the 1922-3 Irish civil war; that Hamas's refusal to recognise Israel – and the enemies of Michael Collins who refused to recognise the Anglo-Irish Treaty and the border with Northern Ireland – are tragedies that have a lot in common, Israel now playing the role of Britain, urging the pro-treaty men (Mahmoud Abbas) to destroy the anti-treaty men (Hamas).
I ended the week in one of those BBC World Service discussions in which a guy from The Jerusalem Post, a man from al-Jazeera, a British academic and Fisk danced the usual steps around the catastrophe in Gaza. The moment I mentioned that 600 Palestinian dead for 20 Israeli dead around Gaza in 10 years was grotesque, pro-Israeli listeners condemned me for suggesting (which I did not) that only 20 Israelis had been killed in all of Israel in 10 years. Of course, hundreds of Israelis outside Gaza have died in that time – but so have thousands of Palestinians.
My favourite moment came when I pointed out that journalists should be on the side of those who suffer. If we were reporting the 18th-century slave trade, I said, we wouldn't give equal time to the slave ship captain in our dispatches. If we were reporting the liberation of a Nazi concentration camp, we wouldn't give equal time to the SS spokesman. At which point a journalist from the Jewish Telegraph in Prague responded that "the IDF are not Hitler". Of course not. But who said they were?

Linda   January 11th, 2009 7:57 pm ET

Dan,
You are my friend.
My feelings are hurt right now.

Annie Tundermann   January 11th, 2009 7:57 pm ET

For every minute taken by world leaders to talk about the crisis in Gaza, more precious lives are lost. It's time to finish talking and stop this senseless killing of innocent Palestinian people.

(I'm a European woman, living in Providence, Rhode Island)

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 7:58 pm ET

Nadeem .

I told you you can not reason with ant brain who call himself Dan and Beny the Israeli soldier.I hope you are convinced now.

one talks about labs and the other talks about 72 virgins how can you lower your self to these racists and bigots.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 8:00 pm ET

Hi Annie,
Nice to have you :)

Professor   January 11th, 2009 8:01 pm ET

AJ,

it was not much... I cannot retire on it... hehe

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:01 pm ET

Beny
aur revoir ... tu este impossible malade a ta tete ....increible
porquoi tu este come ca bete dans da tete?
quest il passe avec toi?

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 8:02 pm ET

Beny.

as usual like your Israeli defeated forces you run when confronted.

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 8:03 pm ET

Linda, What is wrong?

Why hurt feelings?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 8:03 pm ET

Israel is calling the reserves.... I guess Hamas is kicking their ass still....

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 8:05 pm ET

Professor. you are right on target.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 8:05 pm ET

Well, Dan,
If you are my boss, then where the Hell is my Paycheck?

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 8:06 pm ET

Hi Linda, AJ, Solomon, Prof,

Just got back from training the huskies. Looks like the discussion has regressed even further. We're still on the SOS ...

Not sure if I'm gonna stay ....

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:06 pm ET

solomon
'
it is your buddies the terrorists who promise 72 virgins to anybody willing to blow him or herself up in the midst of civilians, the more the better, not me, nor beny

but why do i bother, you don't want to understand , only lies and slander, that's your metier

Linda   January 11th, 2009 8:07 pm ET

AJ,
Because I thought I was doing the right things by checking facts and researching, instead of blindly listening to someone, that ended up being propaganda anyway.
And then I get chastised.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 8:08 pm ET

Hi Lynne, Yes it has
I am about to through in the towel

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:08 pm ET

dan perman

do you hate islam very much ?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:09 pm ET

linda

your paycheck is an open invitation, as soon as you are well enough to come and visit

although according to our "friends" here on the blog, isarel will surely disappear after hamas is finished "kicking our ass" :-)

Maria   January 11th, 2009 8:10 pm ET

I love you Professor

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:11 pm ET

akiva goychik

what do you want now?

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 8:12 pm ET

Hi Lynne
Me too.

I have stuff to do

Meet ya later in a
(hopefully) newly opened blog?

Hope to also see Professor, Rod, Linda and Nona, too.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:12 pm ET

maria

so marry him

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:14 pm ET

dan perman

i was asking... (i quote)...
"Akiva January 11th, 2009 2008 GMT

dan perman

do you hate islam very much ?"

so my question was ... do you hate islam?
shall i repeat my question ?
or do you get what i mean?

Joan   January 11th, 2009 8:15 pm ET

Maria,

No, I would not like to see Gazans as history. They are very much part of the present. I would like to see them with peaceful and prosperous lives.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:15 pm ET

goychik

you are wrong, as always

American Jew   January 11th, 2009 8:15 pm ET

Linda,
I appreciate your fact check.

Remember my motto, sticks and stones...blah blah blah, but names....blah blah blah blah.

Keep the info coming...from ALL sides folks!

Later on...Lhitraoat!

Lynne   January 11th, 2009 8:16 pm ET

Word to the posters having good intent -

Wilkipedia is not a reliable source for factual information. It is not recognized as a reference source (bibliography) by most universities, since anyone can add to the topic without proper documentation. I have found this to be true when you look at some of the science topics.

Linda   January 11th, 2009 8:17 pm ET

Thanks AJ
Wheelchair Warrior #1 out

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:18 pm ET

lynne

but the washington post could be?

see above as to who broke the ceasefire

i never got an answer from the liars on this

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:19 pm ET

dan perman

i am wrong?
what does that mean now?

do you hate islam or not?

Search the Web on Snap.com   January 11th, 2009 8:20 pm ET

I am an Israeli citizen from Jerusalem (I was not called up for reserve duty yet).

fact 1: Hamas does not believe in the very right of Israel to exist (look up their amendment).
fact 2: Hamas's basic method of action is terrorism (look up their amendment).
fact 3: Hamas has been launching rockets into civilian Jewish cities in longer and longer range. So that now 20% of Israel's civilians live under a continuous missile threat. (Read the news or visit Ashkelon and wait of the alert to run for shelter).

None of the above facts are in any way hidden or secret.

How would you expect your own country to react to a self defined terrorist organization firing missiles at your cities, performing suicide attacks in your busses and taking refuge amongst their own citizens?

I am the last person in the world to want to resort to a military solution. Please inform me if you come up with an alternative solution taking into account the situation (this would help minimize my own chances of being called up to leave my children and go fight terrorists covered with explosives and jumping out the tunnels they have prepared).

ahmed   January 11th, 2009 8:20 pm ET

shall we just say ok beat us more ,,,, I wounder
the greatest loser who fight but needs life support for its existance ...
its a vived prove that peace is a joke..

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:21 pm ET

akiva

your mad rumblings do not deserve a reply

answer first who broke the ceasefire, the washington post or cnn?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 8:22 pm ET

Israel broke the cease-fire first when they did not remove the siege of Gaza since they pulled out of it.

Solomon   January 11th, 2009 8:23 pm ET

Lynne.Hi

I am leaving too I will be back latter.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:25 pm ET

professor

bullshit,

hamas was firing rockets from day one

stop halucinating, will ya?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:28 pm ET

akiva

above somebody brought an article by the liar, jimmy carter as proof that israel broke the ceasefire, someone else a piece by cnn

i brought an article (not op-ed) from the washington post from 16 june 2008 reporting the second cease fire violation by gaza terrorist

so who do you believe, cnn or the (article) in the wash. post

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 8:28 pm ET

IDF is having no exit strategy!! and needs to have a face saving victory -any kind of victory -to pull out, and this seems to be far away, what they are going to do after all of this power and this brutality? but here we are at square number one!!

Note : one of the strongest army according to Beny and Dan

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:28 pm ET

dan perman

http://www.thehandstand.org/archive/december2005/articles/zionistmyth.htm
what do you read here?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 8:28 pm ET

Were is everybody leaving? CNN blog might doc your pay guys... I will report you.... LOL

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:29 pm ET

hunk

oh yeah? although it is true, I NEVER SAID THAT

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:30 pm ET

Hunk
"IDF is having no exit strategy!!" 100% true thats why they must do a genocide or go to Den Haag
thats why they cant find peace!

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:33 pm ET

akiva

WOW, you found an impartial on-line magazine and bring that as proof

i pity you, goychik

Professor   January 11th, 2009 8:33 pm ET

The siege on Gaza implemented by Israel since its pulled out of it is an act of war.... Israel still occupying Palestinian territory.... anything done by Palestinians against Israel is considered an occupation resistance and its legit and fair.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:33 pm ET

this israel lobby here is based on fakes on lies on propaganda
and they leave because all is a lie a fake and only propaganda

the same as with hitler and goebels ... the lies are faling down ... and justice is knocking at the door
http://www.icj-cij.org/

Joan   January 11th, 2009 8:33 pm ET

professor,

What you wrote about the world is interesting, but what does it really say ? It's true taht more Gazans than Israeli's are dying, but that only shows that Israel is more powerful. It's very sad that anyone, anywhere, is dying, but comparing numbers does not justify anything or make one side more correct than the other. Do you think Israel should count their dead and then go out and kill the same number of Gazans?? How does that solve anything?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:34 pm ET

akiva

why don't you go to haag, coffee haag that is

felwasa   January 11th, 2009 8:35 pm ET

this is very vived proof that israil is not for peace ..... this intensive care state (patient ) will soon die and stop kiking !

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:37 pm ET

dan perman

the same at a other site
http://www.steinbergrecherche.com/hannabraun.htm

do you need more different sources?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:38 pm ET

"The siege on Gaza implemented by Israel since its pulled out of it is an act of war"

as an expert in international law you fail dismally, as in everything else

JoAnn   January 11th, 2009 8:39 pm ET

I have read so many different versions of the peoples truth in this matter.
I feel it's very sad. I am not educated as so many of you are. Just the human factor of it all bewilders my mind. We are the most evolved specie on the planet. We do not as of yet see the beauty of our very existence.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:40 pm ET

dan perman

do you need this statement by Wiki?
sadly the english wiki dont speak about that
and sadly the jewish wiki also dont speak about that sloagan
but in other languages i can bing it up from wiki

do you know also a other language then english?

harvey   January 11th, 2009 8:41 pm ET

Rod,

Sorry mate had to go out. Thanks for the reply. Interesting to read your point of view. Stand by mine. Think maybe if you visited us here and spent some time here you might feel differently.

I just want to say well done again to all those who demonstrated in London apparently in their tens of thousands in support of Israel. The demonstartion was peaceful. Nothing hurled at police, no one knocked senseless. No shop windows smashed. Nobodys flag got burned!

At the end everybody dispersed after singing Hatikvah and God Save the Queen....

Shalom y'all

Joan   January 11th, 2009 8:41 pm ET

Professor,

You say occupation resistance is legit and fair. Maybe so, I don't necessarily agree. But surely, if it is legit and fair, it is only so inside the Gaza strip.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:42 pm ET

akiva

so you are german? neo nazi or old nazi?

steinberg, another completely unbiased website

you will hav to do much better, goychik

Professor   January 11th, 2009 8:42 pm ET

Coming from you Dan.... I consider it a compliment.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 8:42 pm ET

Rights group: IDF using white phosphorous bombs in attacks on Gaza

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1054532.html

Professor   January 11th, 2009 8:45 pm ET

Joan,

sorry to say that but you are wrong....

Its ligit and fair anywhere in Palestine against the occupier Israel.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:46 pm ET

all it says in the haaretz report quoting another group is taht the other group claims something that was not proven, it is clear opinion

not good enough

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:47 pm ET

who here knows about the "Balfour Declaration"?

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 8:48 pm ET

harvey,

"Nobodys flag got burned!"

One of the Jews burned his passport on the demonstration today on London in protest against Israel .

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:48 pm ET

professor what is anywhere?

so you also deny israel's right to exist?

same party as goychik?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:50 pm ET

dan perman

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balfour_Declaration_of_1917

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:50 pm ET

akiva

du hast meine frage nicht beantworted, neo nazi oder alt nazi?

CYL   January 11th, 2009 8:50 pm ET

The sadness when I saw the news everytime. The children, women and men killed. It's a massacre in 21st century. If only the world and people can give up on the judgmental of race, religion and colour. It will not cost this kind of pain. What is race, religion and colour? Why are all these people so darn sick? How could they kill another human being just because where they live at, or what is their religion and skin colour?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:52 pm ET

akiva,

get off my back, you keep repeating yourself and never reply to anything anybody else says

you bore me

samy   January 11th, 2009 8:52 pm ET

there is no humanitarian crisis in gazza. who say there is one must be dumb.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 8:53 pm ET

Professor,

How do you define Palestine??

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:54 pm ET

akiva

wo bleiben deine antworten, bist du eingeschlafen?

alt nazi oder neo nazi, was ist es?

Pat   January 11th, 2009 8:54 pm ET

Hey Dan! Just staretd reading all this stuff.. Wow what a eye full. I was wondering when someone would bring up the school adjacent to a zoo rigged with ammo. And what about the 'humanitarian' truck on the Egyptian border filled with arms going into Gaza. Where are the reporters...reporting about death always seem to get more viewers ratehr than facts

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:56 pm ET

dan perman

"all it says in the haaretz report quoting another group is taht the other group claims something that was not proven, it is clear opinion

not good enough"

do you shout hanna braun a jewish girl which had to flee to israel because of hitler a liar?
do you think that what she said was not investivatetd by the UN?
do you think she had to say this because the nazis which did put her under preassure in israel??????

and do you think the UN did cal her liar ?
hana braun only tells us the storry ... and investigations of UN broght up the same jewish fascist sloagan by the jews against the arabs
the same sloagan which gave the arabs reason to do the terror ... which jews have forced up

and do you think the UN only lies?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 8:59 pm ET

dan perman

so you speak german?
http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balfour-Deklaration
what do you read here about your history?

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 8:59 pm ET

akiva

so langweilig

ich habe kein wort ueber hanna braun gesagt, nur dass deine quellen nicht neutral sind

neo oder alt nazi?

Joan   January 11th, 2009 9:00 pm ET

And professor, where's the international law that says it legit????

Matthew Lybanon   January 11th, 2009 9:00 pm ET

Has CNN or any other news organization reported the 61st anniversary celebration of the founding of a Palestinian state? Why not? You could have seen that report, if the Arabs had accepted the U.N. partition resolution in 1947. Instead, they chose violence and bloodshed, much of it directed toward civilians. What is different now? The PLO Charter still calls for the destruction of Israel, one of many Palestinian violations of the Oslo Accords.

Don't fall for the big lie. Don't make the mistake of confusing the criminals with the victims.

Israel occupies one-sixth of 1% of "Arab lands," but the Arabs want it all. And they don't care what they have to do to get it.

Why did I say "Arabs" and not "Palestinians?" Does the United States recognize a nation (state, country, . . .) of Palestine? Has it ever? Has any other country ever recognized such a nation, at any time in world history–even an Arab country? Can you name at least one Palestinian leader before Arafat (who was born in Egypt)?

Do you recall the stories, reported worldwide by the AP, of "Palestinians" celebrating the 9/11 terror attacks against the United States?

Do you think that anyone who teaches children to kill themselves in suicide attacks is worth supporting, under any circumstances? Be honest.

Don't fall for the big lie. Don't support the terrorists.

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:01 pm ET

nice discussion

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 9:01 pm ET

akiva

let's call it quits for today, unless you care to reply to my questions

bist du ein neo nazi oder ein alt nazi?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 9:02 pm ET

dan perman

try it with english ....thanks
and read about you history
read about balfour .... and then go on ;)

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:02 pm ET

I agee with you Dan

Professor   January 11th, 2009 9:03 pm ET

Joan,

If you need someone to define Palestine for you then you do not belong on this blog...

harvey   January 11th, 2009 9:03 pm ET

Hunk,

Thanks for pointing that out however.....

I was talking about the pro Israel demonstration. None of my mates (unsurprisingly) were at the other one. At the pro Israel one which packed Trafalguar Square people showed that they could actively appreiate the diversity and dignity of culture. There were representatives from the Hindu community, the Christian Community, Parliament (Anthony Dismore MP). And no ones flag or even passport was burned as far as I know. I rather like the fact that the crowd sang both Hatikva and God Save the Queen. Sends a message....Love it that Jews, Christians, Hindus and a whole pot pourri of folks can end up singing the National Anthem of a country that allows them freedom to demonstrate and express their thoughts and opinions. Beautiful, a true example that diverse cultures can find commonality.

I'm happy for you to tell us all about the anti Israel demonstarations if you want to....

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:04 pm ET

dan
please dont be too harsh on her

Joan   January 11th, 2009 9:06 pm ET

Professor,

I do not need someone to define Palestine for me. I am asking you what your definition is? Or don't you want to say ??

Professor   January 11th, 2009 9:06 pm ET

Joan,

I am telling you.... you really do not belong here..... becuase you lack knowledge of the basics.

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:06 pm ET

harvey
I think israelis dont need a demonstration, do they?

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:07 pm ET

JOAN
Why do you need a definition?

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 9:08 pm ET

what goes on at TV ... and in israel??
israel women cry because theyr men have to go now in the war by foot?

whats that now?

first they are strong? bombin drones hightech ... and now they cry because they musst go and face hamas?

what goig on in israel?

Pat   January 11th, 2009 9:09 pm ET

Just a small intro. I have been to both muslim countries and israel but I can't explain what a shock it was for me as a European to see Israelis living with security all around them while they live their lives. It's crazy what's going on there and ofcourse terrifying that so many are dead but living 8 years under fear, regardless of how many are die (as defining who is worse off by death count is ridiculous) South Israel, they live in fear as a reality during normal times. In Gaza, it is a war. And it is equally ridiculous to put off thousands of missiles targetin cicilians towns in isarel as a bagatelle.

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:10 pm ET

Sorry everybody but what is the topic under discussion? Could anybody help me here?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 9:12 pm ET

Joan,

I am not a Palestinians... so, I leave that to the Palstinians to define.

The British gave a promise to the Jews to establish a homeland for them on Palestinian land. It was not the British land to give it away to begin with.

The UN devided the land between Palestinians and Israelis.... well, the UN has no right under its charter to give someone's land to somebody else.

So, if Palestinians want to give up half of Palestine to the Jews or they want to take all their land back..... thats their fight to fight and their choices to make.... I just support their struggle against the occupation.

harvey   January 11th, 2009 9:12 pm ET

Joan,

Everybody belongs on this web site as long as they refrain from name calling, abusive and foul language. You are entitled to express your opinion even if someone else finds it reprehensible. Thats what the right of reply is for.....

II think the poins you make are pertinent and your questions thought provoking and challenging!

So in soccer parlance Joan 2 Professor Nil!

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:13 pm ET

Is this a forum devoted to insulting professor or what ?
I need an answer.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 9:16 pm ET

joan

you see, if you don't know professor's basics, leave

how considerate of him

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:17 pm ET

I think harvey is right.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 9:17 pm ET

akiva goy

YOU sent me to a german website and now YOU tell me not to speak german

hahahahahahahaha

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 9:18 pm ET

dan perman

Sie sind eine alte jüdische Nazi?
ein, die sich durch einen steifen Tötung Kinder?

harvey   January 11th, 2009 9:19 pm ET

Talking of leaving, I'm out here. Goodnight folks.
And wishing you all peace, shalom and salam!

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 9:21 pm ET

akiva

your german is worse than your english

dreckiges arschloch

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:21 pm ET

Harvey
Why do you have to break glass in the london demonstration?

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:23 pm ET

i personally think that joan should leave this forum too.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 9:23 pm ET

dan perman

you was talking german i saw words as "du" and "deine" and "bist du"
so i thoght your a german ... are you a dutch?
sorry
talk english if you try to make sentence to me ;)

Pat   January 11th, 2009 9:24 pm ET

Professor, I doubt that Joan lacks knowledge but rather wants you to share what your definition of palistine is. And obviously you are trying to swerve away from answering.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 9:24 pm ET

Professor,

No I do not lack knowledge of the basics. You just can't answer my question because there is no real definition of Palestine, only the various definitions that are in various people's minds. YOu are always citing history, so you must know that 'Palestinian area' has been and continues to be occupied by many different countires now and throughout history. So where do you draw the boundaries ? Where do you go back to???

Certainly the British had no right to divide a territory, but they didn't. The UN did. Did they have the right ? Maybe not. But do you really think Israel will ever be dissolved ? And what about all the other divisions and amalgamations that were made throughout history. Should we undo them?? And just where do we go back to??

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 9:25 pm ET

http://translate.google.ch/translate_t#en|de|are%20you%20a%20old%20jewish%20nazi%3F%0Aone%20who%20get%20a%20stiff%20by%20killing%20children%3F

try to translate by your self :D

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:26 pm ET

ok

Joan   January 11th, 2009 9:27 pm ET

harvey,

thanks for the vote of confidence. Don't worry, noone can drive me away.Whenever I ask a question someone can't answer they always tell me to go to sleep, or go away. That always tells me a lot.

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:31 pm ET

I think joan is either dumb or she does it on purpose. She keeps telling us that we should forget history. Which history? do you consider what happened in 1967 as a far history that we should forget and that the refugees of 1948 , who wait in camps near you in lebanon, should dwell there? THIS IS CALLED ESCAPING TO THE FRONT.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 9:32 pm ET

Joan,

see its not enough you do not know the basics but you do not even ready my comment right.... I am telling you.... you'll do yourself a favor by leaving this blog.

You think if Palestine was always occupied that gives the right for Israel to occupy it more? What a twisted head you have...

Pat   January 11th, 2009 9:33 pm ET

Akiva, what language would you prefer?

Damien Blackley   January 11th, 2009 9:34 pm ET

To those who bring religion into the argument, you cannot used it to justify the actions of Israel. Remember prior to 1917 a majority of Jews had no desire to live in Israel.

To those who pretend to be Jewish or of the Islamic Faith, your statements show what you really are, a piece of human waste.

For Jews to claim only they can defend themselves, go and have a look at the way the Yemen Government has defended your people.

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:35 pm ET

Algerians have fought against the French coloniser for 100 years and they sacrificed one million martyr before they broke free. According to your logic, algeria should be called france now. This is pathetic.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 9:35 pm ET

and if you call me old nazi ... or what ever you did

again only for you ... i hate fascism and i hate the shit called hitler
my family had to flee because of this genocide
and i still cant understand why today the jews do the same to others!!!!!!!!!
its more then sad!!!!!!!!!!
but as israelian or as german or what ever you are you may had not to feel the pain and you may dont know what a genocide is
may thats why you legitimate this genocide at gaza all the time

Professor   January 11th, 2009 9:36 pm ET

Joan,

I am answering your question but you are the one who is having trouble understanding it.

When I support an oppressed group I do not try to tell them what they should do or should not do.

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:38 pm ET

I think that we should differentiate between religion and human rights too. Once religion interferes with politics , things go messy.

Pat   January 11th, 2009 9:42 pm ET

Damian, The same is for arabs that live and work in present day israel. They live peacefully next to eachother. Israelis want peace.

dan perman   January 11th, 2009 9:44 pm ET

akiva

your family had to flee in 1945 because otherwise they would have been up in nuernberg

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:47 pm ET

Dan
name calling is a sign of weakness.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 9:48 pm ET

Professor,

I think it is you who cannot or will not read correctly. I did not say that Israel is right.

You are still telling me to go away, so I guess you can't answer my question about what international law sanctions resistance.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 9:50 pm ET

Pat,

thats a lie....

Professor   January 11th, 2009 9:54 pm ET

Joan,

go back and read my comment and then read what your reply was.... it will show that you either did not read mine.... or you did not understand it.... one of the two.

There are no sanctions against occupation resistance.... you do whatever you can to get rid of the occupier. period full stop.

samy   January 11th, 2009 9:54 pm ET

Pat
That is why you destroy their houses in yafa,ramla,etc...you call this peace.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 9:56 pm ET

Professor,

'When I support an oppressed group, I do not try to tell them what they should or should not do??' Does that mean you support a group no matter waht they do?? Blind faith??? Why would we even bother having laws, or courts, or anything else then?? Feeling oppressed justifies anything???

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:00 pm ET

There is a band of bloggers here who come everyday to tell us that the whole world is wrong and that only israel has the truth. One of them is Dan. Well, let me tell you: Israel has already lost this war ethically at the international level. How can levni enter any arab or islamic country without being insulted. The public is awaiting israeli to throw at them old shoes. Shame on infants killers. I dont know how you you can sleep at night without remorse.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 10:00 pm ET

Professor,

BY your logic, it is okay for abused children to become rapists and abusers. Surely you can do better than that??

Pat   January 11th, 2009 10:03 pm ET

Mathew, nicely said

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:05 pm ET

Joan,

Nope that your logice... becuase the Israelis are the Nazi's of today....

So, just becuase they were oppressed by Hitler and Nazi Germany you think they have the right to grow up and become the Nazis?

John puzellfree   January 11th, 2009 10:05 pm ET

The tragedy in Gaza is just what HAMA wanted so they can take pictures and video only of the suffering, the wounded, the dead of the Palestinains and distribute it to all Arab media and western media worldwide. They make all accusations like the Israel is deliberately killing them, they call it genocide. They never tell the truth nor did they mention HAMAS crime even what they did to fellow Palestinian fighter Fatah. All this are to stir hatred and manipulate world emotions.
Since Muslims are already brainwashed they become more and more emotional like robot around the world by demonstrations help by the Leftish west.
These pictures became the tool of brain washing by imam and politician in mosque and political meeting.
We see how hypocrite Muslims and Arabs are, for example they keep silent about the genocide of 200000 African in Dafur by Arabs Janjaweed that cause 2 millions people displaced that is more than Palestinians Gaza. They keep silent when Sunni and Siah bombing each other in Iraq or Pakistan. Palestians laugh when jihadis strike twin tower in NewYork.
Muslim's rambling from the "intellectuals" to ordinary people about the situation in Gaza or any Middle east problems do not make sense. It's like hearing a broken record.
Unfortunately western media seem to ignore their false statement just to please them which make them bolder in making accusation by twisting the truth.
HAMAS has deceived Muslims world and the world by their propaganda machine with the suffering of the Gaza Palestinians and hold their own people as hostage.
Since they control the news and the video and picture coming out from Gaza, they can deliberately targeted their own people who seek shelter then blame the Israeli. This makes an effective weapon to deceived the world to tell the Israeli to stop the war and withdraw from Gaza
Therefore, when the Israel is force by UN to withdraw like in Lebanon, like Hezbolah, they will self declare victory.
The ironic is while the Palestinian suffers due to HAMAS STUPIDITY action( thinking they can defeat Israel with rockets) their leader lives comfortably in Syria giving orders.

Another hypocrite of Arabs and Muslims is they ignore the Egyptians who prevented the Palestinian fellow "brother" to enter the border to seek shelter or medical help. So much brotherhood.

It's time the world, particularly the Muslims to wake up form Islamic brainwashing.
Even if there is no Palestinian conflict, Muslims will have another excuses to terrorised the world. It is in its nature.

Surah 8:12 [Shakir] When your Lord revealed to the angels: I am with you, therefore make firm those who believe. I will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve.
Therefore strike off their heads and strike off every fingertip of them.
Surah 4:74 Let those fight in the cause of allah Who sell the life of this world for the hereafter. To him who fighteth in the cause of allah,- whether he is slain or gets victory – Soon shall We give him a reward of great (value)

Peace in Islam means when the world submits to Islam and there are no more Kaffir.
This is the core of the conflict why Muslims world seems never live in peace that effected the world.
We are facing a spiritual battle.
Therefore, the world will be never able to solve the Palestinian/Middle East problem. As long as Islam slogan remains "the end justified the means" rather than true peace and love for other fellow human beings.

God don't teach hate but Love.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 10:08 pm ET

Professor?
Are you still here? I see even your delusional friend, the dog that says he is Jesus Christ, Mohammed gharbawi, has gone to sleep with his mother. I think it time that you went to bed too. I cannot believe that you are still able to think up so much crap after so many hours on the blog. Please don't tell Joan that she must leave the blog. She writes 100 times more sense than you. Good Night Professor!

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:09 pm ET

When I saw the little boy who has become blind in Aljazeera I could not finish eating. A terrible shock. I have never thought that people can reach this degree of savageness.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:09 pm ET

Samy,

I agree with you.... the whole world now is against Israel and I don't doubt that will cause problems to Jews in general.... so Jews of Israel has only themselves to blame for electing such a trerrorist government.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 10:11 pm ET

Professor,

I did not ask if there were sanctions against occupation resistance. I asked where is ther an international law that sys it is legit. If someone occupies my house, I do not have the right to shoot that person. At least not in any country I know of.??

Besides, you can't define Palestine, so how can you say the people of Gaza have the right to fire rockets into Israel?? If if 'resisting occupation' is legit, as you claim, then how can call it occupation if you can't define what is being occupied??

ahmed   January 11th, 2009 10:12 pm ET

People the history is clear,before 1917 there was a country known as palastine where palastinian people lived in peace there was jews christians and muslims all living in harmony no conflict or war but aftar britain took over palasine in 1918 they gave belfor's promise to the jews all over the world to come and ESTABLISH A COUNTRY ONTHE ALREADY EXISTING PALASINIAN COUNTRY and thus jews from all over the world started flocking to palastine and started establishing a "new home for them" during this time massive brutal massacres where being done to the palastinian population already living there .
since then isreal was formed (or collected) and thru the past 80 years they have been annoying every one beside them they took golan from syraia(wich couldn't retrive it till now) they attacked egypt and took sinai but egypt has succusully took it back and now after announcing themselves as acountry they attack palstinians brutely coz some home made rockets are bieng launched to what thy call there country.
these rockets are so premitive that it kill palstinians by wrong , I m not praising hamas for there uncalculated actions I see they are wrong there rockets have killed 10 or even less isreals while isreal wityh there mighty army killed about 800 with 2200 injured .
and jonan the reason palastinian are eagre to kill every isreal they can see is not religion (islam doesn't order muslims to kill inicent people men children or women but allows muslims to fight an enemy but in this coflict isreals have taken palastinian land killed thousands and thousand of palastinians SO I think it is fair for palastinian to fight back with every thing they have.
And now isreal are defending there country what country???? and they are using there whole army for what?stopping home made rockets?? don't they have a mosad wich can use few agents to find these rockets

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:12 pm ET

jonas
go to sleep with your mother too.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:12 pm ET

Jonas is here to defend Joan now... well maybe you wanna go play in your playstation together...

Pat   January 11th, 2009 10:13 pm ET

II'm not an expert but I have visited every year in the past 5 years, and I've seen with my own eyes that they have made lives for themselves, some prosperous, others less. There are certainlly examples where that isn't the case but there are also many examples that it exists. Have you been in the North, near Haifa?

ahmed   January 11th, 2009 10:14 pm ET

Joan or Jonan
u can google the facts

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:17 pm ET

Joan,

In the US if someone trespass on to your property you shoot him. And no one will ask you why you did that.

I do not know what part of the world you live in. So, i will not tell you how to get rid of someone occupying your house.... But here in the US we shoot to kill.

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:17 pm ET

professor
This notion of "government" in Israel should be handled critically. Itis like a movie. All governments agree on the essential : killing and deporting arabs. they are racists, liers, shameless, etc............. They may have a democracy , but this democracy is internal and race-specific only. When it comes to others, they take away the mask and start killing, deporting, jailing, etc.....

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:19 pm ET

Oh and you might want to read the Geneva convention on that.... do you need me to tell you which article too?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:21 pm ET

Samy,

no doubt about that.... After all they all graduated from the Haganah, Irgun and the Stern terrorist gangs.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 10:23 pm ET

Professor,

I do not support Israel's actions. I have never said that.

However, if someone points a gun at you, you do have the right to defend yourself by firing back, at least everywhere in the world that I know. All I'm saying is that I wouldn't point a BB gun at a guy with a big automatic. That's just suicide. And if I chose to do something that stupid, I would make sure my children, family, and friends were well out of harm's way.

Do you really think that Hamas is helping the Palestinians??

Do you really think that all this effort to make Israelis look bad (and believe me, they do look bad, they don't need any help from anyone to look bad, they can do that all by themselves) is worth the lives of so many Gazans?

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:24 pm ET

Professor
I think it is high time the world found a radical solution to this radical problem, I mean the problem od Israel. It has come to existence with a promise from Belfour. On ly back in around 1890 Hertzel send two religioud persons to discover palestine. You know what they told him:"the bride (palestine) is beautiful but married". They had what they wanted because of Britain and saix Pico treaty. This is the beginning of this cancerous state.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 10:25 pm ET

John puzellfree,

“the end justified the means”

You are blaming the the Gazans for appearing as dead and wounded on the pictures!!! but don't talk of the murder!!!! and who committed it!!! on the pretext of what "self defense".

This your “the end justified the means” and just proved its not Islamic and can be used in what ever manner to pass these pictures as propaganda !! its true when A blogger here ask how you can sleep at night or day.

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:25 pm ET

So, when Jews in Israel elect terrorists to run their affairs they have no one to blame but themselves.

Pat   January 11th, 2009 10:25 pm ET

In any case, everyone seems to cite dates and history figures. But the fact remains that hammas is hiding behind their own people. On either CNN or BBC, a Hammas spokesman sitting in Beirut in his nice suit says that all Palistinians are their soldiers and the occupied lands are from the sea to Jordan. Israel has a right to exist. accept it and then progress can be made. With these slogans full of hate in the arab world being tatooed in the minds of children (you should take a look at the shows for kids), no wonder extremists are finding it easy to manipulate people. how can anyone condemn Israel after an 8 year patience, to strike back. Would anyone in Europe and North america allow this. Ofcourse not.

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:27 pm ET

Professor
dont answer joan.Ignore her. she is ignorant and dumb. she is only to waste your time.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 10:27 pm ET

hey people ...
i wanna say something.... to allllllllllllllllllll
very important
there was a british israel demo

there was a older woman

what she did say i think we have to know!
she did say that she ... as a demonstrant.... as a jew
dont agree with that genocide at gaza done by israel !

so not all jews are nazis :)

it makes me happy :D

i am happy that jews did demontrate against what israel is doing to gaza ... and this at the same time as other jews ... stupid young nazi jews did a pro israel demo :(

Joan   January 11th, 2009 10:29 pm ET

Professor,

You know that in the US you cannot legally shoot trespassers. Please stick to the facts.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 10:30 pm ET

Jonas,

Why you are so pissed off?

Are you here to take revenge from Mohammad on his absence?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:32 pm ET

Joan,

I am glad you finally stated it....

Since you do not support Israel then we can discuss this issue in a more civilized way.

I agree with you if I know that you have a gun I will not pull a knife to fight you with.... but again thats you me speaking while sitting in a warm living room watching a bigscreen TV and watching the Gazan's getting butchered by terrorist and Nazi criminals.

If you or I were in their shoes right now and after 60 years of oppression who knows how we will act specially if you lost a father, a mother, a brother, a sister, a sun or a daughter. or maybe all of them in some cases.

Damien Blackley   January 11th, 2009 10:32 pm ET

Akiva

I know what a genocide is. It not only happen to the Jews, have a look at Africa and the Pol Pot regime in Asia. A genocide is when one race of people believe another race to be inferior or a threat to their way of life.

I do not like people who use Religion or who use History to justify what has happen to both Jew and Palestinian alike at this time. The problem being that they select those things which suit their argument.

Call it a war or a genocide, most times these events occur in the name of Religion.

I was raise to respect all people irrespective of their Race, Color or Creed.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 10:33 pm ET

ahmed,

which facts do you suggest I google?

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:33 pm ET

Israel has come to existance thanks to Britain. Even when britain was in palestins, jews had the right to form their own army in the 1920s. That s why they call the British Samuel " a good jew!".

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:34 pm ET

Hunk,

Joans was born pissed off.... so don't take him seiously.... LOL

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:36 pm ET

Joan,

can you move to the newest blog on the London demostrations?

Professor   January 11th, 2009 10:37 pm ET

Hunk,

I meant Jonas....

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:40 pm ET

In 1925 samuel and Belfour met in jerusalem to think about the next steps. In 1929, tens of jews came to celebrate one of their worships. They were attacked by arabs. Three of these arabs were hung by the British. After that period, colonisers started to triple thanks to the zionist agency , which used to give them money to buy land by force.

Hunk   January 11th, 2009 10:41 pm ET

Pat,

If an occupation force comes to take me from my house... i myself will not leave .... I prefer to die at my own home then to live in shame without dignity ... if you been fighting for your place under the SUN and your father before and your grandfather before that for as long as 60 years , will you not fight for at least something you call HOME .

Have you heard of a SAFE ZONE for civilians , a place where civilians seeking shelter can take refuge at .... no ... so you leave your house to be killed at both cases you are dead.

Joan   January 11th, 2009 10:42 pm ET

Professor,

You are stil supporting the idea that people will react to oppression, abuse etc. I can never justify emotional reaction, because that is what it is. And the timespan just makes it even more illogical. They have had years to figure out a response that might produce a positive and realistic outcome.

You cannot control what happens to you. You can only control how you deal with it. That is what defines character, and success in people.

I don't understand how intelligent people can support the strategy and tactics of the Gazans. They are not working for them. THey keep doing the same thing and it keeps not working. So why are their supporters not trying to help them.

You say you suport them as an oppressed group, and you call yourself a professor. So why don't you try to help them.

You say you don't want to tell them what to do. IF you see your friend doing something destructive to himself, don't you try to help him find another way??

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:43 pm ET

Hunk
Mohammed gharbawi is my brother. Thanks for defending him. I ALREADY ANSWERED JONAS ? THE DOG.

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:47 pm ET

iN 1933 , riots started in jerusalem against the coming of jews. Even the mayor of jerusalem kadem Alhussaini was killed by a british officer. This mayor was 80 years old. the office who killed palestinians by firing 25 bullet was promoted in work.

Jonas   January 11th, 2009 10:48 pm ET

Samy,
Sure, i have seen yours!
Professor,
Your skin is thicker than a camel's! It's one thing to tell your blind friends on this blog that the world hates the Jews, they will believe you, but there is something you forget, the world doesn't exactly like Arabs! Don't think because some stupid people believe your lies and propaganda that the Arabs have suddenly become the darlings of the world. Big mistake, fool. If they thought that you had a real concern for the Palestinian people, it would have been different, but we know that your are only driven by your hatred of the Jews.

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:49 pm ET

In 1931, the number of jews was 4000; in 1935, it has become 61 000.

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:52 pm ET

IN 1930 jews raised their flag for the first time and started exporting the palestinian orange.

barham   January 11th, 2009 10:54 pm ET

Pat Wrote
""how can anyone condemn Israel after an 8 year patience, to strike back. Would anyone in Europe and North america allow this. Ofcourse not.""

So are you giving a fact here that Israel didnt attack Palestinians? How do you define the fact that Israel killed 4895 (twice the number of 911 causalities) Palestinians in the last 8 years? including 1050 Palestinian children? NOT INCLUDING THIS WAR!! go Google Palestinians Killed! before sounding here as a kid repeating a biased propaganda spoon fed to his brain.

samy   January 11th, 2009 10:55 pm ET

in 1936, many houses were destryed inyafa because they belong to arabs who are against the newcomers (the jews).

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:05 pm ET

All these historical facts point to one reality: Israel is aforce of occupation that should be wiped out of palestine.

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:11 pm ET

Who is behind all troubles in the middle-east: Israel. It occupied Sinaa, and the jordan valley; it still occupies the west bank and Ghaza.
It occupied south lebanon. It still occupies shabaa farms. It detains 11000 palestinian. It does not apply UN resolutions. It kills people who disagree with its policy : moghniyya, abu jihad, sheikh yassine, Dr sintissi, Arafat (by poison), etc................................................

Pat   January 11th, 2009 11:12 pm ET

Hunk, I have a husband and 3 kids and if the town in which I live was being struck with missiles for 8 years, I would be in rage that no one is doing anything about it. I wouldn't have waited 8 years. Therefore, I can't see why anyone can dispute the right to self defense. I also know that when israel disengaged, the borders were open and suicide bombers committed not only by men but by women and also children arrived into israel. I think any country would do the same in closing the borders. It is too simple to point the finger at Israel just because they have a stronger military etc. The Hammas were provoking the Israeli population. What can they accept. It is tragic, the death toll in Gaza but the comparison between the deaths on both side can't be used to measure who is right and who is wrong. I can't understand this solidarity between Arabs. I can't imagine siding with another Catholic for example just because he is catholic and I know that he is wrong. And the Hammas and other groups like them are wrong. They are terrorists and they make the world, the whole world, insecure. Where is the criticism on these groups? Where was the rage from Europe and North America when israeli lives were being endangered every day by missiles from Gaza? And how can anyone expect Israel to make any sort of deal with the Hammas? Would anyone ask the US to deal with Al Qaida? Any human with a heart is hurting to see those pictures of dead, injured, crying kids. But when you only see those pics on the one side and just military might on the other, it is easy for an audience to make a quick connection, without really thinking it over. Who is fighting among civilians? Who has endangered their own people? Any whether anyone wants to believe it or not, Israel does value life. What other country would set up humantarian corridors? Some will say they are not letting in enough. But there are reasons for them to be controlling them, Today a supposed humanitarian truck wanted to pas through the Egyptian border. Upon inspection, they found ammo. How can you cry out war crimes everywhere against Israel when the Hammas have been using children to cover them? And then run away and mingle among other civilians?

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:12 pm ET

Why do we have to tolerate this bastard nation?

Pat   January 11th, 2009 11:18 pm ET

well samy, poisoned Arafat? Well you sound like that Hammas spokesman on CNN who was sitting comfortably in beirut. Who repeats propaganda here? I am neither a muslim nor jew, nor a Palistinian nor an israeli, but I support that Israel had a right for self defense

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:19 pm ET

PAT
palestine has never been your land. Do a simle thing: see your family tree if you happen to have one and see where your grandgrand fathers used to live. Read what I wrote about the beginning of the coming of jews to the promised land and judge by yourself. The end of your existence is a question of time, believe me Pat.

Akiva   January 11th, 2009 11:20 pm ET

Pat

how much hate did israel seed ?
all this people in gaza .... after such a genocide?... if they hate israel cant you understand?

if all your children get bombed ... what would you do ... go to israel and gatulate them?
or maybe go in your kitchen and build a rocket?

after all this time of occupation ... of illegal embargo based on lies ?
no food no nothing life in a prison .... and you see how your children must life in gaza ... under occupation ... under ilegal embargo....
hungry ... not able to get what you need only for live .... excludes mp3 playe or such luxus .... hat you would do?????????????

there is no excuse for this holocaust!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

israel must face the international court of justice
there is no sorry for all the pain ... no excuse !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Pat   January 11th, 2009 11:25 pm ET

Another question I have that makes me wonder. Obviously it takes money to arm yourself like the Hammas does and build up their infrastructure. well why wasn't this money used to invest in more productive ways? I don't know like schools, books instead of arms and camps for young kids to learn the ways of Hammas or TV programs that only brainwash the young to hate and want to kill other people. How can you defend that? Or is it again the excuse that they had no other means? If their way of thinking was right, the Hammas wouldn't need to brainwash their kids as young as toddlers.

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:26 pm ET

Jonas the dog
are you dumb or you need to have courses in grammar. When we say "and im jesus christ" or "and im the virgin Mary", we simply mean :you lie. This is a British expression. Muslims don't insult prophets and we don't kill them either, you, jews, do. Go to learn ignorant. Concerning leaving this forum, we would be glad that you do. you are a disgrace to humanity.

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:29 pm ET

Pat we prefer killing israelis to building schools. ok.

Pat   January 11th, 2009 11:30 pm ET

Jonas, do you know of another blog? It's crazy in here.

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:33 pm ET

pat
if you are not a jew or an israeli, why are you working with them full time in this blog. are you from the mosad or what.

Pat   January 11th, 2009 11:34 pm ET

Samy, that's obvious. And in response to an earlier comment, I am nor Muslim nor Jew nor Israeli nor Palistinain. I' m actually a European Christian

EdM   January 11th, 2009 11:36 pm ET

samy: "When I saw the little boy who has become blind in Aljazeera I could not finish eating. A terrible shock. I have never thought that people can reach this degree of savageness." You avoided watching the results of Palestinian suicide bombers killing and maiming Israeli civilians (mostly Jews but some Arabs who were sitting with the Jews also) with bombs loaded with ball bearings to do maximum damage to humans? You avoided watching the Passover massacre of Jews about to celebrate a religious service in a hotel, or at restaurants, or on buses, etc? And then the Arabs celebrate and idolize the murderer? For decades we've felt the same way: I had never thought that people can reach this degree of savageness.
But at the same time I've seen Arabs and Jews in Israel living together in peace and helping each other. So I know it is possible.
Why the killing? My view: land over life, the messengers of hate are winning over those who just want to live in peace. Anyone of us who presents just one side of this sad, sad story is biased and supporting the continuation of the misery. And that's what is going to happen, based on the inputs to this blog. Unable to let go of the problems of the past and live together, as Israelis (Jews and Arabs) have done. So, call me naive, wrong, dumb, etc but you cannot truthfully deny the fact that Jews and Arabs have lived together for decades in Israel and could have in the broader area.

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:38 pm ET

Its better for both of you ,pat and jonas, to leave this forum because you dont have anything to say here.

Pat   January 11th, 2009 11:38 pm ET

Full time? I've been here for the first time a couple hours ago. But hey, someone who deosn't share your view is automatically a jew or Israeili. Which anyway is nothing to be ashamed of. It's sad really

Pat   January 11th, 2009 11:41 pm ET

EdM, I've seen Arans and Jews live peacefully in israel in Haifa while i was visiting, but no one seems to believe me

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:43 pm ET

EDM
You have the solution.It isa simple one.
1- give us our land that you occupied in 1967.
2- allow the people you expelled by force in 1984 to where they belong (some of them in lebanon still have their keys!).
ISNT THIS OUR RIGHT
We will forget about what you did before 1948 (to shothat im not an extremist).

Barham   January 11th, 2009 11:45 pm ET

Pat """ I can’t imagine siding with another Catholic for example just because he is catholic and I know that he is wrong. """

So you think Israelis killing 6000 Palestinians in the last 8 years is not wrong? further Israel occupying palestinians' land. it is a fact, it wont help blinding your brain from FACTS. and you think Palestinians are wrong for trying to defend them selves? tell me please how you see this? how do you think in general someone with an occupied land is wrong? unless you are a terrorist occupier.

Do you hear "occupation" then you try to think of what Bush say " Oh oh they hate us for our way of life " Guess what China has a way of life and no one hates it!! look at your self in the mirror first, and think what you actually doing.

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:48 pm ET

EDM
I mean 1948
Pat
Dont rely on what you visited. Ask the local arab population. They destroy their houses under the pretext that they dont have a building license. Can you accept an israeli to tell you this knowing that the house was built 100 years ago and before by your grandgrand father (before jews were there). IS THIS NORMAL?

Pat   January 11th, 2009 11:50 pm ET

Then they should defend themselves without using children and women. I don't know any normal person regardless of religion that would place their wife or child to protect themselves. No one.

EdM   January 11th, 2009 11:50 pm ET

samy:
"Who is behind all troubles in the middle-east: Israel." How about the Arabs by attacking after UN passed 181, how about the PLO which was kicked out of Jordan after many were killed by Jordanians, how about religious rivalries (Iraq), etc. Both sides samy.

"It still occupies shabaa farms." Israel pulled back from what the UN declared was Lebanese territory. Then Hezbullah declared bascially that the UN was wrong, that Shabaa farms was Lebanese not Syrian. Both sides samy.

"It does not apply UN resolutions." And the Arabs do? How about 181? Don't like 181? Too bad. You can't pick which ones to adhere to.
"It kills people who disagree with its policy" And the Arabs don't??!!!! What about all th ewars they started, all the suicide bombers, etc? Both sides samy.

"palestine has never been your land." Well, if you mean it was never Jewish land, you've missed a lot of history. As you probably really know, it has been settled by many different tribes over its history, including Philistines, Canaanites, Hebrews, etc. Both sides samy.

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:53 pm ET

PAT
how would you react in europe if you were living now under Hitler's occupation. You would accept the situation and say ok this is history. I should forget because he occupied us in 1938. Answer me, please.

Pat   January 11th, 2009 11:54 pm ET

no one has responded about the shows that are aired for kids. It's plain brinwashing. Cartoon characters who idiolise killing the Jew. Idiolising killing to kids! And that sacrificing himself for that is glorified? What is wrong with that picture?

samy   January 11th, 2009 11:59 pm ET

Pat
Dis you see them using children and women? Ghazais a heavily densed population. Israelis bomb the city with artillery and phosphoric bombs. It kills children, women, and men. See the statistics. Hamas soldiers fight in the city outskirts, not inside. Otherwise, who killed the 32 israeli soldiers (a number that israel hides ) . another question: who prevented the israelis from entering the ghaza city from the north yesterday. Let me assure you my lady that even some top leaders in Hamas are participating in the fight as we speak now. try to diversify your sources and see as many channels as you can. Israelis will never give real events. I F THEY ARE NOT AFRAID? WHY DONT THEY ALLOW JOURNALISTS TO FILM.

Pat   January 12th, 2009 12:03 am ET

I live in a country where Hitler was ruler. But the generations of today try to make better lives for themselves. Despite deprivations after WWII, and much distrust and disgust from other European nations, they proved themselves to change. Israelis think of the holocaust daily as they are all the result of survivors, yet the majority can still place history behind, shake hands with germans and Austrians, even hold close relations with them on social, political and economic levels.

samy   January 12th, 2009 12:03 am ET

EDM
i refer you to my earlier comments .see them and tell me if im wrong. everything is documented and verifiable. Give me your email and ill send you the documents or just go the Telaviv university library.

samy   January 12th, 2009 12:06 am ET

Pat
you miss the point. You are free now. we are not. Sorry but I cant simplify more.

Pat   January 12th, 2009 12:07 am ET

Samy, they do use women and children. You would be refusing an international known fact. As I speak different languages, I do watch several channels with different political leanings to get a clearer picture. But if you are trying to say that Arab channels are unbiased and show only the real news, no one can convince me of that

Akiva   January 12th, 2009 12:08 am ET

but let us stay in alert about mossad ;)

samy   January 12th, 2009 12:09 am ET

EDM
YOU DID NOT ANSWER MY QUESTION ABOUT THE OFFER.STRANGELY I NEVER GET AN ANSWER ABOUT LAND AND PEACE IN THIS BLOG.

samy   January 12th, 2009 12:11 am ET

ok PAT
give those channels that show them using children and ill believe you straight away.

Pat   January 12th, 2009 12:12 am ET

You call those who support the Israeli action blinded. Well so be it. It's sad really. Good night all, bonne nuit, Gute nacht, Laila tov

Barham   January 12th, 2009 12:12 am ET

PAT,
Israelis are not bombing military bases with their artillery shells, they are bombing a city, it also happen to be the most human dense city in the world (CIA FACTBOOK) after Israel imprisoned Palestinians there, Now how do you think no children would die? where you think usually children live? what they are attacking are couple hundreds of young resistance men in their actual homes where their families, these non uniformed street resistance men holding AK-47 machine guns mostly, what would any other merely decent army who proclaim to be civilized not to kill thousands of civilians would do is a street war, yet Israel is using artillery shells which is known to be the least accurate, most sever area damaging weapon. and you think they think for children burned alive?

samy   January 12th, 2009 12:15 am ET

Pat
what about the bomb that killed 5 sisters in front of their father and mother in addition cousins. a family which was hiding in one room.
Who caused the little girl to lose both legs when she was playing in the roof with her friend.
Who caused the death of.............................................................etc.
You got to be kiddin PAT.

samy   January 12th, 2009 12:18 am ET

i knew it. I knew pat was israeli.

samy   January 12th, 2009 12:21 am ET

edf
no answer because you are a nation of fighters. you cant line in peace.

samy   January 12th, 2009 12:24 am ET

okkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
i get it????????????????????????????????????????

Akiva   January 12th, 2009 12:24 am ET

Pat is also german ... also the german pro israel gang ?
uhhh "Gute nacht, Laila tov" bye germany :p

EdM   January 12th, 2009 12:25 am ET

samy:
Likewise everything I've written is true. It's all documented and verifiable. It's opposite sides of a complex story.
As you likely know, some of the Palestinian refugees from the Arab attack on Israel were encouraged to leave until the Arab armies won. I have no idea how many. The Arabs then did not incorporate these folks into their countries but left them in camps. They were not driven out by Israel. By the way, are you also aware of how the UN defined a palestinian refugee? A person with a historical home in Palestine? A person who had owned land in Palestine for ages, decades, many years? Nope. "Under UNRWA's operational definition, Palestine refugees are persons whose normal place of residence was Palestine between June 1946 and May 1948, who lost both their homes and means of livelihood as a result of the 1948 Arab-Israeli conflict." Two years !!! And you likely know why; many folks came into Palestine during the 1900s, Jews and Arabs from neighboring countries, who then refused to settle them to avoid recognizing Israel. they allowed the misery to continue for these souls. Quite a trajedy. By the way, it's all documented.

Finally, I had written earlier the following and will repeat it here because no one has addressed it. According to CNN’s short summary of Gaza facts, three-quarters of Gaza is under cultivation. Hamas has built over a hundred tunnels for smuggling things from Egypt to Gaza. Is it really believable that they could not have built underground storage for the weapons in the ¾ of Gaza that is unoccupied, under cultivation for crops, or fired their rockets from unoccupied areas? Instead it seems they have intentionally stored and fired from well-populated areas. This seems to me like asymmetric warfare, intending to either deter attacks on their forces and weapons or use the resulting civilian casualties for PR. The counter to that seems to me to be international outrage at Hamas putting its civilian population at risk. But I see little of that. By the way, I am appalled and feel tremendous empathy for the folks who are just trying to live their lives and are in Gaza. They should not be subjected to such enormous misery, death, injury, destruction, etc. But I see the cause as all sides, including the international community for not condemning little actions that ended up leading (predictably) to this crisis. Address the little actions before they lead to blood, which seems to be about all the media report. This kind of asymmetric warfare is very hard to counter. True?
I'm done for the night. Will check back tomorrow. Hope both sides will have stopped the violence by then but wouldn't bet a dime on it.

Akiva   January 12th, 2009 12:51 am ET

i am in next blog

tarig   January 12th, 2009 4:17 am ET

WE ARE IGNORANT AND YOU ARE AN OUTSTADING SCHOLAR. YOU ARE NOT SUDANESE. YOU ARE ISRAELI. WE KNOW THESE TACTICS. YOU MUST BE ONE OF THE STUDENTS OF DAN.

mohammed

why because i want the world to live in peace, because i am saying both sides are wrong. wake up, you want to do something to benefit your religion stop attacking these people and try educating them. i doubt if you can but the bottom line is violence is never gonna be the solution.

tarig   January 12th, 2009 4:25 am ET

An Isreali supporter hiding behind a nick…. nothing new to the tactics used by Israeli terrorist organizations….
prof.
again i tell you BOTH SIDES ARE WRONG. if you new islam you would know the murder of women and children is wrong, just because isrealis do it doesnt mean muslims should sink to their level. wake up your tactics wont bring peace to the muslim world, only more pain and anguish. but clearly you dont want to read what i am writing, your just obsessed with trying to prove that you are right and the rest are wrong, unless they agree with you. remind me of the US govt. islam is a religion of peace, and when at war women and children are off bounds, if jews jumped off a bridge would you follow? im not questioning palestinians right to resist, only the methods that hamas are following. the world (ie political opinion) is already pro-isreali, muslims dont need to give them more ammo, as is the case whenever a single civillian is injured

tarig   January 12th, 2009 4:45 am ET

lynne,

no it doesnt mean we should destroy those who dont believe what we do, thats genocide were not nazis! it means you should fight, and if need be, destroy anyone who is trying to anihalate you. i only know islamic rules of engagement so i wont comment on other religions, but we are clearly directed that war is and can only be a last resort, when there is no other option and without it we face destruction, and in such a scenario war is just and Allah is on our side. i will say that the palestinian uprising is just, without it they would slowly be exterminated. but it is completely illigitimate to carry out acts in the process of war that can result in harm to women or chiildren or the elderly and impaired. for this reason i dont agree with the tactics that hamas is taking. granted i dont believe the IDF will ever face arabs face to face, but the ANC won their freedom in south africa whilst making every attempt to avoid civillian casualties (and pretty successfully i may add). why cant palestinians follow this example?

i will answer that question for you. people are products of their societies. any palestinian born in the last 60+ years has seen nothing but death and destruction. when this is what you are surrounded by this is all you know, basic human compasion goes out of the window, instead the aim is victory over oppression at all costs, even if you die. if you treat a person like an animal do you expect him to remain courtious to you? no, isreal new what they were doing treating humans this way, it doesnt take a genius to see this. but the rest of the arab world arent in the same situation and we therefore have the responsibility to aid our brothers. not by giving them missiles to aim at civillian populations, but training them in the art of attacking army posts, political structures, the very fabric of a society without harming civillians in the process. if this happened 'the world' (by this i mean political power bases not the general public) would have no reason not to back them in the same manner the ANC was backed because public opinion would be 100% behind them, i think even most isrealis would be (bar the hardliners).

tarig   January 12th, 2009 4:50 am ET

the real question is :Why did israel move from gaza?
well sharon had aplan ; he realized that there is no need for keeping the strip and that the best solution is to leave it. By this step, he wanted to reach two objectives. The first one is the avoidance of casualties by resistance and the second is the creation of a tension between hamas and fattah on that territory. he knew that hama has the majority there and that if it takes control, we wii end up with two palestinian authorities.

mohammed

you missed out the part about the resources that have been overtaken in the west bank, basically isreals source of water, and substantial arable land. whilst they were withdrawing from the gaza strip they were building in the west bank, but the media forgot to mention that part.

Hunk   January 12th, 2009 7:27 am ET

Pat,

It sadden me to know of your life condition, me too I am a family man that will do all he can to protract his family.

I seen the Palestinians thrown stones at the first INTIFADA and seen the breaking the bone torture method and that saddened me too, i heard from both sides of same story .

I look at the suicide bombing as the weapons of the hopeless, and I can understand that you will not agree with me on this, but again, after so many years and no hope and a false peace process that seems to go endlessly forever and ever bringing with it a greater anxiety, having said that, i would like to draw alight to the same doctrine that those suicide bombers refer to ,which is Islam, which put you and all children and all women s , all people at their places of worship irrespective of gender, age and faith plus the elderly and those at their home and all who chose not to fight as non combat and civilians that should not be harmed.

I even called a random number and talked to a retired gentleman living on Israel who received my call on high spirit even coming from an Arab and a Muslim who is me, we kept the respect while we disagreed on all subject.

I hope this bloodshed ends and Palestinians will have a state side by side with Israel.

Hope the best of your Husband and your three kids may god save them.
I wish you wish the best for the children of Gaza who is not living but dying.

tarig   January 12th, 2009 7:39 am ET

Referring to last week's UN Security Council call for an immediate ceasefire, Mr Olmert said "nobody should be allowed to decide for us if we are allowed to strike".
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7823361.stm

mohammed/proffesor

a perfect example of why the arab world should not demean itself to isreali standards. this is a clear statement that isreal believes it is above international law. the sad fact is there right, but this can be changed, not by bombing civillians but by waging a just war. many will die, but they arent people who fear death, and as a muslim you should know that the pleasures they are due in the afterlife far exceed anything they can attain in this one. again i tell you, we shouldnt encourage people to do wrong just because wrong is being commited on them. there are legitimate targets, and illigitimate ones. if your a believer (muslim, christian, jew) you know what i am saying, and if not basic logic should be followed.

tarig   January 12th, 2009 7:50 am ET

brandon, considering your advocating genocide that includes you in the TERRORIST category. im confident there will come a day when you eat your words and no matter what you say in reply to this i wont acknowledge you with an answer because you and people like you simply arent worth it. bottom line you want a nuke dropped, you advocate it make sure your prepared for the fall out.

Ashley   January 12th, 2009 8:04 am ET

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6604775898578139565

This is not the time to point fingers at each other. We need to figure out the root cause of this conflict. PLEASE SEE THIS VIDEO ! It will help you understand the TRUTH about this conflict. U WILL NOT SEE THIS ANYWHERE ELSE & IT IS BEYOND SHOCKING!!!

tarig   January 12th, 2009 8:13 am ET

Despite deprivations after WWII, and much distrust and disgust from other European nations, they proved themselves to change. Israelis think of the holocaust daily as they are all the result of survivors, yet the majority can still place history behind, shake hands with germans and Austrians, even hold close relations with them on social, political and economic levels.

pat

big difference is hitler is dead and the nazis are finished. you want the palestinians to shake your hand and forgive and forget, do what europe did for you for them. give them a homeland, compensate them for there losses, ask for forgiveness and prove you are willing to work towards a better future together. do you really think bombing schools and using legal munitions in illigal methods is going to lead to the palestinians wanting peace with you? do you really think if hitler was still around you and other jews would be shaking german and austrian hands? arabs didnt face the wrath of hitler, but we have faced isreali aggression for decades (which may i add is the supreme international crime)

tarig   January 12th, 2009 8:17 am ET

http://chomsky.info/articles/20070105.htm

jonas this link is for you, follow it, it explains what we were discussing yesterday. its not a referenced article, but if you go back to some of the sources he mentions you will find it to be rather accurate. ashley your a good man.

tarig   January 12th, 2009 8:21 am ET

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7823204.stm

another reason not to follow what you hear blindly and instead try educating yourselves from various different sources.

Jonas   January 12th, 2009 9:54 am ET

Tarig,
I agree, use multiple sources. Maybe this will explain why Arabs in general and Palestinians in particular are not on any Jewish invitation lists:
http://www.themiddleeastnow.com/musnazi.html

tarig   January 12th, 2009 12:12 pm ET

Jonas,

this site refers to muslim extremists not muslims in general it says that clearly in the first paragraph. and just to note, the vatican implicitly backed the nazi holocaust as well, maybe christians shouldn't be on any jewish invitation lists? maybe you are misuderstanding my point all together though. extremists on both sides get their fuel from the ignorance of the masses they claim to represent. i wont deny the info on the link you provided me because it is the first time i have seen anything of this nature, but if you really want peace you have to acknowledge masacres taking place on both sides and being commited by all parties involved. i know its a line from a film but its accurate when you say the greatest enemy will hide in the last place you would look, maybe our greatest enemy isnt the IDF but the people who aim to kill randomly in our so called defense. also maybe your greatest enemy isnt so called terrorists but your very own IDF, both are blocking the way for us to live in harmony by ensuring their masses remain ignorant, and follow THEIR desires blindly. does what i am saying resonate with you in any way?

tarig   January 12th, 2009 1:48 pm ET

http://www.lrb.co.uk/v28/n16/laor01_.html

jonas, check this out to try to clarify what i am saying!

aedi   January 12th, 2009 2:42 pm ET

Israel Gov (TM) is starting to feel alone, and it is being forced to collect more jews willing to live under Israel Gov (TM) protection.
Exporting violence around the world against generic jews will make them decide to go to Israel Gov (TM) resort land. You know, you need new people to continue growing real state business and satellites

Tony Clarke   January 12th, 2009 2:54 pm ET

Hamas have much in common with the Nazis of former times .

Hamas are funded with money from Syria and Iran and supplied with materials for pipe bombs which they transport via tunnels across the border from Egypt, and by any other means across their borders.

Hamas make a nice little profit from firing their pipe bombs to Israel for month, sponsored by their friends for each one fired and for each Israeli citizen reported killed.

Then as expected, eventually Israel decided to respond. As a result Hamas receive an even larger payoff from their friends in Syria and Iran. Hamas leaders are on to a nice earner. – why would Hamas want to stop any of this conflict? They are being paid very well to keep it going!

That is why the leader of Hamas said on TV a few hours ago that the conflict is going well. That is why Hamas have no intention of making a ceasefire. Hamas are on to a ‘good thing’, lining their pockets at the expense of the Palestinian people and sponsored by Syria and Iran.

Hunk   January 12th, 2009 3:42 pm ET

Abbas gov, is closing to an end, do you think he will win in the coming elections? if not then who? .....

Will Hamas be stronger or weaker? .... where Palestine political scene is heading? .....

spiraling down   January 12th, 2009 6:19 pm ET

Arab rhetoric is as usual loud and obnoxious. There is absolutley nothing the "Islamic Republics" can do other than protest in the streets. After this is all over I expect the Arab world to initiate another war, and again blame the start of the next conflict on someone other than themselves.
Get over it already, there is no Palestine. Hamas brought on the deaths of the people in Gaza. Hamas will be the death of Gaza.
The Hamas warriors are still hiding behind women and children. If the lives of Palestinians have no value to them, why should they have any value to the IDF?
Bye Bye Gaza

John puzellfree   January 12th, 2009 9:20 pm ET

ahmed wrote:"People the history is clear,before 1917 there was a country known as palastine "

Palestine was named by the Roman after it conquered the land. However, previously it was Canaan before the Israel came back from Egypt. Then it became kingdom of Israel and Judah where Jerusalem became it's capital city or king David city.
After the Roman destroyed the city many Jews immigrate to other lands.
But, many still live there along with other races. When Islam took Jerusalem the land was occupied by Muslims ruler (caliphate) who build Aqsa Mosque ( by Muhammad claimed having visited Aqsa Mosque during Isra Miraj is proven invalid, because it has not been built yet). Then Arabs Muslims came to occupy the land. Just like they do in Iraq whose original people are the Assyrian. Now it became Arabs land.
There was no such thing call Palestinian country or nations. People who lives there are the Jews and the Arabs and Christians.
Originally, it was the Israeli Kingdom land then taken over by the Roman Kaffir, then turn as part of Roman Christians land then Islam spread and took the land. When Islamic empire power demised and European power increases, the fall of the last caliphate was the turning point where all Muslims countries were defeated and colonised by the western power.
Palestine land was then under the British empire rule who re-drawn the map of the Middle East out of the collapse of the Ottoman empire the last Islamic ruler.
So, Israel Nation was re-created. Gaza was part of Egypt, Westbank was part of Jordan. The people of that land are Egyptians Arabs and Jordanian Arabs.
After a n humiliated defeat of Combine Arabs armies by Israel in 6 days war in 1967, Israel took Sinai and Gaza strip from Egypt but return the Sinai to Egypt as peace agreement. In the meantime, Arabs groups call palestinians let by Arafat creating problems within Jordan and war started between them and Syrian help Arafat. Arafat created terror in Jordan and on Israeli around the world, They also create problems in Lebanon. So in 1988, Jordan give up her souvergn of Westbank while still under Israeli hand) and gave it to PLO Arafat.
So, my point is that the so call Palestinian nation was created by Arafat. Basically, they are Jordanians Arabs Muslims and Christians in Westbank and Egyptians Arab(Muslims, Christians and Jews) in Gaza strip.

The coming of the Jews from around the world to the land, was prophecied in the Bible as God's will.

Isaiah 41:8-14
8 “ But you, Israel, are My servant,
Jacob whom I have chosen,
The descendants of Abraham My friend.
9 You whom I have taken from the ends of the earth,
And called from its farthest regions,
And said to you, ‘ You are My servant,
I have chosen you and have not cast you away:
10 Fear not, for I am with you;
Be not dismayed, for I am your God.
I will strengthen you,
Yes, I will help you,
I will uphold you with My righteous right hand.’
11 “ Behold, all those who were incensed against you
Shall be ashamed and disgraced;
They shall be as nothing,
And those who strive with you shall perish.
12 You shall seek them and not find them—
Those who contended with you.
Those who war against you
Shall be as nothing,
As a nonexistent thing.
13 For I, the LORD your God, will hold your right hand,
Saying to you, ‘Fear not, I will help you.’
14 “ Fear not, you worm Jacob,
You men of Israel!
I will help you,” says the LORD
And your Redeemer, the Holy One of Israel.

This is the reason why combine Arabs armies who tries to wipe off Israel in 1967, were defeated by tiny Israel in just 6 days.

The purpose of HAMAS firing rockets is to create havoc in Gaza, so they can take pictures and video to stir hatred in Muslims world and around the world toward Israel by deception. As HAMAS has no sense of morality, they don't care about the fate of the Gazan..

You said:"And now Israel are defending their country what country??
You are just like HAMAS who does not recognise the state of Israel.
Do you know that HAMAS built tunnels everywhere in home, school, Mosques, institution building and garden/lands?
They fire rockets within these building and then run away inside the tunnels and fire another rocket from another tunnels a war like rats, not as warrior. Because of this the Israeli armies used dogs to sniff off their location.
By the way many of them have been capture.
Of course the Muslims media will not admit it.

Hunk.
"the end justify the means" in context of Gaza conflict done by HAMAS.
1. They start firing rockets KNOWING THAT THEY Cannot WIN THE WAR AND EXPECTING THE ISRAEL TO RETALIATE WITH FORCE THAT WILL CAUSE SUFFERING AND DEATH OF THE GAZAN. THEY DID THIS TO OBTAIN SIMPATHY FROM THE WORLD, ESPECIALLY FROM MUSLIMS WORLD TO ACHIEVE THEIR GOAL "THE DESTRUCTION OF ISRAEL"
2. They used palestinians as human shield by firing rocket behind innocent people and their houses, school, mosque, hospital.
3. They don't care about the Gazan fate as long as their aim is achieved. NORMAL/CIVILISED people will make sure that their people(non combatant) are safe by building shelters. Instead they create tunnels for THESELVES.
4. True there are many pictures are real, but they also made a fake dramatic video. After all the news coming out of Gaza was under HAMAS control since there are no foreign and impartial journalist there.

KM   January 12th, 2009 11:08 pm ET

What gives Israel the right to have weapons but not Hamas? It seems that it is always the "terrorist" card that's being played. Everyone asked for democracy and when Hamas was voted by the people, everyone is now not happy. How hypocritical that when democracy doesn't go the way that the West and Israel wants than it needs to be changed.

We can never have Peace when it's expected that Palestinians should continue to suffer in silence and not have a say in their future. Sadly enough, the only say that they are left with is to protect themselves from a vicious cycle of violence that Israel has raided on them now and the in the past.

John puzellfree   January 13th, 2009 2:00 am ET

hunk ask:"Will Hamas be stronger or weaker? …. where Palestine political scene is heading? "

1. It depends who you ask. For twisted minded Muslims and the leftist, they will say Hamas.

2. Palestinians political scene will be heading to an abyss as long as they want to split Jerusalem and the extremist want to wipe off Israel from the map. Because spiritually they are fighting against the God of Israel.

My better suggestion for Palestinians to live in peace and prosperous along side Israel state in a federation state, to show the unity between the decendent of Isaac and Ismael.
And stop brainwashing their youngster to hate the Jews and Christians.

I guarantee they will prosperous and safe and properly educated.
Just thing of the holy land which will be visited by billions Christians every year whichwill generate muchrevenue.

To back up my claim, read what God of Israel said:
Genesis 12:3
I will bless those who bless you,And I will curse him who curses you; And in you all the families of the earth shall be blessed.”

This verse also proved the reason why the Palestinians and Muslims world are in chaos conditions and bad situation (poverty, many being illiterate, always in conflict, undemocratic, backwardness. It will be worst if there is no oil in their land)
These are because from the beginning they brainwashed their children to hate the Jews, Christians and other Kaffir.

I don't blame Muslims but Islam teaching.

Hadith Sahih Bukhari 004.052.220
Narrated Abu Huraira\par

Allah's Apostle said, "I have been sent with the shortest expressions bearing the widest meanings, and I have been made victorious with terror (cast in the hearts of the enemy), and while I was sleeping, the keys of the treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand." Abu Huraira added: Allah's Apostle has left the world and now you, people, are bringing out those treasures.

That is the reason why there will always be Islamic terrorism even if HAMAS and Hezbolah are gone.
Because the nature the teaching of Islam is terror instead of peace and harmony.

David Freeman   January 13th, 2009 4:16 am ET

Kim,
Nice point ..I agree with you.. Most people that you see here that are manipulating the truth in this blog and many other blogs worldwide.. actually work for a pro Israeli Pressure group called C.A.M.E.R.A..see my explanation below .. For example… people like John Puzellfree.. Beny..and so on..

Israel has been manipulating the US for a very long time..by controlling what we hear ..weather it is print media, TV internet.. you name it…

Did you know that Israel have many watch group organizations ..who are they watching?? Mostly they are watching our politicians and the American media. The most notorious of them is called CAMERA: Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America. They twist the truth in favor of Israel at any cost.. I mean ANY COST..They harass everybody that is critical of Israel and they force journalists to change their story and apologies as publicly… if you do not adhere to their demand they will keep on harassing you your editor, your boss…they will even call your advertisers and advise them not to advertise with your newspaper because your newspaper is anti-Semitic and they also ask the advertisers to stop advertising with unethical newspaper.. they harass news papers, magazines, radio stations.. etc..by calling the news source who is critical of Israel by the thousands.. I am not exaggerating.. Fox News executive received 30, 000 emails in one day because they aired a story that is critical of Israel. (not against Israel) their job is to make life/work environment miserable for anyone who run a story that is critical of Israel.. most Americans are so naive to this facts.. they think Israel is our Ally.. how naive.. Israel spies on the U.S consistently..
According to the FBI we have over 140 Israeli spies in our prisons.. your Ally is not suppose to spy on you and break the law.. they even bite the hand that feed them lol

Watch Fox news story here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JWpWc_suPWo
The Israeli propaganda machine made life so miserable for Fox News ..after airing this report.. this report lasted only one day on the their website before they took out.

The most notorious spy was Jonathan Pollard is an American of Jewish descent, born in Galveston Texas, who established a career as an intelligence analyst for the US Navy.
But by far the most egregious damage done by Pollard was to steal classified documents relating to the US Nuclear Deterrent relative to the USSR and send them to Israel. According to sources in the US State Department, Israel then turned around and traded those stolen nuclear secrets to the USSR in exchange for increased emigration quotas from the USSR to Israel. Other information that found its way from the US to Israel to the USSR resulted in the loss of American agents operating inside the USSR. Casper Weinberger, in his affidavit opposing a reduced sentence for Pollard, described the damage done to the United States thus, "[It is] difficult to conceive of a greater harm to national security than that caused by... Pollard's treasonous behavior." Not only Israel stole secretes from us but they also SOLD them to OUR ENEMY.. Wake up America.. Ally DO NOT do such horrible thing. WAKE UP AMERICA

tarig   January 13th, 2009 5:20 am ET

When Islam took Jerusalem the land was occupied by Muslims ruler (caliphate) who build Aqsa Mosque ( by Muhammad claimed having visited Aqsa Mosque during Isra Miraj is proven invalid, because it has not been built yet).

mohammed PBUH never calimed to have visited Al-Aqsa, it is stated in the Quran as the furthest mosque. scholars after the time atrribute this as temple mount (again not al-Aqsa), while yet others believe it may have been a dream, dont falsify statement it makes you look like a fool, and before you come at me with some hadith that you pull out of your ass, the prophet told us never to follow anything other than that in the Quran, any other statements are suceptible to human interpretation and hence error (as a few religious books that i have studied are)

tarig   January 13th, 2009 5:37 am ET

John puzellfree,
note the literal meaning of Al-Aqsa is "the furthest", and the story involves a journey that included Medinah, Jeruselem, the birth place of the prophet Jusus, and then up to heaven where Mohammed PBUH prayed with all other messengers (not prophets theres a difference). some explainations you will find on the net will explicitly say Al-Aqsa mosque in jeruselem in the translation of the Quranic verses, but the acurate translation is the farthest mosque in Jeruselem, since as you said Al-Aqsa was built, by the muslim caliphate, some 100 years after the messengers death.

http://noblequran.com/translation/surah17.html

tarig   January 13th, 2009 5:47 am ET

The coming of the Jews from around the world to the land, was prophecied in the Bible as God’s will.

is this the same book that claims the devil is a serpent and that women are the cause of all the worlds problems. its a book of God and definately has truth in it, but i am yet to find two bibles that are identical unless published by the same company at the same time, how can such a book be used as a reference. the same story is mentioned in the Quran and since its unedited for 1400 years i would consider it more acurate. follow the above link in the same surah it mentions why the promise made to Jews was taken away from them, and why the house of Allah moved from the Children of Isaac th the children of Ismael.

tarig   January 13th, 2009 5:55 am ET

David KM, good to see you arent lost in the fog that is fasle media. its refreshing to see a few open minds willing to teach themselves and not just follow the crowd.

Tony Clarke   January 13th, 2009 10:45 am ET

David Freeman, I do not work for any Israeli outfit whatsoever. I am interested in the truth only. The truth is as I have said,

Hamas are getting paid by Syria and Iran to cause the Gaza conflict. Hamas dont care what damage happens to the Palestinians, they are completely immoral.

Its no use to point up the Isralis faults, look,who started it. To be very frank, if Hamas were next door to the UK and bombed us like this, we would have razed Gaza by now.

aedi   January 13th, 2009 10:59 am ET

tony clark, UK had I.R.A. which bombed public populated areas and UK did not bomb the region with heavy weapons. Instead UK made raids in order to jail those terrorists.
Israel is out of control

Tony Clarke   January 13th, 2009 11:56 am ET

Mr anonymous Aedi

The Irish form part of our country. Now, for instance you may recall Germany in WW2 did not form part of the UK, so in response to their bombing efforts they got seven times back. The UK made the very road stones in Germany bounce. It would be no different with your Hamas.

People have to be responsible for their actions. OK, so the Israelis are not gentlemen either, but how incredibly stupid for Hamas to send their pipe bombs day after day to Israel. Or maybe, not so stupid – they are making money doing it !!

Aha! So thats the reason!

Hamas knew what to expect. because they are on a nice little earner in the pay of Syria and Iran. Hamas dont care what happens to other Palestinians, they are making plenty of money causing and prolonging a conflict.

Hopefully there will be an inquiry and the pipe bombers brought to justice in the Haague, plus the Isralis who attacked the UN building in Gaza.

John puzellfree   January 13th, 2009 9:04 pm ET

tariq

Fact is THERE WERE NO MOSQUE in Jerusalem during Muhammad live time.
There were only Christians churches.
How can he mention in Hadith 003.031.215 , that there are three mosques?
. "One should travel only for visiting three Masajid (Mosques): Masjid-ul-Haram (Mecca), Masjid-ul-aqsa (Jerusalem), and this (my) Mosque (at Medina)."
Aqsa mosque was built long after Muhammad died.in 709 AD, during Muslims expansion started outside Arabia and took the land.
Even some hadith noted that many Muhammad followers did not believe his claim.
You can't blame them for being critical. After all there were no witnesses of Isra Miraj.
I know Muslims try to justify the illogical fact.

If it was a dream, then some of Islamic rituals i.e. 5 times daily prayer is a con.
However, if you read what happen before Muhammad travel, it's looked like the story of Alien abduction. I.e. being operated by alien (angel?) ha ha ha.

It's doesn't matter if you believe or not, FACT proved, the defeat of combine Arab armies by tiny Israel in just 6 days in 1967 war, that God keep his promises to Israel who just build their state.
Please read again carefully what God promises in Isaiah 41:8-14.
That what happen to Arabs Armies who were humiliated by the defeat.

11 “ Behold, all those who were incensed against you
Shall be ashamed and disgraced;
They shall be as nothing,
And those who strive with you shall perish.

Now , think where were Allah promises of thousands angels to Muslims to fight in his cause?
Surah 8:9 (Y. Ali) Remember ye implored the assistance of your Lord, and He answered you: "I will assist you with a thousand of the angels, ranks on ranks."

Surah 3:125 (Y. Ali) "Yea, – if ye remain firm, and act aright, even if the enemy should rush here on you in hot haste, your Lord would help you with five thousand angels Making a terrific onslaught.

Think man. If Allah is the same God of the Bible, why does he hate the Jews and the Christians?

To KM, and David Freeman (leftist)
You are the victim of HAMAS twisted propaganda,
I am an independent guy that just tells the truth with rational thinking.
There is no such as democracy in Muslims world. The core of democracy is free of will or choice and human right.
Islam teaching is total submission to Allah and Islam. That is the reason why most Leader in Islamic country tended to be for life or handed over to their sons.
Their media are control by the ruler.
Total submission attitude prevent the brain.mind to think rationally, it will only accept a certain formula of information.
HAMAS was elected due to their false promises. Before they were elected, with Iran money, they build social wellfare, school etc. to fool the Palestinian to get vote. But when they are elected, they took over Gaza completely by force and kill many fatah fellow Palestinians or anyone how disagree with them. They then un ashamedly expect to get funds from the West/kafir to run Gaza. Further more start firing rockets to Israel.
This is the reason why Israel doesn't want HAMAS get weapons.
The suffering of Gazan is due to HAMAS policy/ action.

You cannot stop Israel to coming home to their ancestors land theirGod promised. Prove the 1967 war.

KM & Tarig,
Please show me a verse from Allah in Quran, which reflect universal wisdom and mention peace and love for fellow human being!

To aedi.
The IRA at least warned where they will bomb, and they did not constantly firing rockets indiscriminately to mainland. They don't use the Irish people as human shield.
Israel has to do the hard way, because HAMAS used various tunnels that connected houses, schools, Mosque, institution buildings to fire their rockets.
They fight like rats.
Ironically their leader once said, they are firing rockets to make the Israeli living like rats in shelters.
Well, who are the real rats now? Being chased by Israeli forces using dogs to sniff /spots their location.

Democracy   January 14th, 2009 4:45 am ET

If I should shoot rockets at a stronger nation then I will be punished by them and all my countrymen shall suffer too. If I make words as strong as rockets then I could bring them down too. Find your enemies strength and surpass it (Education and Democratic structure that comes from it).

David Freeman   January 14th, 2009 5:50 am ET

Mr. John puzellfree and Mr. Tariq

Both of your arguments are irrelevant or fruitful to current affairs… you may ask why? Because you are confusing religion with statehood. ..A statehood is a political association with effective sovereignty over a geographic area and representing a population. These may be nation states, sub-national states or multinational states. A state usually includes the set of institutions that claim the authority to make the rules that govern the people of the society in that territory, though its status as a state often depends in part on being recognized by a number of other states as having internal and external sovereignty over it.

A religion is a set of stories, symbols, beliefs and practices, often with a supernatural quality, that give meaning to the practitioner's experiences of life through reference to an ultimate power or reality.

If we to depend on religious books to claim statehoods this world will have different maps and millions of people will have to relocate …LOL…

Israel propaganda machine used many passages from the Bible to further their claim of the land of Palestine gaining substantial sympathy from Christians throughout the world. Many people like you two start this debate based on false premise.

tarig   January 14th, 2009 6:27 am ET

david thatnks for making that point, i agree and i am not using religion as a basis for the creation of a palestinian state i am using logic. why should one have the right to exist and not the other? the Palestinians have been abandoned by their brethren, all they want is a land to call their own. basic logic should tell you that if Isreal withdrew to internationally recognized 1967 borders then extremist groups like hamas will no longer be able to manipulate the despair of the people. all i am saying, and i have made this statement in previous blogs, is that you cant fight fire with fire, bombing civillians will only increase hate and result in more so called terrorists. check out the RAND study of the affects of the war in Iraq.

i mentioned the Quranic verses souly to refute the claims made by our brother John, not as a basis as to why this war is happening. I agree religion shouldnt come into this, and it is by far mostly Jews that try to play this card without anyone questioning why a 3000 year old book can act as a basis for western decision making, (as none of this would be happening without explicit western backing).

tarig   January 14th, 2009 6:29 am ET

john i have given you a reply its just awaiting moderation, be patient cool!!

Damien Blackley   January 14th, 2009 6:42 am ET

I have followed this conflict for near on forty-two years. A Palestinian State is just as far away now as it was then.

While both sides are at fault, I will always support the underdog, the Palestinian People.

The problem I have with the government of Israel is simple. If the US said wipe them out they would do so. If the US said give them their independence now, they would do so.

Israel cannot made up its own mind and make peace with its neighbors, for the sake of its own people as well as the Palestinian People.

Does Peace always have to have a price placed on it?

Sleepless in L.A.   January 14th, 2009 7:50 am ET

Such ignorance demonstrated here. And such hatred. Coming from the same people who called for Israel to be wiped off the map? Hmm.

Before the blood dried, you all should take stock of yourselves and see the follies of your deeds. People are starting to loose sympathy to your cause when your measure of success is to survive the onslaught.

If this situation is reversed, would you be clamoring for a ceasefire? Lambs led to the slaughter. By whom?

blood is red   January 14th, 2009 11:09 am ET

Israel doesn’t want a democratic independent Palestinian state without Hamas. If this was possible then not any excuse valid for the Israelis to stop Palestinians asking for their rights and what lawfully belong to them .Also in absolute freedom they will be able to breed like crazy with non stop.
Hamas not want a democratic Palestinian state where people live in peace and prosperity. Because without fear you can’t control people and implement your extreme fanatic policies.
The Arab rulers they hold the power without real and free elections need Israel attacking Palestinians, to keep the mind of their people full of hate and then no one will talk about freedom and democracy challenging the ruling class and the religious fanatics controlling the crowd with promises in heaven.
The Americans want Hamas and other extremists alive and not really dead because if the Middle East issue can resolve then the Israelis not have anymore the excuse that they lives are under threat and they should stop play the sheriff in the region protecting USA interests.
Maybe I am wrong or maybe I am right?

PBL   January 14th, 2009 11:16 am ET

While the killing of Palestinian kids and women sicken my heart I don't see any other way to deal with terrorists group like Hamas.
Only peacekeeping force will stop the suffering in Palestine.

Tony Clarke   January 14th, 2009 11:25 pm ET

How this Hamas can claim to be innocent just defies any logic. Look, they decided to send rockets every day across to blitz Israel. Now they get the result of being attacked by Israel.

Hamas are making money because they are paid to cause trouble by Syria and Iran. Perhaps the only way to resolve this problem is to talk to Iran.

Damien Blackley   January 15th, 2009 12:20 am ET

Master Clarke

Your argument is as good as mine. Who supplies Israel with the weapons to kill the innocent, the UNITED STATES OF AMERICAN.

Thomas   January 15th, 2009 12:28 am ET

Who ever came up with the notion of proportional response? In a war which is what Israel is in with the extremists. If the enemy attacks you you hit hem back so hard that you make them think twice about hitting you again. Israel is in a battle for it's very existence. The goal of Hamas and Hezbollah is not just for a Palestinian state. It is also the elimination of Israel as a country and people. Israel could give back all land gained since 1967 and it would not be enough. That is why the Hamas charter calls for Israel total destruction.

Also in war there will be civilian casualties. Name me a major war in history were there is not? I do not care how many smart bombs you use or how accurate your artillery is there will be Civilian casualties. And especially so when you fight a enemy that hides among it's people and encourages civilian casualties so they can use it as propganda.That is the nature of war. That is also why war should always be the last resort. In this case with Hamas firing rockets and refusing to stop Israel had no choice but to hit back. In my opinion Israel should continue to hit back until they drive Hamas out of Gaza and put the Palestinian Authority back into power.

Anything less then a Hamas defeat is worthless because a simple cease fire will not work. The brand of Islam that Hamas adheres to does not allow for peace treaties with it's enemies. Unless it is temporary to allow for time to become stronger. So you can destroy your enemies later.

tarig   January 15th, 2009 5:06 am ET

The goal of Hamas and Hezbollah is not just for a Palestinian state. It is also the elimination of Israel as a country and people.

Thomas

you shouldnt include Hizbullah in that category considering only 4 countries in the wolrd consider it a complete terrorist group, US Holland Isreal and Canada, the UK and Austrailia consider certain factions as terrorist orgs and the EU DOESNT.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hezbollah#Designation_as_a_terrorist_organization_or_resistance_movement

Furthermore Hizbullahs clearly stated aim is the repatriation of the Sheba farms, which western media will lead you to believe is part of Syria, but all the original owners documents are held by lebanese.

http://www.shebaafarms.org/briefhistory.html
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1184063449109&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull

tarig   January 15th, 2009 5:37 am ET

john

http://www.usc.edu/schools/college/crcc/engagement/resources/texts/muslim/quran/002.qmt.html

why followers of messengers sent before Mohammed PBUH should be respected, and are as entitled to the pleasures of heaven in the same manner as Muslims (provided they live a straight and honest life) see verse 4.

tarig   January 15th, 2009 6:15 am ET

http://www.usc.edu/schools/college/crcc/engagement/resources/texts/muslim/quran/004.qmt.html
How to treat and respect women and orphans (Christianity could learn something from this).

tarig   January 15th, 2009 6:16 am ET

http://www.usc.edu/schools/college/crcc/engagement/resources/texts/muslim/quran/107.qmt.html
those who are unjust to the less fortunate are not in the favour of Allah.

tarig   January 15th, 2009 6:17 am ET

http://www.usc.edu/schools/college/crcc/engagement/resources/texts/muslim/quran/109.qmt.html
why all religions should respect those with different beliefs and not place judgement, it is not the right of man.

tarig   January 15th, 2009 6:18 am ET

http://www.usc.edu/schools/college/crcc/engagement/resources/texts/muslim/quran/063.qmt.html
this one is just for you.

tarig   January 15th, 2009 6:19 am ET

To answer a few of the queries you mentioned, a mosque is a place of worship to the One God, the same as a temple of synagogue, which share the same name in Archaic Arabic. Al-Aqsa mosque is built in a holy area and that is why it should be visited. However I did mention not to use the Haddith (as was the instruction of Allah) as a reference because it is the word of man and subject to error (much like the bible).
You say if it was a dream the 5 paryers is false, how did you come to that conclusion, prayer relates to energy, don’t make claims you cant backup.
You use the bible to claim that isrealis are Gods chosen people. I mentioned a link giving the Islamic version, read it. The winning of a war proves nothing, as wars are won and lost on the battle field. We believe Allah only intervenes upon our request when the war we face is in defense of our right to exist (don’t claim that is what you are facing now because all throughout history you have been closer to extermination than now). As Muslims we are aware that Islam will reach a point of almost complete eradication, then and only then will Allah intervene, because those who remain steadfast and fight for It genuinely believe and aren’t mere posers (as a lot of the world is today).
Furthermore as mentioned the Bible cannot be used as a reference as it is tainted by the word and desires of man.
The surahs you mention clearly are legitimate if you don’t take them out of context as you have. The first (8:9) relates to spoils of war. The chapter is talking about the fact that when a holy war is waged and won the possessions of the losers cannot be taken as spoils, including land (sound familiar). The second if you relate to what I just mentioned becomes much clearer.
You say to KM and David not to fall for Hamas propaganda, tell me who owns almost all the worlds news outlets (including CNN, AP, BBC, and Reuters)? I will tell you, self proclaiming Zionists, how could hamas control it. Furthermore tell me who is restricting the access of international journalists to Gaza, it definitely isn’t Hamas.
You say there are no Muslim democracies in the world. Well sorry to be the bearer of bad news but there is no real democracy in the world, it’s a pipedream controlled by elitists:

http://chomsky.info/interviews/20081010.htm

I would rather submit willingly to the creator of all, than unwillingly to those who want to look out only for themselves (go to youtube and watch a documentary called zeiglist-not sure of the spelling- then check out the sources)
You say to Aedi the IRA gave warning when they were going to bomb, another false claim. I was caught up in the M&S bombing in Manchester, there was no warning, the people of omagh got no warning, that is plain and simply made up.

tarig   January 15th, 2009 6:29 am ET

Lets look at some facts:
FACT The bible that you love to quote so much was formulated more than 500 years after the death of Jesus and is based of hearsay, how can such a book be used as a legitimate reference, and even if it is legitimate, Isreal still wouldn’t exist if western colonizers didn’t need a new method, or base from which to launch their desires to control Arab oil.
FACT Islam and Judaism are essentially the same, the only differences are the Quran and the last two messengers. Its is taught in Islam that the House of Allah shifted from Isaac to Ismael as a result of the rejection of their messaiah (Jesus).
FACT leaders of all sides have lied to their people so as to ensure that they follow their desires blindly and without question. Just as Hamas have carried out acts of evil, so to have the IDF to far greater extent.
FACT this is not, and has never been a holy war, therefore the intervention of Allah is not encompassed in any explanations you may give. Instead this is purely a war of greed to which both sides are culprit to. Allah will not intervene in a war between two evil forces.
FACT the murder of innocents increases the level of so called terrorism as has been determined by numerous studies.
You say where is there universal wisdom in the Quran well here are a few more facts:
FACT science is yet to disprove anything that is mentioned in the Quran as fake, or contradictory to findings, in fact Islam has two basic rules, ask any questions related to religion and science. The reason is simple, look at scientific findings to prove the accuracy of the Quran. For instance the FACT that the waters of two seas never mix is mentioned, as to is the big bang theory, and the story of Adam and Eve doesn’t relate to an apple falling from a tree, and used to blame women for all the worlds problems, instead it relates to premarital sex.

http://www.shajaracode.com/pageID_4689895.html

look at this verse for an example of great wisdom:
He created you (all) from a single person: then created, of like nature, his mate; and he sent down for you eight head of cattle in pairs: He makes you, in the wombs of your mothers, in stages, one after another, in three veils of darkness. such is Allah, your Lord and Cherisher: to Him belongs (all) dominion. There is no god but He: then how are ye turned away (from your true Centre)? 039.006 (how could an illiterate know that pregnancy consists of 3 stages 1400 years ago)
FACT contradiction after contradiction is found in the Bible, both old and new testaments, with science proving the influence of the hand of man.
FACT its you that needs to wake up, the verses of the Quran you mention clearly prove that you haven’t read it, just listened to what others say, just like a sheep following the shepard. The beauty of Islam is that the Quran is there so we can all be shepards. Read it, understand, it study it, then and only then will you have the right to talk about it.
Just to finish, I am I no way attacking you or your right to a belief contrary to mine, merely pointing out a few of the flaws in your argument. Please don’t consider this an insult to a great religion merely a correction of clearly misunderstood elements relative to my religion.

tarig   January 15th, 2009 6:34 am ET

sorry just one more point, if you read the Arabic version of Al-Aqsa the worl Al-Quds is never written (arabic for Jeruselem), instead this appears to be coined into translated versions as it is commonly beielved to be Jeruselem, all that is mentioned is Masjid Al-Aqsa (the Furthest Mosque/temple/place of worship to the oneness of God). on top of that, although the Quran can be translated, a lot of the meaning and beauty is lost, its not quite the same as it is in Arabic, I am sure the Torah is the same in that case.

David Freeman   January 15th, 2009 7:22 am ET

Sleepless in L.A.

Your ignorance is so dangerous.. because people like you get manipulated very easy then controlled.. no one said to wipe off Israel from the face of earth.. (our Zionist media invented this to influence our simple minded American like you for sympathy for Israel) the correct statement was mad “to wipe off Zionism from the face of the earth” it is a similar statements that we made many time during the communist era.. The U.S. vowed many times to wipe communism from the face of the earth, but we did not mean the people of the Soviet Union..

***Zionism does not mean Israel and its people***

Communism did not mean the Soviet Union and its people.. people like you sir scare me.. because they tend to be manipulated easily and that’s what the Zionist here in the U.S like (they love simple minded people like you) who go around repeating what they heard from our biased media.. do what is best for America..use your brain .. I hope you have one.

David Freeman   January 15th, 2009 7:33 am ET

Tariq,

You are back to your old habit of debating religion.. have you ever heard a Zionist debating Torah against the bible??? Are you learning from your adversaries? They are way ahead of in the media war. ..Or are you doing what they (Zionist) want you to do.. (get hated by Christian who hold the power) wake up man. You are reinventing the wheel and wasting your breath

tarig   January 15th, 2009 7:43 am ET

john,

this is why taking words out of context is clearly ignorant and, definately an inaccurate portrayal of our religion (not to mention an insult).

5:32-34 ...If any one slew a person – unless it be as punishment for murder or for spreading corruption in the land – it would be as if he slew the whole people: and if any one saved a life, it would be as if he saved the life of the whole people. Then although there came to them Our apostles with clear signs, yet, even after that, many of them continued to commit excesses in the land. The punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger, and strive with might and main for mischief through the land is: execution, or crucifixion, or the cutting off of hands and feet from opposite sides, or exile from the land: that is their disgrace in this world, and a heavy punishment is theirs in the Hereafter; Except for those who repent before they fall into your power: in that case, know that Allah is Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful.

There are several points to note here. The first is the gravity of the offense. This is punishment for WAGING WAR against the Prophet of God and spreading evil and destruction. In modern terminology this would be considered “terrorism”. This is a punishment for such a severe offense, hence the severity of the punishment. As Muhammad Asad writes on this verse:

The present participle la-musrifun indicates their “continuously committing excesses” (i.e., crimes), and is best rendered as “they go on committing” them. In view of the preceding passages, these “excesses” obviously refer to crimes of violence and, in particular, to the ruthless killing of human beings. (Asad, The Message of the Qur’an)
It is quite shocking to see how many Islam-haters will place this verse under the heading of “inciting Muslims to kill and wage war”, whereas the verse commands nothing of this sort! In fact, it comes directly after a verse prohibiting murder and likening the unjust murder of a single individual to the slaughter of humanity. The Qur’an purposefully describes the gravity of the sin before describing the punishment. The crime of murder and committing terrorist activities is regarded as such a severe violation in Islam, that a severe retribution has been prescribed. Waging war against God’s prophet is tantamount to waging war against Our Creator Himself. It is ironic that Islam-haters will present this verse to justify their claim that Islam supports terrorism, whereas Muslim scholars have always presented this verse as proof that Islam is vehemently opposed to terrorism. For example, the Islamic Fiqh Council of Saudi Arabia writes about this verse:

Obviously, in view of the enormity of such acts of aggression, which are viewed by the Shari’ah (Islamic law) as an act of war against the laws and the creatures of God, there is no stricter punishment anywhere in the manmade laws. (Islamic Fiqh Council of Saudi Arabia, Terrorism – Islam’s viewpoint, Muslim World League Journal, Jumad al-Ula 1423/July 2002 CE)

Adapted from a website (not my words)

tarig   January 15th, 2009 7:50 am ET

your probably right mate, i may be wasting my breath but i cant allow someone to insult my religion on the basis of false information and not answer him, particularly when the insult is directed at me. again i am not even debating Isreal or its right to exist in the above posts, only proving to our brother that the claims and statements made are false, with no basis. if my words lead to someone hating me, it is my fault and i clearly stated that this was not an attack on any persons right to believe what they want (and if they do what i say should mean nothing to them unless i attack them directly – as john did to me). instead it was aimed at refuting the false claims attributed to Islam and furthermore prove that all believers in the oneness of God are entitled to heavenly pleasures provided they live an honest and decent life. again your right but would you accept someone making a direct attack on you without questioning the falsified basis of their claims?

David Freeman   January 15th, 2009 8:24 am ET

Tariq,

There are children dying in useless war..try to help!

this is one of the biggest problems that you will ever face..don’t let your adversary know your religion? (they will know how to make you angry) Your religion should be between you you’re your God.
The biggest problem is that the west is influenced by the false media that is based on lies. Here in America, 98% of the Americans don’t know that we are manipulated by lies (also known as the News)
Perception is every thing

In America when the Zionist get on TV to manipulate us they do not tell anyone about their religion. It is the psychology behind it.. people will have more influence on other people if they think they are equal/same people having the same problems..

I will make it simple for you:

If your enemy is superior deceive him
if angry aggravate him,
if equally marched Fight,
if not split and reevaluate.

tarig   January 15th, 2009 8:41 am ET

David,

im guessing your an American from the way you write, i am glad to see one so open-minded and aware of what is happening. you mentioned a few things i would like to pick up on, namely the danger of ignorance. what a lot of people dont understand is that the way of the world today is only possible because people buy into the lies that they are told (and it happens everywhere-from America to Timbuktu). i am a sudanese man, raised in Britain who lives in the UAE, and i have been bless with being able to live, and experience different cultures (western, African, and Arab). what i have realized is that people are essentially the same with a few acceptions towards various extremes. and also that govts. throughout the world are also the same (democratic-or dictatorship), they aim to control the wills of the public (although it is far more subltle in democratic nations – usually through media and education). what i see happening in the world today (Africans killing Africans in Sudan because they are just a little blacker – contrary to what the media tells you it is nothing to do with religion-, people calling for the use of tactical nukes on palestine and Iran-which i am sure would lead to world war 3-, gang violence at a rate unparralleled through history-people of all religions forgeting the teaching they should be following and listening to their leaders blindly-the monopoly control of the strong over the weak-the UN vetoes, the tax cuts given by Bush to high earners, it makes no sense to me). what i am trying to get at is that race religion or creed is becoming irrelevent in this world. i dont know what you believe if anything, but i know that you are on the right side just because of your lack of arrogance. i see the world breaking into two factions, those with power and money supported by the masses they have been able to indoctrinate into their way of thinking (basically F*** the world and everything in it, look out for number one, even if that will effect your descendents – you can see this in the cars and AC that are damaging to the environment but no one seems to really care, why should they by the time anything happens they will be dead); and the other side is everyone else.

this conflict is a perfect example of what i am saying. both sides are wrong, and anyone who supports either is basically advocating murder, but no one seems to realize that. hamas shudnt fire indiscriminately at a soverign nation, but at the same time Isreal shouldnt force an entire population to live in an open air jail subject to bombing from 40000 feet, again killing indiscriminately. and the people who realize what is happening are stuck in the middle. the question is, if both sides are evil, who is good? who is left to stand up and fight for what is right, knowing that words are more powerful than any weapon, they last through the ages but you can only be killed once? will it be people like me and you, the so called leftists who at the moment are stuck in the middle of a two headed snake at war with itself? why is this happening, who benefits in the long run? i know the answer to that, and i am sure you do to, but its safe to say its not gazans or isrealis, or hamas or the IDF, its far more reaching than these miniscule players it a great big game.

the question we need to ask ourselves is what can we do other than bitch and moan to stop this world heading towards the collision course that it is? is there a way out, or is this really the beginning of the end? anyone reading this, ask yourself this simple question: do yuo want to be around when the next nuke goes off? it might sound far fetched, but thats where we're heading unless something is done, and when that happens all hell will break loose. and the biggest problem isnt those in power, its the ignorant masses that just follow them blindly and listen to the so called news. you people need to wake up, read a book, open your eyes to whats happening because without you people acting like sheep those who want the world to be heading in the direction it is wont succeed.

tarig   January 15th, 2009 8:49 am ET

just read your point, i was too busy writing mine, but we are on the same page, adn we do share the same enemy, but our approaches may differ. the thing that lead me to write what i did was the fact that we are encouraged as muslims to ensure that the word of the Quran is not mis-represented, it was my duty to reply. your right in terms of they try to make you angry, but believe me i am not angry, only trying to provide a brother with the facts about my religion, not the myths that a circulated by those who aim for our destruction!! anger is one of the greatest enemies we face, but love is so much more powerful, me saying what i said was an act of love not anger, if it was out of anger i would allow others to remain in the darkness of ignorance towards tolerance.

ISRAR AHMED   January 15th, 2009 11:56 am ET

america is not a freind of any country nor an enemy, it just mean business. if it find intrest in killing 1000 people for saving one,it will surely does and vice versa.Israel is showing this aggretion because of america's support,the day when US finds no interest in israel,and no longer supports it, israel in great danger.
I think americans should give up faith in god, because fo number of lives they have taken for whatever resons in so many countries.
If god(who ever he is) forgive them for this,then he cant be a god.
not all americans are bad but few certainly are,like in any other community. greatest achievment of G .W.Bush is,giving the world a weapon of mass destroction against muslims called "being or suspected to be a terrorist"

John puzellfree   January 15th, 2009 7:16 pm ET

David freedom wrote:
" Both of your arguments are irrelevant or fruitful to current affairs… you may ask why? Because you are confusing religion with statehood..."

That's is exactly why you the politician, especially the left libertarian. don't have a clue, why the conflict between the Jews and Muslims seem never ended. Just yesterday Osama bin Laden gave order for Muslims world for jihad against Israel and take the Aqsa mosque.
Palestinian case is just a excuse. As long as there is still Kaffir especially the state of Israel, Muslims world will always have an excuse to terrorised, brainwashed the world untill all submit to "Allah"
Since you name is D freedom, please go to http://www.faithfreedom.org , a famous website hated by Muslims, founded by an Iranian EXMUSLIM. It has 12,599,455 visitors since july 2006.
It open the eyes of many kafir as well as Muslims about the real Islam, and not the sugar coated that is being spoon fed by "moderate" Muslims.

ISLAM IS A POLITICAL WITH RELIGIOUS BASE ENTITY. UNLIKE MOST RELIGION, IT HAS NO SPIRITUAL TEACHING (LOVE, KIND, FORGIVENSS AND PEACE)
Hence we see the behaviour and the way Muslims think and react to any event.
In Gaza case many leftist/libertarian western politicians see thing in what HAMAS/ Muslims world want to see and to think.
They see that Israel is the cause for whatever happen. Worst is that the picture and video clip coming out of GAZA are with HAMAS approval since there are no foreign journalist in GAZA. HAMAS has a free ride to shows, what ever they want. All the injured people may have been by HAMAS doing, but of course they always blame on Israel.
DO ANY RATIONAL PEOPLE THINK THAT ISRAEL DELIBERATELY SHOOTING OR BOMBING ON INNOCENT GAZAN?
The reason why HAMAS and Muslims accuse Israel doing so, because in Muslims world war, they do such a thing.
Just like what happen the fighting between Suni and Shiah in Iraq, the Suni bomb Shiah most "holy" Mosques during Shiah rituals, where there were hundreds people worshiping. Then we also notice Shiah bomb a school bus full with children in it.
But, No reaction from Muslims world or from their unholy ally the leftist/liberals western appologies on the event. Instead both blame American.
What's so amazing is that many Muslims and leftist/libertarian still believe that 9/11 terror was an inside job and not done by Islamofacism jihadis.
"You shall know them by their fruits"

You said:"There are children dying in useless war..try to help!"

Exactly, but HAMAS must stop firing rockets. That is what the israel wanted. Unfortunately, the misery in Gaza is just what HAMAS wanted as propaganda to get their goal in undermining Israel and then declare victory.
Your comment, remind me of the film "exorcist" where when the pries tried to cast the demon out, the demon disguised it self as a suffering child to fool the priest to stop exorcise it.
That is what HAMAS the armies of evils are doing now, and fool the world, especially the Muslims world.
Wake up. This is a spiritual battle. There will be no real peace when dealing with Islam based entity.
Here is why;

Sahih Bukhari 004.052.220
Narrated Abu Huraira
Allah's Apostle said, "I have been sent with the shortest expressions bearing the widest meanings, and I have been made victorious with terror (cast in the hearts of the enemy), and while I was sleeping, the keys of the treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand." Abu Huraira added: Allah's Apostle has left the world and now you, people, are bringing out those treasures.

David Freeman said:
"Your ignorance is so dangerous.. because people like you get manipulated very easy then controlled.. no one said to wipe off Israel from the face of earth..."

Have you not heard what Ahmeddinejat said? or have you learn HAMAS and Hesbolah political manifesto?
It's is you who are manipulated by Muslims "Moderate" Because you have in common with Muslims in hating the Jews. Just like the leftist Professor Churchill does.

John puzellfree   January 15th, 2009 7:33 pm ET

Tarig wrote:

"this is why taking words out of context is clearly ignorant and, definately an inaccurate portrayal of our religion (not to mention an insult)." then Quote Surah 5:32-34,

Tarig, you cannot fool me, the Surah you quote is not a message for Muslims but for Israel. IT'S YOU AND THE MODERATE MUSLIMS WHO QUOTE THE VERSE OUT OF CONTEXT.

You did not quote the verse fully by omitting the first sentence line.
Here is the first line omitted:
5:32 (Y. Ali) ON THAT ACCOUNT: WE ORDAINED FOR THE CHILDREN OF ISRAEL THAT ... if any one slew a person..... It has nothing to do with Allah instruction to Muslims, read verse 31.
This prove on the following verse (33) shows how Allah contradict his own message verse 32.

(Y. Ali) The punishment of those who wage war against Allah and His Messenger, and strive with might and main for mischief through the land is: execution, or crucifixion, or the cutting off of hands and feet from opposite sides, or exile from the land: that is their disgrace in this world, and a heavy punishment is theirs in the Hereafter;

Islam does not preach peace love and forgiveness !!
For Islam peace means that there are no Kafir and that Islam rules the world.

Prove that Islam is not a spiritual teaching but religion based political entity, is shown in
Hadith SAHIH Bukhari Sahih 004.052.220
Narrated Abu Huraira
Allah's Apostle said, "I have been sent with the shortest expressions bearing the widest meanings, and I have been made victorious with terror (cast in the hearts of the enemy), and while I was sleeping, the keys of the treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand." Abu Huraira added: Allah's Apostle has left the world and now you, people, are bringing out those treasures.

ISRAR AHMED,
How do you know that the victims figures coming out Gaza is right?
These figure came from HAMAS controled medical people. No western journalist is present.
I saw one healthy man with no blood was taken on a stretcher and look at the camera not in agony.
Why don't they shown wounded HAMAS fighter? Those injured and dead men are most likely HAMAS fighter. But of course the Hamas control media will say that they are civilian.
How do you know what's in the bundle of sheets portrait as a victim?
A BBC inside reporter show during 3 hours lull cease fire, Children playing in a playground, Gazan doing their business as normal and some are laughing.
Man, we know how HAMAS and Muslims in general conduct reporting.
I am not saying that there are no casualty among palestinian, but Muslims way is always exaggeration to fool the world.

John puzellfree   January 15th, 2009 7:34 pm ET

ISRAR AHMED, how do you know that the victims figures coming out Gaza is right?
These figure came from HAMAS medical people. No western journalist are present.
I saw one healthy man no blood was taken on a stretcher and look at the camera.
How do you know what's in the bundle of sheets portrait as a victim?
A BBC inside reporter show during 3 hours lull cease fire, Children playing in a playground, Gazan doing their business as normal and some are laughing.
Man, we know how HAMAS and Muslims in general conduct reporting.
I am not saying that there are no casualty, but Muslims way is always exaggeration to fool the world.

Hila   January 15th, 2009 7:42 pm ET

Fawad Ali

I got sick reading you response.

1. "IN GAZA, Israeli soldiers are killing children like animals" – you are terribly wrong. The IDF instructions is to AVOID killing of innocent civilians. Do you read ? AVOID KILLING.
It is the terrorists, "Hammas" and others, who are killing children like animals. It is the paletinians, their blood, their people whom Hammas are killing by keeping on firing missiles towards Israel. Hammas should surrender to stop the fight. To avoid more casualties, But no – the death toll of their people is of no importance to Hammas, as long as it is serving their ARABIC PRIDE. Hammas does not need to work hard. The world's public opinion towrads Israel is very bad when more of its palestinians people are killed. Why would Hammas stop the terror ? Why ?

2. " They are not allowing Media, isn’t that enough “Israelis are doing everything to hide their crimes and trying their best to falsely implicating Palestinians for things they have not done”

Again – wrong, wrong, wrong. The Media harmed us during the second Israel-Lebanon war in 2006. The Hizbulla knew all they had to know fighting the Israeli soliders with the help of "the Media". I'm so glad that finally my country has learnt the lesson. No Media during war.

Hila   January 15th, 2009 8:16 pm ET

Peter, you need to learn more before you comment with so anti semetic tone:

1. If Israel does not want peace, why does it have peace with Egypt and Jordan? Is it for fun ? Did you ever know that the hebrew word for "hello" and "peace" is the same? "S H A L O M" . This is the third word Israeli babies learn after "Mammy" and "Daddy".

2. ISRAEL HAS A RIGHT TO EXIST like any other nation. ISRAEL HAS ALSO THE RIGHT TO DEFEND ITSELF FROM THE NON-STOP ATTACKS OF ITS ENEMIES (since it got independance at 1948).

3. If Hammas and the PLO were not such biased people, taking the world's money to their pockets, and buying arms and weapons (unfortunately, some of the weapons supplied by Israel to the PLO, isn't that funny ?) with the change – the economy situation of the palestinians would have been very good. I guess under such circumstances, with good economy in Gaza, it wouldn't have been that easy to brainwash their children minds to become "Shahede".

4. You have no idea what a Ghetto is. Please read some books before you dare to compare Gaza to Warsaw Ghetto.

5. I agree that "Palestine has a right to exist and they should have their own state". The problem is that the only sane people in Gaza are the ones supporing Abu-Mazen. But – unfortunately Hammas threw Abu-Mazen away, taking over Gaza. You will say it is because of the Jews, aren't you ? No – it is not because of the Jews. NO PEACE CAN EXIST BETWEEN ISRAEL AND ORGANIZATIONS WHO DO NOT ACCEPT THE EXISTANCE OF THE STATE OF ISRAEL AND CLAIM TO DESTROY IT.

God bless my beloved HOMELAND, my beautifule country ISRAEL!!!

John puzellfree   January 15th, 2009 9:47 pm ET

tarig,
Don't give that link which I already know. I ahve more then one links. OK.
Just write the ayat detail and your comment or tafsir.

You may not aware, that those nice ayats/words/messages from Quran were spoken when Muhammad still promoting Islam to attract the Jews and Christians.
These verses are used by Moderates and ignore the nasties and also they dismissed Hadith verses that is embarrassing
like Muhammad married a 6 years old Aysha and bedded her at 9 yrs old.

But after the Jews and Christians reject his prophethood and have full power after capturing Mecca, Allah words or Muhammad tone turn to nasty. and very much against "the people of the book" especially the Jews.
for eaxample:
[Surah 5:51][Shakir] O you who believe! do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends;
they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend,
then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people.
4:160[Shakir] Wherefore for the iniquity of those who are Jews did We disallow to them
the good things which had been made lawful for them and for their hindering many (people) from Allah's way.

Islam is the only religion
Surah 2:193. "And fight with them until there is no persecution, and religion should be only for Allah, but if they desist, then there should be no hostility except against the oppressors."

Surah 8:39. "And fight with them until there is no more persecution and religion should be only for Allah; but if they desist, then surely Allah sees what they do."

Even Aisha said in Hadith SAHIH Bukhari 004.053.400
Narrated Aisha.
Once the Prophet was bewitched so that he began to imagine that he haddone a thing which in fact he had not done.

HE WAS SO POSSESSED OF TREASURES INSTEAD OF SPIRITUAL MATER
Sahih Bukhari 004.052.220
Narrated Abu Huraira.
Allah's Apostle said, "I have been sent with the shortest expressions bearing the widest meanings, and I have been made victorious with terror (cast in the hearts of the enemy), and while I was sleeping, the keys of the treasures of the world were brought to me and put in my hand." Abu Huraira added: Allah's Apostle has left the world and now you, people, are bringing out those treasures

Woman compare as Dog and donkey,
In Bukhari 1.9.493. Aisha complained to Muhammad.
"The things which annual prayer were mentioned before me (and those were): a dog, a donkey and a woman. I said, "You have compared us (women) to donkeys and dogs...."
Bukhari 1.9. 486: Do you make us (women) equal to dogs and donkeys?...".

In hadith Muhammad regards woman as deficient
Sahih Bukhari
001.006.301
.... The women asked, "O Allah's Apostle! What is deficient in our intelligence and religion?" He said, "Is not the evidence of two women equal to the witness of one man?" They replied in the affirmative. He said, "This is the deficiency in her intelligence......

This is for you,
ALLAH DON'T GUARANTEE YOUR SALVATION;
No guarantee
Yusuf ali
46:9 Say: "I am no bringer of new-fangled doctrine among the apostles, nor do I know what will be done with me or with you. I follow but that which is revealed to me by inspiration; I am but a warner open and clear

Instead, Allah play with Muslims soul:

Surah 11:34 "Of no profit will be my counsel to you, much as I desire to give you (good) counsel, if it be that Allah willeth to leave you astray: He is your Lord! and to Him will ye return!"

Surah 4:119 And surely I will lead them astray, and surely I will arouse desires in them, and surely I will command them and they will cut the cattle's ears, and surely I will command them and they will change Allah's creation. Whoso chooseth Satan for a patron in

TRUE GOD DOES NOT LEAD PEOPLE ASTRAY BUT LEAD TO THE RIGHT PATH BECAUSE THE NATURE OF GOD IS LOVE, PEACE AND FORGIVENESS.

I am truly sorry for Muslims especially the jihadis thinking that God will reward the with earthy pleasure in heaven.

4:74 Let those fight in the cause of allah Who sell the life of this world for the hereafter. To him who fighteth in the cause of allah,- whether he is slain or gets victory – Soon shall We give him a reward of great (value)

TRUE GOD DOES NOT REWARD MURDERER AND TERRORISM BECAUSE IT IS AGAINST HIS NATURE LOVE AND COMMANDMENT.

John puzellfree   January 15th, 2009 9:48 pm ET

American Jew shouted:"AND LONG LIVE PALESTINE, NICK."

Well typical Muslim pretending to be a Jews.
We know Muslims mentality in debate.

Don't fool yourself.

Lynne wrote:
"I am old, and I have found hate breeds hate"

Right. but the question of Palestinian/Muslims and Israel conflict case, who teaches hate first?

Here is one example of Islam God "Allah" said: In Koran/Quran

[Surah 5:51][Shakir] O you who believe! do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends;
they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend,
then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people.

4:160[Shakir] Wherefore for the iniquity of those who are Jews did We disallow to them
the good things which had been made lawful for them and for their hindering many (people) from Allah's way.

Better still visit http://www.faithfreedom.org It will surely enrich you knowledge of REAL Islam.

It's naive people that are easily deceived by sugar coated Islam preach by Muslims Moderate, while they supported the extremist behind their back.
I.e. Why do these "Moderate" and the leftist demostrate after 7/7 london bombing ?? They instead blame UK and USA foreign policies.

adele,
You right the hypocracy of the Media especially Muslims media who are fed by pictures/video clip from media control HAMAS coming out of GAZA.
It is so hypocrite that Muslims world ignored the suffering, genocide entnic cleansing of ethnic African in Dafur done by Arabs Jenjaweed and Muslims Government of Sudan for many years. 200000 dead, 2 millions living in refugee camps. Arabs league say nothing instead they are against western troop to be station there.

Professor said:
"Long Live Palestine…. with their freedom of choice…."

Man, there is no freedom of Choice in Islamic country, Which is based on "Toatal Submission"
Freedom of choice is Western concept.
After HAMAS was elected, they take over GAZA completely and kill their own "brother" Fatah fighter.
Gazan are deceived by Hamas and they are scare to disagree with Hamas, or be killed.

Maria said:
"My GOD is the same as yours ALLAH and I condem the massacre which Israel is doing."

No Maria Allah is not the same with God of the Bible.
Allah did not recognised Jesus crusifixtion as salvation.
He hate the jews and Christians:
Here is what Allah said in Koran/Quran:
[Surah 5:51][Shakir] O you who believe! do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends;
they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend,
then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people.
Surah 4:160[Shakir] Wherefore for the iniquity of those who are Jews did We disallow to them
the good things which had been made lawful for them and for their hindering many (people) from Allah's way.

Please visit http://www.faithfreedom.org It a website founded by an ex-Muslims.

Therefore if Allah is the same as your God, he should also apply the 10 Commanment and not doing Kaaba Pagan rituals in Mecca.

samy
Palestinian nations was created by Arafat after 1967.
The inhabitant on that land were mixed.
Arabs came after Muslims expansion.

Democracy
Democracy will not work in islamic based country, because it's is against Islamic based teaching of "Total submission"
That is the reason why Israel is the only real democratic country in Middle East.

Tarig said:
"the Palestinians have been abandoned by their brethren, all they want is a land to call their own. basic logic should tell you that if Isreal withdrew to internationally recognized 1967 borders.."

1. The Arabs learn the lesson of being humiliately defeated by tiny Israel in 6 days in 1967 war. which resulted the problem with today Gaza and Westbank.
It they did not gone to war for trying to wipe off Israel, Palestinian case will never arise. By the way Palestinian "nations" was created by Arafat after that war.
Israel has aleady left Gaza, but Hamas still firing rockets to Israel.

PBL
wrote:"Only peacekeeping force will stop the suffering in Palestine"

Hamas does not want peacekeeping force in Gaza.
Even where Un peacekeeping runs south Lebanon, Rockets were fired by unknown group from south lebanon to northern Israel. Which Hesbolah denounced it.

Damien Blackley   January 15th, 2009 9:58 pm ET

Let those without sin, cast the first stone.

John puzellfree   January 15th, 2009 10:29 pm ET

TARIG,
Quran is just a compilation of collection of verses taken from various sources, Palm sheet, leather, stones, wood carving etc. and Muslims who memorised Quran verses
Those original sources were all gone.

The first version instructed by Abu Bakr were full of contradiction so under Uthman order a new version is created and the first version were destroyed.

Quran has no background written in it and the compilation are mixed up and not chronological.
That is the reason why the additional books like Hadiths and other are required to explain Quran verses.
Without this additional books Quran mean, nothing and it's just a collection of Muhammad statements.

Therefore, Muslims "scholar" can interpret it as they want or believe and follow literally as is said.

The Moderate practice the early verses of Quran when Muhammad was still promoting his religion, which actually have been abograted

It is mentions i Hadith, here is one example:

Sahih Bukhari
006.060.008 – Prophetic Commentary on the Qur'an (Tafseer of the Prophet (pbuh)) – – – -

Narrated Ibn Abbas

Umar said, "Our best Qur'an reciter is Ubai and our best judge is 'Ali; and in spite of this, we leave some of the statements of Ubai because Ubai says, 'I do not leave anything that I have heard from Allah's Apostle while Allah

"Whatever verse (Revelations) do We abrogate or cause to be forgotten but We bring a better one or similar to it." (2.106)

The fundamentalist / Extremeist "true Muslims" do follow the Quran verses after Muhammad have full power by capturing Mecca.
The verses are nasty, hence it lead Muslims expanssion that change world history and brought the world problem and religious terrorism today.

As Allah said that Muslims are brothers, so the Moderate cannot fully criticise Islamic terrorism nor admited it.
They only play lips service to the world/kafir.

49:10 (Y. Ali) The Believers are but a single Brotherhood: So make peace and reconciliation between your two (contending) brothers; and fear Allah, that ye may receive Mercy.

They promoting a sugar coated islam and not the real one, So they could become the jihadis target because they are brand as kaffir.

9:23 (Y. Ali) O ye who believe! take not for protectors your fathers and your brothers if they love infidelity above Faith: if any of you do so, they do wrong.

49:10 (Y. Ali) The Believers are but a single Brotherhood: So make peace and reconciliation between your two (contending) brothers; and fear Allah, that ye may receive Mercy.

Tony Clarke   January 16th, 2009 3:09 am ET

All this talk of religion is very interesting but fails to address the problem.

Lets concentrate on the problem folks.

Hamas has been for months heavily sponsored to fire rockets at Israel. The cheif sponsor is (surprise surprise) Iran under the hand of Ahmadinajad and his 'Government'.

So Hamas like this because they can get rich and fat with sending these fireworks, and even fatter when Israel retaliates, just what Iran wants – they are paying to wind it up like this.

How to stop this 'war' though? Perhaps there must be some stiff talking between the west and the people controlling Iran. Clearly this situation cannot continue and no-one wants the point where Iran gets attacked or even nuked. But it could happen, things have a way of spiralling out of control, this is a very big box of very evil contents, and the lid is almost off.

John puzellfree   January 16th, 2009 3:45 am ET

Tony Clarke said

:"All this talk of religion is very interesting but fails to address the problem.
Lets concentrate on the problem folks. "

I wish we can sort out the problem so easily.
Unfortunately, the conflict is just the surface.
The deep underlining problem is Islam that breed hatred toward the Jews and others, inside Muslims mindset.
This is the reason why Middle east comflict will never be sorted the way civilsed people wanted.

David Freeman   January 16th, 2009 6:30 am ET

To: John puzellfree- Also known as: Dr. Propaganda

Dear John – You sound to me – you either a paranoid Schizophrenic or Zionist Propagandist…LOL you oppose almost everybody vies against Israel sounds like you believe your press (illusions) few points for you to read (after you take your medication please)

I Said: “religion and NOT statehood”. If your premise is true all Christian can lay claim on Jerusalem and make it their country /city since this was the place where Jesus lived. LOL..
You keep mumbling about crazy religious extremists and what they say.. this is irrelevant..anybody can say anything ..and any body can try to justify anything..the conflict in the middle east (born 60) yrs a ago was not born because of what some religious extremist said .. it was born because Israel laid a religious claim on the Palestinian land …if you’re not aware they call it the (the Jewish State) .. is it ringing a bell now?

I said – “no one said to wipe off Israel from the face of earth”
You – John said…” Have you not heard what Ahmeddinejat said?”

Here you really proved to be either ignorant or propagandist.. either way you’re idiot if facts and imbursement to logic. The statement of the Iranian leader has well been and translated from the original Parsee language translation from C-Span to the correct English vesion (Not the Zionist version) That Ahmeddinejat said “to wipe off Zionism from the face of the earth” he did NOT say to wipe Israel from the face of earth…
it is a similar statements that we (Americans) made many time during publically during the communist era.. The U.S. vowed many times to wipe communism from the face of the earth, we did not mean the people of the Soviet Union..

Zionism does not mean Israel and its people

Communism did not mean the Soviet Union and its people.

That tells me that you are Zionist propagandas since you left out the rest of my statement..

which is a widely practiced trick by Zionist propagandist.. Omit part of the statement that does not fit your agenda.. you are not fooling anyone here.. you are a hijacker of the truth LOL.. you are a joke

John, with all due respect.. you are one of the least intelligent people I have ever encountered… I mean you are smart, but an idiot ..LOL…sorry I can’t explain it.. were you abused when you were a child? That could be it..

Ulrich   January 16th, 2009 5:24 pm ET

I know some are desperate and try to make it look like as if Israel somehow is the victim.
But that's not the case. The victim has now become the perpetrator. Israel is committing terrorism and has been doing so ever since it was founded in 1948.
Israel is a terrorist State. It doesn't want peace, neither with Hamas or Fatah (PLO – Arafat organization), nor with any other Palestinian organization.
Israel says it has a right to exist – but not like that.
Israel controls the entire economic infra structure down there, it controls all the water rights too.
Israel builds a fence around Gaza and stealing more land of the Palestinians. They turned Gaza into a Warsaw Ghetto.
Their arguments for this massacre are nothing but fake and the whole world knows it, except the Media which is controlled by Jews.
Israel was founded in 1948, before that there has never been a State of Israel.
Palestine has a right to exist they should have their own state.
Israel should be internationally isolated and they should give all those Billions back to the US that the APAC funneled out for them.

John puzellfree   January 16th, 2009 6:36 pm ET

David Freeman.

I am not a Zionist, nor an Israeli nor American nor European nor a white guy. I speak the truth and logic.
Unlike you the leftist who is an Islamic apologist. Who make any accuse just to justify Muslims claimed You the leftist are in cahoots with Muslims. Hence you are in tune with th thinking.

Islam is a political based on religion this means Muslims world understand of statehood are blurry.

For Muslims Zionist= Israel=Jews.
Don't be naive for thinking that Muslims knows the different.
I don't blame Muslims but the teaching of Islam which made them the way they think and behave.

Quran/Koran verses are of the highest importance to Muslims.
So, If their own God instigates to hate Jews and Christians, one cannot blame them if Muslims do this from the beginning of Islam.
Here are the verses I quote before:
[Surah 5:51][Shakir] O you who believe! do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends;
They are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend,
then surely he is one of them; surely, Allah does not guide the unjust people.

4:160[Shakir] Wherefore for the iniquity of those who are Jews did We disallow to them
the good things which had been made lawful for them and for their hindering many (people) from Allah’s way.

If you are a free thinker, please visit http://www.faithfreedom.org , to learn more about the real Islam and not the sugarcoated Islam which has been promoted by "Moderate".

It's you who are fooling yourself for being Muslims propagandist and apologist.
You see things through Islamic glasses not through free thinker.
If you are not already a Muslim you are too weak to see the reality of Islamic influence on Western Leftist /liberatarian.
These apologist are being used by Muslims to promote their evil teaching in sugar coated pills.

David, Don't pretend to be an expert in psychology.
You personal attack on me and your naive opinion shows it's you who have a childhood problem or have encountered bad experiences with your neighbourhood. Perhaps some Jewish people.
I am afraid people like you who will be the target for Muslims to be converted to their 7th century Arabian ideology.
Many already got trapped and become jihadis in some form or even do fight against their own Country.
Islam like Socialism hate patriotism even hates their own country for the sake of their ideology.
The reason is both aim is to dominate the world.
Islam ultimate aim is "ummah" (house of Muslims) domination of the world that is submit to Allah.
Leftist ultimate aim is International socialism.
Hence today both form a paradox unholy alliance.

As for my childhood, well my parent love me and I do help them.
So, professor David/Daud your assumption is wrong.
People who debate because they have knowledge.
People who cannot stand a debate have less knowledge, so they expose their imotional expression which often does not make sense.

John puzellfree   January 16th, 2009 6:56 pm ET

Ulrich.
i know many fall victim to HAMAS propaganda who regard HAMAS as hero.
You don't see what HAMAS did in illogical thinking by firing rocket they can win against Israel.
You cannot see that Hamas is using the palestinians a human shield to received the counter attack from Israel.
You are blind not to see that Egypt their fellow "brother" shut the border to prevent Palestinian to enter Egypt or preventing the aids coming to Gaza.
All you Muslims and leftist is focus on Israel ignore anything that Hamas did that make no sense.

As for the creation of Israel 1948, The Arabs were not expelled, but it was the neighbouring Arabs who instructed the Arab inhabitant to evaquate. Not to live in the Jews state. Some did not follow the instruction but stay. Hence you have Arab Israeli in Israel who has representative in Israel Parllaiment/Knesset.
Neither was there a Palestinian country in 1948.
Palestinian nation was created by Arafat after 1967.

John puzellfree   January 18th, 2009 12:15 am ET

tarig,

There are no scientific about Quran.
You are too submissive to Allah that you cannot think properly.
Even Allah is not sure how he created human. He said that human was created from earth, clay, from, ass, water, cloth of blood, sperm and magic from nothing.
Tarig read your Quran regarding how Allah create men.
Muslims scholar tried to justify Allah or rather Muhammad confused statement by arguing that it,s a process of creation. It seem Allah could not tell the different between first creation and re-creation or process.
Ask yourself Tarig if Adam was created by sperm, whose sperm? does Allah not know a foetus cannot exist without a female egg?
But the most contradictory statement of creation of men/adam is that Allah said Man was created from nothing.

19:67 (Y. Ali) But does not man call to mind that We created him before out of nothing?

By the way, who is "we"? Allah+Gabriel+Muhammad?
If he is the powerful and mighty one, sure he will say "I"
Muslims scholar can fool ignorant Muslim like you, but you cannot fool us.
They claim Quran as scientific fact, show how naive muslims scholar are. How much more ordinary Muslim like you.
A statement only cannot be regarded as science.
A science has to be include long research, tested and proven beyond doubt.

By the way, Tarig, do you believe in hadith that the moon split in two during Muhammad lifetime?

Sahih Bukhari 006.060.387
Narrated Ibn Masud
During the lifetime of Allah's Apostle the moon was split into two parts; one part remained over the mountain, and the other part went beyond the mountain. On that, Allah's Apostle said, "Witness this miracle."

Listen Tarig before you denied this verse, remember what SAHIH means.
If non of Hadith are sahih, then Quran is just a collection of Muhammad babbling while in trance. or just lies made up opinion pretending to be from Allah that has no meaning. It's just like a collection of poems. Hence Muslims are to recites.

Even Aisha the most beloved child wife of Muhammad admitted that sometime Muhammad was bewitch.
Sahih Bukhari 004.053.400
Narrated Aisha
Once the Prophet was bewitched so that he began to imagine that he had done a thing, which in fact he had not done.

Listen Tarig. My comment is based on Islam books sources and rational mind.

As I said, those nice verses in Quran were spoken when Muhammad was still promoting Islam to the Jews , the Christians first and to Arabs pagans. At that time he has no full power yet and was poor.
His armies/follower sometimes got so hungry. That he intructed to rob Quraish caravans.

Hadith Sahih Bukhari 007.067.402
Narrated Jabir

The Prophet sent us as an army unit of three hundred warriors under the command of Abu 'Ubaida to ambush a caravan of the Quraish. But we were struck with such severe hunger that we ate the Khabt (desert bushes), so our army was called the Army of the Khabt....."

Allah does not recognise Jesus Salvation, because he is not the same God as God of the Bible who want to save human and you from the punishment of sin in hell.
Equally, Satan hates the cross, because the Cross is the symbol of his defeat.
Allah doesn't like you to recognise that Jesus is the son of God and the words of God. Therefore, in Quran he doesn't like God being partnered.
Allah seemed obsessed with death by terror and be worship by human slaves.
However, real God loves human and gave life and eternal and buy saving human from death and become Gods children and NOT SLAVES OF ALLAH.

Today I watch on TV an imam AlQaeda supporter by saying.
" We (Muslims) fight because we want to die to be with Allah. You (kafir) fight to live"
THIS IS THE PROVE THAT YOUR ALLAH IS MORE INTERESTED IN DEATH TO GET YOUR SOUL BY YOU TO DIE FOR HIM.
WHILE THE REAL GOD GAVE LIFE THROUGH JESUS SACRIFICE SO THAT YOU CAN LIVE.

Can you see now the fruit evident of islam teaching? Or the different teaching between Islam and Yudeo Christianity?

That imam and Muslims are so brainwashed due to total submission that they really believe Allah will reward them with earthly pleasure in heaven. No wonder Allah made Muslims world poor and backward so they can be fooled to die for him.
He is only interested in human soul to get life energy because satan and his demons /fallen angels have no life force.

Well, read Allah slip of tongue?:

46:9 Say: "I am no bringer of new-fangled doctrine among the apostles, nor do I know what will be done with me or with you. I follow but that which is revealed to me by inspiration; I am but a warner open and clear
11:34 "Of no profit will be my counsel to you, much as I desire to give you (good) counsel, if it be that Allah willeth to leave you astray: He is your Lord! and to Him will ye return!"

Tarig, Most holy books of big religions do have universal wisdom words.
Now, give me one example of UNIVERSAL WISDON WORDS(VERSES) OF ALLAH IN QURAN.
Remember Allah claim to be the God of the universe.
I hope you understand what "universal wisdom" means.

Thomas   January 18th, 2009 1:11 am ET

Those who accuse Israel of war crimes and being the perpetrator have no concept of the nature of war. War is a very horrible thing and should only be resorted to as a last resort. Israel endured 8 years of Rocket fire before it decided to take the stance it did. And sorry but collateral damage does not constitute a war crime. If you want to get mad at someone get mad at Hamas and it's Iranian master for bring this upon the people of Gaza.

tarig   January 18th, 2009 5:07 am ET

considering you completely ignored the one about child birth heres one more for you

“Or (the unbelievers’ state) is like the darkness in a deep sea. It is covered by waves, above which are waves, above which are clouds. Darknesses, one above another. If a man stretches out his hand, he cannot see it....” (Quran 24:40)

This verse mentions the darkness found in deep seas and oceans, where if a man stretches out his hand, he cannot see it. The darkness in deep seas and oceans is found around a depth of 200 meters and below. At this depth, there is almost no light Below a depth of 1000 meters there is no light at all. Human beings are not able to dive more than forty meters without the aid of submarines or special equipment. Human beings cannot survive unaided in the deep dark part of the oceans, such as at a depth of 200 meters.
so i guess mohammed developed a way to do so without anyone else knowing right?

you yourself say islamic references notthe Quran. you selectively choose what you want to write and leave out the actual meaning. just to answer one thing we refers to I and my servants (angels) as you would know if you read arabic bottom line is you have a belief, that you will have failed to prove to me because unlike the rest of the people here i know you are using lines and statments that take the meaning completely out of context. every point i make you choose what to answer from, you fail to bring up the verse about child birth because you know you cant question it. you fail to return to the point about it being a dream. you claim to have seen the sites i posted but if you did (as opposed to just having an agenda and wanting to prove it by going to that website you like so much) then all the questions you ask you would know the answer to.

you say : He said that human was created from earth, clay, from, ass, water, cloth of blood, sperm and magic from nothing.

if you didnt just pick this up from someone else you would know that in each case Allah is talking in a different context. earth and clay are the same thing, and refers to the creation of the Adams, water refers to the fact that man is made up of water, clot of blood in Arabic is Alaq, which also means attach or attachment, refering to the embryos attachement to the uterus of the mother, sperm only requires basic logic to know the context, and nothing is in reference to the beliefs of gentiles ie the big bang and evolution.

you say Allah isnt the same as God because he states that Jesus didnt die on the cross. you neglect to mention that Jesus is the most referenced prophet in the Quran, adn that its jews the dont believe in him (a point i have already made but yet again you overlooked because you cant explain it). over and over i have said dont judge these people as followers of islam, they arent muslims and their actions will probably send them to hell (i have no right to judge so i wont). the verses you translate are again taken completely out of context. i will take only the first one because you really arent worth any more of my time and just to prove to all that you are a liar. the verse before it 46:8 reads:
Or do they say, "He has forged it"? Say: "Had I forged it, then can ye obtain no single (blessing) for me from Allah. He knows best of that whereof ye talk (so glibly)! Enough is He for a witness between me and you! And he is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful."
46:9 reads:
Say: "I am no bringer of new-fangled doctrine among the messengers, nor do I know what will be done with me or with you. I follow but that which is revealed to me by inspiration; I am but a Warner open and clear."

clearly this refers to what Allah told the prophet to tell people like you if they say he has made the whole thing up. every mention you have made i have refuted with the least effort, and i am not a religious person in that sense. if you really are open to learning like you say, but i doubt it, then tell me this, how has a minimally religious muslim been able to refute every claim you have made with such ease? and dont say i havent because you dont bring up most of the points i make again, and if you do its just copy pasted info from one single website, damn man make a bit more effort, its just too easy for me and anyone with half a brain can see your just fumbling around with no real purpose. if you really are open minded as you say then go to this link:
http://www.shajaracode.com/pageID_5399562.html
it will explain why muslims are the lowest common denominator at this poin t in history (but remember everythin the west has came from the arab world, from running water to universities, from modern theories of philosophy and science, so before you jump on the band wagon of islam bashing, study up a bit, find out what real muslims have done for this world instead of listening to what others say. i doubt you will but thats your choice. in fact if you really are open minded as you say, buy the book thats advertised at the top of that link, it will explain everything relative to all three monotheistic religions. but yet again i doubt you will. you have a desire to refute islam, but when you try to stand up to a muslim with minimal knowledge you fail to convince me that you have anything other than a desire to be racist. i dont blame you muslims like Hamas dont give islam a good image, but its not the teachings no matter how much you want it to be.

in england we have a saying:
big minds talk about ideas, average minds talk about events, small minds talk about people.

some people here try to talk about solutions to this crisis (ideas). if you look at earlier posts by me and Mr. David you would see thats what both of us tried to do. most talk about what is happening the events. you seem to be determined to talk about people, what does that say about you. in fact i could say your even lower on that scale because you talk about names.

tarig   January 18th, 2009 5:30 am ET

john, hears a few other points of universal wisdom that wont be found in either bible:

The heavens and the earth were one before they were ripped apart. Life started in the water and living things are mostly water [21:30]. Today when scientists look for traces of life on Mars or Jupiter moons, they look for water!
Reptiles came out of the water and were followed by two legged then 4 legged creatures [24:45].
The heavens are expanding [51:47]. Modern science tells us that the universe was started from a singularity. The pictures taken by Edwin Hubbell in Mount Wilson observatory in 1929 showed that the universe was expanding which led to the Big Bang theory. The Qur'an anticipated this "discovery" by 14 centuries.
The heaven used to be smoke [41:11]. We know that smoke is a mixture of hot gases and suspended particles.
The atom is not the smallest unit of matter in the universe which indicates the presence of subatomic particles! [34:3]
The Universe was created over a very long period. For God, some days last 1000 lunar years [22:47, 32:5]. This was used by Professor Mansour Hassab-Elnaby, an Egyptian physicist, to calculate the speed of light C=299792.5 km/s !!!
The Qur'an predicts that the speed of light is not the fastest speed in the universe. Spirits and angels proceed to God at 50 times the speed of light [70:4]
The earth rotates around its axis [27:88], rotates around the sun [7:54], is not flat but is like a ball [39:5] or an egg [79:30].
The lowest point on earth is near the dead sea [30:3].
Iron was sent to earth by God [57:25]. Scientists now believe that iron was introduced to earth by meteors.
The oceans have layers of waves and layers of darkness in which some creatures have light [24:40]. Scientists discovered recently different currents at different depths.
When different seas ( i.e. different in salinity, temperature, oxygen content, etc. ) meet, there is a barrier between them that they do not violate [55:19-20]. This is not apparent by visual observation but temperature sensitive satellite pictures confirm this.
Mountains are pegs that have roots extending below the surface of the earth [78:7], mountains stabilize the earth's crust by minimizing earthquakes [16:15].
Earthquakes precede volcanic eruptions [99:1].
The earth's core is heavier than its crust [99:2].
Our sun is not the only sun in the universe [25:61]. Modern astronomy tells us that the sun is actually a star and therefore the universe is full of suns. Astronomers are looking for other planets like ours. The Qur'an predicts they will find other planets [65:12]
The Bible differentiates the sun and the moon by size only: "God made two great lights–the greater light to govern the day and the lesser light to govern the night. He also made the stars" [Genesis 1:16]. The Qur'an tells us that: the sun is a shining glory while the moon is a light [10:5]; the sun is a lamp and the moon is a light [25:61,71:16]; the sun is a blazing lamp [78:13] .
The solar system is travelling through the universe to a final destination [36:38].
At the end of time, the sun will stop radiating energy and will be folded into a ball [ 81:1] (quasar? Black hole?)
Morning is associated with breathing [81:18]. Now we know that plants produce oxygen in presence of light and consume carbon dioxide.
Sperm attaches itself to the egg to form an attachment or a leach then a chewed-like lump which develops bones which are covered with flesh and then changed into a different form [ 23:14]. This refers to facts discovered only recently when scientists, using special scopes, followed the development of the fetus from a fertilized egg to a form resembling lower vertebrae before turning into the human form.
After contemplating the descriptions of embryonic stages as a leach then a chewed-like lump [23:14], Professor Keith Moore, a Canadian embryologist, compared pictures of different embryonic stages to pictures of leaches and chewed clay and confirmed the amazing accuracy of the Qur'anic verses.
Human pregnancy passes through 3 trimesters [39:6]
Different clouds (positively and negatively charged?) are harmonized to produce droplets of water and lightning [24:43].
This is not surprising since The Qur'an came to detail and explain everything and to settle differences of opinions [12:111, 16:64, 16:89].

dont just look up that one verse mentioned, read those around it so you can get the meaning and not take the words out of context as usual.

tarig   January 18th, 2009 6:13 am ET

john
and when you have look this up ask yourself for real who has been fooled, me by the Quran (not the AlQaeda sources that you quote considering i can quote an Arian nation priest or a KKK member but that wouldnt be an accurate portrayal of christianity)? or you by the vatican that has worked so hard to hide its people from the truth? remember that the bible wasnt freely available to the public before last century and the vatican have used it as a basis to carry out countless acts of terror, from the slaughter of educated women for being so called witches to backing the holocaust to diminishing black people as the lowest form of humanity. and then remember that the vatican is and has always been the official representative of the christian nation, and although certain Muslims clearly contradict the teachings of the Quran in the present day, in the past when Muslims were actually Muslims the middle east was the most prosperous region of the world, with all three monotheistic religions living side by side in harmony, even to this day regardless of what you may want to believe there are jews that live peacefully in Morroco and there are numerous Muslim countries with significant christian populations that have absolutely no problems with each other.

just one more point and this is the last time i will address you because you arent looking to discuss just attack. the statements made in the Quran have been prooved as scientific fact after some 1400 years. the fact that they were just statements means that whoever made them must have already known that they are so. tell me, looking at the long list of statements mentioned above in the Quran that have been prooven as fact by modern science, do you honestly think Mohammed could have made these statements up? are you really so ignorant as to believe that it is just coincidence, or are you so indoctrinated by the teachings of that website you love so much? especially now considering every statement you have taken from it i have refuted with ease and I AM NOT THAT RELIGIOUS. imagine trying to make these arguements of yours to a well educated muslim scholar like the man who wrote the book i referred you to?

John puzellfree   January 18th, 2009 6:47 pm ET

tarig

Sorry, mate it's clear you(Muslims) don't understand what universal wisdom words means.

All the verses of Quran you quoted are only a statements IT IS NOT A WISDOM NOR SCIENTIFIC.
i.e.
21:30 (Y. Ali) Do not the Unbelievers see that the heavens and the earth were joined together (as one unit of creation), before we clove them asunder? We made from water every living thing. Will they not then believe?

Do you as a rational person really believe that Allah CREATED ALL LIVING THINGs FROM WATER? WHICH INCLUDE TREES/PLANS AND ADAM AND EVE?

Man, As I said Muslims scholar is just trying to fitted things, not knowing how to be cretical in solving problems. Unfortunately, Muslims like you can't think so you just echoing what their "scholar" said.
You see, you Muslims regards those ayats as wisdom, s more like a illiterate slaves praising a master grand statement without knowing what he is talking about. For slaves have no right to questioning their master's statement.
tarig

Sorry, mate it's clear you(Muslims) don't understand what universal wisdom words means.

All the verses of Quran you quoted are only a statements IT IS NOT A WISDOM NOR SCIENTIFIC.
i.e.
21:30 (Y. Ali) Do not the Unbelievers see that the heavens and the earth were joined together (as one unit of creation), before we clove them asunder? We made from water every living thing. Will they not then believe?

Do you as a rational person really believe that Allah CREATED ALL LIVING THINGs FROM WATER? WHICH INCLUDE TREES/PLANS AND ADAM AND EVE?

Man, As I said Muslims scholar is just trying to fitted things, not knowing how to be cretical in solving problems. Unfortunately, Muslims like you can't think so you just echoing what their "scholar" said.
You see, you Muslims regards those ayats as wisdom, s more like a illiterate slaves praising a master grand statement without knowing what he is talking about. For slaves have no right to questioning their master's statement.

18:70 (Y. Ali) The other said: "If then thou wouldst follow me, ask me no questions about anything until I myself speak to thee concerning it."
5:101 (Y. Ali) O ye who believe! Ask not questions about things which, if made plain to you, may cause you trouble....."
5:102 (Y. Ali) Some people before you did ask such questions, and on that account lost their faith.

Sahih Bukhari 009.092.395
......" He also wrote to him that the Prophet used to forbid; .....(2) Asking too many questions (in disputed Religious matters);"........

The a Wisdom Words is words that have MORAL AND LIFE meaning that applies to ALL MANKINDS.

I give you one example from Jesus wisdom words.

Luke 6:39
And He spoke a parable to them: “Can the blind lead the blind? Will they not both fall into the ditch?

Matthew 15:14
Let them alone. They are blind leaders of the blind. And if the blind leads the blind, both will fall into a ditch.”

These wisdom words apply to Muslims world today that consequently lead the muslims in chaos, poor, mostly illiterate. Especially, you see the fruits of HAMAS and the Islamic extremist.

The a Wisdom Words is words that have MORAL AND LIFE meaning that applies to ALL MANKINDS.

I give you one example from Jesus wisdom words.

Luke 6:39
And He spoke a parable to them: “Can the blind lead the blind? Will they not both fall into the ditch?

Matthew 15:14
Let them alone. They are blind leaders of the blind. And if the blind leads the blind, both will fall into a ditch.”

These wisdom words apply to Muslims world today that consequently lead the muslims in chaos, poor, mostly illiterate. Especially, you see the fruits of HAMAS and the Islamic extremist.

Now, try again, find a verse in Quran that reflect Allah's universal wisdom words.

John puzellfree   January 18th, 2009 7:38 pm ET

Tarig,
You are the one being fooled by Muslims scholar s about Quran being scientific.
I don't blame you, because Muslims has been programmed to only understand in a certain mindset.

Quran verses and Hadith are Islamic own sources which have been adopted literally by Islamic fundamentalist included Al Qaeda.
It's they who are the real Muslims. You are a compromised Muslims .
Who compromise Allah teaching because you follow the Quran verses that had been abrogated. Because if it is still being used then It created many contradictory statements of Allah.
Especially, when you ignore Hadiths, it makes your faith even worst.

Quran mean nothing without any additional books, like hadiths , Sirat Sunnah to explain or tafsir. because there is no story background written in it as the context the statement.

As for Arians supremacy case which was Hitler main belief, has nothing to do with Christianity or Jesus teaching " love"

Where else some Muslims do believe that they are superior than the Kaffir. Minority race in Islamic Country which practice Shariah law is treated as second class.

John puzellfree   January 18th, 2009 8:36 pm ET

Tarig, please visit www,Faithfreedom.com founded by a learned Ex-Muslims who became a freethinker.

As for Muslims scholar/expert, well Dr Zakir Naik dare not to debate openly in the forum with the founder of the site. Despite many Muslims debater urged the founder to debate with Zakir.
But Zakir lets them down by refusing the challenge of the site founder.
It seem Muslims scholars only like debate in Muslims setting where Muslims control the stage.
Dr zakir naik dare not debate in the forum, because he knows the debate will be seen by people around the world who will participate in the debate.

So go to the site and learn more about your religion fact.

John puzellfree   January 19th, 2009 2:16 am ET

Tariq
You said:"you say Allah isnt the same as God because he states that Jesus didnt die on the cross. you neglect to mention that Jesus is the most referenced prophet in the Quran, and that its jews the dont believe in him.."

If Allah is the same God as God of the Bible, why does he not want you human to be saved?
Why does he not recognise the sacrifice of Jesus Christ, who nota bene was witnessed by many?
Why does Allah want human to be his slave instead of God's children?
Why does he hate the people of the book(Jews&Christians)?
Why does he change or altered the stories of the Bible?
Why does he not accept the God 10 commandment?
etc etc.
Jesus was referenced in Quran is no surprised, how can he/Muhammad not did, if he wanted to attract Christians to his new religion/Islam? What's more at that time many wrote about Jesus.
Even the devil/demons cannot deny the divinity of Jesus.
However, Allah/Muhammad reference to Jesus is only lips services;
Jesus knew it already:
Matthew 15:8
‘ These people draw near to Me with their mouth,And honour Me with their lips,But their heart is far from Me."

As for the Jews, they were expecting the Messiah as a warrior, who will deliver them from Roman occupation.
They don't understand that Jesus mission was to tackle the underlining sin first. He will come back on his second coming as the judge and God who will sort out once and for all the world and Satan.

You said:
"the verses you translate are again taken completely out of context. i will take only the first one because you really arent worth any more of my time and just to prove to all that you are a liar. the verse before it 46:8 reads:
Or do they say, "He has forged it"? Say: "Had I forged it, then can ye obtain no single (blessing) for me from Allah. He knows best of that whereof ye talk (so glibly)! Enough is He for a witness between me and you! And he is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful."
46:9 reads:
Say: "I am no bringer of new-fangled doctrine among the messengers, nor do I know what will be done with me or with you. I follow but that which is revealed to me by inspiration; I am but a Warner open and clear."

How do I lie?
Verse 46:8 was about people who questioning Muhammad about his prophethood.
Especially, when he could not perform miracles.
Verse 46:9, just prove that Allah let Muhammad to say that Allah doesn't guarantee future salvation for Muhammad nor for Muslims.
Why?, this was clarify by his words:
11:34 "Of no profit will be my counsel to you, much as I desire to give you (good) counsel, if it be that Allah willeth to leave you astray: He is your Lord! and to Him will ye return!"

So, Allah indeed wants to play with your soul.
When Muhammad was very ill, Allah did not grant Muhammad or Gabriel prayer to make him well. Even though Muhammad was Allah beloved messenger and have been able to met Allah in "heaven".

You claimed:
"then tell me this, how has a minimally religious muslim been able to refute every claim you have made with such ease? and dont say i havent because you dont bring up most of the points i make again, and if you do its just copy pasted info from one single website, damn man make a bit more effort, its just too easy for me and anyone with half a brain can see your just fumbling around with no real purpose"

Typical Muslims , like HAMAS and Hezbollah who have a habit of self declare victory.
To just answer a debate does not mean that you have correctly refuted my comment.
Man, it's you who are naive.
I have been debating with Muslims for a long time, I also learn other religions, The website is not my only sources. It just makes easier to get data i.e. Quran/hadith verses quickly.
On the other hand your sources/knowledge is limited to what your imam said and Islamic books which are unreliable.

You brag:
"(but remember everythin the west has came from the arab world, from running water to universities, from modern theories of philosophy and science,"

I know Muslims like to claim this.
However, the truth is, during Muslims expansion with sword, the lands they conquered are more civilized and advance than Arabs.
Muslims conqueror not only looting the land they conquer, but they took/copy the local knowledge and translate it to Arabs. i.e. Alexandria in Egypt was Roman biggest libraryof knowledge in the world. Muslims armies came and took it over.
They also destroy local culture and turn it into Arabs culture (Arabisation). Hence the whole Middle east and north now became Arab nation.
The Assyrians whose local people of now call Iraq and Persian now Iran were more advance than Arabs muslims,
aa early Muslim scientist in islamic center learing of Bagdad was a Persian.

My point is if islam really produced all those science you claimed, why are Muslims world now poor, mostly illiterate, never invented thing and undemocratic????
Answer:
1. Plagiary can never be advanced because it copied other knowledge and doesn't use their own motivated freethinking.
2.islam teaching of total submission discouraged or prevents Muslims to think freely and creatively and the desire of exploration. Thus they became fatalist (Insja Allah).
As the result, they becomeemotionally charge because their true being is suppressed by their Allah Islam teaching. Worst is that what they learn in Madrasah are mostly Islamic knowledge and not a proper universal knowlege education. They were heavily brainwashed everyday by Quran verses. Some Imam teach hatred toward the Jews and Christians.
No wonder, Indonesian who has no Jews in their land hate the Jews for no reason.

Proof today the state of Muslims world. Here is some example Islamic Countries who practice Shariah laws
Percentage Literacy of Islamic Country 2008;
-----------------
- Saudi Arabia 78.80% centre of Islam(despite rich in oil and Mecca pilgrim income)
- Afghanistan 28.10 % the poorest Islamic Country who do not have natural sources (oil/gas)
Semi "democratic" with sjariah law.
- Egypt 71.40% Central Islamic learning.
- Pakistan 49.90% The only Islamic nuclear power.
Compare it to
-Turkey a not fully democratic country literacy is 87.40%
- Indonesia who does not practice Shariah law, the literacy rate is 90.40%
- Azerbajan was a communist based education country . Her the literacy is 98.80 %

This proof that Islam mentality do effect Muslims countries standing in the world.
Therefore, get real and be rational rather than emotional and not just accepting what you were being told.
Your sided with HAMAS is based on emotional for being a Muslims. That is illogical.

John puzellfree   January 20th, 2009 2:16 am ET

Tarig wrote:
". i wont answer anything you have written because your just repeating the same thing over and over, i have answered and given links to it all. you want words of wisdom here:"

You don't won't answer me because you can't.
It is useless to give me Islamic link, because I know already.
I know you are seeking help to refute me. One of them is by looking at Muslims wesite. by

You quote Quran verses which you regard as Allah wisdom word.

[17/70] with your explanation as;
"Respect and honour all human beings irrespective of their religion, color, race, sex, language, status, property, birth, profession/job and so on"

Here is the details of verse in Quran.
17:70 (Y. Ali) We have honored the sons of Adam; provided them with transport on land and sea; given them for sustenance things good and pure; and conferred on them special favours, above a great part of our creation.

What are you getting at Tarig? Your explanation does not reflect what the verse said.
It's just a wishful thinking of moderate Muslims scholar.
As I said before, those nice words were spoken when Muhammad was still promoting Islam in a correct manner and not by force after he got full power.
Here some of Allah words which contradict his early verses:
3:85,(Y. Ali) If anyone desires a religion other than Islam (submission to Allah., never will it be accepted of him; and in the Hereafter He will be in the ranks of those who have lost (All spiritual good).
4:144,(Y. Ali) O ye who believe! Take not for friends unbelievers rather than believers: Do ye wish to offer Allah an open proof against yourselves?
5:51, 5:51 (Y. Ali) O ye who believe! take not the Jews and the Christians for your friends and protectors: They are but friends and protectors to each other. And he amongst you that turns to them (for friendship) is of them. Verily Allah guideth not a people unjust.

9:29 (Y. Ali) Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued.
9:123.(Y. Ali) O ye who believe! Fight the unbelievers who gird you about, and let them find firmness in you: and know that Allah is with those who fear Him.

All those other Quran verses you quote with Muslims scholar enterpretations, are NOT UNIVERSAL WISDOMS WORDS. They are just rules of Allah for within Muslims ummah and does not apply to nonMuslims Kaffir. Further more it mentioned Allah, satan, fear, hell heaven, punishment which is typical Islamic or religious teaching.
Universal wisdoms words should not include or mention those entities nor threat of hell and punishment and reward heaven.
Because there are people who do not believe in Allah, satan, supreme being nor hell nor heaven. But want to live a normal, peace and order.
So, those Quran verses have no meaning for people like an agnostic, atheist, Budhish, paganism, Jew, Christians. Especially, when Allah hates people of the book and condemn kafir.

It seems you copy paste those explanations with verse details but without quoting the verse itself. So you are trying to deceived Muslims and non Muslims alike for giving interpretation without the details of the verse. Because, if those verses are quoted as well, any intelligent person can see that the explanation does not reflect with the verse as I explain nor relevant.

Finally, since you don't have knowledge about Christianity nor have you read the Bible by yourself, your argument those Bible verses are useless. Because you only parroting Muslim scholar and atheist thinking.
As the Bible got story back ground in it (unlike Quran). You can read it by yourself, what's more it has the power to open your spiritual mind.
The verses in the Bible should be understood and practice, unlike Quran ayats are more like poems to be recited, hence many non arab speaking muslims have no clue what they are reciting.

Dennis Junior   January 27th, 2009 4:35 am ET

Jomana Karadsheh:
The Arab World was watching the situation because it, did not want to do anything for Palestinians on this occasion since it was in waste of resources....

Whofalsfluell   July 31st, 2012 3:33 am ET

Vancouver led lighting store, When using the services provide, we will collect personal information such as: Name, Delivery Address, Contact Phone Number and E-Mail Address. Order information is also stored at this time to track previous transactions. http://www.vancouverledlighting.com/

wedding favors   August 18th, 2012 12:27 pm ET

You really make it appear so easy along with your presentation but I in finding this topic to be really something that I believe I would by no means understand. It sort of feels too complex and very huge for me. I am taking a look ahead on your next submit, I'll try to get the hold of it!


subscribe RSS Icon
About this blog

This blog has now been archived and commenting has been switched off. Visit the Inside the Middle East site for news, views and video from across the region.

Read more about CNN's special reports policy

Categories