Khalid Jone is – in theory – one of the lucky ones. He fled bloodshed in Sudan after his family was killed in bomb attacks, and made it to safety in the Netherlands.
“You’re not looking for work, or to start a new life. You’re just saying, ‘I want to save myself,’” he says, remembering his desperation.
But instead Jone found himself trapped in limbo. He is one of hundreds of refugees whose requests for asylum have been rejected by Dutch authorities; unable to return home, they are also blocked from work or study.
“The biggest mistake I made in my life was to demand asylum in the Netherlands,” he says.
As the Dutch prepare to vote in a general election where the far-right, anti-immigrant politician Geert Wilders and his Party for Freedom (PVV) are expected to poll strongly, Jone says he fears the status quo more than a Wilders win.
“I’m not afraid of Wilders, I’m afraid of those who are running the system now,” he says.
“If Wilders becomes [Prime Minister], I don’t know how he’s going to run his government. But I know these people, I was with them already for 16 years — 16 years I’ve been fighting, just for little rights.”
Jone is part of a collective called We Are Here (WAH), founded in 2012 after a number of asylum seekers had their applications rejected simultaneously. With nowhere to go they squat in unoccupied buildings in Amsterdam – partly for shelter, and partly to make themselves noticed.
The group’s over 200 members come largely from war-torn African and Middle-Eastern countries, and are stuck in what human rights groups say is an “asylum gap,” legally barred from integrating into Dutch life via jobs or training courses.
“If you want to be active to fight for your rights, first you need shelter over your head,” says Jone. “When you have a place to sleep, you can relax and … it can help you think about what you want to do.”
Over the past four and half years the group has taken over approximately 30 empty buildings across the city for varying intervals, staying until they are evicted, and then moving on to the next site.
Jelle Klaas, a prominent Dutch human rights lawyer, says the Netherlands generally has a good track record on human rights issues, but that the current government has been criticized by the UN’s Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, which voiced its concern over an “increase in hostility towards refugees and asylum-seekers” in the country.
Human Rights Watch has also raised “serious concerns” over the Netherlands’ “extensive use of detention for migrants and asylum-seekers, lack of safeguards in the asylum appeals procedure, and the lack of support for rejected asylum seekers who cannot be returned to their countries of origin.”
“I think it’s the most important problem that the Netherlands is facing,” says Klaas, who says the government is working with “the fiction” that asylum seekers can leave “even though they know that’s not true.”
A spokeswoman for the Netherlands’ Immigration and Naturalization Department, Yvonne Wiggers, told CNN that when an asylum seeker’s application is rejected “they go back home.”
Wiggers says cases are reviewed individually, but if the system determines that asylum is not an option, then “the conclusion is that they need to leave Holland and go back to their own country.”
For asylum seekers in WAH who have been rejected, she said the options are limited: “That’s not to say they don’t get any shelter, because of course there are citizens in Holland and churches and all kinds of people who help these people, but from a government side, they can’t claim shelter anymore.”
The decision about whether to provide shelter to asylum seekers whose claims have been rejected is largely up to local municipalities, and varies widely in practice.
The current government’s view of outsiders was reflected in an open letter recently published by Prime Minister Mark Rutte – whose conservative VVD party is neck and neck with Wilders in a recent poll of polls conducted by Leiden University. In it, he tells immigrants, “If you so fundamentally reject this country, then I’d prefer you to leave.”
Klaas describes the letter as “horrible,” adding “if you look at the rhetoric not only from [Rutte’s VVD party] but a lot of the political parties, they want to get these votes from Wilders, so they’re also shifting to the right.”
Wilders has referred to male asylum-seekers as “testosterone bombs,” and insisted that the Netherlands should “close our borders for all asylum-seekers and all immigrants from Islamic countries.” Male asylum-seekers already in the country should be locked up, he says.
Members of WAH told CNN they’ve noticed an anti-refugee, anti-immigrant tone in many aspects of their life in the Netherlands.
“When you come here they try to intimidate you,” says Eric Bimule. “You’re telling your story and they’re saying, ‘You’re lying, it’s not true.’ That’s hard. How can you tell me my story’s not true? It’s my story. I’ve lived this story.”
Bimule says he was flown out of the Democratic Republic of Congo aged 16 by his mother, a Dutch national, after the Congolese militia repeatedly tried to recruit him as a child soldier.
Eleven years on, he says he no longer believes in the asylum process.
Even for refugees whose applications are successful, there can be difficulties.
Somali refugee and WAH advocate Bushra Hussein’s asylum request was recently granted and she is now living in the Netherlands on a temporary residency permit, which allows her to study. She says she wanted to become a doctor, but the years spent waiting for asylum have limited her options. Instead, she’s studying to be a nurse.
But even while helping people, she says she’s subject to racism. During work experience at a nursing home, one elderly man told her she doesn’t belong in the country as a Muslim.
Despite this, Hussein still hopes to be able to integrate into life in the Netherlands.
“In the younger generation, most of them, they don’t care about religion,” she says. “I hope [they] can bring change to the country.”
Many WAH members who are still waiting for documents don’t share her optimism.
Tegisti Taklo fled Eritrea over fears of military conscription and religious persecution as a Christian. Having left her mother and young son behind, she says she has more problems as an undocumented refugee in the Netherlands than she did at home.