Wednesday, March 28, 2007
Asking questions gets you noticed

A minder shadows me as I chat to the director of the Nubian Museum.

The most innocuous of inquiries, the most aboveboard of assignments pique the interest of security agencies across the Middle East.

In Egypt, television journalists know this all too well. I experienced it once again, first hand, while filming this month's edition of Inside the Middle East.

Since first traveling to Upper Egypt in 1991, I'd always been curious about the ancient Nubian community. Distinct in their traditional dialect and ethnicity, the Nubians, who once ruled over the rich and lush land on the banks of the Nile, have become exiles of sorts in their own country.

A series of floods from the construction of dams on the mighty Nile displaced up to a million Nubians over the last generation. The government relocated many of them in the early '60s, sometimes deep into the desert, far from their ancestral homeland. Their Nile culture has drowned under the water of the river that made their glory for a period thousands of years ago.

We spoke to an old man who remembered what life was like in Nubian villages before the floods. In the open-air patio of a government-provided home, he energetically showed me deeds of his family property and spoke of the difficulty of adjusting to a more urban lifestyle.

"The children," he said remembering his days as a school principal, "don't draw colorful pictures anymore. Not the way they used to."

His wife, sitting on a wooden bench behind him, nodded "no" when I asked if all Nubians had been compensated fairly for the homes they were forced to abandon.

I interview a Nubian tribal leader

Then, the old man started changing his story. Life for Nubians was actually wonderful, he said with verve; they had all been given a fair swap for their property. The schools, he added, were top-notch.

It wasn't making sense; and then, I knew.

I turned around and saw a government minder taking notes. Leaning against a wall, behind the camera, the young man Egyptian authorities had "assigned" to our television crew was busy writing away.

I asked a few more questions and ended the interview. It was pointless to go on. The old man did not want to appear overly critical of the authorities. In Egypt, as in many countries in the Middle East, that can get you in trouble.

Later, I took the minder aside:

"Why are you taking notes?" I asked.

"Does it bother you?" he replied, smiling.

I wasn't smiling.

"Yes, actually, it does."

His expression turned serious. He reached into his pocket and pulled out an official ID card.

"Look," he says pointing to his picture, thinking I was questioning his credentials, rather than complaining that his presence was a nuisance.

The following day, a man who'd helped us on the ground in Aswan was called in to a local police station for questioning. We immediately called the police chief and dictated our shooting permit numbers over the phone, finally convincing the authorities that our contact had nothing to hide.

Add to that the checkpoints and the questions from soldiers calling their superiors. During this trip, I would hear fragments of conversations from the window of our van.

"Americans ... Tourism ... Yes sir."

This isn’t unusual in Egypt or anywhere else in the Middle East. Sometimes, information ministries don’t impose minders, but when they do, the "escorts" are simply following orders. In the end, I even warmed to the young man assigned to us in Upper Egypt. Young, shy, with a pencil mustache and a soft smile, he was easy to like. Others have been more intrusive and more aggressive.

In the end, we get around them. When conducting interviews, we make sure they're out of earshot. When alone, we spend that time speaking to ordinary people on the street. For more sensitive stories, we shoot interviews in hotels. In other words, we can report accurately and fairly, but the presence of minders is a constant reminder that we are being watched and that our presence is deemed a threat.

In Egypt a few weeks ago, 22-year-old blogger Abdel Kareem Nabil was imprisoned for four years for criticizing President Hosni Moubarak and "insulting Islam." All the while, opposition politicians complain proposed constitutional changes will further choke the democratic process in Egypt.

Dissenting voices are not easily tolerated within one of America's strongest allies in the Arab world.

In the Middle East, asking questions gets you noticed.

-- From Hala Gorani, CNN International Anchor
It is a sad state of affairs when that man cannot even describe his own life history, in what is supposedly, his own country! If the government is so pro-democracy, why is there a necessity for a "minder" anyway? For that matter, how much difference is there between this and how journalists are treated in communist Cuba under Castro? Ridiculous, and sad. Thank you for doing the best you can to report from areas so restricted & in my estimation, paranoid. What does anyone have to fear from the truth?
I bet you don't have this kind of censorship when you go to Israel. There you're free to write anything, good or bad, about what you see. It's your own censorship that is the problem there - very little good ever gets printed or reported on CNN about Israel.
when some one insults islam he insults GOD and that is why he is being punished.if he was a scholar on islam he may have a point,but he seems to be loner that needs some attention,lo and behold he got it.I am for freedom of speech but there are restriction as to how far you want to take it.why is it that reporters are implying that its ok to insult can he insults islam when he has some knowledge about islam but is not a sheikh/mufti/moulana(scholars or professors in english )salaam(peace)
Dear Hala,

You know that these people will get in trouble for speaking, even mildely,
against government insjustice or sub-standard practices & yet you choose to quote & show the picture of the tribal leader. You can be sure that this article will impact his life & the life of his family, courtesy of the Egyptian government or one of its security agencies.Humiliation, harrassment, arrest will be on his agenda for a long time to come. I bet he didn't plan on that when he trusted you with his safety & well being. What is the difference between your article & the report of your escort ? different is published by Time, the other by Mokhabarat.
Don't worry, be happy
Thanks for the link "Inside the Middle East" you provided in your article... Unfortunately,other then the one hour of "Your World Today" news, broadcasted sometime during the day, Cnn International is not broadcasted here in the Southern Ca. And so, programs such as "Inside the Middle East" is not being viewed. Somehow Ironic, since it is precisely these kinds of programs, our seemingly insulated, parochialist world need to see...
Hear from CNN reporters across the globe. "In the Field" is a unique blog that will let you share the thoughts and observations of CNN's award-winning international journalists from their far-flung bureaus or on assignment. Whether it's from conflict zone, a summit gathering, or the path least traveled, "In the Field" gives you a personal, front row seat to CNN's global newsgathering team.
    What's this?
CNN Comment Policy: CNN encourages you to add a comment to this discussion. You may not post any unlawful, threatening, libelous, defamatory, obscene, pornographic or other material that would violate the law. Please note that CNN makes reasonable efforts to review all comments prior to posting and CNN may edit comments for clarity or to keep out questionable or off-topic material. All comments should be relevant to the post and remain respectful of other authors and commenters. By submitting your comment, you hereby give CNN the right, but not the obligation, to post, air, edit, exhibit, telecast, cablecast, webcast, re-use, publish, reproduce, use, license, print, distribute or otherwise use your comment(s) and accompanying personal identifying information via all forms of media now known or hereafter devised, worldwide, in perpetuity. CNN Privacy Statement.