Major coding error responsible for Dem app problem
From CNN's Mark Preston
A Democratic source tells CNN that the issue seems to lie with a major coding error in the app that was discovered once data started flowing into the IDP and party officials began to see discrepancies in the three data streams as the results started coming.
The source said it took time for party officials to identify and address the issue and noted there was not a problem with the raw data being put in by the individual precincts.
The national party is trying to help Iowa resolve it.
11:13 a.m. ET, February 4, 2020
The Buttigieg campaign has used the same company that developed the app in Iowa
Pete Buttigieg's campaign said they have used Shadow Inc. — the same app company that developed the app in Iowa that caused the reporting area.
A Buttigieg campaign aide said they "have contracted with this vendor in the past for text messaging services to help us contact voters. Totally unrelated to any apps they built for the party.”
Sen. Bernie Sanders' campaign sent an email to supporters asking for donations following the confusion in Iowa.
Here's a portion of the email:
"Like you, we are disappointed with what happened last night in Iowa.
But while we wait for the results, we cannot lose focus of the fact that New Hampshire’s primary, the first in the nation, is just seven days away.
And we have to be ready, and Bernie cannot do that alone.
Can you make a $2.70 contribution to our campaign today? There is no more important day to make your first donation to our campaign.
We will be in touch as soon as we learn more."
10:38 a.m. ET, February 4, 2020
A delegate tie between Sanders and Buttigieg was decided by a coin flip
From CNN's Paul P. Murphy
The official results may not be ready just yet. But at one precinct in Des Moines, Iowa, an apparent delegate tie between Sen. Bernie Sanders and Pete Buttigieg was decided by a coin flip.
Jaylen Cavil said he took this video of the coin flip at precinct 80:
10:43 a.m. ET, February 4, 2020
The Warren campaign will provide photos and other data to Iowa Democratic Party
Sen. Elizabeth Warren's campaign manager Roger Lau said they will provide photographs and "other raw documentation of the results" to the Iowa Democratic Party "to help ensure the integrity of their process."
He said the campaign collected data from "hundreds of caucus locations."
10:26 a.m. ET, February 4, 2020
Deval Patrick takes a shot at fellow Democratic candidates
Democratic presidential candidate Deval Patrick took a shot at his fellow candidates, in the face of uncertainty over the results of the Iowa caucuses.
“One candidate is calling the results into question because he apparently didn’t do well. Another is declaring victory without any votes being confirmed. The way to beat Donald Trump isn’t to act like Donald Trump. Our party and our country deserve better," he said in a statement.
Meanwhile, Democratic presidential campaigns remained in the dark this morning over when and how many results of the Iowa caucuses will be released, two officials tell CNN. Without knowing who won the first contest of the 2020 race, many candidates departed Iowa and traveled to New Hampshire, where the state's primary will be held next week.
10:05 a.m. ET, February 4, 2020
Iowa Democrats will huddle again with campaigns to go over caucus results
From CNN's Jeff Zeleny
Iowa Democratic Chairman Troy Price is holding another conference call this morning with representatives of the Democratic presidential campaigns. Until now, campaigns have told CNN that they’ve been in the dark.
Price released a statement this morning, explaining the inconsistencies in the reports.
"Because of the required paper documentation, we have been able to verify that the data recorded in the app and used to calculate State Delegate Equivalents is valid and accurate. Precinct level results are still being reported to the IDP. While our plan is to release results as soon as possible today, our ultimate goal is to ensure that the integrity and accuracy of the process continues to be upheld," Price said.
10:44 a.m. ET, February 4, 2020
Iowa Democratic officials woke her up to get results
From CNN's Jeff Zeleny
Linda Nelson, a Democratic caucus chair in Pottawattamie County, was among the first to publicly sound the alarm yesterday about concerns with the app used to count Iowa caucus results.
When CNN talked to her on Monday afternoon, she said she kept getting an error message when she entered her PIN. Nelson said she planned to do it the old-fashioned way — by calling in her results.
That turned out to be impossible, as the phone lines were jammed. Nelson texted a picture of her Caucus Math Sheet to Troy Price, chairman of the Iowa Democratic Party, and went to bed.
Nelson said she got a call from the Iowa Democratic Party at 1:23 a.m., and she shared the totals with them after "both alignments and delegate distribution."
"They are probably still making calls," she said via text.
Indeed they are. A senior Democratic official tells CNN they estimate that about 250 precincts are still outstanding.
Nelson shared this photo of the Caucus Math Sheet, which shows Amy Klobuchar carried her precinct, winning four delegates, followed by Joe Biden with three, Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren each with two:
9:48 a.m. ET, February 4, 2020
Senior Iowa Dem says the "goal today is clarity and getting to results"
From CNN's Dan Merica
A senior Iowa Democratic tells CNN that while the “goal today is clarity and getting to results,” the source was unable to commit that all results will be released today.
The party will hold another call with campaigns later this morning, the Democrat said, and right now the party is wholly focused on “working towards today” for getting results out.
The Democrats described a chaotic and tense situation inside the Iowa Democratic Party’s boiler room at the Iowa Events Center on last night and this morning, with top party officials making the “strategic decision not to release any data that has any questions.”
“There was not going to be a good choice here and to buckle under the pressure to kick something out last night that was wrong would have been much worse,” the Iowa Democrat said.