Edition: U.S. | Arabic | Set Pref
Friday, August 10, 2007
The hidden side of Beijing


There's a sense of timelessness in the hutongs.

We all by now know the story of the new China.

A confident, powerful, even threatening nation to some, taking its place at the head table. A permanent member of the U.N. security council, W.T.O. member, inward investment magnet and now a country who's own money and people are spreading across the world. And at its center is Beijing.

I've been coming here for about 12 years and the changes have been extraordinary. A city of bicycles is now a city of cars, bumper to bumper along 12-lane roads lined by monumental new buildings. A city of glass and steel. An architect's playground where money is no object in creating something new, something different.

The Bird's Nest national sports stadium, the Watercube swimming center are not only centerpieces of the Olympic Games but symbols of the revival of a country no longer locked behind a bamboo curtain.

But there is another side to Beijing. The hutongs. Not the well-worn tourist areas where beautifully preserved century-old houses have been turned into high-class restaurants and offices for attorneys, but the older, more careworn parts of town.

The name hutong literally means alleyway. In Beijing they are more like a maze. Winding, tree-lined streets of cobblestone, bitumen or gravel, many too narrow for a car, where life goes on pretty much undisturbed by the blossoming city around them.
Brick houses with tiled sloping roofs and tiny cluttered courtyards, carved pillars and painted oak doors. In one courtyard we looked into, plump ripe grapes were growing across an arched entrance.

They are not all pretty, some look close to ruin. Some don't have running water and the residents share public bathrooms and toilets. But it's real. There's a sense of timelessness in the hutongs. And it's a welcome contrast to the new city that is rising up to engulf them.

I went to the Quanmen hutong area, barely a mile from Tiananmen Square. It could be a thousand miles away judging from the pace of life there.

But it, like many others, are disappearing. The government say it wants to preserve just a handful of hutongs to make way for high-rises with modern facilities. Fair enough perhaps, except many of the hutong dwellers don't want to go and the payout offered by the government (about $U.S.1,000 per square meter) is not enough to buy one of these new apartments.

They are being shunted to the outskirts of the city, the only place they can afford.

Even the hutongs under protection are not necessarily safe, says activist Hua Xinmin. She's been fighting the demise of the hutongs for the last 10 years. She says corrupt local city officials and property developers are in many cases ignoring protection orders.

Beijing is not the first city in the world, and it won't be the last, to bulldoze over history in the name of progress, but the sheer speed of development in the capital means that these areas are disappearing fast.

So my advice to you, if you are planning a trip to Beijing, is try to get off the main tourist track and visit some of these hutongs. Because once they are gone, they are gone forever.

-- From CNN Anchor/Correspondent Andrew Stevens
Andrew:
My question is: Are the hutongs part of the communist history of China or just China in general? Are these residents part of a collective based on the communist rule where everything is shared...i.e. bathrooms?

Beijing may be not so far away from the evolution of many American cities where low-income homes are being eliminated to bring about sophisticated urban townhouses and condos in once historical areas of town.

Or are we talking about apples and oranges here?
Max,

I am sure the party would say that their reasoning is for the greater good of the people, but it is hard to accept that that is true. Some estimates put the displacement in Beijing to be over 1 million, and the compensation is not nearly enough to allow people to relocate to another home, certainly not anything close to what is being built on top of their old home. There is no recourse for those being displaced.

In addition, Beijingers see the hutong as the soul of the city. The hutong have existed for close to 700 years. We are witnessing the destruction of culture, not just homes.
This is probably the basement of the modern M shape society, where most of us live at the ground floor.
Both, I think Max. Every time I go into the city of Buenos Aires I pass a slum that lines the railroad, and reminds me of any such place I have witnessed for 30 years in Latin America and elsewhere. I reflect that population pressures will always reveal this ugly side of humanity, as cities expand beyond what they can hold comfortably. However, we can see why people choose to live close together when they are vulnerable. The best refugee camp I have ever seen had four small housing units for two familes each and placed four in a sqaure with a small courtyard inside. It offered maximum security to the dwellers, closeness, protection of women, etc. Slums need to be transformed into such housing, never put into high rise individual units. They can be near transport outside of town, or placed wherever if choice property is needed for investment. Hire the displaced for labour to build sky rises for the rich. Compensate concretely as a tax for our ¨progress¨ and over population. I would love the media to advocate as much as report, but greatly appreciate you bring light to a global problem everywhere...thanks
Angela in Buenos Aires
Andrew:
Thank you for your article. I share the same feeling with you, because it is also my concern about my city, Beijing. I grew up in a Hutong, in Dongcheng District. Although I'm now living in a building,and have a better living condition, my happiness of living in a Hutong has never been surpassed.
I feel it very heartrending to witness the disappearance of Hutongs, which once were the symbol of the historical city. Now, Beijing is larger,more modern and international than before, however, it is losing its own identification to cater for the taste of foreigners so as to develop the economy. Maybe, 50 years later, when we are rich enough, we will realize that we have destroyed the Chinese style, and set about a series of sound preservation project with wonders why people once tore those houses down and with curses of our former generation who made the unwise decision.
Well, as I have mentioned, it is the task for us to undertake 50 years later, our main task at present is to earn more dollars from tourists and get more investments from foreign countries. So, that's it.
the picture is really ugly--why not choosing a picture to show what hutong really is? every building seeing from the top is not so informational. imaging andrew's picture from his bottom.
the picture is not about hutong. it seems to be a line of storage rooms expanded from the original buildings.
The city of Beijing is becoming one of the busiest cities of Asia as well as of the world. It however is losing its identity as part of the ancient Chinese culture.
Yes, this picture is definitely not of any hutong I've ever hung out in. Looks more like some sort of shanty housing.

I've always loved the hutongs, but to play devil's advocate for the pro-modernization side of the coin, where would you rather live in the middle of a Beijing winter: in a character-filled, picturesque 500 year old brick house in central Beijing with no insulation, communal outdoor bathing and bathrooms, or in a generic apartment out past the third ring road with private bathrooms, indoor plumbing and central heating?

For sure, it's a trade off. Culture or clean toilets?

As for Jonathan's comment that we're witnessing the destruction of a culture, I think what we're seeing in Beijing has some similarities to what's already happened throughout small-town America, where Walmart and other cookie-cutter franchises have sucked the life out of so many once vibrant, character filled small town main streets. Like those mom & pop stores that have the misfortune to own stores within ten miles of a Walmart super-center, Hutong dwellers have the bad luck of occupying centrally located real-estate better suited to Beijing's new yuppie elite.
The only culture destroyed is the Chinese virtue for patience. Overzealous leads to unsafe and overconfident practices. I don’t trust the Chinese Government judgement anymore.

We have seen this new overzealous for Progress putting Safety in food exports at risk. Now recently seeing 6000 bridges deemed unsafe and one recent collapse Aug13/07 to take advantage of fast production while compromising and short-cutting all long-term safety measures. Utilizing LEAD poisonous paints in children’s toys to hopefully make use of products instead of accepting the cost of paint disposal.

I have no patience for the new Chinese philosophy. The old I care very much for and the people that suffer in the gasses of their own production all in the name to produce and make more profits for all those but not for the people in the hutongs. I hope the world realizes before we too may see ourselves in our own hutong…maybe not in our life time. The problem is: do we really care? And is the old virtues of Chinese patience, a virtue that we are too blind to see disappear in our very own backyard?
CNN's Bill Schneider did a despicable and distorted poll aimed at discrediting General Petraeus before he issues his report. The Democrats seem intent on McGovernizing themselves.
I just returned from a visit to Beijing with my husband and two daughters. We were taken on a carefully scripted tour of a hutong in the center of Beijing by our tour guide from the Chines government's Chinese International Tourist Service. Our tour even included a supervised visit to the room of a 70-year-old Chinese woman who is paid to be a representative hutong dweller.We were told that 18% of Beijing's population lives in such traditional quadrangal housing, but that number seems inflated. The hutong we visited is a set, sponsored by the government to sway the attitudes of foreigners who visit Beijing. Truth is, China's communist revolution will produce the largest materialistic middle class...a bourgeosie..that the world has ever seen. Everyone we met and talked to was concerned only about their own economic welfare and greatly prefer a new apartment with modern appliances to life in the hutong.
our country should not support Taiwan or interfere in China's internal affairs.
Time goes by and people want to live more comfortable, even in Beijing.
Compare your own birth places now and at the time when your mother´s gave birth to you guys: whichone would you choose yourselves as adults and your children to live in?
Childhood memories are just that: childrens emotional pictures of the past.
I´m sure no females/mothers/grandmoms have that kind of a romantic view of the hutongs as elder males.
Honestly, all the ladies I spoke to in Beijing, living in the poorest areas or wherever, would have greeted a modern apartment whenever.
Romantics and war is ok on screen and in film, but reality is a different story.
It´s easy to be a Hutong-saver while sipping a dry martini in the chilled condo on the 22nd floor, but a real mess when you´re keeping it warm in the wintertime and washing all those working clothes of thy beloved husband, every night... :)
it's diffcult for foreigner to full understand the intrinsic content of hutong to the old beijingers,it's not the dwelling place,it's the symbol of historical culture which faded away ,mostly destoried by the former governor .Once some elite architectors,such as liangsicheng, suggested not to ruin the circumvallation of old peijing and to build new blocks outside of the old city ,just like what happened at Athens.tragical, history didn't give mercy to this city. An opinion from japanese historian said that real china had vanished after the song dynasty ,it refered to the inherent spirit whcih inherited from generation to generation, dispeared .maybe we can find it among the japanese race,diligency,bravery,propriety,alos ,forbear!
i'am not native english speaker,hope you can understand what i said .
ABOUT THIS BLOG
Hear from CNN reporters across the globe. "In the Field" is a unique blog that will let you share the thoughts and observations of CNN's award-winning international journalists from their far-flung bureaus or on assignment. Whether it's from conflict zone, a summit gathering, or the path least traveled, "In the Field" gives you a personal, front row seat to CNN's global newsgathering team.
SUBSCRIBE
    What's this?
CNN Comment Policy: CNN encourages you to add a comment to this discussion. You may not post any unlawful, threatening, libelous, defamatory, obscene, pornographic or other material that would violate the law. Please note that CNN makes reasonable efforts to review all comments prior to posting and CNN may edit comments for clarity or to keep out questionable or off-topic material. All comments should be relevant to the post and remain respectful of other authors and commenters. By submitting your comment, you hereby give CNN the right, but not the obligation, to post, air, edit, exhibit, telecast, cablecast, webcast, re-use, publish, reproduce, use, license, print, distribute or otherwise use your comment(s) and accompanying personal identifying information via all forms of media now known or hereafter devised, worldwide, in perpetuity. CNN Privacy Statement.
Home  |  Asia  |  Europe  |  U.S.  |  World  |  World Business  |  Technology  |  Entertainment  |  World Sport  |  Travel
Podcasts  |  Blogs  |  CNN Mobile  |  RSS Feeds  |  Email Alerts  |  CNN Radio  |  CNNAvantGo  |  Site Map
© 2008 Cable News Network. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.