May 31, 2023 House passes US debt ceiling bill

foreman debt ceiling
What each party gave up and gained in the debt ceiling deal
02:48 - Source: CNN

What we covered here

  • The House of Representatives passed a bill Wednesday night to suspend the nation’s debt limit through January 1, 2025. The final vote tally was 314-117 with 71 Republicans and 46 Democrats voting against the bill.
  • Next: The timeframe to avoid an unprecedented debt default is extremely tight. The legislation will now need to be passed by the Senate before it can be sent to President Joe Biden to be signed into law.
  • What’s in the bill: In addition to suspending the debt limit through the 2024 election, the bill caps non-defense spending, expands work requirements for some food stamp recipients and claws back some Covid-19 relief funds. Read more about it here.

Our live coverage has ended. Read more about the debt ceiling talks here or read through the posts below.

39 Posts

McCarthy takes victory lap after debt limit passage: “One of the best nights since I’ve been here”

House Speaker Kevin McCarthy reacts during a press conference at the Capitol on Wednesday night.

House Speaker Kevin McCarthy took a victory lap immediately after the House passed the debt limit deal with a big bipartisan showing. 

The speaker thanked his negotiating team, Reps. Garret Graves and Patrick McHenry, saying: “They’ve given their time and talents in this effort for more than a month.”

When pressed on his relationship with President Joe Biden after this process, he lamented that “he hasn’t invited me to dinner or lunch yet, so.” 

McHenry said it was an honor to be part of the team. Graves said many believed this would be a dysfunctional Congress, but instead the speaker was making this a “transformational Congress.” 

Biden called McCarthy and other congressional leaders after vote, White House says

President Joe Biden called House Speaker Kevin McCarthy and other congressional leaders Wednesday night after the debt ceiling bill cleared the House, a White House official said.

Biden called McCarthy, Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, Minority Whip Katherine Clark and House Democratic Caucus Chairman Pete Aguilar, the official said.

Biden watched the vote with staff from Colorado Springs. Counselor Steve Ricchetti and Legislative Affairs Director Louisa Terrell, two of the White House negotiators, joined by phone as votes were being cast.

Ricchetti, Terrell and other legislative staff held a watch party in the West Wing, for which Ricchetti provided pizza.

Republican who voted against debt limit deal says she still trusts McCarthy

Rep. Nancy Mace said that she still trusts House Speaker Kevin McCarthy, despite her frustrations with and opposition to the debt limit deal that passed the House on Wednesday night.

“I do. I disagree with him vehemently on this thing tonight, but we can agree to disagree on a lot of things,” she said. 

Mace defended her vote against the bill, despite 149 of her Republican colleagues supporting it.

Conservatives in the House will discuss ousting McCarthy from the speakership, Rep. Ken Buck says

House Speaker Kevin McCarthy pauses during a news conference at the Capitol on Wednesday night.

Rep. Ken Buck told CNN after the debt limit deal passed the House that conservatives will be having discussions about ousting Speaker Kevin McCarthy “in the next week or two,” although he didn’t commit to following through with that threat.

“The discussion about the motion to vacate is going to happen in the next week or two,” Buck, who opposed the debt limit deal, told reporters Wednesday.

Buck added that he has received calls from constituents about removing McCarthy from the speakership.

“My constituents are furious and you know what’s so interesting about the calls in the district? They are not only ‘vote against this bill,’ but they are ‘take McCarthy out.’ That’s what the calls are coming in,” he said.

Buck emphasized more Democrats voted for the bill in the House than Republicans.

However, pressed on his position on ousting McCarthy, he would not commit to attempting to do so at this point.

“My position is we’re gonna have a discussion. Remember, you got that on there? And I — we are going to have a discussion starting next week,” Buck said.

Asked by CNN if he would trust McCarthy to get them through the appropriations process, as conservative Rep. Ralph Norman suggested, Buck replied: “You trust him for appropriations? Because here’s what happens – no.”

Biden praises House for passing debt limit deal and urges Senate to “pass it as quickly as possible”

President Joe Biden praised the House for passing the bipartisan debt limit deal Wednesday night, and urged the Senate to “pass it as quickly as possible” so he can sign it into law.

Trump on the debt ceiling deal: “I would’ve taken the default if you had to”

Former President Donald Trump weighed in Wednesday for the first time on the debt ceiling deal reached by President Joe Biden and House Speaker Kevin McCarthy.

Trump said he would have liked to see “a lot of things” happen, but acknowledged the deal “was a good opportunity.”

“It is passed, and I guess I knew it was going to pass,” he said.

Lawmakers are now racing to approve the deal to avert a catastrophic default ahead of the expected June 5 deadline. The deal suspends the nation’s debt limit through January 1, 2025, caps non-defense spending, expands work requirements for some food stamp recipients and claws back some Covid-19 relief funds.

JUST IN: House passes debt limit bill

The House has passed the debt limit deal to suspend the nation’s debt ceiling through January 1, 2025. 

The final tally for the vote was 314 to 117. 

A total of 149 Republicans and 165 Democrats voted for the bill, while 71 Republicans and 46 Democrats voted against the bill.  

The bill will next need to be passed by the Senate before it can be sent to President Joe Biden to be signed into law. It’s not yet clear when the Senate will vote. 

NOW: Vote on the debt limit bill is underway

Members of the House of Representatives are now voting on the final passage of the debt limit bill.

The bill is expected to pass. It needs a simple majority – 218 – to pass.

The current CNN whip count has at least 56 votes against the bill – 13 Democrats and 43 Republicans. 

Speaker Kevin McCarthy told CNN earlier Wednesday that he is confident the debt limit deal will pass with a majority of House Republicans’ support, a critical threshold that GOP leaders have been feverishly working to secure over the last several days. 

McCarthy defends debt limit deal on floor ahead of House vote

Speaker Kevin McCarthy defended the debt limit deal from conservative criticism during a speech on the floor while the House debated. 

He said if he voted no on the agreement because of what it lacked, he “would never vote yes.” His comments come after conservatives in his conference have claimed the bill does not go far enough to cut spending.

McCarthy touted the bill’s provisions on work requirements, clawing back COVID funding and rescinding funding for the IRS.

He also previewed the appropriations fights to come.

Senate leaders want vote on debt ceiling bill as soon as Thursday. Here's what would need to happen

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and Republican Leader Mitch McConnell have made it clear they want to move ahead with a vote on the debt agreement bill as early as Thursday – but would need an agreement from all 100 senators to do so.  

If the House passes the legislation Wednesday evening, Schumer would take a procedural step to bypass committee and bring the bill straight to the floor. In order to meet the deadline, however, senators will need to find a time agreement, which both sides are optimistic can happen. 

How quickly is the question.

All 100 senators must agree on a timeline before the vote can begin. Otherwise, any single senator can hold up the vote. 

McConnell said Wednesday he hopes that the Senate can be done voting before the weekend if the House passes the bill Wednesday evening.

Amendments: Senators will be allowed to offer amendments to the bill. However, Schumer said Wednesday he does not want to have to send the bill back to the House — meaning that no amendment can actually pass. 

Amendments will be offered by senators from both sides of the aisle, but all 100 members must agree to schedule a vote on an amendment.  

The bill is expected to get more than 60 votes and overcome a filibuster attempt. 

Opposition: Several Republicans and a handful of Democrats have already said they will oppose the bill. A number of senators from both parties also told CNN they are still reviewing it. 

Some Senate Republicans said they are concerned about the defense number being too low. That was an issue that was raised Sunday night on a private conference call by Mississippi Republican Sen. Roger Wicker and Maine Republican Sen. Susan Collins. 

Sen. Bernie Sanders, an independent who caucuses with Democrats, is a “no.” Democratic Sen. Jeff Merkley is also opposed.  

At least one Republican senator is leaning toward voting against debt ceiling bill

Sen. Roger Wicker, right, listens during the Senate Armed Services hearing on May 4, in Washington, DC.

Sen. Roger Wicker, the top Republican on Senate Armed Services Committee, is leaning against voting for the debt ceiling bill out of concern that the spending on defense is too low. 

“Probably not,” he told CNN when asked if he’d back the package. 

Wicker is a close ally of Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell. 

Asked about the timing of the vote, Wicker said he’s never sure with the Senate. 

GOP Sen. Lindsey Graham has shared similar concerns and has called for changes to that defense number. Graham could get an amendment, but it can’t pass or the entire bill would have to go back through the House again, blowing the deadline.

Lawmaker defends himself and other Democrats who crossed aisle to support debt limit vote rule

Rep. Josh Gottheimer defended his decision and that of other Democratic members who voted for the debt limit rule vote.  

Traditionally, the minority party does not vote for the rule, and there was drama on the House floor as Democrats held back at first while 29 Republicans voted against the rule. Ultimately, it was approved, thanks to support from 52 Democrats.

Asked how Democrats came to the decision to vote for the rule, Gottheimer pointed to House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries.

“Our leader is the one in charge in terms of making sure that we are doing everything we can to get this across the finish line,” he said.

Jeffries says House Democrats bailed out the GOP "from their own extremism"

House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries speaks at a news conference on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC, on Wednesday.

House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries would not answer directly when asked if Democrats extracted any concessions when they bailed out the GOP by supporting the rule covering the floor debate Wednesday afternoon that cleared the way for a vote on the debt ceiling bill tonight.

Instead, he slammed Republicans saying, “What does that say about this extreme MAGA Republican majority?”

Jeffries called it “stunning” that 29 Republicans voted against the debt ceiling debate rules.

These are the 29 Republicans who voted "no" on the debt ceiling rule

Rep. Matt Gaetz arrives to Rayburn Building on Wednesday, May 24.

The House of Representatives is on track to vote Wednesday on a bill to suspend the nation’s debt limit through January 1, 2025, as lawmakers race to prevent a catastrophic default.

Earlier Wednesday, the chamber cleared a key hurdle to advance to a final vote when it approved a rule governing floor debate for the debt limit bill.

Rules are typically supported by just the majority party and opposed by the minority. But in this case, 52 Democrats voted “yes” to get the rule across the finish line after 29 Republicans voted against it.

These are the 29 Republicans who voted “no”:

  1. Andrew Clyde
  2. Matt Gaetz
  3. Andy Biggs
  4. Chip Roy
  5. Eli Crane
  6. Bob Good
  7. Clay Higgins
  8. Josh Brecheen
  9. Paul Gosar
  10. Tim Burchett
  11. Bill Posey
  12. Ken Buck
  13. Matt Rosendale
  14. Dan Bishop
  15. Anna Pauline Luna
  16. Lauren Boebert
  17. Victoria Spartz
  18. Scott Perry
  19. Mary Miller
  20. Keith Self
  21. Diana Harshbarger
  22. Tom Tiffany 
  23. Eric Burlison
  24. Michael Cloud
  25. Barry Moore 
  26. Ben Cline
  27. Morgan Griffith
  28. Ralph Norman
  29. Andy Harris

House passes rule for debt limit debate, clearing the way for final vote on bill later tonight

The House has passed the rule governing floor debate for the debt ceiling bill.

The tally was 241 to 187, with 29 Republicans voting “no” and 52 Democrats voting “yes.” Passage of the rule clears the way for a final House vote on the debt ceiling bill this evening. 

Rules are typically supported by just the majority party and opposed by the minority, but in this case, Democrats had to cross the aisle to get the rule across the finish line.

The GOP defections exposed deep divisions within the House Republican conference.

Democratic leaders instructed their members to let Republicans put up their votes for the rule first, a source familiar with the matter told CNN.

The strategy for the Democrats: Let Republicans sweat and show how many defections GOP leaders had. 

US markets close lower as debt ceiling deal progresses through Congress

Traders work the floor of the New York Stock Exchange in New York City on May 31. 

The Dow slipped more than 100 points on Wednesday as investors kept a close eye on the progress of the debt ceiling deal in Congress.

The Dow closed down 132 points, or 0.4%. The S&P 500 was 0.6% lower. The Nasdaq Composite also lost 0.6%.

President Joe Biden and Republican House Leader Kevin McCarthy reached a spending deal over the weekend to raise the debt limit. The House is expected to vote on the bill later today.

Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell told reporters on Wednesday that he hopes the chamber will finish voting on the debt ceiling agreement tomorrow or Friday.

Still, the timeframe to get the bill passed through both chambers of Congress and signed into law is extremely tight.

Lawmakers are racing against the clock to avert a catastrophic default ahead of June 5, the day the Treasury Department has said it will no longer be able to pay all of the nation’s obligations in full and on time.

The debt ceiling deal won't have much of an impact on the economy, analysts say

Analysts say the proposed debt ceiling deal could have only marginal effects on the US economy.

That’s based on various estimates showing that government spending will be only slightly pared back over the two years of the deal, creating a small effect on overall economic output as measured by gross domestic product, including a limited number of job losses.

Despite the deal’s limited macroeconomic impact, some analysts say it could also usher in a new era of tighter fiscal policy as congressional lawmakers contend with a national deficit that ballooned during the years of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Here’s what’s in the proposed deal and how it would show up in the broader economy:

What’s in the deal? The deal would suspend the federal government’s $31.4 trillion debt limit through January 2025. It would keep non-defense spending relatively flat in fiscal 2024 and then set a cap of 1% in spending increases for fiscal 2025. The US government’s fiscal year runs from October through September.

In addition to curbing spending, the deal would protect veterans’ health care benefits, temporarily broaden work requirements for certain adults receiving food assistance benefits, claw back some Covid-19 relief funds, cut funding for the Internal Revenue Service, restart student loan repayments, maintain climate measures, and expedite a natural gas pipeline in West Virginia.

The debt deal and GDP. Economists at Goldman Sachs expect the deal to reduce federal spending by as much as 0.2% of gross domestic product per year over the two years of the deal, compared with their baseline estimate.

However, Ian Shepherdson, chief economist at Pantheon Macroeconomics, said in a webinar that he expects the deal to reduce GDP growth by about 0.2% in 2024 and by a further 0.1% in 2025, which are “well within the margin of GDP measurement error.”

And Gregory Daco, EY-Parthenon’s chief economist, estimated that the proposed deal would have a 0.3% drag on real GDP in 2024 and lead to 250,000 job losses. The economy had about 161 million filled jobs in April, according to data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

At least for now, the light at the end of tunnel in the form of a debt-ceiling deal seems to have reassured financial markets.

Read more.

House now voting on rule for debt limit bill

The House of Representatives is now voting on the rule governing floor debate for the debt ceiling bill. The rule must be adopted to clear the way for a final House vote on the bill later this evening. 

Rules are typically supported by just the majority party and opposed by the minority. But in this case, Republicans are expecting as many as 20 GOP lawmakers to vote against the rule, according to a conservative lawmaker familiar with an internal whip count among the bill’s critics.

That means Democrats will have to step in to help push the rule over the finish line. 

Some Democrats have signaled they would be willing to back the rule if their votes were needed, so the rule is unlikely to be in danger of passage.

Still, having that many Republicans defecting on the rule would expose deep divisions in the GOP, which could be problematic for House Speaker Kevin McCarthy. 

"We can't send anything back to the House, plain and simple," Schumer says on debt limit deal vote

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer said that the chamber cannot send a debt ceiling bill back to the House with amendments — even though they may have to agree to votes on some amendments to get all 100 senators to agree to a timeline for the vote.  

The majority leader again emphasized the importance of getting the vote done quickly.

“We’re getting close to putting this threat of default behind us, but there’s still more work perhaps the most important work to do passing it into law. I hope the House will do its job later today and urge my colleagues in this chamber to be prepared to do the same when the time comes, and it’s coming soon,” Schumer said.

Schumer also responded to the criticism from some that Democrats could have solved the debt ceiling problem last Congress when they had control of both chambers.

“We didn’t have the votes, plain and simple,” Schumer said.

As many as 20 Republicans are expected to vote against debt ceiling bill rule, conservative lawmaker says

As many as 20 House GOP lawmakers are expected to vote against the rule for the debt ceiling bill, according to a conservative lawmaker familiar with an internal whip count among the bill’s critics.

That means Democrats will have to step in to help push the rule over the finish line, which are typically party-line votes. 

Some Democrats have signaled they would be willing to back the rule if their votes were needed, so the rule is unlikely to be in danger of passage.

Still, that many Republicans defecting would expose deep divisions in the GOP, which could be problematic for House Speaker Kevin McCarthy, who has enjoyed a surprising level of unity in his ranks since his bruising speaker’s battle.

Democratic leaders have instructed their members to let Republicans put up their votes for the rule first, a source familiar tells CNN. The strategy for the rule vote: let Republicans sweat and show how many defections GOP leaders have. 

Rep. Brendan Boyle, a Democrat from Pennsylvania, told CNN he plans to take his cues from leaders before he steps in to help Dems on the rule.

CNN’s Haley Talbot and Lauren Fox contributed reporting to this post.

READ MORE

House to vote on debt limit deal as lawmakers race to avert default
Debt limit deal clears key hurdle ahead of final House vote
US oil prices sink below $70 on debt ceiling jitters and Russia-Saudi tensions
These companies are winners in the debt ceiling deal
Obama agreed to $2.1 trillion in spending cuts to end 2011 debt ceiling crisis. Here’s what happened next.

READ MORE

House to vote on debt limit deal as lawmakers race to avert default
Debt limit deal clears key hurdle ahead of final House vote
US oil prices sink below $70 on debt ceiling jitters and Russia-Saudi tensions
These companies are winners in the debt ceiling deal
Obama agreed to $2.1 trillion in spending cuts to end 2011 debt ceiling crisis. Here’s what happened next.