Thai junta urged to drop criminal defamation case against journalists

Phuketwan journalist Chutima Sidasathian and editor Alan Morison speak to reporters in Phuket, Thailand before appearing in court.

Story highlights

  • Hearings have concluded in the trial of two Thai-based journalists on criminal defamation charges
  • They're on trial for reporting on the alleged involvement of Thai naval forces in human trafficking
  • They will hear the verdict, which could be up to seven years in jail, on September 1

Bangkok (CNN)Proceedings have ended in the controversial trial of two Thailand-based journalists facing criminal defamation charges for reporting on the alleged involvement of Thai naval forces in human trafficking.

The charges against Alan Morison, the 67-year-old Australian editor of independent Thai news website Phuketwan, and reporter Chutima Sidasathian, a Thai citizen, could earn them seven years in jail -- two years on criminal defamation charges and five years for breaching the Computer Crimes Act.
    The judge's verdict in the case, heard in a Phuket court, will be delivered on September 1.
    The charges relate to a Phuketwan article published in July 2013.
    The story included a 41-word paragraph from a Reuters investigative article alleging that "Thai naval forces" had profited from involvement in the smuggling of ethnic Rohingya from neighboring Myanmar.
    No-one from Reuters, which won a Pulitzer Prize for the series of reports on Rohingya that the article featured in, was charged over the original story.
    "We are confident," that the court will vindicate them, Morison told CNN at the end of Thursday's hearing.
    He said the Royal Thai Navy should have responded to the allegations by launching an investigation inside its own organization, rather than pursuing a case against journalists.

    'Threat to democratic society'

    The case has been slammed by press freedom organizations and human rights groups, including the U.N.'s Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.
    Eight international rights groups signed an open letter to Thai Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha calling on him to drop the charges, claiming that the case constituted a threat to the "bedrock of Thailand's democratic society."
    "The fact that these two journalists are even on trial is a scathing indictment of the Thai government's unwillingness to respect media freedom and clear indicator of how far and fast the environment for free expression has deteriorated under military rule," Human Rights Watch's Asia division deputy director Phil Robertson said in a statement.

    Article 'in public interest'

    Chutima told CNN that she and Morison had testified in court on Wednesday, defending the use of the paragraph that had prompted the charges.
    "We explained to them that the term 'Thai naval forces' doesn't mean the Royal Thai Navy, but it means any forces with capability or resources to work in water or at sea," she said.
    An English linguistic expert gave further evidence for the defense in support of their argument, she said Thursday.
    A second witness, with expertise on the Computer Crimes Act, also testified in their defense Thursday, arguing that the law was intended to prevent crimes such as hacking or credit card skimming, but had been abused.
    Chutima told the court that, in writing the article, she and Morison had been simply doing their jobs and acting in the public interest.
    The apartheid you've never heard of
    The apartheid you've never heard of


      The apartheid you've never heard of


    The apartheid you've never heard of 02:38
    Phuketwan has halted its reporting for duration of the trial.
    A statement on the website says: "Our reporting on vital matters about Phuket and Thailand will halt for the trial of two journalists on July 14-16 and may not resume. Phuketwan's future is uncertain because of a highly controversial criminal defamation action."

    Migrant crisis

    The persecution of the stateless Rohingya Muslim minority in Myanmar has fueled a migrant crisis in Southeast Asia, as tens of thousands have been driven into the hands of traffickers in their attempts to flee.
    Migrants remain stranded at sea
    lok mohsin thai rohingya boat refugees_00001828


      Migrants remain stranded at sea


    Migrants remain stranded at sea 02:21
    In May, dozens of graves and a number of secret detention camps were found in trafficking hotspots around the Thai-Malaysian border.
    The ensuring Thai crackdown saw trafficking networks abandon their human cargo at sea, leaving thousands of vulnerable migrants on rickety wooden boats ping-ponging between different countries as they attempted to make landfall.
    The crackdown led to dozens of arrests, including of a senior army officer in the region, Lieutenant General Manas Kongpan, on human trafficking charges.

    Media clampdown

    Thailand's military junta, which toppled the government of Yingluck Shinawatra in a coup last year, has introduced strict controls on media, amid a clampdown on civil liberties.
    Thai PM: I have never been against democracy
    pkg stevens thailand prime minister democracy_00012325


      Thai PM: I have never been against democracy


    Thai PM: I have never been against democracy 03:39
    Prayuth has repeatedly griped publicly about journalists, and was slammed for an offhand comment at a press conference in March that he would "probably just execute" any reporters who stepped out of line.
    Benjamin Ismail, head of the Asia-Pacific desk for Reporters Without Borders, called on the Thai government "to end their policy of harassing the media."
    "The trial of these two journalists, who just did their job as news providers with a great deal of professionalism, poses a great danger to all those independent voices in Thailand who want to use their freedom of expression and information," he said in a statement.