Skip to main content /WORLD /WORLD


Spy plane standoff put China's WTO entry at risk

Bush plane
"Do the right thing" Bush tells China, as he asks for the return of the plane and its crew


In this story:

Swift resolution

Something much larger

RELATED STORIES Downward pointing arrow

HONG KONG, China (CNN) -- Experts are warning an extended dispute over the U.S. spy plane and its crew may prevent China's entry into the World Trade Organization this year.

They are encouraging a fast resolution to the dispute, which began four days ago when a U.S. surveillance plane and a Chinese fighter jet collided near Hainan Island forcing the American spy plane to make an emergency landing.

The Chinese pilot is still missing in the South China Sea, and 24 crew members of the U.S. spy plane remain in detention in China.

U.S. president George W. Bush has insisted China provide further access to the crew members after they met U.S. diplomats in Hainan's capital Haikou for the first time on Tuesday night.

U.S. President George W. Bush calls for the return of a military plane and crew from China

Play video | TRANSCRIPT
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)

CNN's Jamie McIntyre reports that it's still unclear how much intelligence China will gain from spy plane

Play video
(QuickTime, Real or Windows Media)

More related video
graphic U.S.-China Collision: A diplomatic solution
 • About freighter returning EP-3
 • Look: Inside the EP-3
 • Facts about the EP-3
 • Map: Locating the incident
 • Big picture: High stakes
 • Classroom discussion guide
 • Historical US-China timeline
 • Whidbey arrival images
 • Crew speaks out
 • Crew's return images


The U.S. China Business Council's Robert Kapp says the incident may broaden

1.43 MB/2:16 min.
AIFF or WAV sound


Dr. Eden Woon, a former U.S. China policy advisor, says China's WTO entry could be at risk

1.67 MB/2:38 min.
AIFF or WAV sound
  • Facts about EP-3 Aries II
  • Map of Collision
  • China names missing pilot
  • U.S. plane crew send messages back home
  • U.S. takes firm tone, but hopes not to antagonize China
  • GOP lawmakers: Arms sales to Taiwan more likely
  • Plane called an 'electronic vacuum cleaner' on routine mission
  • Standoff may harden Bush on China
  • Collision may fuel broader SE Asian debates
  • Mike Chinoy: Chinese reaction in the U.S. spy plane stand-off

    China blames the U.S. for the incident, and on Wednesday president Jiang Zemin repeated his demands for an apology.

    Dr. Eden Woon, a former China policy advisor for the United States secretary of defense and the current director of the Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce, told CNN the confrontation threatened to jeopardize China's scheduled WTO entry later this year.

    Swift resolution

    In order to ensure China's WTO accession, he said the issue needed to be resolved swiftly.

    Given the Chinese president's repeated demands for the U.S. to apologize for Sunday's mid-air collision, Woon said Washington should offer some form of sympathy for the missing pilot while not apportioning any blame for the collision, which it officially describes as an accident.

    Woon added China should also release the 24 crew members of the U.S. Navy EP-3E Aries II, suggesting such an act would immediately defuse the situation and allow quieter diplomatic discussions to smooth over relations between the two nations.

    Woon's warning came as Britain waded into the debate for the first time, with foreign secretary Robin Cook urging China to return the U.S. spy plane and its crew, and suggesting an apology from the U.S. would be unrealistic.

    Hong Kong-based economist with the Bank of America, Frank Gong told CNN the risk of a prolonged standoff was very high, as it appeared "hard liners are running the show" on both sides.

    He said such a situation would have “huge implications” for north Asian economies, in particular Hong Kong and Taiwan.

    "I think somehow if the relationship deteriorates and the chances are high then we will not see China's entry into the WTO by the end of the year," Gong said.

    The president of the U.S. China Business Council, Robert Kapp, echoed concerns by the U.S. ambassador to China, admiral Joseph Prueher, that the incident had the potential "to bleed" into broader issues of China-U.S. relations.

    Something much larger

    "Time is not on our side. If this is not managed maturely and quickly by both sides and if the crew is not on its way home I think very, very soon then there is the possibility that this disagreement will metastasize into something much larger," he said.

    Kapp said although a degradation of relations had not yet occurred it was not good for regional security and stability at a time when U.S. companies were anticipating more stability and predictability due to China's anticipated entry into the WTO.

    China has been trying to join the global trade body for 15 years. Its entry is expected to fuel much greater trade between its massive internal markets and Western trading partners, but in recent months China's subsidies to farmers have proved a sticking point with several key nations, including the U.S..

    "When the United States accidentally destroyed China's embassy in Belgrade in the spring of '99 the negotiations that were about to resume between the two counties on the WTO accession were iced, and they remained iced until September when they resumed and led very quickly to final agreement between the two countries,” Kapp said.

    He said there was no sign yet that WTO negotiations slated for the second half of April in Geneva would be delayed.

    Frank Gong from the Bank of America said the annual vote by the United State congress on normal trading relations for China on June 3 was definitely at risk as well.

    He said the longer the standoff between the U.S. and China dragged on the worse the outcome of the vote would be.

    He said the looming issue of U.S. arms sales to Taiwan threatened to further antagonize the situation, and warned that economic and political relations between the U.S. and China could easily go into a tailspin.

    China declines U.S. search offer
    April 3, 2001
    Plane crew safe, China assures U.S.
    April 1, 2001
    U.S. Navy study 'backs Taiwan arms upgrade'
    April 1, 2001
    Beijing looks to get tough
    April 2, 2001
    Chinese jets intercept U.S. Navy plane
    April 1, 2001
    U.S.-based scholar a spy, says China
    March 28, 2001
    Taiwan critical to Bush's China policy
    March 23, 2001
    China, U.S. come in from the cold
    March 15, 2001
    Jiang blames U.S. for crash
    April 3, 2001

    USCINCPAC Homepage
    The Pentagon
    U.S. Navy
    Navy Fact File: EP-3E ORION (ARIES II) Aircraft
    U.S. Department of Defense
    Government of China (in Chinese)
    U.S. Department of State
    Embassy of the People's Republic of China in the U.S.A.
    Government Information Office, Republic of China

    Note: Pages will open in a new browser window
    External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.


    Back to the top