A year’s worth of tariffs have given a shot in the arm to the US steel industry — but not for their shareholders.
Although the nation’s steelmakers have benefited from reduced competition, their stocks have plummeted in the year since the Trump administration first signaled that tariffs were coming.
The stocks’ march lower will probably continue. Analysts have been cutting their price targets and recommendations on steel stocks this month, even before the Trump administration announced Friday that it would lift the tariffs against steel imports from Canada and Mexico, two major sources for imported steel.
Despite the tariffs, American steel companies’ stock prices have tumbled for complex reasons.
Only a short-term gain
The tariffs provided some positives for the industry, such as a drop in low-priced imports and increased profits.
Steel customers worried about how much the tariffs would hurt their supply, so they went on a buying binge early in 2018. That drove up prices.
But last year’s large rise in steel prices proved to be short-lived. The supply problems never actually took place. Customers started working off their stockpiles, which cut into overall purchases.
Slowdowns in the auto, energy and construction sector also hurt demand.
Flooding the zone with steel
The price spike early last year prompted steelmakers to increase output. Steel mills reopened, adding about 9,000 jobs to the industry. Existing mills also increased their output.
Production from domestic steel mills rose by 1 million tons in the first quarter of this year compared to the same period last year, before the tariffs took effect, according to the American Iron and Steel Institute, the industry trade group.
But they made way too much steel. The increased production far outpaced the drop in steel imports, which fell by only a half-million tons in the first quarter.
Prices for rolls of sheets of steel, a higher-priced product used in autos and appliances, has fallen 25% since it peaked at $925 a ton last July, according to UBS.
“We observe that supply exceeded demand … over the last six months,” said UBS analyst Andreas Bokkenheuser in a note to clients. “This explains the corresponding 25% price correction.”
Spending money in the wrong places
More domestic capacity could be on the way. American steelmakers