trump immigration plan serfaty lkl_00001920.jpg
Trump says he gets military advice from TV shows
01:59 - Source: CNN

Story highlights

Bombing Iraq's oil fields would hurt Iraq more than ISIS, says military experts.

ISIS does control some oil fields, but they are located in Syria, not Iraq.

Washington CNN  — 

Donald Trump wants to “knock the hell out of” Iraq’s oil fields in order to strike ISIS.

And then he wants to take over the oil fields and funnel the profits back to the United States, funds he would use to take care of veterans and their families.

“You take away their (ISIS’s) wealth, that you go and knock the hell out of the oil, take back the oil,” Trump said this weekend on NBC’s “Meet the Press.”

“We’re going to have so much money,” he added.

Trump said he would use ground troops to accomplish that mission.

But that strategy might do more harm than good, according to military experts who have looked at Trump’s proposal – experts that include the outgoing Army chief of staff.

“There are limits to military power,” Gen. Raymond Odierno said last week when asked about Trump’s plan. “It’s about sustainable outcome. And the problem we’ve had is, we’ve had outcomes, but they’ve been only short-term outcomes because we haven’t looked at, we haven’t properly looked at, the political and economic sides of this. It’s got to be all three that come together. And if you don’t do that, it’s not going to solve the problem.”

Bombing Iraq’s oil fields would also be a serious blow to Iraq and efforts to recover once ISIS is expelled from the country.

“You’re destroying the infrastructure of Iraq, you’re not really doing much to hurt ISIS,” retired Lt. Col. Rick Francona said. “At some future point those oil fields will have to help regenerate Iraq.”

The United States did strike oil fields in Kuwait during Operation Desert Storm in the 1990s, which hurt Kuwait for years after the war.

While Trump suggested that he would then send in Exxon or another oil company to quickly rebuild the infrastructure once the conflict is over, Francona and Lt. Gen. Mark Hertling, another CNN military analyst, said rebuilding infrastructure is easier said than done – especially when other surrounding infrastructure has been damaged in the process.

“We’ve made some huge mistakes in terms of just bombing things we think can just bring a nation to its knees,” Hertling said. “It’s not the people you’re going against and yet those are the ones you’re going against the most when you’re talking about indiscriminate carpet-bombing.”

FAA renames ‘Trump’ navigation points

Trump has previously said that “there is no Iraq” because of longstanding Sunni vs. Shia divides in the country that have come to the fore amid ISIS’s advance.

Hertling said that’s just not true and that “there most definitely is an Iraq” despite political and ethnic divisions.

Hertling points out that he’s remained apolitical throughout his military career but said Trump’s comments are “just troubling.”

“You have to understand the issues a little bit better than just bombing things,” Hertling said. “This is very complex and there are hundreds of thousands of Iraqis who believe they do have a country.”

Both Francona and Hertling said there are many better ways to hurt ISIS than striking oil fields in Iraq – few of which ISIS actually controls.

A large part of ISIS’s revenue has come from oil sales, but the terrorist group is mostly pumping oil out of refineries in Syria, not Iraq.

And even in Syria, the U.S. military and coalition partners have showed restraint in not bombing oil fields in Syria, though the U.S. did strike mobile refineries in ISIS hands there – not as crippling in the long-term than a blanket bombing of oil fields.

While the Iraqi government is seriously reliant on the United States and other countries in its fight against ISIS and as it strives to keep its country together, Iraq’s top leaders would do more than just object to U.S. bombing of oil fields in its country – a central part of the country’s economy and infrastructure.

CNN’s Barbara Starr contributed to this report.