One out of every 250 Americans visited the ER due to a drug reaction each year during 2013-14, estimates the CDC
Anticoagulants, antibiotics, diabetes drugs, opioids and antipsychotics are the most common culprits
We are a nation of prescription drug users. In any given month, half the population – an estimated 48% – take at least one pharmaceutical medicine.
One possible downside to what are often helpful medications is made clear in a study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, published Tuesday in the Journal of the American Medical Association.
One out of every 250 Americans visited the emergency room because of a drug reaction each year in 2013 and 2014, researchers estimated.
This is an increase from 2005 and 2006, the last time drug reactions were studied.
Estimates for children, teens and young adults remained the same. However, elderly Americans ended up in the ER at a higher rate during 2013 and 2014 than in the past, even when taking into account different population numbers during the two periods.
About 35% of ER visits due to drug reactions occurred among adults 65 or older between 2013 and 2014, compared with just 26% during 2005 and 2006, the CDC estimates.
Anticoagulants (blood-thinners for preventing blood clots), antibiotics (for infections), diabetes medicines, opioids (pain medications) and antipsychotics are the most common culprits, according to Nadine Shehab, a senior scientist in the CDC’s Division of Healthcare Quality Promotion, and her co-authors.
“The finding that the same drugs identified a decade ago continue to be common causes of emergency department visits for adverse drug events indicates that safety interventions should be focused on these drugs,” Dr. Daniel Budnitz, the senior author of the paper and director of the CDC’s Medication Safety Program, wrote in an email.
Hemorrhages and severe allergic reactions
The researchers looked into the reasons for emergency room visits in the United States during the 2013-14 period. Specifically, the team focused on drug reactions, including prescription medications, over-the-counter medications, dietary supplements and vaccines.
After analyzing data from 58 emergency rooms, they estimated how frequently the problem occurred on a national level and then compared that data to their estimates for the 2005-06 period.
Based on 42,585 cases, the team estimates that four out of every 1,000 people in the United States went to emergency rooms each year because of a drug reaction during the 2013-14 period. More than a quarter (27%) of these patients had to be hospitalized.
Overall, the estimates indicate that blood thinners, antibiotics and diabetes drugs led to just less than half of the total ER visits.
Among young children (5 or younger), antibiotics were the most common drug class leading to an ER visit: 56% of the total. Among older children and teens, antibiotics were the most common cause of an ER visit (32% of the total), followed by antipsychotics (nearly 5%).
Slightly more than a third of all ER visits for drug interactions were by the elderly during the study period – a nearly 10% increase since the last study. Older adults also experienced the highest hospitalization rates.
Patients experienced hemorrhages (from anticoagulants), severe allergic reactions (from antibiotics) and hypoglycemia with neurological effects (from diabetes drugs).
Budnitz explained that past studies have found about 30% of outpatient antibiotics are prescribed unnecessarily. The way to minimize the risk of a severe allergic reaction is simply to not prescribe antibiotics “unless they are really needed.”
By comparison, diabetes drugs and blood thinners are lifesaving drugs for those who require them. The risk with these drugs is incorrect dosing, so doctors need to carefully oversee and manage patients taking these drugs.
“This is not a surprise, as overall medication usage has increased on a per-patient basis and the population is aging,” wrote Timothy P. Ryan, founder of Sano Informed Prescribing, a health care technology company. Ryan said the data in the new study “are a microcosm of a much larger medication issue.”
“Patients are often cared for by multiple physicians, each having an incomplete view of the patient’s drug use,” he said.
The authors of an editorial accompanying the article agree.
“In this fragmented health care system, clinicians often hesitate to discontinue medications because of lack of familiarity with the medication or patient,” wrote Drs. Chad Kessler, Michael J. Ward and Candace D. McNaughton. They add that even when doctors are familiar with patients, it is difficult to coordinate medications for multiple conditions (for example, one patient has both heart problems and chronic kidney disease).
Kessler, of Durham VA Medical Center in North Carolina, and Ward and McNaughton, both of Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Tennessee, were not affiliated with the original research.
Join the conversation
In a study published last year in PLOS One, Ryan and his co-authors found an increasing number of patients who were prescribed multiple medications simultaneously. Additionally, they found that some patients were taking medications without their doctors’ knowledge, and among these patients, some were combining drugs that are dangerous when used together.
Why do Americans need to be aware of this issue?
It’s a “largely unrecognized health issue,” Ryan said. “Americans are increasingly overmedicated.”
He added that “fixing the system” will require changes in both the health care system and its patients.