Brazil's top court backs special protection for indigenous communities, but won't set timeline for exit of outsiders

A member of the Yanomami community gets medical attention on July 1, 2020 in Roraima, Brazil.

(CNN)Brazil's Supreme Court on Wednesday handed a partial victory to the nation's embattled indigenous communities, who are struggling against an insidious new enemy: the Covid-19 virus.

The court affirmed an earlier court decision that required the federal government to implement safety measures to contain the spread of the coronavirus, which has swept through the many remote communities with deadly effect.
"It was a great victory," said Dinaman Tuxa, executive-coordinator of APIB, an indigenous group that brought the lawsuit against the government along with six political parties, describing the ruling as a historic reparation for injustices against indigenous people even before the pandemic.
    "If it wasn't for [the court], this demand would be still in the drawers of the Executive and the Legislative," he said.
      But the indigenous groups' main demand was rejected: A deadline for all outsiders -- including miners, developers and the military -- to leave their lands.

      Hard-hit communities

      Brazil's indigenous communities have been hammered by Covid-19. By early August, more than 22,000 indigenous people had been diagnosed with the coronavirus, and least 631 had died from it, according to APIB. But due to limited testing, the real toll could be higher.
        In a tragic coincidence, a prominent indigenous leader Chief Aritana Yawalapiti of the Upper Xingu territory died of the virus on the day of the ruling, according to his nephew Kaiulu Yawalapiti. "My heart is in pieces, bleeding," Yawalapiti told CNN.
        The chief, 71, was admitted to ICU on July 22 after suffering from severe breathing problems. His son, Tapi Yawalapiti, told CNN that same day that the Upper Xingu lacked medical supplies, testing kits, and medical assistance to fight the Covid-19 pandemic.
        "Covid-19 spreads very fast, the whole community is sick, children, the young, the elderly. We are being neglected by the Brazilian government, they are not helping us enough and it seems that they want to decimate us," he said.
        Dinaman Tuxa of APIB said Yawalapiti's death meant much more than the loss of a singular life. "Those elderly are the keepers of knowledge, languages, traditions, festivities, rituals," he said. "We are losing much more than people, we are losing our culture, our nation."
        Some 800,000 indigenous people live in villages throughout Brazil. As the pandemic has spread, many of the communities have echoed Yawalapiti's complaint about government neglect.
        As the coronavirus spread through Brazil this year, the country's health ministry and local governments did install indigenous wards in hospitals throughout the Amazon. In conjunction with the defense ministry, they also sent medical equipment, supplies and personnel to military hospitals in remote areas such as São Gabriel da Cachoeira, Tabatinga, and Javari Valley.
        But some key initiatives to protect indigenous Brazilians have been stymied at the very highest levels of government.
        On July 8, President Jair Bolsonaro vetoed parts of an emergency bill that would have assured access to drinking water, free distribution of hygiene products and the distribution of cleaning and disinfection materials to indigenous communities, citing the cost. He also vetoed a proposal ensuring mandatory emergency funds for indigenous people's healthcare and has argued that legislating mandatory expenditures does not "account for the respective budgetary and financial impact, which would be unconstitutional."
        The vetoes fit into a larger pattern for the pro-business, right-wing leader, who has a historically antagonistic relationship with indigenous Brazilians. Many rights activists have protested the increase of illegal mining and logging on their lands which followed Bolsonaro's rise to power.
        The judge who wrote the July 8 ruling that was affirmed Wednesday by the Supreme Court cited Bolsonaro's remarks in his decision. "It is also worth noting that there has been a large government resistance to the realization of rights indigenous peoples' rights," Justice Luis Roberto Barroso wrote, citing media reports quoting Bolsonaro's support for development, including "indigenous reserves make the Amazon unfeasible."
        Indigenous people in Brazil often live in communities which are far from hospitals, in areas which often lack basic infrastructure. Those who move to towns or cities can end up in precarious living conditions with few public services, increasing their vulnerability to health issues.
        A study conducted in May and June reported that indigenous people are five times more likely to contract the coronavirus compared with the country's white population.
        The study by Pelotas Federal University found that indigenous Brazilians' vulnerability remains higher than that of white Brazilians, even within the same socioeconomic status and with the same number of residents in the home.
        "The interpretation of these analyses suggests that indigenous subjects were at substantially higher risk than other ethnic groups," the study said.
        Overall, Brazil is second only to the United States in terms of coronavirus cases, according to the Johns Hopkins University tracker. As of Saturday morning, it had reported nearly 3 million cases with fatalities inching toward 100,000 people.