The art world responds to Russian invasion of Ukraine by canceling shows and cutting ties
Published 17th March 2022
Credit: Robbie Jack/Corbis Entertainment/Corbis/Getty Images
The art world responds to Russian invasion of Ukraine by canceling shows and cutting ties
Stage curtains are closing, art exhibitions are being halted and performers are being replaced. Over the past month, major cultural players worldwide -- including some within Russia -- have reacted to the invasion of Ukraine by canceling shows and applying pressure to the country's art institutions. So far, more than 2.5 million refugees have fled Ukraine as the Kremlin continues its assault on the country's most populated cities, including the capital, Kyiv.
While much of the focus has turned to sanctions meant to cripple Russia's economy, the country's cultural influence is also being curtailed. Russia will no longer be represented at major international events like the Venice Biennale and the televised music competition, Eurovision. Artists and performers, from Iggy Pop to Franz Ferdinand, are also canceling shows in the country, while those who have expressed support for President Vladmir Putin are being shunned. In Germany, the Russian chief conductor of the Munich Philharmonic, Valery Gergiev, was fired for his refusal to condemn the war or Putin, with whom he has close ties, according to a statement from Munich's mayor Dieter Reiter.
Ukraine's minister of culture, Oleksandr Tkachenko, has joined a group of Ukrainian artists, gallery owners, actors, musicians and film directors in demanding stronger, sweeping cultural sanctions. They have signed a petition calling on international institutions to cancel cultural partnerships with the Russian Federation, sever relationships with Russian nationals sitting on advisory boards and ban Russian participation in major art events, including Art Basel and the Cannes Film Festival.
"The Russian Federation is a rogue state," reads the petition. "Russian culture, when used as propaganda, is toxic! Don't be an accomplice!"
But some are cautioning against culturally isolating all Russians over the war. Raimundas Malašauskas, who was set to curate the Russian pavilion at April's Venice Biennale, pulled out of the event, but said he doesn't want the art world to turn its back on Russian artists.
"I explicitly oppose the current assault and subjugation commanded by Russia. I also believe that people from Russia should not be bullied or cast away solely due to their country's oppressive policies and actions," he said in a statement on his website. "I want to avoid flat-falling divisions, and instead advocate for multi-leveled forms of solidarity where there are international forums for art and artists from Russia to express the freedom that they can't express at home."
Below are some of the ways that artists, cultural organizations and institutions are reacting to the war in Ukraine.
Russia will be absent from the Venice Biennale
When Malašauskas and Russian artists Alexandra Sukhareva and Kirill Savchenkov resigned from participating in the Venice Biennale, they effectively canceled the Russian Federation's representation at one of the biggest and most prestigious art gatherings in the world.
The Russian pavilion, designed by architect Alexey Shchusev, has been a permanent fixture in Venice Giardini since 1914, opening its doors every two years to showcase the work of some of the country's most important contemporary artists.
In a statement, the Biennale expressed its "complete solidarity for this noble act of courage." Savchenkov, who works in sculpture, installation and performance art, meanwhile wrote on Instagram that "there is no place for art when civilians are dying under the fire of missiles, when citizens of Ukraine are hiding in shelters and when Russian protesters are getting silenced."
The fate of the Biennale's Ukrainian pavilion was also unclear after the curators posted an official statement on Instagram on February 24 explaining that all work on the exhibition has ceased. But on March 8, they provided an update saying they would continue with the exhibition after evacuating parts of the artwork from Kyiv.
"In times like this, the representation of Ukraine at the exhibition is more important than ever. When the sheer right to existence for our culture is being challenged by Russia, it is crucial to demonstrate our achievements to the world," the curators said in the statement.
The Metropolitan Opera won't work with pro-Putin artists
The most famous opera house in the US, New York's Metropolitan Opera, announced on February 27 that it will not work with Russian artists or organizations that support President Vladimir Putin until the country's invasion of Ukraine ends.
"While we believe strongly in the warm friendship and cultural exchange that has long existed between the artists and artistic institutions of Russia and the United States, we can no longer engage with artists or institutions that support Putin or are supported by him -- not until the invasion and killing has been stopped, order has been restored and restitutions have been made," said Peter Gelb, general manager of the Metropolitan Opera, in a video message shared on Facebook.
This means that the Met will likely freeze its relationship with Moscow's Bolshoi Theater, whose coproduction of Wagner's "Lohengrin" is currently planned for next year. On March 3, the opera house announced that famed Russian soprano Anna Netrebko, who was set to play the title role in Puccini's "Turandot" at the Met later this spring, will not return for this season or the following. She has now pulled out of all scheduled performances, according to a statement from the Zurich Opera House, where she was scheduled to perform this month.
"It is a great artistic loss for the Met and for opera," Gelb said in a statement to CNN. "Anna is one of the greatest singers in Met history, but with Putin killing innocent victims in Ukraine there was no way forward."
Earlier in the week, Netrebko wrote on social media that she is "opposed to this war," but "not a political person." The Zurich Opera House described her post as a "positive development," but her inability to "distance herself further from Vladimir Putin" was incompatible with its own "decisive condemnation" of the Russian president's actions.
Russian star ballerina Olga Smirnova quits Bolshoi Ballet
One of the stars of Moscow's Bolshoi Ballet, Olga Smirnova, quit the company on March 16 over Russia's invasion of Ukraine and will instead dance for the Dutch National Ballet in Amsterdam.
Smirnova, whose grandfather is Ukrainian, wrote on Telegram that she is "against war with all the fibers of my soul."
"I never thought I would be ashamed of Russia," she wrote in the statement, which was later republished by the Dutch National Ballet. "I have always been proud of talented Russian people, of our cultural and athletic achievements. But now I feel that a line has been drawn that separates the before and the after.
"It hurts that people are dying, that people are losing the roofs over their heads or are forced to abandon their homes. And who would have thought a few weeks ago that all of this would happen? We may not be at the epicenter of the military conflict, but we cannot remain indifferent to this global catastrophe."
The Bolshoi Ballet is one of the oldest ballet companies in the world, responsible for the first ever production of "Swan Lake," among others. But its status as one of the country's greatest cultural symbols is complicated by its entanglement with the Russian government.
Smirnova joined the prestigious Bolshoi Ballet in 2011, before taking lead roles in a number of performances, including "Swan Lake" and "Giselle." She has since toured internationally with the troupe and has appeared as a guest performer for the American Ballet Theatre and the Vienna State Ballet.
In a statement published Wednesday, March 16, the Dutch National Ballet said Smirnova had been "welcomed with open arms." She is expected to make her debut there with its staging of "Raymonda," which premieres in early April.
The announcement comes a little over a week after two other Bolshoi members -- Brazilian soloist David Motta Soares and Italian principal dancer Jacopo Tissi -- both announced they were resigning.
Artists and museums cancel exhibitions in Russia
Contemporary Icelandic artist Ragnar Kjartansson, who is known for performance works and video installations that reflect the human condition, pulled his exhibition at Moscow's new GES-2 museum in February. Speaking to CNN via email, he cited the bravery of local Russian artists who have canceled their own shows in response to the war.
"I was following the(ir) example... which is way more dangerous than my cozy stand here in Iceland," he said.
Kjartansson, who in 2009 became the youngest artist to represent Iceland at the Venice Biennale, has exhibited at the Barbican in London and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. He believes that artists, curators, collectors and institutions must "consider every move" in order to "stand by" Ukraine and stand "against Putin's regime," but called for artists themselves to be protected from boycotts.
"Boycott Russian collectors who do not publicly oppose Putin... not Russian artists, (except) those very few that support Putin," he said. "Support Ukrainian artists with residencies in safe countries (and) exhibition platforms, and (do) the same for Russian artists from the opposition."
Meanwhile, the Garage Museum of Contemporary Art in Moscow, founded by Russian oligarch Roman Abramovich and Russian American art collector Dasha Zhukova, announced that it has postponed all exhibitions until the invasion of Ukraine has ended. This includes halting shows that were already underway, including the work of German artist Anne Imhof and British artist Helen Marten. "We cannot support the illusion of normality when such events are taking place," reads a statement on the museum's website.
Eurovision bars Russia from competing
On February 25, less than a day after the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) said it would allow Russia to compete in the Eurovision Song Contest, a popular televised music competition, the organization reversed course. This May, no performers representing the country will be allowed to compete, the EBU confirmed in o a statement released on Friday.
"The decision reflects concern that, in light of the unprecedented crisis in Ukraine, the inclusion of a Russian entry in this year's Contest would bring the competition into disrepute," read the statement.
Russia had yet to select an act to perform on its behalf at the annual competition, which was watched by 183 million people last year.
UK distances itself from Russian ballet
The UK's Royal Opera House (ROH) has canceled a residency by Moscow's famed Bolshoi Ballet company. The residency had been scheduled for this summer and was in the "final stages" of planning, according to a statement provided to CNN. A spokesperson for the ROH said: "Unfortunately, under the current circumstances, the season cannot now go ahead."
The company's former artistic director Alexei Ratmansky, who is now an artist-in residence at the American Ballet Theatre, had been working on a new performance for his former company in Moscow when Russia invaded Ukraine. The Russian-born choreographer, who was raised in Kyiv, has since departed for New York with his entire creative team, according to the New York Times.
"I was absolutely torn between creation, love and desperation," he told the Times of his decision to leave. Ratmansky's new ballet was supposed to open March 30, but has been postponed indefinitely.
Performances by several other Russian ballet companies have also been affected, with shows by the Russian State Ballet of Siberia pulled in the English town of Northampton and a performance of Swan Lake by the Royal Moscow Ballet called off in Dublin, Ireland.
The European Film Academy boycotts Russian films
The Ukranian Film Academy has set up a public petition calling for the international boycott of Russian cinema, including showings on the international film circuit. The European Film Academy (EFA) has responded in support, saying it will exclude Russian entries from the European Film Awards.
"The European Film Academy remains a place to support and unite all filmmakers who share our belief in human dignity, freedom, democracy, equality, rule of law, and human rights," the EFA said in a statement. "We acknowledge and appreciate those brave filmmakers in Russia who stand up against this war. But in view of a brutal and unjustified attack, we have to stand with our sisters and brothers in Ukraine whose lives are at risk."
Within the film festival circuit, however, responses have been mixed. The Stockholm International Film Festival has said it will ban films funded by the Russian government. But the Venice Film Festival and the Cannes Film Festival -- two of the most prestigious cinema gatherings -- have stopped short of excluding any Russian films or filmmakers. Instead, both festivals will bar any Russian officials or institutions from attending, as well as anyone with ties to the Kremlin.
"Unless the war of assault ends in conditions that will satisfy the Ukrainian people, it has been decided that we will not welcome official Russian delegations nor accept the presence of anyone linked to the Russian government," notes the statement from Cannes, which was posted to its website on Tuesday.
"However, we would like to salute the courage of all those in Russia who have taken risks to protest against the assault and invasion of Ukraine. Among them are artists and film professionals who have never ceased to fight against the contemporary regime, who cannot be associated with these unbearable actions, and those who are bombing Ukraine."
Russian oligarchs step down from top art institutions
Cultural institutions are under growing pressure to cut ties with Russian oligarchs. In February, British parliamentarian Chris Bryant called on UK gallery group Tate to revoke the honorary member status of Russian billionaire and Putin associate Viktor Vekselberg, reported the Guardian. A spokesperson for Tate told CNN that Vekselberg donated seven years earlier and "there is no ongoing connection," adding that there are "no UK sanctions on any of Tate's supporters." But on March 14, Artnet reported that Tate had revoked the title, and had also severed ties with Petr Aven, who heads Alfa-Bank in Russia and is sanctioned by the EU.
On March 1, the Royal Academy of Arts announced that Aven had stepped down as a trustee of the Royal Academy Trust. The arts institution said in a statement to CNN that it had also returned Aven's donation toward the "Francis Bacon: Man and Beast" exhibition, which is currently on view through mid-April.
The Guggenheim in New York has lost a benefactor as well: Trustee Vladimir Potanin has stepped down, according to the museum. The oligarch has been a longtime supporter of the museum and funded its current exhibition about Russian abstract pioneer Wassily Kandinsky, which is running until this fall.
"Vladimir Potanin has advised the Board of Trustees of his decision to step down as Trustee effective immediately. The Guggenheim accepts this decision and thanks Mr. Potanin for his service to the Museum and his support of exhibition, conservation and educational programs," a spokesperson for the Guggenheim said in an email to CNN. "The Guggenheim strongly condemns the Russian invasion and unprovoked war against the government and people of Ukraine."
This story will be updated as developments happen.
Top image: The Bolshoi Ballet's production of Swan Lake at The Royal Opera House on August 2, 2019 in London, England.