Skip to main content /LAW /LAW
find law dictionary

FBI says it withheld evidence from McVeigh lawyers

McVeigh is scheduled to be executed on Wednesday
McVeigh is scheduled to be executed on Wednesday  

In this story:

Conspiracy theory raised again

Attorney: 3,000 documents

Prison official: Execution still scheduled


DENVER, Colorado (CNN) -- An FBI admission that it failed to give certain documents to convicted Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh's defense attorneys has them considering whether to seek a stay of next week's scheduled execution.

"Mr. McVeigh is considering all his options," attorney Nathan Chambers said after the documents, used in a separate trial involving McVeigh's co-defendant Terry Nichols, were delivered to his office in Denver.

Chambers also said he had talked to McVeigh but refused to say what was discussed.

The Execution of Timothy McVeigh
graphic DOCUMENT
Read Timothy McVeigh's agreement with the Coroner of Vigo County, Indiana - March 9, 2001 (FindLaw) (PDF format)
Documents in PDF format require Adobe Acrobat Reader for viewing.
graphic VIDEO
Oklahoma Governor Frank Keating tells CNN's Greta Van Susteren he's 'puzzled and concerned' about the withheld McVeigh evidence (May 10)

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)

CNN's Major Garrett reports on a U.S. Department of Justice statement on the withheld McVeigh evidence (May 10)

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)

CNN's Susan Candiotti reports on the type of evidence that might have been withheld in the McVeigh trial (May 10)

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)
Lesson Plan: Oklahoma City remembers
graphic ALSO
Justice Department letter to McVeigh's attorneys


Latest Legal News

Law Library

FindLaw Consumer Center

McVeigh case prosecutor Patrick Ryan called the failure to turn over the documents "embarrassing" and "totally unacceptable."

"I think the government ought to go along with it," he said, referring to the granting of more time for the defense to review the documents. He said he thought the government should be the one to ask for a stay.

Oklahoma Gov. Frank Keating said reaction in Oklahoma City to the latest development in the McVeigh case was one of "stunned disbelief."

"Obviously, until we know why they weren't turned over, there is a big question mark over this whole proceeding," Keating said.

McVeigh, 33, is scheduled to be executed Wednesday at the U.S. Penitentiary in Terre Haute, Indiana.

Conspiracy theory raised again

Richard Burr, a death penalty specialist who helped defend the decorated Gulf War veteran and is now acting as a consultant for the legal team, told CNN the lawyers do not have approval from McVeigh to seek a stay.

Asked on what grounds a stay could be justified after McVeigh admitted he planted and detonated the bomb that destroyed the Murrah Federal Building in 1995, Burr said, "What if Stephen Jones is right and he is protecting others?"

The reference was to McVeigh's lead trial attorney, later fired, who contended his client was part of a larger conspiracy.

Jones said Thursday that he feels "vindicated" by the government's admission. "I said from the beginning they were withholding evidence, and they were."

He also said that that he's been told the documents contain over 200 interviews and he suspects they are about what witnesses said about a second suspect the FBI called John Doe #2.

"If this should turn out to be about John Doe #2, I think it is far from clear that the Oklahoma City bombing case has reached a conclusion in federal court," Jones said.

The FBI later concluded McVeigh acted largely alone, because of a hot apple pie he bought at a McDonald's in Junction City, Kansas, minutes before renting the bomb truck. A security camera caught McVeigh on film arriving alone, eating by himself and then leaving alone.

McVeigh did not take the stand in his own defense during his trial. Jones suggested then that the real bomber was killed in the blast, and suggested the evidence was contaminated in the much-maligned FBI crime lab.

However, in a book published last month, "American Terrorist: Timothy McVeigh & The Oklahoma City Bombing," McVeigh claimed sole responsibility for the bombing of the Alfred R. Murrah Federal Building.

"My decision to take human life at the Murrah Building -- I did not do it for personal gain. ... I did it for the larger good," he told the book's authors.

Attorney: 3,000 documents

A source close to the case told CNN Correspondent Susan Candiotti that an FBI archivist discovered the withheld documents as all the materials related to the case were compiled.

The U.S. attorney in Denver informed his defense team and the federal court in Denver on Wednesday of what the FBI has called an oversight. It had only just discovered the day before - that investigatory documents, including reports on FBI interviews, photographs, letters and tapes, were withheld from McVeigh's defense.

A source said there was "nothing of major significance" withheld from the defense, Candiotti reported. The documents included some of the original notes of FBI investigators who had earlier turned over summaries of their findings.

Burr said the materials included 3,000 pages of documents, but the Justice Department declined to quantify it.

Another source told CNN that the discovery was made on Tuesday.

"Once the government was made aware of the documents, they were turned over to the defense. They are not material to the case and have no bearing on the outcome of the conviction," a Justice Department official said "If the defense disagrees, they will contact us."

Prison official: Execution still scheduled

McVeigh was convicted in a Denver trial of the 1995 bombing of the federal building in Oklahoma City that killed 168 people. He was sentenced to death by lethal injection. He later dropped appeals in the case, opting to die rather than spend life in prison. His death would be the first federal execution since 1963.

Dan Dunne, a spokesman for the penitentiary where McVeigh would be executed, told CNN that prison officials have not been notified of any change of plans.

"There's been no change at this point," he said. "It's still scheduled."

CNN correspondents Gina London and Susan Candiotti contributed to this report.

McVeigh attorney to witness execution
May 10, 2001
Some Oklahoma City bombing families fight for McVeigh's life
May 4, 2001
McVeigh execution witness list climbs to 300
May 2, 2001
Oklahoma City remembers
April 19, 2001
U.S. wants McVeigh webcast lawsuit dismissed
April 13, 2001
Bill Press: McVeigh to die on television
April 13, 2001
Ashcroft OKs closed TV feed of McVeigh execution
April 11, 2001
FBI: McVeigh knew children would be killed in OKC blast
March 29, 2001
McVeigh autopsy deal says no 'invasive procedure'
March 19, 2001
McVeigh scheduled to die by lethal injection May 16
January 16, 2001
Judge says McVeigh can drop appeals
December 28, 2000

Federal Bureau of Investigation
U.S. Department of Justice
The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms
Oklahoma State Government
Death Penalty Information Center
U.S. Federal Bureau of Prisons

Note: Pages will open in a new browser window
External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.



Back to the top